Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Daniel Alexandre Portoraro

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel Alexandre Portoraro
 

With Garneau Gone, the Liberal Party Is Truly Lost

Posted: 03/14/2013 8:06 am

My congratulations to Justin Trudeau. My condolences to the Liberal Party of Canada. With Marc Garneau's recent withdrawal from the race for the party leadership, the "battle" is all but won for the Terrible Thing from Papineau.

Yes, there is still Martha Hall Findlay, and Joyce Murray is somewhere there, too. I hear there are another four candidates vying for the top job under the red tent, but recent medical reports suggest they might be suffering from delusions of political grandeur.

Everyone knows, come April, the leader of a party in dire straits, a broken-down party -- which is in desperate need of rebuilding its relationship with Canadians -- will be Justin Trudeau.

We all knew this from the start. But Marc Garneau offered a glimmer of hope for the optimists amongst us who wished to see a Liberal who might give the Conservatives a run for their money in 2015. As Jonathan Kay noted in his column yesterday, the once-astronaut, the once-president of the Canadian Space Agency, the once-naval captain, and physics engineer was a policy junkie's wet dream.

Garneau knew he could not win on flash -- he had none. So instead, he threw himself whole-heartedly in dealing with issues, economic and social, which affect us every day in the hopes that Canadian voters might think to themselves, "Hey, this guy might look like my father, but he's got some great ideas."

BLOG CONTINUES AFTER SLIDESHOW

Loading Slideshow...


For one, he sought to fight the telecommunication companies; you know, those service providers that gouge you month after month for your insurmountably high cell phone bill. He wanted to open the doors to the competition, and let you -- yes, you! -- the customer get a better deal for your money. Garneau knew he could not tempt the female vote with brunette curls, so instead, he announced policies that would seek to minimize, if not completely abolish, the pay gap between genders (81 cents for every dollar a man earns). Furthermore, the MP from Westmount sought to create a woman's council to advise him on certain issues. This may sound like political hogwash, but I should think it is a somewhat more proactive way to deal with gender matters than to pose for photographs with fangirls.

Marc Garneau, November 2012 to March 2013, sought policies that would help curb youth unemployment by offering incentives to companies to hire young people. If there's one thing retarding the progress of my generation, it's students with bachelor degrees who are forced to brew coffee for a living. For immigrants, he came up with the idea of devising a loan system in which foreigners might turn their credentials into recognized ones in Canada. He sought to cut payroll tax for small businesses, as well as abolish taxes on capital gains for investments in start-ups so that companies such as Blackberry needn't be this country's sole claim to fame in the realm of technology (and what a pitiful claim).

But naturally, none of this was as attractive to the Liberal voter as, say, a man of 41 who can throw a right-hook. Think about this for a second. Liberals placed the future of their party in the hands of a once-drama teacher who can rile up a crowd (but not enough, clearly, to ensure that they register to vote!) instead of a man who, over the course of his 64 years, proved himself time and time again in various fields and who, if he met presidents and leaders of state, got to that point due to his personal accomplishments, as opposed to being the plus-one of a prime minister in life and in death.

But what the insistence of Trudeau's supporters has ensured is that, come 2015, the Liberal Party of Canada will not be the party in power. Garneau was the candidate who could have swayed lukewarm Conservatives to the red camp, but Trudeau is a man who forces voters to say, as a friend of mine did, "This might be the first time I find myself voting blue. I never thought I'd see the day."

We can envision the attack ads already: "Do you want an untested man leading the country?" "Would you really put your nation's future in the hands of a man who has no callouses? A man to whom everything was given, if not by his father, then by friends of his father?" "Are you sure you want those brown locks of social media to stand alongside the world leaders during the next G8?" "Will Trudeau share plan for foreign policy with the President of the United States, or just ask him to follow him on Twitter?"

