Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Beverley Golden

GET UPDATES FROM Beverley Golden
 

Looking for Love in the Online Dating World

Posted: 02/10/2012 2:12 pm

This is an article I honestly never thought that I'd write. Although I sincerely would love to be in a committed, loving relationship, as a person who cherishes personal connection and one-on-one interactions, I admit I'm probably not the most likely person to be reporting on my experiences with online dating sites.

Alas, in this month of all things love and romance, I was compelled to sit down and share my stories. Experiences that have me wondering how anyone ever possibly meets someone of integrity on these online sites. The claim from Match.com that one out of five new relationships now start online, was eye-opening. Wow, 20 per cent! Got me thinking that something, so far, is definitely not working for me.

The current site I'm on, (which I discovered while doing research on intimacy), intrigued me and I was curious to take their online test and uncover my dominant personality type. The test was created by author and biological anthropologist Helen Fisher PhD, one of the world's leading experts on sex, love, marriage and dating. On this site, it's all about the chemistry between the four personality types. I was surprised to discover that I'm an explorer, with strong negotiator skills coming in a close second. Everyone I shared this with confirmed they saw me perfectly as an explorer. True to my type, I jumped in, ready to explore.

I've currently been on the site several months and frankly I've have had more conversations with their customer service people than with any prospective matches. The male supervisor, my inside connection, and I have had lively, laugh-out-loud conversations as he continues to encourage me to stick with it. In the last conversation, I actually asked if he was available, as he appears the closest thing to a match that I believe this site will offer me. He laughed. Gotta love a guy who gets my sense of humour!

Recent events finally convinced me that I just had to sit down and tell all. A few days ago I got three close together email interactions from what appeared to be a lovely man, who lives a mere four and a half hour drive from Toronto. Remaining open to possibility, I wouldn't let the distance between us stop me. In his photo, he looked impeccably dressed in a dapper smoking jacket with ascot. Personally I have no interest in a partner who smokes (or wears a smoking jacket), but when I checked out his profile, I was relieved to see that I could safely move forward. He claimed that he never smokes.

His email immediately flattered me and he expressed a keen desire to have a voice-to-voice conversation, suggesting we jump to that ASAP. So far, so good. Less than 12 hours later, I got a notice that once again I was being matched with the same gentleman. Same name, but magically he was now a year younger than he had been the day before. A bit confusing. I wondered if that was something he could teach me how to do, considering I just had a birthday and in a 12-hour period, I actually became a year older. His picture was the same, only now it was a close-up, so the smoking jacket and ascot were less visible. I was happy I hadn't answered the last email and given him my personal contact info.

When I called my trusty, laughing, in-house supervisor, he explained that sometimes this happens. Oh, this crazy world of online dating. I asked, "Wouldn't you at least change your name if you were attempting to get a profile backup?" More laughing from my inside man. The bottom line was that this match was flagged and his profile withdrawn and he immediately tried to create a new profile which was also flagged and removed. I asked if this happens often? Unfortunately, it happens.

Because this wasn't the first time this happened to me, I'm not sure why I was surprised. Back in the very beginning, I was actually excited about a man who appeared to live about 15 minutes from me and whose profile sounded great. Although his wide acceptable age range for potential matches was 18-105, somehow I didn't see the warning flag in that. Some might call me naive.

He emailed me after we expressed mutual interest and perhaps again I should have known something was wrong when he signed his email with a different name than his profile name. Hmm. And, he was actually a really lonely guy on contract in Malaysia. So much for the potential short drive to meet up with him. He too was flagged and pulled from this site. Where are all the real, authentic men? Does this happen to men looking for women too?

They've now sent me many possible matches and only a very few even look remotely interesting to me. Having just read Jane Fonda's new book Primetime, I remembered reading that sometimes you have to go through a lot of matches to find one worth exploring. For me, it feels incredibly time-consuming and two-dimensional. One of my main criteria is that men at least put up a photo. I've been told that many men don't because they are either hiding something (like they're married) or don't want to be judged by how they look. So, what would happen in person?

A recent Business Insider article reported that apparently smiles in online photos are out for men. I wondered why. Men who look away from the camera and don't smile have a much higher chance of getting a response than those who look directly into the camera.  Apparently guys who look at the camera get less messages than those who don't, according to OkCupid CEO, Sam Yagan, who guesses the reason is because it's intimidating to women.  I don't get that at all, as I personally always go for the smiling man looking directly at me.

