Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bernie Farber

GET UPDATES FROM Bernie Farber
 

Let the Bully Bloggers Talk Amongst Themselves

Posted: 05/28/2012 10:20 am

I never really liked the word "tolerance." It suggests the bare minimum. Simply tolerating each other is far from accepting or, better yet, celebrating each other. In the end "tolerance" is not much of a value statement.

It's for that reason that we have a responsibility to aim higher, and that means that we not only develop an acceptance and respect for those who are different from us, but also for those who hold different opinions. It also means that we need to work harder to give people the benefit of the doubt. In both cases it means that we have to consider the impact that our words can have on other individuals.

My tradition is rich in stories that tell us of the importance of guarding our tongues. We are told that the tongue is so powerful that it requires two gates (the lips and teeth) to restrain.

There is an old Hasidic tale that tells of a man who spoke ill of his neighbour. Realizing his mistake he went to a rabbi and asked forgiveness. The rabbi said he would be forgiven but first he must take a feather pillow to the centre of town, rip it open and spread the feathers to the wind. The villager did as the rabbi asked. When he returned he told the rabbi his job was completed and asked for forgiveness. "Now," said the rabbi, "go and collect each of those feathers."

"But that's impossible" said the man.

"Precisely," the rabbi answered, "and while you may sincerely regret the damage you have done, it's as impossible to undo it as it is to recover all the feathers."

Like those feathers, hateful words have consequences. On a human level they simply degrade relationships. In the age of Facebook, blogs and Twitter, hateful words become the bully's new weapon.

Instead of the threat of the fist, the intimidation comes in the form of words that can be distributed to potential thousands in the blink of an eye. And like those feathers, even with hindsight and the understanding that a wrong was done, the words can simply not be retrieved.

In the past it was difficult for bullies to gain a public pulpit. Letters to newspapers were closely monitored to ensure that slander and intimidation were not published. Magazines and television likewise; the professional mainstream media for the most part undertook the responsibility to self-regulate. Today anyone can publish virtually anything. And sadly, more often than not, bullying and ad hominem attacks are de rigueur.

Here are just a few examples of the type of discourse that can regularly be found on some political blogs:

"X is an incredibly stupid twit, note I didn't say man as he isn't. Ask his wife."

"This guy has a face like a can of worms IMO. Just puked on my keyboard looking at it"

"Y is too stupid to really be Jewish"

And this little gem from a notorious blogging bigot who took offence at me running for public office:

"What a genius! International laughing stock, wearer of tee-shirts and credit-taker Bernie Farber once again proves he's completely witless by hooking up with Canada's Liberal Party just days after the party went down to historic defeat. I mean, if there was a Holocaust Party, he'd be perfect, but otherwise? Jezuz."

To be sure, the above quotes originate from the far right of the spectrum. There have been similar attacks from the far left blogosphere as well. And let's not forget the comment sections of some online newspapers which have become feeding grounds for racists, bigots, homophobes and those who slander without compunction.

Thankfully most newspaper comment sections are moderated and complaints are taken seriously.

Do not mistake this blog as advocating for uncivil behaviour to be regulated. Indeed, Canada has some very robust anti-hate laws that deal with the most egregious hate speech. My point is to make a case for what Canadians do best; engage in vigorous, passionate civil discourse.

My dear friend and past CJC colleague Eric Vernon hit the nail firmly on the head when he wrote of John F. Kennedy's 1961 inaugural address admonishing both sides of the Cold war divide reminding the world that "civility is not a weakness".

More than 50 years later Vernon expounded quite wisely noting "civility is an essential component of a healthy, vibrant democracy that encourages civic engagement and the frank discussion of opposing perspectives in the public square."

When it comes to civility let's not settle for mediocrity. Let's work towards true civility. In the end, I am always reminded of the words a prudent teacher once taught me, "Never engage in a pissing match with a skunk; just let the skunks simply "talk" amongst themselves."

 

Follow Bernie Farber on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@berniefarber

FOLLOW CANADA
I never really liked the word "tolerance." It suggests the bare minimum. Simply tolerating each other is far from accepting or, better yet, celebrating each other. In the end "tolerance" is not much o...
I never really liked the word "tolerance." It suggests the bare minimum. Simply tolerating each other is far from accepting or, better yet, celebrating each other. In the end "tolerance" is not much o...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:16 PM on 05/30/2012
While this is well written and all, I wonder if it's not better in the end to do exactly as is suggested in the title.
02:32 PM on 05/30/2012
Thanks to Google I was able to find some of the Bloggers alluded to in this article. They had no shame attacking Farber and acted exactly the way Mr. Farber explained is their way. They attacked him personally. Now I feel like I have to take a shower.
11:43 AM on 05/29/2012
Wow. The comments read like a high school exchange. Most of the comments Farber lists in his column, I would consider reflect more on the blogger than on him (negatively, that is). So I wouldn't engage with people like that.