Answer me this, does any Canadian want to hear from a cherub face that his country will go to war? Obviously, this is an extreme example, but it is one that will be stuck in the backs of Canadians' minds when they go to the ballots. Trudeau may exude attractiveness, but his is the type you might find intriguing at the bar, not when it comes to making serious political decisions. And at this point, the last thing Canadians want is an experienced leader heading a broken party. A leader, I'm forced to mentioned, which has yet to give Canadians a reason to say "No" to the Boys in Blue next election -- besides a smile, of course.

I have quite a few Trudeau supporters on my social media streams -- and yes, before you ask, they're quite politically-minded -- yet, I cannot remember a single instance in which one of them posted something about Trudeau other than a picture of him standing alongside the MP. Go on, ask one of your Trudeau-supporting neighbors exactly what it is about the man that makes him fit to lead this country. As I've noted in a previous piece, the Terrible Thing from Papineau is unable to answer the question himself, so maybe one of his diehard followers might be better suited.

But what truly makes Garneau's withdrawal and Trudeau's win by default so heart-wrenching is that it is a testament to the Liberals of my generation. Time and time again, millenials have been given the opportunity to make a name for themselves, to shove their stake in the soil of political history. There was Occupy, which turned into a wasted effort, an ideological abortion, which did nothing but turn parks into landfills and drive up Twitter traffic. There were the protests in Quebec which were squabbles over meagre tuition rises which ended with a quasi-fascistic minority government taking over the reins of the province. And now, there was an opportunity for millenials to help create a new Canada in 2015. They could have supported the quiet, steadfast, solid candidate who might not have been flashy, but would have shown the world that we can be a mature group that votes with its head, as opposed to a "Like" button. But to consider concrete policies would have been too complex. So instead, the millenials placed their bet with Trudeau, the archetypal politician who says nothing of value, but, God, he says it oh-so-well, and it feels so good to listen to him communicate about the importance of communication.

Garneau's receding into the political background should be the shame of Liberal voters everywhere. After all, they know full well their party must undergo a serious period of rebuilding its relationship with Canadians. Garneau had the acumen, skills, and -- most importantly --policies to do this; Trudeau has but the experience of seeing his name in lights. If this piece sounds like a eulogy, it's because it is; but not for Marc Garneau, but rather, for the prospect of the Liberals' brighter future in 2015.

 

Follow Daniel Alexandre Portoraro on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dportoraro

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 88
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greenmonk
The Only Thing We Have to Fear Is Fear Itself
05:11 PM on 03/17/2013
Joyce Murray is the ONLY hope for the country. The only candidate that puts the Country before her party. The only candidate that supports Strategic Voting for a one time strategy together with the NDP and the Greens. Then she will set up a new Proportional Representation system so that never again will Canadians have to suffer through an extremist ideologue like Harper winning with a minority of votes.

Even if she doesn't win, I implore my fellow Canadians to still embrace Strategic Voting in your own riding to vote for the non-Conservative that has the best chance to win.
06:45 PM on 03/17/2013
Yeah, the NDP would love that. People can choose for themselves if they want to vote strategically. It shouldn't be imposed by the parties.

The Liberals have governed Canada on their own in the past and they can do so again in the future.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
greenmonk
The Only Thing We Have to Fear Is Fear Itself
03:17 PM on 03/18/2013
No, the NDP doesn't love it. At least at the top. Similar to the Liberals. The Hubris in both parties is palatable. Because those at the top are always thnking more about their careers than the country.
The point is to get rid of Harper. Its a one time strategy. You can have your favorite pet party after for years to come, don't worry.

But the second part of her plan is perhaps even more important. Setting up a proportional representation voting system. That way, even if two or three parties have to vote together, at least the Cons will be marginalized to the same degree that they are in society.
01:33 PM on 03/16/2013
Lol!!!

This from a kid whose chief writing credit seems to be the David Frum Forum!

Neo-con Twinkies forever!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
10:06 AM on 03/15/2013
The level of arrogance and disrespect being shown towards Justin will only get worse as the year goes on, that is if it doesn't backfire before the year is over.

