Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dave Kaufman

GET UPDATES FROM Dave Kaufman
 

I'm Not a Quebec Protester, But Police Assaulted Me Anyway

Posted: 05/25/2012 7:54 am

On Tuesday evening, just before midnight, I was assaulted by a police officer. No warning, no explanation, just a swift swing of a nightstick to the back of my leg.

It was on Rene Levesque Boulevard. I was walking west, away from the protest area, near the corner of Sanguinet. I was with one other person. Both of us are freelance journalists, and had been observing the protests from Ste. Catherine Street for about 90 minutes.

About a quarter of the way up the block two younger looking kids ran past us. Ten seconds later, we heard a police car pull up behind us. It stopped and two officers got out, wielding batons. Right away we moved to the edge of the sidewalk, assuming that the officers were about to give chase to the two that had just ran past us. We were mistaken. For reasons I still cannot understand, they charged at us.

"Bouge! Bouge! Bouge!"

Two police officers, both swinging their batons, were charging at us, telling us to run in the same direction we had been walking in. My colleague ran until the end of the block. Once he crossed the street, the officer stopped giving chase. The officer chasing after me threw me into a parked van. I bounced off it and started to run up the block, towards the officer, who had chased my colleague and was holding his ground on the corner.

I knew that as I ran by he was going to hit me with his nightstick. I felt like I was about to run a gauntlet.

As soon as I was parallel to him, he hit me in the back of my calf. I yelped, kept running, and crossed the street to relative safety. Just like that, they were gone. I didn't get a badge, a name, and their faces were a complete blur to me. It happened extremely fast.

There were other points in the evening where we were observing the protests and felt much more susceptible to danger than we had at that moment. It was an unprovoked attack on two innocent people walking on a (at that time of night) completely empty street.

This is Montreal under Bill 78.

I am not a student, I don't wear a red square, and I am not on strike. After four rogue protesters left smoke bombs in the metro, any public support of the "Maple Spring" was as good as dead. Public opinion was at a low, and it looked as if the movement would fizzle out. Then, the provincial government ratified a bill that is likely in violation of rights guaranteed by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, like freedom of speech and freedom of association.

There was a peaceful rally on Tuesday afternoon through the streets of Montreal. Over 100,000 people marched, possibly more. There were professionals, retirees, moms and dads, immigrants and "pure laine," and Anglos and Francos. It was one of the single largest acts of civil disobedience in the history of our country.

It's a shame that so much of the rest of Canada doesn't understand that this is now an issue about basic rights in a democracy. There are several factors for this, namely that the people who make the most noise are usually the ones who get heard.

While a broken bank window makes for a great visual for television, it does not tell the
story. Watching some news channels one would get the impression that there are wild packs of roving students causing havoc all over the city. While I'm not everywhere, what I have seen seems more like a disproportionate response by the government to a public exercise in civil disobedience.

The police are not in a favourable position here either. They are overworked, underpaid, and are being asked to enforce a law that has done nothing but make their jobs harder and lives more difficult. That being said, both sides need to be held accountable for their actions. To paraphrase Rodney King, both sides need to find a way to "just get along."

And this is the biggest problem. The movement has degenerated into an "us vs. them"
mentality on both sides, and this leaves a potential for the strife to continue well after the dust from this conflict has settled. Our country has always been renowned for its tolerance and acceptance of differences, be them cultural, religious, or many things in between.

Both Quebec and Canada need to look to the bigger picture. This is not about the
$325 a year raise in tuition anymore. This is about the fundamental rights and freedoms that define Canada. The public response to Bill 78 is democracy in action.

For that Canadians should be embracing Quebec, not shunning it.

