Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Chelsea Vowel

GET UPDATES FROM Chelsea Vowel
 

I'm in a Life-Threatening Abusive Relationship...With My Government

Posted: 12/12/2012 8:46 am

Although thousands of indigenous people all over Canada rallied together under the banner of Idle No More on December 10, there has been very little media coverage on the movement. Most of what is being said in the mainstream media is focused on Bill C-45. I'd like to make it clear...they're getting it wrong.

Chief Theresa Spence of Attawapiskat did not launch a hunger strike over a single piece of legislation. The women who are planning on supporting her in a nationwide fast, in relay, are not doing this because of a single piece of legislation. Canada, this is not just about Bill C-45 or even all the other Bills rammed through Parliament lately.

I'm going to go to the Idle No More page and click on "Manifesto":


We contend that:

The Treaties are nation to nation agreements between Canada and First Nations who are sovereign nations. The Treaties are agreements that cannot be altered or broken by one side of the two Nations. The spirit and intent of the Treaty agreements meant that First Nations peoples would share the land, but retain their inherent rights to lands and resources. Instead, First Nations have experienced a history of colonization which has resulted in outstanding land claims, lack of resources and unequal funding for services such as education and housing.

We contend that:

Canada has become one of the wealthiest countries in the world by using the land and resources. Canadian mining, logging, oil and fishing companies are the most powerful in the world due to land and resources. Some of the poorest First Nations communities (such as Attawapiskat) have mines or other developments on their land but do not get a share of the profit. The taking of resources has left many lands and waters poisoned -- the animals and plants are dying in many areas in Canada. We cannot live without the land and water. We have laws older than this colonial government about how to live with the land.

We contend that:

Currently, this government is trying to pass many laws so that reserve lands can also be bought and sold by big companies to get profit from resources. They are promising to share this time...Why would these promises be different from past promises? We will be left with nothing but poisoned water, land and air. This is an attempt to take away sovereignty and the inherent right to land and resources from First Nations peoples.


In short, this is what we have always been talking about. Whether the particular focus has been on housing, or education or the environment, or whatever else. What lies at the heart of all these issues is our relationship with Canada. And Canada? This relationship is abusive.

Things are not getting better. In fact, many of us feel that things are getting worse. Many of us feel that the reason things aren't getting any better, is because Canada has forgotten it is a Treaty nation too.

When the relationship between indigenous peoples and Europeans first began here, it was based on Treaties of Peace and Friendship. As indigenous peoples understand this relationship, it is one that should work to the mutual benefit of all involved. That relationship quickly became overshadowed by one more focused on extinguishing aboriginal rights, particularly as they relate to the land.

I am not speaking about events hundreds of years ago. I am telling you that Canada continues to focus on stripping away all of our rights and land while at the same time telling the world that it is doing the opposite.

In this document Canada clearly lays out its interests in any negotiations it enters into with indigenous people. The term "certainty" has replaced "termination," but the intent is still the same.

I can go find dismal statistics on pretty much any aspect of life for indigenous peoples in this country; trot them all out and say, "look it's really bad" and you will nod and say, "wow it sure is," but that still won't make it clear for you. I need you -- WE need you, to see the forest and not just the trees.

BLOG CONTINUES AFTER SLIDESHOW

Loading Slideshow...
  • Vancouver Rally


Aaron Paquette does a wonderful job of highlighting why this is not just about indigenous peoples. It is about everyone living in Canada:

This is much greater than angry protesting natives, this is about becoming aware of the world in which you live.


First they gutted the sciences, long term studies that would help us understand our ecosystem better so we could develop more responsibly, and no one said a word.

Then they cut funding for our shared history and those who work to preserve it, while at the same time dumping tens of millions of dollars into celebrating a British colony war that happened before we were even a country, and still no one said anything.

Then the world was made aware of the shameful conditions for small children growing up on underfunded, polluted Reservations. A small murmur and then nothing.

And now, because of the apathy they see, this government has taken galling steps to sell out our wilderness, our resources and sovereignty. And not even to the highest bidder. It's a yard sale with no regard for responsibility or care for anyone who might be negatively affected (in other words, all of us).

From millions of protected waterways a couple weeks ago, we now have hundreds. Yes, you read that right.