People don't think of the fact that this is a democracy. The entire notion that ANY elected official is not worthy of PM is undemocratic. People elect every MP, and those people probably like to believe that their MP could one day be PM. So, when someone takes the plunge and sacrifices part of their family/personal life to lead a party, we should respect that no matter who it is. It's fair to criticize him on experience, but to just shoot down his entire political career because of his last name is just weak politics and likely won't work.. Canadians can see his sincerity when he speaks and it seems like he genuinely cares unlike Harper or Mulcair who constantly look like they're just looking for easy political points.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
07:58 AM on 03/16/2013
it might backfire......Canadians are getting tired of negativity and secrecy methinks......I am not sure how Canadians will look at attack ads aimed at a man we all grew up with and whose father still is considered the best PM ever ( according to several polls and surveys)
06:50 PM on 03/17/2013
It's going to be just like the boxing match. They will make fools of themselves under-estimating Justin. I agree that the attacks are going to backfire on the Cons. There will be no loud backlash but the polls will reflect Canadians opinion of Harper's disgusting behavior.
07:28 AM on 03/15/2013
Justin is the right man for the job, we don't need substance in the Prime Minister, we need substance in the Prime Minister,s advisors. Mark Garneau would be good as a dictator not as as person who can bathe in the filth of politics and bureaucrats and come out smelling like a rose.
09:06 PM on 03/14/2013
what is justin going to offer besides empty rethoric?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ProgressiveCDN
A Progressive Moderate
09:54 AM on 03/15/2013
Empty rhetoric?? How about a rallying cry for all Canadians who want a government not governed by ideology, instead governed by facts and science and rational debate... Not the dictatorship we have now.

It's the mass appeal that the other parties fear... Canadian politics is volatile like that. This idea that he is an empty suit becomes null & void after you meet with the man or see him in person. I've shaken the hands of a lot of politicians, and Justin Trudeau was the first one to actually ask me my name... It seems like a small thing, but it's this relatable persona that will attract Canadians.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
08:02 AM on 03/16/2013
yup..saw him give a speech 2 years ago.....since then I have often wished he would run......young blood...electable.... a team player........sense of humor....and can REALLY pack a room and fundraise............honestly for me it's all about who can beat Harper
10:13 PM on 03/16/2013
so justin is not driven by ideology but conservatives are - please. justin is steeped in liberalism so that's fine but anything else is not, right? justin doesn't come out as he really has a platform. so far all his 'wins' are thanks to his name, nothing else. his shear lack of experience will show very soon.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
08:00 AM on 03/16/2013
a talented cabinet for one thing....maybe one that believes in science
10:14 PM on 03/16/2013
and what makes you say that present government doesn't?
04:44 PM on 03/14/2013
Island Cynic: How many people do you know? And 'terrified' is a word that you probably dug up out of your own subconscious.
We are NOT terrified, expectant, maybe; 'hopeful' also .....that cynics (you called it!) such as you, will not rule the day.
It truly IS a 'new day'. We have a winner!
Hurrah!
04:37 PM on 03/14/2013
You could not be more wrong in your analysis, Daniel.
The LPC will rise again and like so many times in history (most times) assume their 'rightful mantle' as Canada's premium party.
It is written.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dennis Schmunk
03:21 PM on 03/14/2013
Never was a 'contest' to begin with. Chretiens bagmen had already delivered the money and memberships that go with it to win long before the debates.