Loading Slideshow...
  • The clanging pots of student unrest that have rattled Montreal and Quebec City for several nights are coming noisily to life in other parts of the province. (Text: CP)

  • People took up the percussive protest Thursday night in several towns and cities including Sorel, Longueuil, Chambly, Repentigny, Trois-Rivieres and even in Abitibi -- several hundred kilometres away from the hot spot of Montreal (Text: CP)

  • They were still loudest in Montreal, where a chorus of metallic clanks rang out in neighbourhoods around the city, spilling into the main demonstrations and sounding like aluminum symphonies. (Text: CP)

  • The pots-and-pans protest has its roots in Chile, where people have used it for years as an effective, peaceful tool to express civil disobedience. The noisy cacerolazo tradition actually predates the Pinochet regime in Chile, but has endured there and spread to other countries as a method of showing popular defiance. (Text: CP)

  • Thursday's protest in Montreal was immediately declared illegal by police, who said it violated a municipal bylaw because they hadn't been informed of the route. They allowed it to continue as long as it remained peaceful. (Text: CP)

  • Although there was a massive police presence throughout the evening with the roar of a provincial police helicopter competing with the banging of the pots, there was little if any tension reported between demonstrators and police. (Text: CP)

  • People tapped the pots as they walked, the sounds mingling with shouts and chants. Others leaned out of car windows to bang their pans and one protester smacked a pot right in front of one police officer who looked on indifferently. (Text: CP)

  • Usually the nightly street demonstrations, which have gone on for a month, have a couple of vigorous drummers to speed them along their route. At the very least, someone clangs a cow bell. (Text: CP)

  • But in the last few days, the pots and pans protest -- dubbed the casseroles by observers -- have acted like an alarm clock for the regular evening march, sounding at 8 p.m. on the nose in advance of the march's start. (Text: CP)

  • While thousands, including children, their parents, students and the elderly, packed the streets in support, the Twitterverse exploded with reactions and observations. (Text: CP)

  • "Spotted a man in an Armani suit banging a pot," tweeted Christina Stimpson on one of Thursday's participants. "Feel the love people." (Text: CP)

  • Another man rolled a small barbecue through the streets of Montreal, banging the lid. The joviality was a far cry from late Wednesday when police decided to shut down a largely peaceful evening march after they said projectiles were thrown and criminal acts were committed. (Text: CP)

 

Follow Dave Kaufman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/thekaufmanshow

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
On Tuesday evening, just before midnight, I was assaulted by a police officer. No warning, no explanation, just a swift swing of a nightstick to the back of my leg. It was on Rene Levesque Boulevard.
On Tuesday evening, just before midnight, I was assaulted by a police officer. No warning, no explanation, just a swift swing of a nightstick to the back of my leg. It was on Rene Levesque Boulevard.
 
 
  • Comments
  • 182
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
l monroe
I question authority.
12:26 PM on 05/28/2012
Freedom of the press,
Get press credentials from a press club or professional union. Dues.
Next time carry a poster saying press, not protestor, $3.99.
In the other hand carry a very large cheap video camera $50.00
on your head a very small high quality spy camera $4,000.
Filing charges for assault using the spy camera. Priceless.
04:06 PM on 05/27/2012
90 Minutes in the area when you should have been out 89 minutes earlier. Maybe wearing a big "media" sign may help. They assumed wrongly you were the two. That is what happens when you put yourself near a riot/demonstration. Get with the program. There is time to be a spectator and there is not. Everybody is on edge. You guys put yourself in the line of fire and got whacked for it. Saying you were non participants sounds hollow. I am of the thinking once the riot act is read and people are left-- its birds of a feather flock together thinking.
11:01 PM on 05/27/2012
No matter what those 2 who the officers were chasing did, if it was illegal, they should have been arrested, if it was not, the cops had no business chasing them. And under no circumstances is it EVER ok for a cop to whack you with a club unless their safety or someone else's is at risk. Neither was the case, which is what makes this blatant police brutality. This is partly what people are protesting against. Please refrain from sharing your ignorance with the rest of us in the future.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:57 PM on 05/26/2012
There may be a Canadian spring yet. An awful groundswell of us have really had it with the Harper Cons. There may be new elections in some ridings found to have been voter-suppressed. Some Cons may cross the floor given the Harper scandals. We might not have to wait 3-4 years to walk this guy out the door.
05:23 PM on 05/27/2012
It is not going to happen. Keep wishing though. Now look at Mulcair. Pretty active where he is not wanted and shuts his yap where he should be taliking . He may be one reason why I may vote dipper but so far he is working harder at losing the next election than Harper.

