Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Craig and Marc Kielburger

GET UPDATES FROM Craig and Marc Kielburger
 

Behind the Headlines: Why Chief Theresa Spence Is Hunger Striking

Posted: 12/17/2012 12:49 am

Behind The Headlines: The social causes in current events.

In a unique take on daily news hits, Free The Children co-founders Craig and Marc Kielburger go behind the headlines to explore how the stories you read are connected to the causes you care about. You'll never read the news in the same way again.

The headline that caught our attention: Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence begins hunger strike: "I am willing to die for my people."

As we write, Chief Theresa Spence begins her sixth day without food. In the middle of a chilly December she's making her stand in a tepee on Ottawa's Victoria Island to secure a meeting with Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

In the scale of protest, a hunger strike is about a Defcon Two. Anyone willing to put her own health -- and life -- at risk to make a point isn't fooling around.

In October 2011, Attawapiskat First Nation declared a state of emergency. With temperatures plummeting, families lived in tents and uninsulated shacks without electricity, heat, clean water or sanitation.

More than a year later, 22 modular houses have been built, but according to Attawapiskat elder Danny Metatawabin there has been little other progress. He told us many families still live in overcrowded houses or unheated shacks, and the water from the taps is still undrinkable.

However, the story behind the headline is that Chief Spence's hunger strike is not simply about the appalling conditions her people continue to face. Spence is one of many aboriginal leaders looking for a way to express her frustration with the Government of Canada passing laws that affect their lives and land, as well as violating treaty rights without involving them in any of the decision making.

Last January, 170 aboriginal chiefs and leaders sat down in Ottawa with Governor General David Johnston, Prime Minister Stephen Harper and 12 cabinet ministers to reset the relationship between First Nations and the federal government.

Shawn Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations (AFN), tells us this Crown-First Nations Gathering was an historic event that gave Canadian aboriginal community leaders hope they might be entering a new era of cooperation and respect with the government.

Their hopes were bolstered after the conference when Prime Minster Harper said that "fundamental change requires that we redouble our collaboration with First Nations to develop the elements upon which our renewed relationship will be based."

However in the months that have followed, Atleo says the government-aboriginal collaboration has not redoubled, it has retreated.

The AFN national chief points to a long list of legislation introduced by the government on issues like the financial management of aboriginal bands. While aboriginal groups support many of the principles behind these laws, such as accountability and transparency, Atleo says the laws were drafted without any prior consultation or consent from the aboriginal communities whose are directly impacted.

"These patterns of 'government knows best' harken back to the Indian Act 100 years ago, and to residential schools," Atleo argues.

The latest legislative irritant is Bill C-45 -- the government's omnibus bill that lumps together a menagerie of legislation into one big package. C-45 includes changes to the Indian Act and the laws governing aboriginal fisheries. The Bill was introduced in October and just passed Third Reading this past week.

"Our government has been hard at work modernizing legislation in order to allow First Nations and aboriginal organizations to operate at the speed of business," Aboriginal Affairs Minister John Duncan said in a recent speech.

According to Atleo, the government's actions actually violate constitutionally-entrenched aboriginal treaty rights, not to mention the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, which repeatedly states that governments must obtain the "free, prior and informed consent" of aboriginal peoples before passing laws that affect their lives."And consent doesn't just mean a drive-by consultation," says Atleo.

Aboriginal groups are also unhappy with the changes C-45 makes to the Navigable Waters Act. The Act provided protection against harmful development for all of Canada's more than two million lakes and rivers by requiring environmental assessments. C-45 limits that protection to just 159 specific lakes and rivers. First Nations like Attawapiskat, which sits downriver of the Ring of Fire mining projects, worry the changes will bring even more development and environmental devastation to the waterways that are integral to their communities.

Atleo says more than 80,000 aboriginal people in Canada still need homes, 200 communities need schools, and more than 120 communities can't drink the water from their taps. The only way to solve these problems, he argues, is for aboriginal leaders and government to collaborate as partners.

Speaking with Atleo and Metatawabin it's impossible to miss the frustration as they look back on a year that started with so much promise. "It's getting demoralizing," says Metatawabin.

The AFN has launched a campaign called "Idle No More" that calls the federal government to"honour and fulfill Indigenous sovereignty which protects the land and water." Demonstrations by aboriginals and supporters are springing up across Canada.

Spence, meanwhile, is avoiding interviews and rallies, conserving her energy while she waits for the Prime Minister to answer her call to come to the table.

Craig and Marc Kielburger are founders of international charity andeducational partner, Free The Children. Its youth empowerment event,We Day, is in eight cities across Canada this year, inspiring more than100,000 attendees. For more information, visit www.weday.com

Loading Slideshow...
  • Vancouver Rally

 