The formulaic bromance of the older patron giving over to the young turk has been done to soap opera effects in much more poignant style. But give the Quebecer their due. They actually believe their own hubris.
03:14 PM on 03/14/2013
I do not know anyone that supports Trudeau for PM. They are all terrified that this will happen.
Trudeau will be a very polarizing figure as you either believe in him or not. The leadership was won on social media popularity, not on issues and abilities. What a big mistake the Liberals have made in supporting their shiny new pony. ABJ
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
09:22 AM on 03/15/2013
well of COURSE the NDP supporters don't support JT for PM.....why it "terrifies" you is beyond me considering what we have in the PMO right now
06:58 PM on 03/17/2013
It terrifies the Cons and the NDP because both know that with Trudeau at the helm they will both lose support. NDP are upset because they thought they were going to keep the Liberals that voted NDP last election, especially in Quebec. They were even thinking that in 2015 they could win the election. Had the Liberals allowed Rae to run and be elected leader the NDP might have won a minority government in 2015. Now that dream is over. That's why the attacks on Justin are so over the top. Justin Trudeau winning in 2015 is their worst nightmare.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
canobserv
08:03 AM on 03/16/2013
NDP didn't do themselves any favors by picking Mulcair.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AlwaysCanadian
Lifelong Pacifist
02:33 PM on 03/14/2013
Exaggerated article. The leader of a political party may influence the policies slightly, however, no leader can turn his party's policies around 180 degrees. So, basically, there is no difference to the platform of the Liberals party whether Justin or Marc heads it.
01:45 PM on 03/14/2013
Bitter much? If it is not okay to condemn someone for being physically unattractive why is it okay to condemn someone for being attractive? Have you asked one of your Trudeau-supporting friends why they support him or are you just assuming that you already know why?

Maybe people are supporting Justin Trudeau because he is the most radical moderate politician out there. He does politics differently but pretty much all the pundits are missing it because they are so focused on his appearance and his name. You're just refusing to hear the message. The first mainstream pundit that gets it will be ahead of the game in understanding where this is going.

Policy wonks make good administrators and advisors. I am sure Garneau will have a prominent place in Justin's cabinet.

Justin has already stated that he agrees with Garneau on telecommunications so you don't need to worry on that front, but he doesn't agree with Hall Findlay on dismantling supply management without more evidence on the outcome.

Why are you so certain he will lose the 2015 election when polls are stating the complete opposite? Maybe you don't understand what is going on as well as you think you do.
01:43 PM on 03/14/2013
Garneau is not 'gone': he has merely withdrawn as a leadership candidate. All in all this is probably a good thing, since Garneau's campaign seemed to be empty of anything except boasts about how smart Garneau is combined with attacks trying to frame Justin Trudeau as a flake.

Garneau is smart and undoubtedly cares deeply about the future of Canada and I understand how his sincere and dedicated approach has endeared him to his electorate, but I think he is missing a bit of the charisma and diplomacy that would be most helpful to a new Liberal leader. The party has plenty of worthy 'ideas' members, but the last thing the Liberals need is another intellectual technocrat as leader. They need someone intelligent who is a good communicator and who can connect with people.

I think I am hoping Justin Trudeau does win, and Trudeau has not been attacking the other candidates in debates, which I hope bodes well for him being able to keep the best talent 'on board'.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cael
01:23 PM on 03/14/2013
He was not the one for the job.

He cared.
He thought about the issues.
He thought about the people.

There is no place for any of that in today's politics.
01:14 PM on 03/14/2013
The Libs are virtually indistinguishable from the NDP; they have gone too far over to the left. I miss the old center-focused party. Canada is a diverse country, I've been around long enough to believe that we are at our best from a centrist position. Being too far to the left (Libs, NDP) is as bad as being too far to the right (Cons).
I'm not happy with any party at the moment...If the Greens could get their act together and get folks to take them more seriously they may be a viable alternative. Their platform in the last election seemed the most balanced.
It's going to be tough to figure out who to vote for come next election...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:58 PM on 03/14/2013
What is the point of a Liberal win if it based on a move to the conservative right.

Nothing.

JT is not his father but neither is he an inexperienced pup. Privilege did not lead him to Katimavik or teaching in a BC school. Every one of these debates is taped in the PC offices to be stretched out of shape for election attack ad's. JT's approach is ok for now as he is not in the race to make only one point but to prepare for the bigger battle against Harper.