The statistics relating to online dating sites are quite staggering. According to Dating Site Reviews, the dating service industry in the United States is projected to be worth $2.1 billion, with an estimated 1,500 dating sites in the U. S. alone. Sounds like a small country of hopeful relationship seekers. Seems any criteria can be a launching point for a dating site. Whether that be age, religion, spiritual beliefs, or your intelligence, there is probably a dating site you can sign on with.

In the United States, there are 54 million singles with 5.5 million of those using dating services. Twenty-five per cent of Canadians have tried online dating with 69 per cent saying they probably wouldn't try them. Sixty-four per cent of online daters say common interests are the most important factor in finding a potential partner online, with 49 per cent reporting it's more about the physical characteristics seen in photos and videos. Online dating sites in the U.S collectively had an amazing 593 million visits in October, 2011.

Not too long ago, a male friend actually suggested I write an article on online dating, after hearing a radio report that women are hiring private detectives to screen and check out perspective matches found on the Internet, as dating sites typically don't engage in any background checks. Hiring a private detective. "Count me out of that," I thought. It seemed absolutely outside my realm of understanding. One thing I do continually hear is that it is imperative to be cautious. Generally trusting by nature, I was curious and wanted to understand where people most often choose to misrepresent themselves.

Catalina L. Toma, an assistant professor in the communication arts department, University of Wisconsin-Madison, investigated how people present themselves and how they judge misrepresentation. For me, the findings were shocking, indicating that about 81 per cent of people misrepresent their height, weight or age in their profiles. The "bright side" conclusion was that people tend to only tell small lies because they may eventually meet in person. My question: In these areas, are any lies actually acceptable?

So, although I'm staying open to being found by an ideal match, I do take a deep breath every time I open another email introducing me to a potential match. I know this way of meeting works for many people. I've heard numerous success stories. At the very least, I see it as a great way for me to do research on human behaviour. As an explorer and curious investigator, it offers a wealth of new personal experiences and potential stories. Maybe even some great new cyber friends in really far away places, too.

What stories do you have of your online dating experiences...whether good, or not so good?


Visit me at: www.beverleygolden.com

 
This is an article I honestly never thought that I'd write. Although I sincerely would love to be in a committed, loving relationship, as a person who cherishes personal connection and one-on-one int...
This is an article I honestly never thought that I'd write. Although I sincerely would love to be in a committed, loving relationship, as a person who cherishes personal connection and one-on-one int...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:29 PM on 03/09/2012
Hi there,
I think you should give up waiting and depending on the matches that are sent to you by a computer. People answer those questions according to their mood. If you are in a great mood at the time of the questionnaire, you may project sunny personality when you are not usually that of optimists personality.

I think go with your gut. Meet as many as possible for coffee. Stop yapping online too much because the more you yap the less you know....people write stories which you can see a lie in a split second over a coffee.

Also, do not be so full of rules and regulations, be laid back. You are not perfect!

I am surprised that you are finding all the weirdoes which tells me you are trying too hard or judging too much....and then you end up at the bottom of the barrel!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Beverley Golden
02:46 PM on 04/01/2012
Just saw your comment and do appreciate you reading and offering your feedback.

For me, I believe it is the nature of the site, as they do all the matching. I keep everything simple and the bottom line is, I haven't actually been matched with anyone who lives close enough to even meet up with. Did connect with two great men in the U.S., both hours away from where I am.

