Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM David Menzies
 

Why Is Paul Henderson Not in the Hockey Hall of Fame?

Posted: 09/26/11 02:19 PM ET

It was 39 years ago today that the most famous goal in Canadian hockey history was scored. And yet, in the almost four decades since that piece of vulcanized rubber got past Soviet Union goaltender Vladislav Tretiak, the Canadian who scored that goal, Paul Henderson, is still inexplicably not in the Hockey Hall of Fame.

That's more disgraceful than a Todd Bertuzzi mugging.

Henderson's goal has been immortalized on coins and stamps. Ask any Canadian older than 45 where he or she was on Sept. 26, 1972, and they'll know. (For what it's worth, Game 8 was played on a weekday; like hundreds of my schoolmates, I was sitting in the hallway of Danesbury Public School in Toronto watching the game on a grainy black and white 20-inch screen TV - and loving it.)

After all, this was history in the making. Far more than a mere set of exhibition hockey games, the 1972 Summit Series took on overtones of "us versus them"; "capitalism versus communism"; "democracy versus dictatorship."

Losing to the evil U.S.S.R. was simply not an option.

And lest we forget, Paul Henderson was not a "one-hit wonder" in that series. The Toronto Maple Leaf forward also scored the winning goals in Games 6 and 7. Amazing.

And yet, for reasons that remain murky, the powers-that-be at the Hockey Hall of Fame are of the opinion that Paul Henderson isn't worthy of inclusion.

Granted, Henderson's NHL and WHA career statistics (he played from 1962 to 1981) won't make Wayne Gretzky green with envy. But who cares about those games? It was Henderson's goal 39 years ago today that literally had Canadians dancing in the streets.

To add insult to injury, last year, the Hockey Hall of Fame became yet another Canadian institution beholden to the tyranny of political correctness due to the induction of Cammi Granato and Angela James.
With all due respect, hands up how many people have actually seen Cammi Granato play a game of hockey?

And would any hockey fan ever be able to recognize Angela James in a crowd? (Hint: She's a dead-ringer for Howard Stern's producer, Baba Booey.)

But at the Hockey Hall of Fame, apparently gender equity now trumps bona fide achievement. Wow.
It's not too late to correct this mistake, however. Next year will be the 40th anniversary of The Goal. Let's collectively hope the Hockey Hall of Fame will correct its egregious error and grotesque oversight and admit Paul Henderson to the Hall where he belongs.

It's called doing the right thing.

 
It was 39 years ago today that the most famous goal in Canadian hockey history was scored. And yet, in the almost four decades since that piece of vulcanized rubber got past Soviet Union goaltender Vl...
It was 39 years ago today that the most famous goal in Canadian hockey history was scored. And yet, in the almost four decades since that piece of vulcanized rubber got past Soviet Union goaltender Vl...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:28 PM on 11/09/2011
Are you kidding me. Everyone on that team, from the trainers up, should be in the hall of fame. That was a moment in hockey that no Canadian or Russian hockey fan over 45 will ever forget. Henderson played like a superstar and that's what the HOF is all about. Maybe he was a superstar for one tournament but since when did the HOF say how long you had be great. It's a hall of FAME and there's no goal more famous than the one Henderson scored in 1972. If he would have fanned on the shot he would've been the biggest goat in Canadian hockey history but he didn't, he played like a superstar and buried it. Put him in the Hall!
11:29 AM on 09/30/2011
"More disgraceful than a Todd Bertuzzi mugging" -- dumb comment, and no where near the truth.

Yes, the series and the goal deserve to be in the Hall, but not Henderson as a player, whose fame begins and ends with those final three games - which really does almost amount to a one-hit wonder. A good player, but not a great player.

Cammi Granato and Angela James, however, have played a significant role in extending the popularity of hockey among women, and women's hockey among men. They have a far better case to be there.
11:11 AM on 09/27/2011
Because, outside of "that" goal, Henderson had a very ordinary career. Not really a Hall of Fame candidate - sorry.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stanschurman
09:18 AM on 09/27/2011
You know, just before that series began everyone was saying the Soviets would be lucky to get a goal, we would run over them like a train squashing a penny, this was going to be the laugher of all time and on and on. Then they won the first game and it was panic time. These guys could play hockey and worse, they could play with NHL all-stars. Two things caused all the hoopla over Henderson's goal (which was set up by Yvon Cournoyer - something usually glossed over), first he was a Leaf so Foster Hewitt became even more nasal and hysterical than usual, and secondly because we were relieved that we were able to squeek out a win against a team we were supposed to crush.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
anugs
08:34 AM on 09/27/2011
I've never been to the Hockey Hall of Fame, so I not sure if there's at least an exihibit of Henderson's goal. If there isn't there certainly should be. But as far as Henderson being a full member of the Hall of Fame, I don't think so. His career is rather, other than the 3 winning goals of that series, non descript.
06:32 PM on 09/26/2011
For the same reasons that Mike Eruzione isn't in the Hall of Fame.
06:15 PM on 09/26/2011
Geez, Eaglrson was in Hall before he was booted out after they found out he was a crook. Henderson certainly desrves it. I totally agree with the author. Its not just how many points you averaged over your career but what you did for the game. In my opinion he practically single handidly saved the credibility and bragging rights for Canada's game for years. I wonder how many teamates from the series would recommend him for the Hall, I bet most of them. He must have been a darn good player just to make that team. Thanks for the memories Paul you did Canada proud. I think he should get the Order of Canada too!!!!
01:30 PM on 09/30/2011
Henderson "practicall­y single handidly saved the credibilit­y and bragging rights for Canada's game for years" -- I don't think so.

First, he had a lot of help from other players. Who can forget how much Espo grew as a leader, the stellar defence of Stapleton and White, or Dryden in goal?

Second, the narrow games and series victory saved the NHL and the pros from walking around with bags over their heads. Remember Espo's famous "We tried" speech after the Vancouver game?They never discounted the Russians again.
07:07 PM on 09/30/2011
Point taken. Of course others played huge roles in Canada's success. I base my opinion on the amazing achievement of scoring 3 game winning goals in a row in what was Canada's most important tournament up to that point. The last one if I remember correctly with little time remaining in the game. I would bet that there are very few players, if any, I'm not sure, who have scored 3 gamewinners in a row ever, let alone a playoff series, nevermind a huge tournament as this.
sunnydee07
"Your micro-bio is empty". Yes, yes it is.
05:07 PM on 09/26/2011
It's the goal itself that should be immortalized but much as Paul Henderson is famous for scoring it, he himself shouldn't be in the Hall of Fame. His career doesn't merit it.

As far as Cammi Granato and Angela James, the Hall is also there to immortalize those who changed the game, and as top flight female players, they did.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:44 PM on 09/26/2011
Paul Henderson is not in the Hall of Fame because he doesn't belong there. He scored the winning goal (actually the winning goal in the last 3 games) in the Summit Series, which is very memorable, but not worthy of The Hall of Fame.

Henderson had one 30-goal season in the NHL and finished with 236 goals over 12+ Seasons in the NHL, which averages to under 20 goals per season. Not even close to Hall of fame Numbers.

The fact he scored a big goal in an Exhibition Series with the Soviets, while exciting and emotional, does not merit Hall of Fame consideration, let alone admittance, in my mind.