Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Betsy Hart

GET UPDATES FROM Betsy Hart
 

Why All the Single Ladies are Still Single

Posted: 02/14/2012 8:25 am

It's not every day a woman gets to observe a bunch of guys learning how to develop significant relationships with women. But that's exactly what I was allowed to watch a few weeks ago.

The men gathered in a "boot camp" led by Dr. Paul Dobransky, 42. Dr. Paul is a practicing psychiatrist in Chicago who has a special interest in relationships and what makes men and women tick. These guys were learning how to approach a woman and understand her signals, what's important to her, how to court her, and how to choose the right woman for a long-term commitment.

The boot camp, which Paul and his staff conduct about once month, comes with a price tag: $1,800 a piece. Seriously.

So, these must have been socially inept nerds, right? No. Here's what so surprised me as I met the men in a Chicago restaurant, and listened to them talk: The four gathered for this session were all nice-looking, intelligent, sociable, professional fellows. They ranged in age from late 20s to early 40s.

To paraphrase a lament from the "Sex and the City" girls, "everyone knows a million great single gals -- but no one knows a million great single guys." So with the deck so stacked in his favor, why in the world is any guy shelling out big bucks for this class?

Well, here's what the "students" told me: They don't think the deck is stacked in their favour at all. Yes, they agreed, there are lots of single women out there; and yes, they are typically sexually available. But, what these guys so want, and what they assured me their (honest) friends also admit to wanting, is to find a woman who really believes in her man. Who respects him, looks up to him, cares about his work and knows how much of his identity he's built to derive from it. A woman who thinks he can do anything. That, they agreed, is so crucial. And so rare.

That was my biggest takeaway, and something Paul says he hears all the time. Yes, his is a self-selecting group, but it makes sense to me. Relationships today are so geared to a woman's needs -- is he sensitive, does he understand her, does he take care of the kids and listen to her feelings? Of course, women should be treated well. But in our dialogue on relationships today, there seems to be very little interest in a man's needs.

I've seen lots of advice in the popular culture, for example, about dealing with the "callous" husband who doesn't do enough housework or childcare even when he works full time and she is home full- or part-time. But I can't recall the reverse -- an instance when such a wife was advised to learn about her husband's work and how important it is to him, and to regularly let him know how much she admires him for laboring so hard to support their family.

I've often whined about this trend, which manifests itself in so many ways. It's what I call the feminization of the culture. Paul says it also has to do with the way men are built. He notes that, unlike women, it's typically difficult for men to ask for a need to be met, including "I need you to respect and honour me."

So, Paul said it's not surprising that when a man in our culture finds a woman he is attracted to and who admires him as a man, he typically feels he's found a gem. A rare one.

Anyway, after a few hours, I left the guys to continue with their "studies." I newly appreciated that the numbers don't tell the whole story, and that men don't have it so easy after all. No matter how we distill it down, relationships between men and women will always be wonderfully challenging and mysterious.

And, by the way, Paul also teaches classes for women, including skills for discovering that right guy. I think maybe I'll see if I can drop in on that one next time.


This is an excerpt from the author's book: "From the Hart: A Collection of Favorite Columns on Love, Loss, Marriage (and Other Extreme Sports)" published by the Scripps Howard News Service.

 

Follow Betsy Hart on Twitter: www.twitter.com/BetsyHartSpeaks

 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
jf12
Esta vez saldré como las otras y me escaparé.
02:29 PM on 02/15/2012
Each man wants a woman who respects him. It is sad that there are no such women; it isn't the man's fault.
02:09 AM on 02/15/2012
"A woman who really believes in her man..." How so? His ability to succeed in life? Fair enough.

But "a woman who looks up to her man?" Should she call him "Daddy" while she's at it?