Mulcair needs to be PM for all Canadians. Not Quebec/Ontario. It now looks he is dropping the ball on Quebec. Can you say ignore the issue ?
04:21 PM on 05/26/2012
Smoke cans were not an issue. Evacuation was not needed for that kind of prank. Because of the occasional possibility of fire, the metro is required to be able to evacuate any smoke very quickly. Smoke used is non-toxic non-irritant smoke used in large quantities in rock shows. Everything is pointing at the authorities for making up a 3-hour interruption of service for no bloody reason other than to exaggerate the prank into a national security issue and charge the four persons with appearance of terrorism, as if the authorities had been fooled.

Making that prank was quite dumb, but almost all of the actual practical trouble was caused by the authorities, and further exaggerated by the media.
12:23 PM on 05/26/2012
This sort of thing will stop when a few people recognize the cops who hit them... when they don't have their guns and batons around.
02:40 AM on 05/26/2012
And how much proof do we have of this? There's a lot of anti-government, anti-establishment B.S. everywhere. Without some degree of documentation or video or photo footage, I'm not ready to believe it. The whole "down with the machine" movement is getting excessive especially in places where there is relatively larger amounts of freedom and leeway (based on my world travels). I don't believe this any more than I would believe some report on FOX or CNN's right-wing zealot networks, unless i'm given proof.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:39 AM on 05/26/2012
Really? In Libya there was a goddamn civil war, and you are saying that our anti-establishment beliefs are more than theirs? When this happens in unfree countries such as Bahrain, Libya, and Syria, people die.
01:26 PM on 05/26/2012
No, their anti-establishment beliefs are more valid than ours. I've been all over. Canadians have it good... TOO good in fact, that people feel entitled to even more. I hear numerous people say ludicrous stuff such as "well, higher education SHOULD be free."

listen to yourselves. Nothing SHOULD be free. This is a real world, not kindergarten. Nothing is entitled to you - you work it and you earn it and you pay for it. In fact I don't even want to see higher education being free even if we could afford it. It devalues it, and it dilutes the quality of it. A strict vertical hierarchy in human society is inevitable and even necessary no matter how many idealists try to preach "equality" and all that. Equal right to vote and drive and attend school it one thing - but education should have some bars so that those who strive to excel can power through it, and those who are not as willing should remain below-blue-collar workers mopping floors and flipping burgers. Rich cannot exist without the poor - and it's an overall better system than everybody being equally mediocre.
11:52 PM on 05/25/2012
I'm thinking that Quebec still has not signed into the constitution.
Hence, no charter rights for Quebec?
07:06 AM on 05/26/2012
Quebec is under the Canadian charter of rights and liberties, but more than that, there is also a Quebec charter with more or less the same things in it. So two charters of rights to respect in his law.
11:51 PM on 05/25/2012
"When the governments boot is on your throat, whether it is a left boot or a right is of no consequence"
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
12:16 PM on 05/26/2012
Fanned.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drama Llama
12:18 PM on 05/26/2012
"Beware the fish people, they are truly the enemy" Frank Zappa
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
10:06 PM on 05/25/2012
I find it hilariously hypocritical that the same media who claim police brutality for isolated incidents of bystanders being hurt are the same people that cry foul when anyone points out the protestors are condoning violence by claiming that it's isolated incidents.