It has been an interesting opportunity for me though. I'm an intuition kind of person, not a rules and regulations one and much prefer in person meeting than online for sure. Appreciate you joining in the conversation!
01:39 PM on 02/13/2012
I met the man that is planning to share life with me on Zoosk. We are both in our late 40's and had tried several other sites. I was pleased with the matches Zoosk had for me and was impressed with their support and services. My advice..don't rule out any site, be honest with yourself and with others (don't post the picture from 5 years ago where you were 25 lbs lighter than now), and go outside your "comfort" zone. My soon to be hubby is 4 years older than me and has the cutest beer belly, if I had stayed on my typical search he would have been knocked out for the beer belly and moustache. How sad it would be to have missed him because of a few physical things that aren't really that important anyway.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Beverley Golden
02:20 PM on 02/14/2012
Thanks so much for sharing your story! It's great to hear how when we go past our normal comfort zone, amazing possibilities show up for us. Most people are commenting on their experiences on Match, but I'm glad to hear you had a great experience on Zoosk! Congrats and wishing you continued happiness in your soon to be marriage!
11:51 AM on 02/13/2012
There certainly are times when the effort of kissing a lot of frogs is worth it. I met my wife on line. A week's worth of emails, a week of phone conversations, finally a "lets meet for coffee." We met on a Saturday. I moved into her appartment on Monday. We have been together for just shy of three years and married for a bit more than a year.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Beverley Golden
02:19 PM on 02/14/2012
That's a great story! And you moved fast. Thanks for sharing and showing how when it works, it works! Really appreciate you joining in the conversation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:06 AM on 02/13/2012
I tried it once and after my potential match saw my picture I was never contacted again. That kinda stung, I also didn't like how it would match me up with people that had certain criteria that were deal breakers. After being single for quite some time I've finally become very comfortable and am so glad I never got married or started a relationship. I love my freedom and can't see myself compromising with anyone but myself.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Beverley Golden
02:21 PM on 02/14/2012
Thanks for sharing your experiences. It's great to hear how much you appreciate your freedom and are willing to stand for what is important to you. All the best and I really appreciate you joining in the conversation!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
feyangel
06:40 PM on 02/12/2012
I think it is a case of you have to kiss a lot of frogs to find a prince. I have been with a man for almost 5 years that I met on Match.com-- and I love our relationship. It and my partner are WAY better than the three marriages and MANY other relationships I had with men I met the usual way. BUT-- the men I met on-line prior to the man I am with were HORRIBLE-- almost turned me off to dating altogether.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
11:54 PM on 02/12/2012
Thanks for sharing and I see you too have had success with Match.com. It's always great to hear the positive experiences people have and how when you stay open, you never know who might show up. This online dating topic seems to engage people and the range of experiences is wide and varied. For me, as I explore many topics to do with relationships and intimacy and love, I found this one interesting to have my own experiences and then to hear all the feedback from other people, both men and women. I see that it is equally challenging for most people regardless of age or gender. Cheers and appreciate you joining the conversation! May your relationship continue to flourish.
03:25 PM on 02/12/2012
I'm on a number of dating sites,and the men all seem to be engineers,military men,construction workers and import/export people working in foreign countries.In the last 4 years I have actually met only 2 in person who were real.
I'm so disgusted I don't even look at the sites anymore. I have resigned myself to being single for the rest of my life.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
11:48 PM on 02/12/2012
Appreciate you taking the time to share your experiences. There are so many dating sites and so many people who use them, it is always interesting to hear how some people have great experiences and then others (like me and you) find them challenging to meet someone on.

Stay hopeful. You never know when someone will show up when least expected, not necessarily from an online dating site of course. Thanks for being in this conversation!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RoughCollie
Destination: A new way of seeing things.
09:59 PM on 02/11/2012
I had a great experience on match.com, meeting and dating some really nice guys in good professions who seemed as straightforward and nice as can be. They were quite surprised that I looked exactly like my picture, was the size I said I was and was accurate about my personality. There was this attorney from Boston named Lyle who had seven bourbons during our dinner date and when he hinted he'd like to spend the night I cracked up laughing and pointed him out the door but other than that everyone else was nice, normal and respectful.

Ohh..met my husband on the site the week of my 50th birthday...we're still married. I don't know why dating is so difficult for some and not for others, maybe it's the state you live in. I was in Maine, the land of LL Bean, lobster and down to earth men...lol...maybe you should move.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
10:25 AM on 02/12/2012
Thanks for taking the time to read and share your experiences. Sounds like Match is a great place to connect and meet people. Congrats too, on meeting your husband on that site! I hear you on the "maybe I should move" thing, as I've had literally no matches who even live close to where I am. :) Still fun and it is interesting that the whole world becomes a possibility, if you have an open perspective. Appreciate you joining in the conversation!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrVeronicaEyeMD
06:05 PM on 02/11/2012
I tried the online dating sites. Match.com and Chemistry.com were the worse. But what was most useful is signing up for several sites at once. Ultimately, I met my husband through a mutual friend, offline. But if you look at online dating as another way to meet cool people to hang out with rather than take it really so seriously than perhaps your success rate would be higher. There is also a mathematical equation to finding a long-term relationship. You have to date at least 12 people to get to lucky 13. Get out there and meet people. Go on those coffee dates and alway tell a friend where you are going and with who with a phone number of that person.
Now this may sound silly or harsh but remember what one calls doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result? Insanity.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
09:27 PM on 02/11/2012
Thanks Dr. Veronica. Interesting, as Match.com and Chemistry.com are owned by the same people. And, most people report that Match is a very good one to meet people. Currently I haven't even been matched with anyone who lives close enough to meet and hang out with. That is primarily what I would hope any online dating site would offer the people who sign up.

