WASHINGTON — Canada isn't committing to a massive boost in military spending, such as is being demanded of U.S. allies by Donald Trump as part of his presidential election platform.
Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan was asked during a visit to Washington about the request that NATO allies meet their stated goal of spending two per cent of GDP on the military.
Trump warned recently that allies should be prepared to defend themselves without any American help if they won't bother following through on the international spending goal set years ago.
Sajjan expressed skepticism Thursday about the value of that two-per-cent yardstick, without committing to it or ruling it out. He said the government will seek a plan that works for Canada, and for its allies, through its current review of defence policy.
Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan speaks during a news conference in Ottawa, Canada, Apr. 6, 2016. (Photo: Chris Wattie/Reuters)
There are other ways to calculate a country's contribution, he said.
"We had 158 soldiers who died — sacrificed — in Afghanistan. Having been alongside them, contributions can be measured in many different ways,'' said the minister, a veteran of the Afghan war.
"We as Canada will make a decision based on what type of military capability, size, composition, is going to be needed for Canada — but more importantly how we integrate with our multilateral partners.''
The minister's language echoes that of the discussion paper put out by the government for its ongoing review, which suggests the two-per-cent target is a questionable measure for calculating military effectiveness.
"We had 158 soldiers who died — sacrificed — in Afghanistan. Having been alongside them, contributions can be measured in many different ways."
— Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan
Canada would need to double its spending to reach that target. It's currently in the bottom tier of NATO countries in terms of spending, at one per cent of the national economy.
Reaching the target would require another $20 billion per year — the equivalent of nearly the entire federal employment insurance program, or half of health transfers to the provinces.
But NATO countries signed onto that target a decade ago. It's been a source of annoyance to politicians in the higher-spending countries that only four nations have reached the target.
Trump made it a theme of his recent foreign-policy speech — attached to a threat.
Republican U.S. presidential candidate Donald Trump arrives at a campaign rally in Eugene, Oregon, U.S., May 6, 2016. (Photo: Reuters)
"Our allies must contribute toward the financial, political and human costs of our tremendous security burden. But many of them are simply not doing so,'' he said recently.
"We have spent trillions of dollars over time — on planes, missiles, ships, equipment — building up our military to provide a strong defence for Europe and Asia. The countries we are defending must pay for the cost of this defence — and, if not, the U.S. must be prepared to let these countries defend themselves.''
An international observer of military spending calls the two-per-cent figure arbitrary, essentially political, and unconnected to real security requirements.
But he said the recent invasion of Ukraine has increased pressure on NATO allies.
"... the U.S. must be prepared to let these countries defend themselves.''
— Donald Trump
"I think given the political climate, most NATO members who are currently below two per cent — i.e. most of them — will be reluctant to reduce military spending, and may increase it slightly, unless faced with poor economic conditions,'' said Sam Perlo-Freeman, head of the Project on Military Expenditure at the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute.
"As Canada is one of the lowest spenders as a share of GDP, it would be in particular politically awkward to further cut spending. But the two-per-cent figure remains more of an aspirational target for many members, which is not going to be reached or approached in the foreseeable future.
"Of course if Donald Trump becomes President, then all bets are off, and if he means what he says about NATO being obsolete, then who knows.''
'I look forward to the discusson': Sajjan
Sajjan is in the U.S. for meetings, and for a ceremony at the North American Aerospace Defence Command in Colorado.
That's the home of the monitoring system for the U.S. missile-defence program, which is another part of the new Liberal government's defence review.
Canada declined to join the program a decade ago but remains involved in monitoring the skies for incoming objects — and works in the same room in Colorado with U.S. officers involved in missile defence.
"I look forward to the discussion,'' Sajjan said of missile defence.
"This is right now exactly what the defence review is trying to do — is making sure that we have a wide dialogue.''
The government is soliciting opinions for the review through July 31.
