OTTAWA — The federal government has weighed the pros and cons of a financial deterrent aimed at shrinking bulging waistlines: a tax on soda pop.
Finance Minister Bill Morneau's office requested an internal analysis last winter to explore the "issues and impacts in respect of a potential tax on soft drinks."
The information was contained in a Jan. 29 briefing note prepared for Morneau as he drew up the Liberal government's maiden budget, which was tabled in March.
"A number of health organizations have called on the government to implement taxes on sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs), as a strategy to address obesity," reads the memo signed by deputy finance minister Paul Rochon.
Bill Morneau speaks during the International Economic Forum Of The Americas in Montreal, on June 13. (Photo: Brent Lewin/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
The partially redacted, "secret" briefing was obtained by The Canadian Press under the Access to Information Act.
As an example, the document pointed to a pre-budget recommendation made by the Heart and Stroke Foundation, which urged Ottawa to impose a tax of five cents per 100 millilitres on sugar-sweetened beverages.
The Heart and Stroke Foundation told Ottawa that such a levy would be a sustainable source of tax revenue that would generate $1.8 billion every year for the public treasury.
In Morneau's spring budget, the Liberal government pledged to help "families make better food choices" and indicated it would take steps during 2016-17 to add more details on food labels about added sugars and artificial dyes in processed products.
The budget made no mention of imposing taxes on sugary or fatty foods and beverages.
Support for a tax on sugar-filled drinks has increased in the past months. (Photo: Getty)
Asked about the analysis, a spokeswoman for Morneau said it was requested during the pre-budget period when the finance minister's office was in exploratory mode and had a responsibility to examine options and proposals.
"This (is) an issue that was raised in the pre-budget consultation period by several stakeholders — both for and against — and we asked for an analysis in order to better understand it," Annie Donolo said in an email.
"We encourage anyone with a point of view to engage with us. It's an important subject with many facets, and we expect it will come up again as we hear from people ahead of the next year's budget."
The push to tax sugar-filled beverages has gained momentum in recent months.
Sugary drinks 'significant' in causing obesity
In its pre-budget submission, the Heart and Stroke Foundation said health experts have described sugary drinks as a "significant driver of chronic disease and obesity." It also insisted that taxing sugary drinks has cut down on consumption in some jurisdictions.
In March, a Senate committee released a report about fighting obesity that recommended Ottawa explore the possibility of implementing a new tax on sugar-sweetened and artificially-sweetened beverages.
Citing the Senate report, members of the Green party voted last weekend in support of a resolution that stated a Green government would introduce a tax on these sweetened drinks.
"It make sense in public policy because it is a burden on our health-care system — so, if you want to look at dollars and cents it makes sense financially," Green leader Elizabeth May said before the vote.
Tax would increase grocery costs: group
However, the Canadian Beverage Association has opposed any plan to tax sugar-sweetened and artificially sweetened drinks.
The association, which represents 60,000 workers in the industry, has said that efforts to tax these products have proven ineffective in reducing consumption in other jurisdictions. It also warned it would increase the cost of groceries.
"It is important to note that obesity has continued to rise steadily over the past 20 years, while consumption of sugar-sweetened beverages and beverage calories overall, has been declining over the same period," the association said in a March statement in response to the Senate report.
The analysis portion of Morneau's document was largely blacked out, though it did note that other governments have introduced various taxes on soda, fat and sugar "with differing results."
Indeed, the idea of taxing unhealthy grub and drinks is far from new.
Other governments have tried similar taxes
The memo listed some examples, including targeted taxes imposed on specific products to improve nutrition.
Among them, it said Denmark's government repealed its 15-month old "fat tax" in 2012 and announced it would abandon a proposal to tax sugar out of concerns they would hurt low-income earners. Denmark also repealed its decades-old tax on soft drinks in 2013.
The document listed more-recent examples in Mexico and Berkeley, Calif., where governments have taxed unhealthy foods and drinks.
Morneau's note also highlighted a 2013 plan in New York City to impose a 16-ounce size limit on bottled and fountain drinks that were sold at places like restaurants, corner stores, sports venues and movie theatres.
The document noted that the ban never came into effect because it was overturned by the courts.Also on HuffPost:
A new study by researchers at the University of California has determined that soda is actually shortening your life by 4.6 years. The study looks at the sugary drink outside of it’s known relationship with obesity and found that it actually ages your cells. The findings reported in American Journal of Public Health show telomeres, or the protective units of DNA, were much in white blood cells of people who drink more soda. This type of health issue has been found to develop diseases associated to aging including heart disease, diabetes, and certain cancer types. Photo Credit: © Flickr / dcJohn Click Here to See More Ways Drinking Soda is Killing You
A study published in Diabetes Care found that aside from additional weight gain, regularly drinking soda increases a person's risk of developing type 2 diabetes by 26 percent more than those who drink soda more sparingly. This risk was found to develop in those often drinking 1-2 servings of soda a day. Photo Credit: © Flickr / Roadsidepictures
Over the course of 22 years, one study, published in JAMA, found that sugar-sweetened soda was associated with an increasing risk of gout in women. In the 80,000 women study it found that those who drank soda had a 75 percent higher risk than those who rarely drank. Photo Credit: © Flickr / Daniel Foster Click Here to See More Ways Drinking Soda is Killing You
A 2012 study published in Circulation found that drinking soda increases your risk of heart disease. In the men studied, there was a high increased risk of CHD (coronary heart disease) and adverse changes in inflammatory factors, lipids, and leptin. The study found that those who had an average of one can of soda a day were 20 percent more likely to have a heart attack or die from a heart attack. Photo Credit: © Flickr / Ken Edwards
Many studies have found crazy chemicals in soda such as 4-methylimidazole in the brown coloring. This chemical has proven to make animals sick and in sodas are in higher levels than legally allowed without a warning label. BPA has also been found to keep acids from reacting to the metal of cans, and BPA has been found to interfere with hormones. Click Here to See More Ways Drinking Soda is Killing You Photo Credit: © Flickr / poolie