So why are Canada's Indigenous Peoples the only ones who are standing up? Why are they now the World's Protectors?


What are the issues? The issues are many. The issues are well documented. The issues have been studied and researched and reported on ad nauseum until we have literally filled libraries with the issues and the recommendations and words, words, words.

What is all boils down to is this: Canada has not committed itself to addressing the colonial relationship it still has with indigenous peoples. Canada is in denial about that relationship. I think it's fair to say that most Canadians believe that kind of relationship no longer exists. We are trying to tell you that you are wrong.

Contrary to popular perception, indigenous peoples are not just about blockades and protests. We have engaged in every dialogue Canada has been willing to enter into since before Canada was even a nation. When the requirements changed, often arbitrarily, we complied. When Canada pulled out of the structures it built, dumping years of work down the tubes only to decide to set up a different structure and begin again, we were there, at the table, ready to do it over.

This has gone on for too long. The Canadian government continues to mouth platitudes about its supposed dedication to this relationship, while it slashes funding, ignores our emergencies, pulls out of comprehensive land claim discussions, "consults" with us and then ignores everything we told them, all while pursuing a hard-line agenda which accepts only termination as a result.

We have been backed into a corner and we are literally fighting for our lives. We are literally dying, in so many preventable and unacceptable ways. I'm not being poetic or hyperbolic here and I don't just mean culturally. We are dying.

No one should expect us to stay quiet or polite about this. We have done what has been asked, we have played along to the constantly changing rules. It hasn't worked. It hasn't saved us. Idle No More is about saving ourselves.

We will continue to talk, and meet, and submit hundreds of thousands of reports each year...but we will also rise. We are rising. You will find that you have many issues in common with us, as Aaron pointed out. This is not us against you. This is hopefully all of us. Together.

This article was originally posted on the author's blog, âpihtawikosisân.

 
FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
Although thousands of indigenous people all over Canada rallied together under the banner of Idle No More on December 10, there has been very little media coverage on the movement. Most of what is bei...
Although thousands of indigenous people all over Canada rallied together under the banner of Idle No More on December 10, there has been very little media coverage on the movement. Most of what is bei...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 326
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
09:00 PM on 01/19/2013
Sorry this is start of mental illness because she is facing extream
depression and insult to her community and stress and anxiety
this strike over food can lead her to psychotic direction

someone need to stop her to save her life first
suicide is not going to resolve aboriginal problems

as long as she put some few days to take attention is enough

some one MUST help her before it is too late

her all organ can get damage if she continue and not seek any doctor to see her

poor woman need help first and quickly

then seat and resolve the aboriginal community problems second
aboriginal problems is not going to resolve in short term there is long term solution need to seek for them and in mean time only add their welfare cheque but watch them to not buy any more drug by give them more money

relocated them to empty building underconstruction ready to use in ontario

so many condomium are empty in Toronto by builder

find solution to problems not make it worst

angry and revenge is not justice but also aboriginal need justice to help rebuilt their community

histroy can not change but it is not fault of group of who are not belong TODAY to aboriginal community blame to histroy
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Harry Bradford
12:44 PM on 01/12/2013
"We are dying." I hear you, I BELIEVE you, and I am WITH you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
10:36 AM on 01/07/2013
Update:
http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/2013/01/07/attawapiskat-audit-theresa-spence_n_2424177.html

Another audit confirming what all of the other financial statement audits (freely available on their website if anyone is interested) have said: the Reserve leadership in Attawapiskat is either corrupt or financially incompetent.
08:59 PM on 01/05/2013
Even on a cursory review of the first page of the financial stement, on Schedule A, the administrative write-off for a bad debt in the amount of $440,110.00 is unusual and requires an explanation that has not been provided. That is not the sort of expense you expect to see under "administration". Who got the money. why and for what? We cannot tell.

