Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Conrad Black

GET UPDATES FROM Conrad Black
 

Time's Fatuous and Egregious Coverage of Wall Street Prosecutor

Posted: 02/15/2012 7:18 am

For most of its history of nearly 90 years, Time magazine has been a staple for the smug, clichéd, only-in-America, lumpen bourgeoisie; the Mencken-roasted, Lucian masses always ready to believe that if it's American it must be the best, and if it's happening in America, it must be good.

As the wheezing, purblind, quasi-survivor of the palsied medium of the weekly newsmagazine, Time's deathbed achievement was outlasting Newsweek, its ancient foe, which opted for accidental suicide by dispensing with news altogether and imagining that commercially adequate numbers of people would pay for a glossy magazine composed of the boring opinions of undistinguished commentators. They didn't, and Time plods on into the sunset, relatively unvexed.

Its February 13 locker room pep talk for America featured the U.S. attorney in Manhattan, Preet Bharara, who "collars the masters of the meltdown." This is vintage Time: The good sheriff goes forth to avenge the wronged populace against the swindlers. People whose indictments are highlighted are implicitly pre-judged and convicted, Time's tokenistic contribution to poisoning the jury pool; no cleaving nostalgically to a presumption of innocence for the prosecution cheerleaders at Time.

It was the old Time formula that I remembered from more than 50 years ago when I tired of and stopped reading its treacle that recorded every week the latest milestone in the inexorable march of mid-America toward its apotheosis of gelatinous, platitudinous, universal, and permanent embourgeoisement: a premonitory Pleasantville. Thus Mr. Bharara: a passionate seeker of justice, exemplar of the American Dream (as if ambitious people from modest circumstances didn't get on in any other country), and a Bruce Springsteen fan who is also a full-time crusader for justice.

This is the happy story of this happy week: America's largest city has a federal prosecutor who is finally flinging into prison those responsible for the economic debacle that came upon us in 2008. Time thus throws its flyweight avoir du poids on the side of the political class in the lengthy finger-pointing and buck-passing contest between the politicians and the financial community about whose responsibility the crisis was.

The executive branch, mainly the Clinton administration, directed Fanny Mae and Freddie Mac (Newt Gingrich, millionaire company historian) to pour hundreds of billions of what was ultimately tax-guaranteed money into non-commercial (i.e. worthless) mortgages, and the administration and the Congress, both parties, joined in the legislated requirement that lending banks consign 25 per cent of their mortgages to the waste basket in the same promotion of home ownership (for which read the big political pay-off from the building trades and residential real estate speculators).

Mark to market was imposed on merchant banks along with the ability to borrow up to 30 times their equity, ensuring that as soon as a slide started, as it did at Lehman Brothers, alert short sellers could drive the target under by selling shares they didn't own and cover them as new and ever cheaper stock was issued to preserve the required ratio, all the way down the drain.

The political leadership, including the regulators, created the context in which the disaster was bound to occur. This does not whitewash the stupidity, venality, and cowardice of much of the financial community. "When the music's playing, everyone has to dance," said Citigroup's Mr. Prince, as the world's largest financial institution descended into insolvency, consoled by the presence as vice chairman of former Treasury secretary St. Robert Rubin; and, "We're doing God's work," said Goldman Sachs chairman Lloyd Blankfein, after his firm peddled huge quantities of worthless real estate-backed securities out the front window to its clients with a false investment grade certification from the (unprosecuted) rating agencies which are now sitting in pseudo-Solomonic judgment on the credit ratings of the countries of the world, while short-selling them out the back door for its own house account -- were just two examples.

But in the blame game, the political class locked arms to scream from the Capitol and White House steps and from the skyscraper tops that "greed" was the problem, in the private sector of course. The tangible encouragements heaped by unsound countrywide on, inter alia, Chris Dodd of Dodd Frank, didn't count -- i.e. the politicians aren't counting. And Attorney General Holder and his acolytes in the federal prosecution service such as Time's current cover heart-throb, set out to end the debate by indicting the opposition debating team, with the enthusiastic collusion of most of America's bovine, law and order-deluded national media.

Thus the instant pantheonizee, Preet Bharara, who is in fact chasing after alleged inside traders, an activity which had nothing to do with the economic crisis, "collars the masters of the meltdown." He may be a capable and even, against the odds, a principled prosecutor, but this fatuous bit of Time-puffery does not incite optimism on that score.