Yes, individuals have more of a platform: but that's where our media is taking us. You can hold back progress (so the saying is). People have to discern where they get their facts and opinions. But that's no different from any previous time or media source. Everyone has an angle.

Focusing on the worst of the "blogosphere" is not helpful. Bloggers also offer valuable counterpoints to the traditional media views. That's one of the benefits of free media. I'd focus on that, leave your detractors' comments (particularly if they are racist) to rot in the dust as they belong, and focus on the real issues.

The world is.
09:20 AM on 05/30/2012
Couldn't agree more. Yet we also cannot ignore the bully pulpit and the fact that younger bloggers do not necessarily discern and sift well. That noted your comments are well taken
Wonder Land
...Words Matter
10:11 AM on 05/29/2012
Ref: pissing match > skunk
Admirable advice to be sure, however; a stench is so very difficult to ignore. N'est-çe pas ?
photo
Puller58
Man of Mystery
08:51 AM on 05/29/2012
I'm tired of the paid bloggers/trolls that pop up here and other places. Just silly to think some think tank/political group uses this nonsense.
11:10 AM on 06/11/2012
My goodness!
There is money in that??
Where do I sign up?

http://zorkthehun.wordpress.com/
photo
Turdinthepunchbowl
I float, therefore I am
01:42 AM on 05/29/2012
Dishonesty is the worst form of incivility Farber. And you're an excellent example.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Whistlejackett
Hey stop doing that
12:48 AM on 05/29/2012
I can appreciate your views and understand your concern. I would however like to make one point in defense of the contrarian. People in power can have a very serious effect on millions of lives, and alter their lives in a negative way for long periods of time. They may be educated or not, but they will have in common, a standard of living from which it seems they cannot escape. You are not responsible for their condition in any way however.

In a way this part of society with their vulgar ways are handing you a knife, one that has the power to message it's receiver, succinctly and without reservation. Whether or not you approve it's message, it's intent is to hurt or maime an others' stature, or ego. It is their only way to relieve a frustrated life. You have the choice to stab yourself with that knife any way you choose. You may not like personal attacks coming your way, but I can assure you that those same kinds of attacks, are delivered covertly, like a maelstrom on the masses below. All you have to do is respond with compassion.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bernie Farber
10:40 PM on 05/28/2012
I wrote a piece on those who chooses incivility over decency when it comes to dealing with public discourse. My focus was on personal attacks and its proliferation on blogs and comment sites. I always find it amazing how certain people can take virtually any topic and then try to make it about Israel. Go figure.
07:54 PM on 05/28/2012
Good Read.
What is sad is that Newpapers have become as bad as Bloggers for slander and bad reporting, look at Tech news and see reports about RIM and constant miss information, financial analysts are nothing more than blogger bullies these days creating daily miss information about the state of affairs for many company's News papers no longer seem the check facts before publishing to the web, though hard copy still has some standards, one can't just blame the Internet blogger as in independent t shirt wearing loud mouth, but professional writers for every major publication seem to write first, and correct miss information slowly if at all with updates.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:50 PM on 05/28/2012
I wonder what your "friend" at CJC has to say about Israel's 60+ years of ethnic cleansing of Palestinians.
photo
Charles Howarth
“I became insane, with long intervals of horribl
07:23 PM on 05/28/2012
Good read - everyone is a target and there is no effective safety net (moderation). There is no more being held accountable for one's actions and privacy is a thing of the past. Welcome to the 21st Century.
03:31 PM on 05/28/2012
Where is the civility in trying to supress any criticism of Israel that uses the word 'apartheid'? It's a words used frequently INSIDE Israel by Israelis, its a word that survivors of South African Apartheid such as Bishop Tutu say unambiguously applies to the lives of those in the occupied territories but Farber has been at the forefront of attempts to banish its use and tar those making the comparison with the brush of antisemitism and hate.

Censorship isn't civility.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:14 PM on 05/28/2012
A fine sentiment, but alas likely futile. The anonymity of the internet and the extraordinarily polarized politics of our time, where the difference between opponent and enemy is seldom recognized, conspire to make the internet the domain of bullies.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bernie Farber
02:17 PM on 05/28/2012
Blazing Cat Fur, I am appreciative that your latest post on your blog proves the point of my piece.
12:46 PM on 05/28/2012
Bernie I hear you're going to be the next Chair of the Ontario Human Rights Commission - you're perfect for the job and I mean that sincerely!