Funny how uncomfortable it is when the shoe's on the other foot, though.
08:24 AM on 05/26/2012
The police are supposed to follow rules, so that there are no "isolated incidents".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
08:31 AM on 05/26/2012
And the protestors are supposed to obey the laws, so that there are no "pockets" of violence.
10:06 AM on 05/26/2012
Okay, no point in arguing if you just aren't going to see the difference.
02:47 PM on 05/26/2012
The isolated incidents of the protesters involve breaking windows and destroying property. The isolated incidents of the police involve attempting to maim and physically harm people. Difference.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
06:52 PM on 05/26/2012
No difference: a criminal act is a criminal act. The isolated incidents on the part of the students also include assaults in Victoriaville, and violently dragging non-striking students from class.
08:40 PM on 05/25/2012
Don't try exporting your struggle to the rest of Canada. We aren't interested in a $325 increase in Quebec tuition.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JTCan
09:26 AM on 05/26/2012
How insensitive. Didn't you even read the article? It's not about the money any longer...it's about rights and it WILL get to TO before you know it.
10:05 AM on 05/26/2012
What rights? If it is no longer about higher tuition costs, then what is it about? Bill 78? It's a Quebec law so why would they be exporting it out of province. If you want to see insensitive, how about all the students (the 99%) who wanted to stay in class and study?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:40 AM on 05/26/2012
This is a Quebec issue, I dont really care what the rest of Canada thinks. Hell, I only moved here from Ontario 4 years ago and am an anglo, but I've already started to understand where the frenchies come from.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kristopher Leang
training to take down the elite
07:58 PM on 05/25/2012
This is exactly part of the problem why people are protesting.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dclintn648
Conservatism is dread
05:45 PM on 05/25/2012
Well, here's one Ontarian embracing Quebec for their defence of democracy! Bien fait!!! We're all in this together, and it's NOT just a Canadian thing. The rich are cementing their power around the world, and it's time we commoners start working together instead of fighting over the crumbs!
07:54 AM on 05/26/2012
And another Ontarian offering support here! Well past time that we made a stand against the slow erosion of our rights.
11:02 AM on 05/26/2012
A third Ontarian offering his full support to the people of Quebec and their struggles with our democratic institutions. Hopefully their victory will prevent the export or worse federalizing of such repressive laws.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
schmoozey
05:23 PM on 05/25/2012
Awwww... memories of what we had to deal with during the G20. Canada - not as friendly as it used to be ;)
photo
The Canadian
Stop Harper
04:41 PM on 05/25/2012
The police are out of control all across this country. Did anyone else just catch the story about how 45 Toronto police officers, including top commanders, are to be severely reprimanded for violations of the law during the G20 protests two years ago?

Police violence has got to be reigned in immediately. Just because there are protests in Quebec doesn't mean that basic rights should be suspended and the police can assault whomever they want to under the guise of restoring order.
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
10:43 PM on 05/25/2012
Re: "...45 Toronto police officers, including top commanders, are to be severely reprimanded..."

We'll see about that.

It's one thing to say "we made a mistake", and quite another to gleefully commit the same actions over and over again.
10:13 AM on 05/26/2012
As an auditor, I can tell you that "tone at the top" is everything. If our leadership turns a blind eye and says the ends justify the means, then so will the police, so will the protesters, and so will everyone inbetween. We need leaders who will say the right things, do the right things, and even think the right things. The example set by Canada's leaders is pathetic, and we are all suffering the effects.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
William Muller
04:22 PM on 05/25/2012
Yes, this is about the $325 raise in tuition fees. That's when the protests started. And if smoke bombs weren't thrown in subway stations and protesters obeyed the laws that apply to all of us, there wouldn't have been a bill 78. Some temporary measures have to be taken to protect the majority from a small anarchistic minority. As imperfect as todays society is changing it through violence never worked and never will.
05:32 PM on 05/25/2012
Just to correct the information : don't forget that it is a CUMULATIVE increase of 325$ on five years : 325$ on the first year, 650$ on the second, etc. The real increase is 1625$ per year, 75% of total tuitions fees.
08:34 PM on 05/25/2012
I doubt facts can enter the mind of such servile creatures who will obey what ever laws their masters will write up. Charest didn't have to start all this trouble and could have kept the fees frozen as before, there are plenty of other ways to get extra money (but lets not go after the powerful class that evades their taxes as much as possible).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:11 PM on 05/25/2012
You are in the minority. Today, 55% of Quebecois disagree with Bill 78 (ot was on Huffpost).
You cannot make that claim about the need to protect the public if the public rejects it.