Huffpost Canada ca
THE BLOG

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors

Diane Francis Headshot

Why Canada Has Fewer Elliot Rodgers Than the U.S.

Posted: Updated:
Print
YouTube
YouTube

From New York Daily News

In California, people 70 and up must renew their driver's licenses in person to be interviewed, take a vision test, make a practice run and pass a written quiz.

And yet the state gave Elliot Rodger, who openly posted threats to the public on YouTube and Facebook, a gun license that allowed him to buy semiautomatic guns that helped him to slaughter six innocent people.

Nationally, Homeland Security has the power to hold, question and search suspected terrorists, and yet the American homeland remains vulnerable to those among our own citizens who have mental health issues -- not religiously motivated -- and can buy guns more readily than Sudafed.

It's time America looks up to Canada, where anyone can own a gun -- but licensing is properly managed with a process that takes weeks, requires applicants to show up in person and includes background checks and a personal safety-training course.

In 2012, Canada, had 172 gun homicides. The U.S., with 314 million people, had 6,371 -- four times as many per capita.

There are mass killings in Canada, including two mass stabbings this year by mentally ill persons, but far fewer than in the U.S.

A big reason why is that Canada provides mental health care (and drugs and financial support) for all its residents, and enforces proper gun controls to protect the public.

Canada catches mentally ill people in its health care net, because it has one. Rodger would almost surely have been turned down for a gun license in Canada, given his history -- and if he had posted threats online, he would likely have been taken to a hospital by police and kept there for diagnosis.

Too many Americans have no access and cannot afford help or medications -- a hole budget cuts have widened. Canada also has a larger share of psychiatrists than America, and the number is rising in the Great White North even as it's declining south of the border.

What's annoying is the Second Amendment nonsense spouted by the NRA and its allies. As my social studies teacher once explained about liberty and its responsibilities, freedom is the right to swing your arm but not to hit anybody else with it.

This applies to everything in life except, in the United States, guns. The right to bear arms by militias, established in the 18th-century, has been stretched and corrupted by litigators and inept judges to effectively allow anyone anywhere in the U.S. to use semiautomatic weaponry at will.

Americans aren't so much more violent than Canadians. They are just far more likely to use guns -- which account for nearly three-fifths of all murders in the U.S., compared to just one-third north of the border -- and thus far more likely to see violent incidents end with fatal results.

Americans, like Canadians, realize that guns, like cars or prescription drugs, should be carefully regulated and licensed. No one should shoot a gun, or drive a car, without proving to the public he or she can safely and responsibly do so.

Perhaps Americans need Homeland Security to protect them from craven commercial interests, incompetent politicians and government officials as well as terrorists.

This article previous appeared in the New York Daily News.

MORE ON HUFFPOST:

Close
Santa Barbara Shooting
of
Share
Tweet
Share this
close
Current Slide