OTTAWA — A Conservative MP is hoping to expand access to palliative care throughout the country but the Quebec government says it wants nothing to do with a potential new federal plan.
Marilyn Gladu’s Bill C-277 will be debated in the House of Commons Wednesday. It comes on the heels of the Liberal legislation to expand physician-assisted dying, and the Sarnia, Ont., MP believes her bill may help Canadians who are suffering choose to live rather than seek help ending their lives because they can’t manage their pain.
Conservative MP Marilyn Gladu says that improved palliative care could stop some suffering Canadians from choosing to end their lives.
“Where there is good palliative care, people choose to live as well as they can for as long as they can,” she told The Huffington Post Canada Tuesday.
The rookie MP’s bill calls for the development and implementation of a framework designed to give Canadians access to palliative care in hospitals, home, care, long-term care facilities, and residential hospices. Among other things it gives the federal government one year to work with the provinces to identify:
- training and education needs for health providers;
- measures to support palliative caregivers, and;
- measures to facilitate consistent access to palliative care across Canada.
Gladu also wants the federal government to consider amending the Canada Health Act to include palliative care services.
An e-petition in support of her bill notes that 70 per cent of Canadians do not have access to quality palliative care. More than 1,400 people signed on to let Health Minister Jane Philpott know they want the government to endorse Gladu’s bill. It is one of 89 petitions focused on palliative care that has been tabled in the Commons since last November.
Federal government supports 'intent' of bill
Philpott’s office on Tuesday declined to comment substantially.
“The government supports the general intent of the bill, but tomorrow we will be announcing our official position,” a government staffer said.
But Quebec Health Minister Gaétan Barrette’s office said it sees no need for a federal framework.
“This is a question of provincial jurisdiction and we are already deeply involved in this file. We have developed a plan already in Quebec on this topic,” said Barrette’s spokeswoman Julie White, pointing to the provincial Liberals’ five-year plan.
Quebec Health Minister Gaetan Barrette responds to the Opposition during question period on April 14, 2016 at the legislature in Quebec City.
Gladu isn’t worried. She believes she has the full support of the NDP and her Conservative colleagues, including those from Quebec.
“They realize that palliative care is so important, it’s so underfunded, it is such a big gap that the federal government does need to step in and provide money and some leadership,” she said, in an interview.
Many palliative experts are also throwing their support behind her bill calling it a much needed approach to expand standards and accessibility.
"Palliative care is so important, it’s so underfunded ..."
Sharon Baxter, executive director of the Canadian Hospice Palliative Care Association, said Canada’s primary care sector isn’t prepared to deal with the growing palliative needs. Of the approximately 260,000 Canadians who die each year, Baxter said too few — about 35 per cent — have access to adequate care and many are only given access a few days or weeks before they die.
“It’s hit and miss across the country,” she said, adding that there are large gaps between some rural areas and urban centres and in doctor referrals.
Many documents prepared in conjunction with the Liberals’ Medical Assistance In Dying bill noted the need to improve palliative care in Canada, said Dr. David Henderson, president of the Canadian Society of Palliative Care Physicians.
“Well, so far nothing has happened towards that,” he said.
Bill may pressure government to do more
By highlighting the gaps that exist across the country, Henderson said Gladu’s bill may pressure the federal government to spend more in this area.
The Liberals campaigned on a $3-billion injection for home care, including palliative care, over four years across the country. But last month, Philpott suggested that $3 billion would go to home care alone and be part of a new five-year health care accord with the provinces and territories.
“We certainly don’t begrudge homecare...it’s an area that needs to be funded well,” Henderson said. “But we are concerned that homecare in general will swallow up most of that money — unless there is some designation and a real plan of how to use [palliative care] money.”Also On HuffPost:
Efficiency score: 62.6 Life expectancy: 81.8 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 9.6% Healthcare cost (per capita): $5,331 Source: Bloomberg In this file picture taken on January 27, 2010 a man rides a bike past the frozen sea in Stockholm's harbour as many people go to work by bike no matter how the forecast is. (OLIVIER MORIN/AFP/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 63.1 Life expectancy: 82.7 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 11.5% Healthcare cost (per capita): $9,121 Source: Bloomberg A general view of Davos and its St. John's Church on January 10, 2012 in Davos, Switzerland. (Photo by Harold Cunningham/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 65.1 Life expectancy: 80.9 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 7.2% Healthcare cost (per capita): $1,616 Source: Bloomberg A long exposure photograph shows traffic commuting at night near South Korea's landmark Namdaemun gate in Seoul on May 4, 2013. (KIM JAE-HWAN/AFP/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 66.0 Life expectancy: 81.8 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 8.9% Healthcare cost (per capita): $5,939 Source: Bloomberg General view of Sydney Opera House on June 13, 2013 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 66.1 Life expectancy: 82.1 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 10.4% Healthcare cost (per capita): $3,436 Source: Bloomberg A gondola passes on a canal on April 12, 2012 in Venice. (GABRIEL BOUYS/AFP/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 68.3 Life expectancy: 82.3 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 10.4% Healthcare cost (per capita): $3,027 Source: Bloomberg Revellers run with Torrestrella's ranch fighting bulls at Calle Mercaderes during the sixth day of the San Fermin Running Of The Bulls festival on July 11, 2013 in Pamplona, Spain. (Photo by Pablo Blazquez Dominguez/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 68.7 Life expectancy: 81.8 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 7.8% Healthcare cost (per capita): $2,426 Source: Bloomberg A picture shows the skyline of Jerusalem with the Dome of the Rock mosque on September 5, 2008. MARCO LONGARI/AFP/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 74.1 Life expectancy: 82.6 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 8.5% Healthcare cost (per capita): $3,958 Source: Bloomberg People enjoy boating among Cherry Blossoms on a moat of the Imperial Palace in Tokyo on March 30, 2008. (TORU YAMANAKA/AFP/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 81.9 Life expectancy: 81.9 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 4.4% Healthcare cost (per capita): $2,286 Source: Bloomberg A sculpture, the 'Surrealist Piano' by Salvador Dali is displayed near the clock tower in Singapore, 12 September 2006. (THERESA BARRACLOUGH/AFP/Getty Images)
Efficiency score: 92.6 Life expectancy: 83.4 Healthcare cost (% GDP per capita): 3.8% Healthcare cost (per capita): $1,409 Source: Bloomberg A junk sails on Victoria Harbour in front of the city's skyline in Hong Kong on June 3, 2013. (PHILIPPE LOPEZ/AFP/Getty Images)