The family of a man shot and killed by Calgary police are concerned the decision to not lay charges against the officer involved might have been swayed by a biased expert.
Anthony Heffernan, 27, was fatally shot four times in his motel room in 2015.
The Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT), an independent government watchdog, conducted an investigation and concluded there were grounds to lay charges against the officer who shot Heffernan.
However, once ASIRT's recommendation was passed onto the Crown (ACPS), prosecutors recommended no charges be laid.
The Crown's decision was based on the opinion of expert Chris Lawrence, an advisor to the Force Science Research Centre.
Controversial police psychologist
The director of the centre is controversial police shooting expert Bill Lewinski.
Critics of Lewinski say he is "the kind of witness you call in if you want to have the police exonerated," CBC News reported.
Despite experts calling his work "pseudoscience," the psychologist charges $1,000 hourly rate to appear in court. His testimony has helped exonerate dozens of officers who charged in shootings, according to The New York Times.
The Heffernans are concerned that ACPS chose to reject an expert they had requested in favour of one who might have an agenda.
"When you reject a highly-qualified expert, you don't even go to him ... and then you go to a guy who is at this Force Science Institute. It looks like you're expert shopping," the family's lawyer Tom Engel told CBC News.
Police say concerns are 'ridiculous'
Howard Burns, the head of Calgary's police union, has dismissed accusations the officer involved bears all fault and responsibility with the shooting.
"To say it's murder is ridiculous," he told the Calgary Herald.
The family is planning to sue the Calgary police in hopes the officer involved in the shooting will be forced to testify.
Also on HuffPost:
In a lawsuit filed July 26 Shoshoni police chief Andy Rodriguez was accused of using a Taser on a man whose lawyer refers to him as a "cat guy." A police report explains what happened when Rodriguez tried to arrest the "cat guy," L.J. Faith, for animal cruelty. "I deployed the Taser to Faith's left side arm. During the attempt to control Faith's arm, I realized the Taser was not having a meaningful affect [sic]..." Not deterred, the officer loaded another probe, but something went awry: "As I was attaching [another] probe cartridge to the Taser, I had the sensation of falling backwards... I recall the Taser discharging... a probe had penetrated my right index finger... I pulled the probe out of my finger and was going to reload with a second probe cartridge when officer Cruche told me he had been hit as well. I looked over and [he] was bleeding from the top of his head near the hair line."
Texas Deputy Constable Jimmy Drummond. was charged in the brutal 2011 beating of a young man and his family. Police dashboard camera footage, released in September, allegedly shows Drummond beating a man who was pulled over for speeding. The suspect's father and mother also claim they were dragged and kicked by deputies. The beatings left the son's ribs broken and his father's face bruised. A criminal complaint filed against Drummond said his actions were "gratuitous" and "furthered no law enforcement purpose."
Philadelphia police officer Jonathan Josey was suspended last year after video emerged of him punching a woman in the face. Despite the brutal video, Josey was acquitted of any crime and got his job back in August.
New Mexico resident Marlene Tapia filed a lawsuit in November over an incident that took place two years prior. KOB explains what allegedly happened: According to court records, police arrested Tapia for a probation violation tied to a previous drug case. While at the Metropolitan Detention Center, Tapia said two officers strip searched her and asked her to bend over at the waist. That’s when they noticed a plastic baggie protruding from Tapia’s vagina. Instead of taking Tapia to a doctor to have the baggie removed, she said one of the officers – Blanca Zapater – sprayed a chemical agent directly on her genitals twice.
In January, New Mexico man David Eckert was subjected to a series of invasive and degrading drug search procedures after a traffic stop. The procedures, which included x-rays, digital anal penetration, enemas and a colonoscopy, were all performed without Eckert's consent. Authorities conducted the searches because Eckert allegedly clinched his buttocks.
Michael Saffioti's family filed a lawsuit in November after the 22-year-old Washington resident died in his cell following an arrest for pot possession. According to the lawsuit, Saffioti may have suffered an allergic reaction in his jail cell caused by the food he was given while behind bars. He made several attempts to call for help, but guards ignored his requests until it was too late, according to the suit.
An investigative report released in October, 2013 by the St. Louis Post-Dispatch found that the St. Louis Police Department had accidentally arrested 100 people over the last seven years. The department said that mistakes will happen in a city where officers make 30,000 arrests every year. But Jeffrey Mittman, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Eastern Missouri, told The Huffington Post that these accidents are unacceptable. "To say we are a large city and mistakes will happen as if that justifies a depravation of liberty is simply incorrect," Mittman said.
An audit filed in October, 2013 found that law enforcement offices in Fulton County, Georgia are using asset forfeiture money on galas, back-rent, fancy restaurants and a field trip to see Headline News anchor Nancy Grace, among other questionable expenditures. Fulton County D.A. Paul Howard said he disagreed with the report and said he'd continue spending the money as he saw fit.
A report by the Los Angeles Times in December, 2013 found that the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department had made several sketchy hires including a man who said he kissed and groped a 14-year-old girl when he was 28.
Three high school teens in Rochester, N.Y., were arrested while they waited for a bus, but authorities claimed the trio was obstructing the flow of other pedestrians on the sidewalk. "We tried to tell them that we were waiting for the bus," One of the students, Wan'Tauhjs Weathers said. "We weren't catching a city bus, we were catching a yellow bus. He didn't care. He arrested us anyways." The police department denied any wrongdoing but prosecutors elected not to bring charges.