Follow Craig and Marc Kielburger on Twitter: www.twitter.com/craigkielburger

FOLLOW CANADA IMPACT
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:30 AM on 01/06/2013
Maybe the Government should stop any oil, gold, uranuim etc. research in the North then we will see how bad things will be for the Indians of Canada. Be happy with all the money you are receiving from these companies and maybe work with them to help your people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Johnny LaRue
political correctness is just incorrect
09:20 AM on 12/26/2012
If people live in a rural or wilderness area they cannot expect big city amenities. If someone decides to live there then there are sacrificies and benefits. Expecting the rest of the country to provide this things when it is not realistic is the problem. Any town or village that has few employment oppertunities will shrink as people leave. They may not want to but it is not society's job to give them a lifestyle they haven't earned.
06:43 PM on 12/29/2012
You're ignorant if you think they are simply choosing to live "in the wilderness". Why not do a little research on the history of the horrible treatment of First Nations people before you start criticizing their "choices". Asking for drinkable water and heating should not be considered unrealistic. Clearly you were born without a capacity for empathy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Johnny LaRue
political correctness is just incorrect
09:56 AM on 12/30/2012
Asking people to pay for others so they can live in a tough environment with big city ammentities is wrong. If the lifestyle is to hard,leave. Getting others to pay for a life style that is not self sufficent, be it actors or artists in the city that can't draw enough intertest to pay the bills or  to people that live where there is no work or facilities  is typical Canadian sense of entitlement and it is wrong.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frnkndad
08:45 AM on 12/26/2012
I understand and agree with the frustration of the first nations peoples. But at a recent protest I saw many atemts at creating sound bites, but no real focus. I was a little concerned, because, what I'd read in the media lead me to believe this would be a movement that all Canadians would rally to.
I started talkign to people.
In a completely unscientific survey.
I asked 9 people why they were protesting. All 9 mentioned 'Idle no more'. None could explain what it was. 2 people mentioned bill C-45, but neither of them could tell me what it was about.

When I asked about Chief Spence, I was told how terrible it was that she was being starved (the same 2 people who had heard of C-45 thought she was in custody)

Idle no more could be great.

It IS needed.

But right now, al it is is protesting for the sake of protesting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cinderelladressmaker
02:27 AM on 12/26/2012
I have no respect for Chief Spence. I find it even hard to call her Chief.
She and her friends and family lived high off the hog while she let the rest of the people on her reservation live in squalor! She mismanaged the gov't funds.
It is said that the fact that we are not hearing from other Chiefs regarding her hunger strike is that they also don't have any respect for her.
I hope this movement grows and is successful. But please do not align yourselves with her. She is doing this to win sympathy when we should still be disgusted by her past actions.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Ike Awgu
10:28 PM on 12/25/2012
Where was Chief Theresa Spence's "hunger strike" when the people of Attawapiskat First Nation were living in third world conditions for years? "Idle No More" should also be about holding leaders (Chief Theresa Spence) accountable for their incompetence.
08:52 PM on 12/21/2012
This Movement was not started by the AFN it was the work of 4 young female Native lawyers from Saskatoon, it is not politician led, it is a grassroots movement. For many First Nation people the AFN is looked upon as inept and self-serving, granted they receive the bulk of the medias attention however they dont have the support of the Native majority.
05:00 PM on 12/18/2012
To express solidarity and support towards Chief Theresa Spence in her hunger strike for Native Rights, perhaps you would be willing to send Mr. Harper a Christmas card request on her behalf.

pm@pm.gc.ca
Subject heading: Christmas Greetings request for Chief Theresa Spence

Dear Mr. Harper,

As winter has descended upon us, I would like to extend a request for the Prime Minister's office to dispatch a merry holiday greeting to Attawpaskat Chief Theresa Spence (post-haste) so that she may warm up this season. I would suggest however that this card be made from recycled paper and printed with vegetable based inks to be friendly with the environment and non-carcinogenic if Mrs. Spence requires a source of fuel to literally stay warm.

Attawpaskat Chief Theresa Spence
Victoria Island, Ottawa, ON, K1R 6K4

Sincerely,
01:22 PM on 12/18/2012
reading this after having read that Harper pulled Canada out of the Kyoto agreement, I become scared of Harper's government. he's leading us down the same destructive path the US is leading. God help us all.
09:46 AM on 12/18/2012
Capitalizing Aboriginal is the first step you can take to recognizing Indigenous sovereignty and decolonizing yourself.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
All Seeing Guy
Center of the storm
12:29 AM on 12/26/2012
aboriginal
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:44 AM on 12/18/2012
People of Greenpeace (The Netherlands) were in Alberta to live with and talk to the aboriginal people who are in trouble because of the oil multinationals who are taking away their land to get oil out of the ground. We saw the docu on t.v. in The Netherlands. Oil multinationals who want to take lakes and rivers from the native people for oil-tankers to go through...Hundreds kilometres of woods have changed into oilsands and lakes with poisonous chemicals. Oil-industry is more important then the earth and the waters. That's capitalism...
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kapjam
09:28 AM on 12/18/2012
Your trip to the land of myth sounds very interesting. Can you actually give us one example of an oil company taking away native lands from natives? Why didn't you also mention the FN communities that have sold rights to oil complanies with incredible dividends paid yearly to all band members?

Stick to whale boats and leave the real issues to the grownups.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:39 AM on 12/19/2012
I didn't go to Canada, but people from Greenpeace. Excuse me for my bad English (but I guess you don't speak Dutch) All I mean to say is: Many countries in the world are making use of oil from oilsands in Alberta.(I don't know exactly which countries) It's very bad for the environment, so governments must find another way to get their energy out of. Where there was green forest before there is now only oilsands. The government wants to make an oilpipeline from Canada to the US, which runs through beatifull nature areas...If the oilpipe will start leaking...I am just saying.

http://watchdogprogressive.com/2012/01/photos-of-before-after-of-tarsands-mining-in-alberta-canada/
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
north of 60
Quando Omni Flunkus Moritati
11:43 PM on 12/17/2012
She is not healthy, loosing weight will do her a lot of good. It might even improve her perspective on life.
03:08 PM on 12/18/2012
The word is "losing",with one "o". "Loosing" would mean releasing something that was tight,or restrictive. For example,one could say that loosing the blindfold might allow someone to see more clearly and therefore be more understanding and compassionate.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]