If Time had had the privilege of a Damascene bolt of revelatory lightning (that it did not mistake for a UFO), it would have mentioned, as more serious magazines such as the New Yorker's Adam Gopnick and the Economist recently have, that the U.S. criminal justice system is a compost-heap of corruption and hypocrisy. All is governed by the plea bargain system, the wholesale extortion and subornation of perjury in exchange for immunity or a reduced sentence. The Fifth, Sixth, and Eighth Amendment guaranties of the grand jury as an assurance against capricious prosecution, of no seizure of property without due compensation, of due process, an impartial jury, access to counsel, prompt justice, and reasonable bail, have long since shrivelled into figments of the imagination of the sentimental, without that erosion being noticed by the national media or even the Supreme Court.

Prosecutors routinely use false affidavits and ex parte proceedings to freeze defendants' assets, depriving them of the means for a defence. Most public defenders are stooges of the prosecutors, most defense counsel are court corridor chums of the prosecutors who spend most of their time holding up their side of the charade about the citizens' day in court and settling cases on a plea.

Prosecutors win over 90 per cent of their cases; about 90 per cent don't go to trial because it is such an unaffordably costly stacked deck; sentences are exorbitant. Most prosecutors would be disbarred in any other serious jurisdiction. The United States has six to 12 times as many incarcerated people per capita as Australia, Canada, France, Germany, Japan, or the United Kingdom, and probably one million of America's 2.5 million prisoners are held in objectively barbarous conditions.

There are 48 million Americans with a "record" hobbled to some degree and often severely, for life, no matter how long ago or innocuous the offense. (There is no excuse for a DUI of 20 years ago preventing someone from entering Canada. In Canada, incidentally, only 65 per cent of prosecutions are successful, and only 40 per cent of those lead to a custodial sentence.)

The prosecutocracy, in which, ex officio, no one plays a more prominent role than the U.S. attorney in Manhattan, has hijacked the rights of the people of the land of the free with the enthusiastic -- if often witless -- complicity of much of the media, including Time, ever the quavering national town crier of "America's century."

Since I count it as an honour to be a vocal victim of this appalling system, and to write this piece from the federal prison where I have been sent, (for a few more weeks), despite the fact that all counts against me were abandoned, rejected by jurors, or vacated by a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court, (in another magic surprise of U.S. justice), and frequent readers would have seen comments similar to these from me here and elsewhere before, I must reassure you that I have not become senescently repetitive or descended into autocue.

I revisit this subject because Time awarded me a miscast cameo role in its lionization of Mr. Bharara, in the highest traditions of their infamous "fact-checking department." (Only at Time do facts need to be checked.) Thus was brought to my attention: "U.S. Attorneys in Houston took advantage of a relatively new law that made it a crime to deprive shareholders of honest services. Down went Enron CEO Jeff Skillings and Hollinger's Conrad Black on honest services fraud and other charges."

The statute in question goes back to an interpretation of 1941 -- which after being reversed by the Supreme Court in 1987, was re-legislated by Joe Biden on Christmas Eve, 1988 -- and had nothing to do with shareholders, but was designed to punish public officials who took bribes. When the Supreme Court struck down and rewrote the statute and vacated my few counts that survived the trial, and sent them back to the Circuit Court for the assessment of the gravity of its errors, one spurious mail fraud charge and an even more fatuous obstruction charge were self-servingly retrieved by the most notorious egomaniac and sociopath on the federal bench (who described himself as "callous" and "cruel" in a famous interview with a New Yorker writer 10 years ago). Black didn't go down; the malformed statute did. This was a side issue in Mr. Skillings' case.

Time gets to some of this inconvenience in its cover story, in its way: "History shows a mixed record for forward-leaning prosecutors," (a category that is defined to include America's most renowned public masturbator, Eliot Spitzer), "and Appeals courts rolled back some" (i.e. vacated all)" of the honest services fraud convictions related to...Conrad Black." This is vintage and unchanging Time, and consistent with the rest of the piece, as the "facts" are fitted like a figure-hugging body stocking onto the subject of the hagiography.

The fraudulent conviction of the late Senator Ted Stevens was referred to as "unsuccessful," which it was, after he lost reelection by a hair's breadth. "Prosecutorial witness-rigging" is mentioned, but not the failure of the court-appointed investigator to recommend prosecution of the prosecutors, because the trial judge did not admonish them to "obey the law." The transcript reveals that this was because the prosecutors said that they knew not to break the law without being admonished, as they broke the law.

It would have been somewhat persuasive if Time had waved the incense pot around Mr. Bharara while at least hinting at the moral bankruptcy of much of the American prosecutorial system in which he works. But that would be hard to square with the Disney World Fantasyland of America Time has been exuding and secreting since it sprang whole from the robustly wholesome imaginations of co-founders Henry Luce and Briton Hadden when the "American Century" was young, and "fact-checking" had not, "as it must to all men," become tedious (and therefore, to Time, superfluous).

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 81
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
10:24 PM on 02/19/2012
Sour grapes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
darttabb
Alcohol, Tobacco, & Firearms. Where's the chips?
08:28 PM on 02/19/2012
Well, that should make Mr. Black and his thesaurus feel better.