Appreciate you reading and bringing your insight. I personally never do the same thing over and over expecting different results. Glad to hear I'm at least on the right track by changing it up. :) The feedback I've been receiving is quite interesting and goes from the crazy experiences to the great ones! Definitely a topic that engages others for sure.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DrVeronicaEyeMD
10:54 PM on 02/15/2012
Keep and open mind and heart and love will roll in and surprise you when you least expect it. The idea is perserverance which is the same answer for anything good you get in life.
08:49 AM on 02/11/2012
I believe Online dating can be one of the best ways to meet someone. Where else can you meet a potential date without leaving your house?

However, as your article states, there are certain inherent rules in the online dating world.

Dating, especially online dating, is nothing more than a numbers game but the major obstacle to dating is that human beings are emotional creatures who tend to make choices and decisions based on instant gratification.

We grow up in a society of I want what I want when I want it and I'm gonna have it now even if it's gonna make me fat, broke or divorced months or years from now.

But the good news is once a person understands the rules of the game, and they play the game with their eyes and ears open, it is much easier to put themselves in position to win.

Dating is equally challenging for a man who is seeking a relationship as it is for a woman. Ask any single man over 35 who is looking for a LTR and he will tell you it is just as frustrating and depressing.

The reality is we were never taught how to date and as a result we try to figure it out on the fly. Throw in the fact that emotions dictate our choices and decisions and it is easy to see why the whole thing is so difficult for so many.

The good news is it doesn't have to be!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
09:19 PM on 02/11/2012
Thanks Joe for reading and commenting. I always appreciate your experience and wisdom. Thanks for sharing that both women and men have equal challenges in the online dating world. Look forward to hearing more tips from you on how to be able to be in this "game" and to meet real and sincere people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wistfulslinking
World traveller, bon-vivant, writer..
09:32 PM on 02/10/2012
I attended a group Thanksgiving in 2002 where there were 5 couples who had been married several years after meeting on match.com.

Online dating is old news, it was even then.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
10:49 PM on 02/10/2012
I appreciate your feedback. Yes, it probably is old news, but somehow it is becoming a larger and larger industry and certainly is an interesting comment on where people continue to turn to meet others. Sounds like, from the feedback I'm getting, that Match.com gets positive results. Thanks for taking the time to comment!
07:01 PM on 02/10/2012
I had a blast doing online dating. I suddenly and unexpectedly found myself single at the age of 32 after 16 years with my ex-husband. I credit much of my positive experience with the fact that I expected to move across the country within a few months, so I was not looking for anything serious (I just wanted to see how dating men was different than dating high school students!). I took my step-brother's advice and did not waste much time on email or phone contact, instead I met for coffee early on with each match. This led to quite a few dates and the discovery that spreadsheets are useful dating tools. It worked out well for me; I met my current partner of two years during those crazy 3 months on Match.
http://lessonsfromtheendofamarriage.com
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
10:44 PM on 02/10/2012
Great to hear you had a fun time with online dating! Sounds like Match produces positive results. Thanks for sharing your experiences!! Much appreciated.
photo
jf12
Esta vez saldré como las otras y me escaparé.
03:30 PM on 02/10/2012
I filled out the Helen Fisher thing too, no age preference, and got 121 unique matches, all younger than me. Some much younger. I'm not sure about the uniqueness of the matches.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
"Beverley Golden"
10:43 PM on 02/10/2012
Appreciate you sharing your experience. For me, they suggested I extend the geographical distance, yet that doesn't seem to make to much difference either! It has still been an interesting exercise and observation of human behavior.
photo
jf12
Esta vez saldré como las otras y me escaparé.
01:06 PM on 02/11/2012
I'm a 61 yr old man in the Houston area. Based on the one sample point, maybe most online dating females are divorced and 40ish. There were zero matches above menopause.