"A woman who cares about his work and knows how much of his identity he's built to derive from it."
Sure, if he'll return the favour - particularly when it comes to children. We'll both take parental leave and I get that his job is important to him, but parenthood requires many sacrifices. He'd never suggest that I just stay home since he makes enough to support us, right? Given how important his career is to him, he'd never suggest that my professional degree and career are something I can just leave in the past because I'm a mom now and what's more important?

And once I'm sufficiently shamed into doing just that, he wouldn't dream of proposing that he is exempt from ALL housework and parenting. I'm home ALL DAY!

I have no idea how demanding his job is. How could I possibly know what it's like to work full time in a demanding career? What do I mean it feels like he cares about his job more than he cares about his family? That job is supporting us! He doesn't have the option of staying home!

Men sure do have it rough, but I'm curious: If "they can do anything," why are they complaining?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leanne McKenzie
You can't make this sh*t up.
08:43 PM on 02/14/2012
Please. Male-female relationships for the whole of history have most often been women as property. Women as chattel. Women are finally making how they feel part of the relationship equation.

The fact that men now have to attract a woman based on her criteria, instead of women "learning about cars" and how to make his favourite foods, is a fine idea.

Women are not desperate to marry or willing to settle. They have alternatives and options. Men have to fit into their lives, not the other way around.
08:25 PM on 02/14/2012
Almost all the women I know work fulltime; with marriage and then children, most of the responsibilities invoved in running a household fall on their shoulders. Plus they are expected to stay attractive and compete with the world of ubiquitous online porn. Even the women running as fast as they can to accomplish all the expectations of boss, husband and kids, may find themselves jettisoned as the result of hubby's midlife crisis.
Men who are whiners in the dating stage will hardly have enough stamina for family life in the trenches especially in times of such economic uncertainty.
07:57 PM on 02/14/2012
I'm not sure where the culture of "find a guy and change him" started, but wherever it did, it needs to stop.

There is a fraction of the female population that seems to view men as children, or perhaps something you tolerate and have to "correct." My wife (fiancee at the time) worked at an organization in a department that was largely staffed by women in their second careers, presumably after having kids. The culture in that department was by all accounts horrific: the women had nothing good to say about their husbands, and it was de rigeur to belittle them all day. Scary.

I am sure, by the way, that some fraction of men do things similarly destructive in relationships, but I don't date men so I wouldn't know. :-)

In any case, every girlfriend I ever dumped I did because they tried to manipulate me, and wouldn't accept me for who I was. I married the girl I did because she accepted all of these things about me, embraced them and even involved herself in them when she felt interested. She offers the same things to me, and I accept her for who she is. We trust each other implicitly. I feel so lucky. So today I gave her a Valentine's gift: I pulled her into my lap and told her l have I never felt so fortunate, and that my only regret was that I didn't meet her sooner. She got all weepy. :-)
07:04 PM on 02/14/2012
Why is it that so many of these "why women can't get men because they don't cater to the needs of men enough" articles are always written by women? Men are very capable of articulating their own needs....and very good at taking care of and getting what what they want.....nothing to do with women not taking enough consideration of their needs....it is what it is....men do very well for themselves and women don't need to settle
photo
laymancanuck
IGNORANCE has used up its quota of TOLERANCE
05:30 PM on 02/14/2012
The issue most relationships face is many people are self absorbed and not generous, it's not a gender issue at all.
12:52 PM on 02/14/2012
Isn't this article premised on the stereotypical notion that the man has the full-time career and the woman either works part-time or not at all? That is not to say that some women may be guilty of focusing too much on their own needs and not enough on the needs of their partner, but this article is way too one-sided. Most women that I know, at least, have careers that they care a great deal about, or derive part of their identity from. I hope that those things that the men in that seminar admitted to wanting are also things they're prepared to offer their partner (ie if they want their woman to look up to them, do they also look up to their woman and recognize her own strenghts and accomplishments, or do they just want recognition of their own?). I'm not saying that men shouldn't expect to be respected and honoured in their relationship - it's just that it should be mutual.