Now, where's my TIME for this week?
07:52 PM on 02/19/2012
Wow, such a lot of sound and fury ...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
free reign
My country tis of thee!
05:49 PM on 02/19/2012
OJ got locked up in Las Vegas. I guess our system isn't perfect, but sometimes even if treasonous elements bought tax code and deregulation to allow them to rob millions of hard working Americans of their earned and held wealth, some tiny little, innocuous safety net catches them before the flush free into impunity.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:17 PM on 02/19/2012
Me thinks Mr. Black doth protest too much.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zooots999
11:16 AM on 02/19/2012
i agree with many of your comments regarding the problems with the US justice system, Mr Black. the problem is that not enough influential conservatives like yourself have done anything to change this system. right now, our prisons are in the process of being turned into private 'for profit' enterprises - a VERY dangerous thing that not nearly enough people are going to fight back against until they find themselves (as you did) on the wrong side of that door. i cannot help but feel you have, in some sense, been hoisted by your own petard.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
free reign
My country tis of thee!
06:44 PM on 02/19/2012
Of course. That system will be fixed as soon as it starts prosecuting bankers. Just like how the lechers that plundered millions of Americans life savings, through successive heists, justice is only performed on the crooks that robbed the rich. Madoff, and numerous con artists rubbing elbows on the Phila. Main Line, and other wealthy outlying counties, are in jail. The racketeers that are streaming and pirating property from millions, not millions from a few, walk scott-free. Cute.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
zooots999
04:06 PM on 02/20/2012
couldn't agree more
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
gutenmorgen
a.k.a. crowsnest
09:03 AM on 02/19/2012
The fact that the U.S. public once began to buy huge numbers of Japanese and German cars dismembers your thesis.
02:05 AM on 02/19/2012
The state of civil liberties and due process in American is far worse than most Americans imagine. The incredible discretion of prosecutors in deciding which cases to pursue and which to ignore, the incredible resources available to prosecutors to prosecute the cases they choose, the cobweb of laws and statutes that no ordinary citizen is aware of, the enormous expense of defense in criminal cases and the tendency of judges to incarcerate defendants who should be candidates for supervised probation are only the surface of the problem.

All crime is to some degree political. The twenty years given to a second-offense petty criminal vs. the probation given to a corporation executive who swindled stockholders and employees out of millions of dollars, jobs and pensions is the most obvious example. The criminal justice complex exployees hundreds of thousands of people whose jobs and futures depend upon a steady supply of fodder for the prisons. The long food chain beginning with the beat policeman all the way of to the District Attorney depends on a criminal justice system that creates laws to enforce, enforces them and punishes offenders. The majority of these laws didn't exist not too many years ago because they weren't necessary and most of them are not necessary now. The criminal justice system as operated in the United States desperately needs reform.
08:00 AM on 02/19/2012
All crime is political. Superstitions aside, all crime is defined, prosecuted and punished by men/women and their political institutions. The vatican did it. The Kings and Monarchs did it, now in America the people through their representatives do it.

That said, I doubt that the US is as bad as as countries run by the elitist vestiges of the oligarchies in say Canada and Europe which have no constitutions to impede their ruler's control over their subjects with arbitrary laws that would not pass Constitutional muster here.
08:55 PM on 02/19/2012
Typically ignorant comment by the sort of typically ignorant American
that CB writes about.Yes, the justice systems in Europe and Canada
are not simply "just as good" as that of the US, they are much better.
And this may be a news flash for you, but most European countries
do have constitutions, and do not have "rulers" - they have democratically
elected officials (who are, moreover, not bought and paid for by Wall
Street and the merchants of war, as is the case in the US).
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mrbarolo
01:23 AM on 02/19/2012
Another steaming load of self-serving, self-righteous indignation from the greatest, most self-infatuated snob outside of the works of Somerset Maugham.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Debra Moore
Play nicely or go away....
11:29 AM on 02/19/2012
Hahaha, an apt description and an especially enjoyable reference to Maugham. (As I drudged through the torturously torrid prose, I wondered, "This stuff reminds of a writer from one of my grad school English lit classes—who the hell is it?" Then you mentioned Somerset, and my brain said, "Ahhhhhhh....")
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
free reign
My country tis of thee!
06:06 PM on 02/19/2012
Whew. This is not the showcase of excellent command of the English language.
We, foxhunters call a run like that, "heavy going."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
georgeny
01:04 AM on 02/19/2012
Once again, most of what Black says is extremely insightful and correct. But it is saddening that it looks like a lot of comments, once again, attack him as an individual and have no comment on what he actually says. And remember when one dismisses Black as "convicted felon," but after all the time and money spent on this man, isn't the only count that still stands "obstruction of justice," which in his case means he actually had the gall to make the government try and prove what was initially charge under a crime that was void for vagueness.
08:29 AM on 02/19/2012
His conviction for obstruction of justice was not overturned for vagueness but was affirmed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
georgeny
11:15 AM on 02/19/2012
Yes, but didn't the justice he allegedly obstructed involve "justice" that shouldn't have occurred in the first place. All he really did was take the prosecutor to task, which should not be a crime at all
03:23 PM on 02/19/2012
Who can blame a reader for trying to discern the bloviation from the substance, the pretense from the prescient? Denser than an over-baked oatmeal cookie that rips the flesh from your palate, Black offers very little chamomile tea to sooth the overblown and twisted path of words for words sake. He'd benefit from studying Hemingway's writing to reassure himself that people can know how smart he is without forcing them to find him in the goose down that hides his assertions and makes his readers' noses itch with a longing to simply move on to another writer.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
free reign
My country tis of thee!
06:17 PM on 02/19/2012
We can't help bt peek, to take note and assess his position. The words are to be wielded as swords. No matter how heavy or strong the sword, it's direction is all important and determines the legitimacy of the swing. He has a stock of sharp swords, which take alot of dramatic swaths.
06:29 AM on 02/17/2012
Hey Conrad, getting screwed by the "justice" system in the US is no party, but you might at least show a bit of humble gratitude for the fact that you are not also poor and uneducated.
Jack Canuckski
Canadian Observer of the passing scene
04:06 AM on 02/17/2012
I wonder what Mr. Black's view of the US justice system was before he himself became entangled in it.