Also On HuffPost:
Party: Liberal Riding: Vancouver South, British Columbia Military Organization and Past Titles: Commandant, British Columbia Regiment; Lieutenant-Colonel, Canadian Forces; Aide de Camp, Lieutenant Governor of British Columbia
Party: Liberal Riding: Aurora--Oak Ridges--Richmond Hill, Ontario Military Organization and Titles: Logistics Officer, Canadian Forces (Air Force), retiring with the rank of Captain
Party: Liberal Riding: Orléans, Ontario Military Organization and Past Titles: Chief of Transformation, Canadian Forces; Chief of Staff, Canadian Forces (Army); Deputy Commander, International Security Assistance Force in Kabul, Afghanistan; Commander, Land Force Doctrine and Training System; Commander, Land Force Command; Director of Command, Control, Communications and Computer Systems, Canadian Forces; Commander, 1st Canadian Mechanized Brigade Group; Colonel, Canadian Forces (Army); Member, 1st Field Regiment, Royal Canadian Horse Artillery; Member, 30th Field Artillery Regiment
Party: NDP Riding: Abitibi--Témiscamingue, Quebec Military Organization and Past Titles: Officer Cadet, Canadian Forces (Army), and Corporal, 52nd Field Ambulance
Party: Conservative Riding: Durham, Ontario Military Organization and Past Titles: Member, Canadian Forces; Officer, Royal Canadian Air Force; Officer, Royal Canadian Air Force 8 Wing (Trenton, Ontario); Air Navigator, Royal Canadian Air Force 17 Wing (Winnipeg, Manitoba); Captain, Royal Canadian Air Force 423 Squadron (Shearwater, Nova Scotia); Training Officer, Royal Canadian Air Force 406 Squadron (Reserve)
Party: Conservative Riding: Beauport--Limoilou, Quebec Military Organization and Past Title: Master Bombardier, 6th Field Artillery Brigade
Party: Bloc Quebecois Riding: Terrebonne, Quebec Military Organization and Past Titles: Infantry Officer, Royal 22e Régiment
Party: Conservative Riding: Charlesbourg--Haute-Saint-Charles, Quebec Military Organization and Past Titles: Commandant, Regiment de la Chaudière, and Officer, Canadian Forces (Reserve)
Party: Liberal Riding: Kelowna--Lake Country, British Columbia Military Organization and Past Titles: Flight Commander, Canadian Forces Instrument Check Pilot School; Officer, 2nd Canadian Forces Flight Training School; Major, 1st Canadian Air Division; Flight instructor, Canadian Forces (Air Force)
Party: Liberal Riding: Westmount--Ville-Marie, Quebec Military Organization and Past Titles: Captain, Canadian Forces (Navy) and Combat Systems Engineer, Canadian Forces (Navy)
Party: Liberal Riding: Winnipeg Centre, Manitoba Military Organization and Past Titles: Petty Officer 2nd class, Royal Canadian Navy; Sergeant-at-Arms, 5th Valcartier Field Ambulance, Member, Canadian Forces (Navy Reserve)
Party: Liberal Riding: Winnipeg North, Manitoba Military Organization and Past Titles: Air Traffic Controller, Canadian Forces (Air Force)
Party: Liberal Riding: Kanata--Carleton, Ontario Military Organization and Past Titles: Lieutenant-Colonel, 429 Transport Squadron; Air Navigator, Canadian Forces (Air Force); Member, Windsor Regiment (RCAC) and Royal Canadian Army Cadets
Party: Liberal Riding: Pitt Meadows--Maple Ridge, British Columbia Military Organization and Past Titles: Member, Canadian Army Reserve Force
Party: Liberal Riding: Ville-Marie--Le Sud-Ouest--Île-des-Soeurs, Quebec Military Organization and Past Titles: Commander, Canadian Infantry
Party: Liberal Riding: Brampton Centre, Ontario Military Organization and Past Titles: Member, Indian Air Force
UP NEXT: Unseen Sides Of The Afghan War
Check out a selection of photographs from Razistan below showing the unseen sides of the war. Mussa Ahmadi, an 18-year-old heroin addict in Kabul. Photo: Sandra Calligaro
A refugee camp on the outskirts of Kabul. Photo: Jonte Wentzel
Outdoor school for children in eastern Afghanistan. Photo: Jacob Simkin
Afghan National Army recruits on a night-time training exercise. Photo: Joel van Houdt
Fahim Bash rehearses in his studio in Kabul's musicians' neighborhood on Koche Kharabat Road. Photo: Lorenzo Tugnoli
Audience members at Afghan Star, a popular Afghan television show. Photo: John Wendle
A Pashtun man and his wife visit the doctor. Photo: Mikhail Galustov
Soldier in a sandstorm in Northern Afghanistan. Photo: Joel van Houdt
The cast and crew of the production "Doste" film a scene on the outskirts of Kabul. Photo: Jonathan Saruk/Getty Images
An Afghan commando on patrol in Helmand Province. Photo: Pieter ten Hoopen