Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Beverly Akerman

Theatre Review: Innocence Lost: A Play about Steven Truscott

Posted: 02/06/2013 11:42 pm

Went to see the shocking play about Steven Truscott at Montreal's Centaur Theatre last weekend.

There are multiple reasons for the shocks. First, there is the story itself: In 1959, a 12-year-old girl was raped and murdered near Clinton, Ont., and a 14-year-old boy was pegged for the killer, even though there was virtually no evidence.

What probably convicted him, as far as I'm concerned: lesions on his penis that two doctors (including his own family physician) said could only have come from raping the girl. These doctors were not experienced in examining rapists. I think the mere fact that he had lesions on his penis was enough to make him a "sicko" in the eyes of the jurors.

It turns out Steven Truscott had some sort of skin sensitivity that caused cysts.

What's most shocking are the differences between the Canadian justice system c.1959 and now. A sampling of things that happened then that would not today:

--there was no change of venue
--they didn't have to inform Steven of his rights
--the prosecution was not required to fully disclose all pertinent information
--the process was incredibly speedy: the rape and murder happened in June, the 15-day trial in October, and the death sentence was set for December 8, 1959.

One of the other reasons the play is shocking: It is so badly written. The playwright, Beverley Cooper, used court transcripts and apparently knocked it together in a short time.

It shows.

Despite the strength of some of the actors -- Fiona Reid and Jane Wheeler, for example -- and some design touches (e.g., the lovely initial setup of a map of the area on the stage floor), there is not much here. The characters, for the most part, parade through, reciting little speeches. There are so many actors playing so many parts that the chance of bonding with anyone is nil.

How this play continues to be produced is a true mystery, not quite on par with the identity of Lynne Harper's murderer (who has never been fingered), but mysterious enough. The money and the energy wasted.

It is to weep.

If you have a couple of hours and want to know what really happened to Steven Truscott, you would be much better off reading a book about it. In preparation for attending the play, I read Nate Hendley's book Steven Truscott: Decades of Injustice.

It's short and to the point, yet written with empathy and craft. You can hear the crickets on the summer evening when it all happened, and feel the pain of injustices committed in our name. It made my blood boil anew at the Conservative government's boneheaded "tough on crime" strategy.

Under the guise of no longer "coddling" criminals, Mr. Harper seems to want to return to the bad old days when innocents could be railroaded in a matter of months. The protections accused people now have were hard won and to tamper with them is despicable. You may be interested in reading more about the organization that helped Mr. Truscott win the setting aside of his conviction, The Association in Defence of the Wrongfully Convicted. I know I am.

Other great books worth looking up: Isabel LeBourdais' The Trial of Steven Truscott, the book that convinced the country of Steven's innocence, and Julian Sher's 'Until You are Dead' Steven Truscott's Long Ride into History, which dug up new evidence that helped clear Truscott's name and paved the way for a $6.5 million settlement from the government. If ever there was an argument to be made for the value of newspapers and investigative journalists, and for crusading writers, these authors have made it.

Find out more from CBC's The Fifth Estate.

Loading Slideshow...
  • The 9 Key Changes In The Tory Crime Bill

    With files from <em>The Canadian Press</em>. (CP/Alamy)

  • 9. Bringing Prisoners Home

    Provides the government, through the minister of Public Safety, more discretion to decide if a Canadian imprisoned abroad can transfer home to serve his or her sentence. (Getty)

  • 8. Rights For Terror Victims

    Introduces new measures to allow victims of terrorist acts to sue responsible individuals, groups or state sponsors in Canadian courts. (Alamy)

  • 7. Denying Work Permits

    Gives the Immigration minister new powers to deny work permits to foreigners based on the rationale they may be exploited. (Alamy)

  • 6. Victims Get More Say In Parole

    Provides victims of crime more say in parole decisions under the Corrections and Conditional Release Act. Increases size of parole board by 25 per cent. (Alamy)

  • 5. Fewer Conditional Sentences

    Reduces sharply the use of conditional sentences, such as house arrest, for a variety of property and other offences. (Jupiter Images)

  • 4. Pardons Harder To Get

    Changes the pardons system and makes certain ex-convicts, such as some sex offenders and repeat offenders, ineligible for life. Essentially doubles the waiting period for pardon eligibility to five years for summary offences and 10 years for indictable offences. Replaces the term "pardon" by "record suspension." (Alamy)

  • 3. Harsher Sentences For Young Offenders

    Sets tougher penalties for young offenders, including mandatory consideration of adult sentences and possible publication ban removal for violent crimes. Expands the definition of violent crime to include reckless acts that don't actually cause harm. (Alamy)

  • 2. Mandatory Minimums For Sex Crimes

    Establishes new mandatory minimum sentences and longer maximums for sex crimes against minors, including the addition of two new offences related to grooming or luring minors. (Alamy)

  • 1. Mandatory Minimums For Drug Crimes

    Provides new mandatory minimum sentences for drug offences related to production and distribution, including mandatory sentences for growing as few as six pot plants. Doubles maximum sentences to 14 years from seven. Offers potential exemptions for those entering drug treatment programs. (Getty)


Follow Beverly Akerman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/beverly_akerman