I know that Mr. Black prides himself as being a conservatives. Canada's Conservatives have long been known for their "tough on crime" philosophy, which has presently come back to bite them. I don't know about Mr. Black himself, who may, before he became involved in the business end of the American so called justice system, have been more enlightened, but if I recall, his newspaper, The National Post, generally shared the sentiments of the Conservatives on virtually all matters, including the justice system.
08:33 AM on 02/19/2012
Fascinating that Canada holds secret trials and its civilian prosecutors can indeterminately detain people by merely filing a 'security certificate".

Of course Mr. Obama by signing our military detention bill is playing catch up.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:57 PM on 02/16/2012
FBI IS THREATENING TO SEND A 71 YEAR OLD FLORIDA MAN TO PRISON FOR "MORTGAGE FRAUD"!
THE BANKS GET BAILOUTS AND THE LITTLE INVESTOR GET'S A "DEATH SENTENCE"!

"A PRISON SENTENCE FOR ME WITH MY MEDICAL PROBLEMS IS A DEATH SENTENCE! " SAYS THE 71 YEAR OLD FORMER FLORIDA REAL ESTATE INVESTOR.
IT'S NOT FAIR; THE FBI AND IRS HAVE BEEN HARASSING ME FOR 5 YEARS AND ARE NOW THREATENING TO SEND ME TO PRISON FOR 5 YEARS! I FEEL I WAS A VICTIM OF THE REAL ESTATE PROFESSIONALS (REALTORS, MORTGAGE BROKERS, APPRAISERS AND LENDERS) WHO WERE AFTER MY MONEY AND 700 CREDIT SCORE AND LURED ME IN WITH EASY, NO-MONEY DOWN, SUB-PRIME, MORTGAGE LOANS TO BUY OVERPRICED HOMES IN AN INFLATED REAL ESTATE MARKET, WHICH QUICKLY CRASHED LEAVING ME WITH MULTIPLE FORECLOSURES , BROKE AND NO CREDIT!
FTR
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
free reign
My country tis of thee!
06:32 PM on 02/19/2012
No different than all Americans. The Fed pirated OUR held wealth to run us into the ground years ago.
What party even defends your property? Reps? Dems? Only OWS at this point.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:15 PM on 02/20/2012
What is OWS?
02:15 PM on 02/16/2012
Amazed to learn that A) Mr. Black seems to be doing so well as an ex con and B) That anyone still thinks of Time as an influential publication. So dear.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jack Hope
Occasionally quoted by Mainstream Media
01:38 AM on 02/19/2012
Prisoner Black is not technically an "ex-con." He is still currently a guest of the Federal Correction Institute of Miami.

You can locate him using this handy webpage: http://www.bop.gov/iloc2/LocateInmate.jsp
02:09 PM on 02/16/2012
Comments about our "prosecutocracy" are spot on. If so many sanctimonious people in America think putting more people in prisons than Stalin's Gulag is fine, then we should not preach human rights to other countries.

After reading some of these comments, I see so much venom ... so sad!

God save our country!
03:10 PM on 02/16/2012
t
08:34 AM on 02/19/2012
Let Freedom Ring!

Set them all free.