Maybe everything is okay with the financial statements ... and maybe it isn't. I certainly cannot tell from reading the financial statement -- and with the greatest of respect -- YOU CANNOT EITHER. Please be careful about tying your own credibility to a document you did not create and cannot verify. You should know better. And if you didn't -- you do now.
03:12 AM on 01/03/2013
Idle No More update ~
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:40 PM on 01/01/2013
To tecchie, who moaned, “Your land, your sovereignty, your nation to nation talk, just annoys me.” Clearly, you’re clueless about Canada’s Indigenous people, who’ve withstood centuries of theft, lies, broken promises, disenfranchisement & genocide--for the material benefit of oblivious ingrates like you. You’re clueless about land rights, human rights, democracy, social justice, the right to self-determination & the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, which Canada signed in 2010. Here's a tip: Before spewing your doltish claptrap, know something about what you're lambasting. In 1996, the last of Canada's Indian boarding schools closed, after more than 100 yrs. of forcibly trying to "kill the Indian in the child" by kidnapping Native children from their families; punishing them for speaking their own languages; physically, sexually & psychologically abusing them; sterilizing them; failing to treat their illnesses & killing them. This disgraceful “chapter of integration” is recognized as genocide, but you probably don't know anything about that, since you live in a smug little bubble. You haven't a clue how the tribes of long ago lived. You don't even know how they live now. But it's all so tiring & annoying to you. Poor pitiful you. You get zilch sympathy. It's people of your ilk--self-righteous, lacking conscience & knowledge & full of your own superiority--who condone appropriation & genocide by being willfully blind & slavishly following "us versus them" propaganda. Your take is morally reprehensible & intellectually bankrupt.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
techhie
12:54 PM on 12/24/2012
This little rant on the part of the "First Nations" is very sad. It reminds me of the vitriol that comes from the mouths of diehard separatists in Quebec.Two hundred years of subjugation by the "English".

So just how far back do you want to go? There is no doubt the Indians lived here and elsewhere in Canada, but not as land owners as we understand it. The truth is there is a history of conflict among "First Nations" which would indicate the concept of "ownership" changed from war to war and battle to battle. Or are you trying to say the First nations were just one big happy family.

The story of the Indians in Canada is the story of conquered peoples around the globe. That is not to say they should be treated as second class citizens, but then they should not behave like them. Stop with the whining and the guilt trip you are trying to have me take. It doesn't work.

Successive government policies have led to the very concept of "First Nations" and it is getting very tired very fast. It is now almost 2013 and time to write a new chapter of integration. Your land, your sovereignty, your nation to nation talk, just annoys me.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:04 PM on 12/25/2012
Or, give it back because we broke every one of the rules that we brought so proudly from England.

What makes you think that you who, I presume, does not even live on resource-rich territory, is better qualified to look after it than people who managed for thousands of years?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
techhie
12:10 AM on 12/27/2012
I think you need to look up the word "manage".

And check your history with regard to the "rules" brought to North America by the British. Just what were they exactly?

And just how are you planning to give Vancouver "back"?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebbyM
09:50 AM on 12/28/2012
No one is suggesting that the way First Nations People lived eons ago was the be all and end all. Sure there was strife back then, BUT we entered into agreements and it sounds like by force of numbers and power, we changed the rules whenever we wanted to. Our signatures should be our words, but apparently most don't care about integrity because you don't seem too bothered by the allegations of our breaking those same agreements and that should be a source of shame for each and every one of us.

At this point in time, we have grown up enough to know how to do right and yet it seems that far too many are still insisting that might makes right and the rest should just 'suck it up' and crawl back under a rock quietly. To die perhaps??? Very nice....
07:39 PM on 12/22/2012
TREATIES ARE COVENENTS, WHICH ARE NOT TO BE BROKEN, UNLESS AGREED UPON.THEY SHOULD NEVER BE IMMORAL.~~ WHO WILL DWELL IN THE HOLY HILL WITH GOD.~~HE THAT SWEARS TO HIS OWN HURT AND DOES NOT TURN BACK.
04:47 PM on 12/22/2012
Sorry natives, but your plight has indeed taken a turn for the worse and WILL become even more overlooked. There probably is no turning back from this situation as the world gets smaller, for a lot of us, not just natives. You either adapt and become a soulless cog or a willing oppressor making your fortune off the backs of others, or your done. Sorry, just the way it is.
08:19 PM on 12/27/2012
If everybody thought like you do, this world would be even more messed up than it already is. There are a lot of obnoxious and stupid comments in this thread. I give the natives huge credit for being ticked off and willing to do something about it, and I hope they get more support. Otherwise we nonnatives too will be pushed aside while control freaks like Harper destroy anything good about Canada as we knew it and usher in an unprecedented era of greed and environmental and social destruction.
10:17 PM on 01/19/2013
He is very right, North America has followed that philosophy for a long time.
This comment has been removed.
photo
Liz Wilson 2
“a small group can change the world
04:27 PM on 12/16/2012
Chelsea Chief Spence is joined by Raymond Robinson, 57, from the Cross Lake First Nation who has been on a hunger strike since Thursday. There is so little attention paid to this issue. Do you have the ability to keep us posted

