Canadians, rightfully, consider themselves a welcoming people. In 2014, Canada welcomed over 250,000 new permanent residents. We celebrate our diversity. We don't build walls -- we open doors.
Except, perhaps, in real estate. Surging house prices have led to a hunt for a culprit -- and for a large number of Canadians, foreign buyers are to blame, leading for calls to ban foreign ownership of Canadian homes.
But what is this other than another sort of wall?
Teranet data shows that the average resale house price jumped 14.5 per cent and nine per cent annually in Vancouver and Toronto respectively in February. The most commonly repeated explanation for the price surge last year and into 2016 is an increase in foreign buyers, especially Chinese buyers looking to launder their ill-gotten funds. Anecdotal evidence of this happening is at record high, but actual data to support it is severely lacking.
The Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) has started its own investigation into the phenomenon, but is apparently finding the task challenging. Statistics Canada has been promised $500,000 in the Federal budget to tackle the issue.
For Fortress Real Developments' latest Market Manuscript report on the state of the Canadian residential real estate market, we surveyed mortgage brokers and agents regarding their client base. Survey respondents indicated that approximately eight per cent of their clients were foreign buyers or recent immigrants. This is consistent with many surveys done on foreign ownership nationally, but belief is that the share is much higher in the core markets of Vancouver and Toronto.
Is it worth the potential damage to our national reputation as a welcoming nation?
This means that foreign buyers are having an effect on the market. Simply having this five per cent to 10 per cent additional demand will lead to price growth (assuming builders and developers are not building an equivalent number of homes to offset this demand). But the real difficulty lies in determining how much more these foreigners are paying than the next highest bidding domestic buyer. That is, how much are foreign investors driving up prices, compared to rich locals? Another extremely important factor is speculation: are they short-term flippers, or long-term investors that are renting units to people who live in the market they're investing in?
Instead of trying to answer all these difficult questions, should we simply just ban all international buyers? A quarter of the mortgage professionals surveyed for the Market Manuscript indicated that banning foreign buyers would help prevent a housing correction in Canada. This potential solution creates new dilemmas: In a country of immigrants, do we truly have the right to say "we were here first?" With tourism, immigration and construction being strong contributors to economic growth, do we really want to discourage potential second-home owners and future Canadians from coming here? Is it worth the potential damage to our national reputation as a welcoming nation?
More importantly: Would this solution even work?
More tepid measures to stem foreign ownership in Australia have not succeeded in slowing price growth in that market. Foreigners in Australia can purchase homes if they prove that their investment will increase housing supply, which essentially limits them to buying new homes. An outright ban of foreign buyers would likely reduce supply in Australia and Canada, where many investors like to buy pre-construction condominiums and townhouses. This decreased supply would have the opposite impact as desired, and could further drive house prices up.
Before Canadians and our government make a decision to ban, restrict or add taxes to foreign buyers, we need to consider the potential negative side-effects and consequences of such actions: less tourism, less immigration, fewer consumers, less new construction, marred reputation.
Hopefully we don't let anger prevent us from examining many of the other forces driving up house prices in Canada, and finding a solution to our mismatch of supply and demand.
To learn more about the other forces driving up house prices in Canada, download the Spring 2016 Market Manuscript by Fortress Real Developments.
Follow HuffPost Canada Blogs on Facebook
ALSO ON HUFFPOST:
This Tudor home in Vancouver's ritzy Shaughnessy neighbourhood was listed for $5.99 million in May. After 12 days, it sold for just over $8 million. “When you’ve got too little supply (of detached houses) and too many buyers, that’s always what happens,” realtor Stuart Bonner told The Province.
This abandoned home (read: eyesore) became a dumping ground over several months in 2015. Piles of rotting trash and unwanted furniture attracted rodents to the area, and the smell was sometimes so bad that neighbours refused to open their back doors. The house was assessed at $813,000, and others in the area were valued at over $1 million.
"Avail now. Bring your tent." A Craigslist ad advertised a backyard for rent for $500 per month. WiFi, use of the home's bathroom, kitchen, laundry, and "art room" were part of the deal. Great for travellers, apparently!
This home was listed at just under $3 million in June, and was sold to an offshore buyer for $4.1 million after a couple hours, the realtor said.
Bargain alert: a former grow-op hit the market in March for $930,000. The 1968 two-storey home was in such bad shape that no one could live in it. The house got an occupancy permit back in 2001, and was renovated before it was listed. The price was mostly because of the 6,000 sq.-ft. lot.
This rare, 3.6-metre wide home sold in April for $1.35 million. Tucked in the upscale Point Grey neighbourhood, the floor space is only 945 sq.-ft., but manages to cram in a full kitchen, master bedroom, living room, garage, den and 1.5 bathrooms. The home is believed to be one of the last of its kind in the entire city, according to the realtor.
This house, listed for just under $1.6 million, sold for $2.17 million in March — a mind-boggling 35 per cent over asking. "It was the highest price per square foot ever achieved for an East Vancouver home," realtor Paul Eviston told CBC News.
Chump change, amirite? This 25,000 sq.-ft. mansion, which sits on a 1.09 hectare property, was purchased in December 2014 for $51 million. (Details of the sale were made public in March.) The deal included a movie theatre, grass tennis court, and 10-car garage, according to the CBC.
Talk about a sweet deal! This (very well-decorated) gingerbread house was advertised on Craigslist for $4.5 million in December. It's a one-bedroom home that's a single sq. ft. in size. The baking sheet upon which it stands was not included in the sale. The seller asked for "serious" inquires only.
Follow Ben Myers on Twitter: www.twitter.com/benmyers29