Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Bruce Moncur


Our "Meeting" With Minister Fantino Made Me Sick

Posted: 01/31/2014 9:08 am

As you may or may not know, this past week I was part of a delegation of veterans that pled and begged that the designated Veterans Affairs offices earmarked for closure remain open.

Tuesday on Parliament Hill, in between meetings and press conferences, we were trying to argue that the Conservative government should reconsider its decision.

Instead our pleas fell on deaf ears. It was a dark day for Canadian veterans. Minister Fantino didn't show up for the scheduled time, and when he did appear right before our press conference, his behaviour was condemnable.

What I witnessed that day is but another slap in the face, and the slaps keep coming. The slaps I have endured over the last seven plus years fighting an insurance company are unbelievable.

To continue to follow the triple D credo -- delay, deny and die -- has left my face red and raw. The outline of the fingers glow, my cheek throbs. Hopefully a few more will help develop a callous and they won't sting as much. It was easier fighting Taliban than being a wounded veteran.

When Minister Fantino was a no-show for the meeting I was not surprised. When military veteran MPs came to the meeting instead and repeated the same rhetoric about service centre employees who will be able to fill the void of personal support workers, or how we are "misinformed" again, I was not surprised.

My colleagues felt betrayed. Sending fellow veterans in Minister Fantino's place was in poor form. Yet we are pawns for the union. We could have argued until we were blue in the face that the expectation we drive upwards of eight hours to Parliament is unacceptable. They did not mention a gas allowance, or a per diem for kilometres, or a hotel accommodation. But hey, if you can't come to them they will come to you, right Harper?

When we left our "scheduled" meeting at 5:35 p.m., we were offered dinner while we waited for the minister who was away at a cabinet meeting. We respectfully declined as we had a press conference scheduled for 6:30 p.m.

Blog continues below slideshow...

Loading Slideshow...
  • Alex Atamanenko

    <strong>Party:</strong> NDP <strong>Riding:</strong> British Columbia Southern Interior, British Columbia <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Officer, Royal Canadian Navy

  • Corneliu Chisu

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Pickering--Scarborough East, Ontario <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Major, Canadian Forces (Army)

  • Marc Garneau

    <strong>Party:</strong> Liberal <strong>Riding:</strong> Westmount--Ville-Marie, Quebec <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Captain, Canadian Forces (Navy) and Combat Systems Engineer, Canadian Forces (Navy)

  • Peter Goldring

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Edmonton East, Alberta <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Royal Canadian Air Force. (He received electronics and police training).

  • Laurie Hawn

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Edmonton Centre, Alberta <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Honorary Colonel, 417 Combat Support Squadron, and Fighter Pilot, Royal Canadian Air Force

  • Kevin Lamoureux

    <strong>Party:</strong> Liberal <strong>Riding:</strong> Winnipeg North, Manitoba <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Air Traffic Controller, Canadian Forces (Air Force)

  • Jean-François Larose

    <strong>Party:</strong> NDP <strong>Riding:</strong> Repentigny, Quebec <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Private, Canadian Forces (Air Reserve)

  • Pierre Lemieux

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Glengarry--Prescott--Russell, Ontario <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Lieutenant-Colonel, Canadian Forces

  • Wayne Marston

    <strong>Party:</strong> NDP <strong>Riding:</strong> Hamilton East--Stoney Creek, Ontario <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Apprentice Sapper, Canadian Army

  • Christine Moore

    <strong>Party:</strong> NDP <strong>Riding:</strong> Abitibi--Témiscamingue, Quebec <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Officer Cadet, Canadian Forces (Army), and Corporal, 52nd Field Ambulance

  • Gordon O'Connor

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Carleton--Mississippi Mills, Ontario <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Brigadier-General, Royal Canadian Armoured Corps

  • Ted Opitz

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Etobicoke Centre, Ontario <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Lieutenant-Colonel, Reserve Militia

  • Erin O'Toole

    <strong>Party:</strong> Conservative <strong>Riding:</strong> Durham, Ontario <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Member, Canadian Forces; Officer, Royal Canadian Air Force; Officer, Royal Canadian Air Force 8 Wing (Trenton, Ontario); Air Navigator, Royal Canadian Air Force 17 Wing (Winnipeg, Manitoba); Captain, Royal Canadian Air Force 423 Squadron (Shearwater, Nova Scotia); Training Officer, Royal Canadian Air Force 406 Squadron (Reserve)

  • Djaouida Sellah

    <strong>Party:</strong> NDP <strong>Riding:</strong> Saint-Bruno--Saint-Hubert, Quebec <strong>Military Organization and Title:</strong> Volunteer Doctor, Gulf War I

  • UP NEXT: Unseen Sides Of The Afghan War

  • Check out a selection of photographs from <a href="http://razistan.tumblr.com/" target="_hplink">Razistan </a>below showing the unseen sides of the war. Mussa Ahmadi, an 18-year-old heroin addict in Kabul. Photo: Sandra Calligaro

  • A refugee camp on the outskirts of Kabul. Photo: Jonte Wentzel

  • Outdoor school for children in eastern Afghanistan. Photo: Jacob Simkin

  • Afghan National Army recruits on a night-time training exercise. Photo: Joel van Houdt

  • Fahim Bash rehearses in his studio in Kabul's musicians' neighborhood on Koche Kharabat Road. Photo: Lorenzo Tugnoli

  • Audience members at Afghan Star, a popular Afghan television show. Photo: John Wendle

  • A Pashtun man and his wife visit the doctor. Photo: Mikhail Galustov

  • Soldier in a sandstorm in Northern Afghanistan. Photo: Joel van Houdt

  • The cast and crew of the production "Doste" film a scene on the outskirts of Kabul. Photo: Jonathan Saruk/Getty Images

  • An Afghan commando on patrol in Helmand Province. Photo: Pieter ten Hoopen

While preparing for the press conference, the minister entered our room. The veterans, some upwards of 85 years old, had been going non-stop for 12 hours at this point. Dinner was planned for after the press conference. Hungry, weary and upset at the minister's failure to materialize at the earlier scheduled meeting made the room feel like a ticking time bomb. The minister proved to be the match.

The tension was immediately palpable. I felt sick to my stomach and I knew this would end badly. Combative and rude we needed calmer heads to prevail, but a harmless hand gesture from a veteran who pointed a finger at Minister Fantino proved to be the smoking gun. When the minister took his leave, anger and frustration took over the veterans -- it was a fresh hand print across all our cheeks.

Before the minister left in a huff he claimed there are over 600 points of contact for veterans. But all I ask is that in light of his regrettable actions in the green room that night, he should open himself up to veterans.

He has since apologized and I hope he means it. I hope he knows he can't take such a heavy-handed approach with veterans in the future. Some say this is not good enough and call for his resignation, but this will not save the offices.

The issues are looming and it is clear that Veteran Affairs Canada is broken. The insurance company way of dealing with veterans, the measly lump sums and the "meat chart" are all a black eye for this country.

Like it or not, these closings will go forward and we still have another year of a conservative majority. The victims in this are the men and women that are not receiving the services they have earned fighting for their county. Many of whom were ordered to fight by the very men and women in office today.

So I feel it is I who would like to issue an apology to the minister, because I should have turned the other cheek.


Follow Bruce Moncur on Twitter: www.twitter.com/tornadomoncur