Thank you
03:26 PM on 12/13/2012
I find it interesting and discouraging that there so many unquestioned assumptions posted by those who assume that there is (a) nepotism and (b) grossly overpaid elected officials in most Indian band councils. In Attawapiskat, for instance, there was never any evidence in the end of either misuse of funds or nepotism - only a situation where a band council spend money on an emergency evacuation when the community's homes flooded (in large part due to sewage releases by the DeBeers mine), and never recouped those $ from Ottawa, which put it in a bad cash flow situation. I work with First Nations across the country and the number of Chiefs or band councillors who receive salaries that are on par with their neighbouring municipal, provincial or federal government officials are very, very few. The average Chief's salary is in the range of $30 - $40,000. How many mayors or premiers or federal mnisters do you know who receive that for a salary? Before people make harsh statements about nepotism and inflated salaries, they should check their facts. Just sayin'.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peas Family Buffet
It's simple...right or wrong!
08:03 PM on 12/13/2012
Where can we find the actual facts? The Canadian Taxpayer Magazie has published an article in 2011 about the salaries of most reserves. Do you think they have it completely wrong?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TwoZeroOZ
09:50 PM on 12/13/2012
"In Attawapiskat, for instance, there was never any evidence in the end of either misuse of funds"
Only large sums of money spent on the 18 Councillors and 1 mayor, with no proper record keeping.

Do you think its a coincidence that Chief Theresa keeps almost no record of expenditures while Attwapiskat band members are accusing their own leaders of mismanagement (among other things)?
12:33 PM on 12/16/2012
Where did you get this information? If you followed the whole story from start to finish you will know that the book were very much open and the Government in the end was proven wrong. It's like the Drunken Indian stories..everyone keeps repeating that as if it were fact, without really looking at all the drunken white people.
11:25 AM on 12/13/2012
As a foreigner looking in and not knowing what exactly this bill c45 is, i do see however a huge divide between the people of canada, its them (the whites) and us ( the ndns) its about time you all got on and faced the future together as 1 nation , it can be done whilst still keeping your culture and traditions...
07:42 PM on 12/13/2012
totally agree we are all people no matter what our color is we are all canadians
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Peas Family Buffet
It's simple...right or wrong!
08:14 PM on 12/13/2012
They way it is now and for quite sometime in the past it has been us and them. You are right things need to change because as a white man living in Canada they have a lot more rights and freedoms than I do. Special treatment in the legal system to be more leanient for commiting the same crime. How can you be integrated as 1 people when one of the eastern provinces want to split away because they speak a different language. Lots of people in Canada seem to be ok with the setup and be very tolerant and thats ok too.
08:41 AM on 12/13/2012
The new Omnibus Bill has a confusing air to it. Its definitely not for the layman, its put into a language not many can or willing to comprehend. The bill itself refers to amendments made to the original acts. So in order for a person to see what acts are amended under this bill one would have to refer both the original as well as the amendments made. That in essence doubles the 400+ pages of reading and trying to comprehend the language it is printed in. It is written as such to confuse and frustrate those that try to make sense of it all. This I believe is what the government is trying to do. It seems so..as so many amendments to many acts are lumped in with this bill. This only makes one suspicious of what the government is trying to hide and the unreasonable time frame to rush it through to get it passed. The Harper Government definitely doesn't have any scruples or regard for the people of this country whether it be Native or Non-Native. I know for certain the Senate south of the border pass bills that aren't even read because of the confusing doublespeak they are written in. Is this bill going to receive the same treatment?