Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Don Chapman

GET UPDATES FROM Don Chapman
 

On Canada Day, Lost Canadians Sit on the Sidelines

Posted: 07/01/2011 8:10 am

Today is Canada Day, and on televised ceremonies across Canada our government will be rolling out the welcome mat to thousands of newcomers. Now consider what that feels like to a Canadian-born, Canadian WWII veteran being told they're not wanted in Canada. That's what it's like to be a Lost Canadian.

Almost 50 years ago the civil rights movement was gaining tremendous strength in the United States. It was about an egregious issue -- an abomination if you will -- called discrimination. The pressing question was, should all people be afforded equal rights?

We as Canadians readily admit that everyone should be equal, but when Canadians learn about our country's ongoing discrimination in citizenship law, they seem content sitting on the sidelines in silence.

In 1963 U.S. President John F. Kennedy gave his famous Civil Rights Address. In 2011 -- on this Canada Day -- regrettably a lot of his words are just so apropos.

In what I'm about to say, I'll change a few of President Kennedy's words to make it Canadian specific- but sadly, his message is as true today in Canada as it was half a century ago in the deep south:

More legislation is needed,

but laws alone cannot make men see right.

Today, Canada is confronted with a moral issue.

The heart of the matter is, should all Canadians be treated with equality, so that each and everyone of us is afforded the same opportunities.

Should we treat all Canadians in a manner that we ourselves wish to be treated?

Some of the remaining Lost Canadians cannot send their children to a public school.

They cannot collect the pension they've paid into for most of their lives.

They can be denied medical coverage.

Or they cannot travel outside of Canada because they can't get a passport.

Consider: They can't even vote against the very politicians allowing these injustices to continue.

In short, who amongst us would willingly trade places with one of the five per cent of Lost Canadians who still remain disenfranchised from their own country? If it was you or your child being denied citizenship, would you be satisfied with the continued bureaucratic and political delays to correct the discriminatory legislation which has been enforced in Canada since 1868, or just one year after Confederation 144 years ago?

Or do you believe that Canada, and Canadians, can do better? Shouldn't the example we bestow to the world, is a Canada that at the very least nurtures and protects its own people -- regardless of age, or gender, or race, or whether a person was born in or out-of wedlock.

Proudly, it was a Canadian who wrote the first draft of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, yet today our own government refuses to abide by its provisions.

When confronted with the facts about citizenship and belonging, Canadians often turn a blind eye. To the Lost Canadian it's a deafening silence. Dr. Martin Luther King once said, "The greatest tragedy in this period of social transition was not the strident clamour of the bad people, but the appalling silence of the good."

Canadian human rights activist June Callwood said, "Once you know about the abuse you become a part of it." In that sense all of you now share some responsibility for the outcome of your fellow Canadians.

One question remains: How many of you will come forward to help Lost Canadians? They too are part of our Canadian family -- except that our government continues to discriminate based on gender, age, and family status, while steadfastly refusing to recognize their citizenship. As I said, its an abomination.

Please, step forward and help me. Together there's much we can do. Individuals, especially with community support, can make a huge difference. A shining example of this was Denmark during WWII, where the Danish people so protected their fellow Jewish citizens. That lesson, of 'doing what is right,' should not be lost here in Canada.

On this Canada Day, let me end with two more quotes from President Kennedy:

"Those who do nothing are inviting shame. Those who act boldly are recognizing right, as well as reality."

And, "Ask not what your country can do for you -- ask what you can do for your country."

Reaching out to help a Lost Canadian in need is a really great place to start.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
Today is Canada Day, and on televised ceremonies across Canada our government will be rolling out the welcome mat to thousands of newcomers. Now consider what that feels like to a Canadian-born, Cana...
Today is Canada Day, and on televised ceremonies across Canada our government will be rolling out the welcome mat to thousands of newcomers. Now consider what that feels like to a Canadian-born, Cana...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbertaud
Je ne regrette rien, rien de rien
03:29 PM on 07/01/2011
Lost Canadians or Canadians by convenience ?...those who have Canadian citizenship through a grandparent or parent, but do not live in Canada, do not pay taxes here, have no connection with the country and use the Canadian passport just to travel to places for which they'd be required to have a visa in case they had no Canadian passport?...those who are Canadian only when there is a natural disaster or conflict and want to be evacuated...or those who are Canadian only every time they get in trouble and need consular assistance...?
08:51 PM on 07/01/2011
See my reply to BlackRabbit below. Yours is clearly one of the misinformed perceptions I was referring to.
01:21 AM on 07/02/2011
I am a Lost Canadian and not one by convenience. I grew up in Canada, was educated here, paid taxes, voted, had a family here and I'm still being denied citizenship by the Canadian government. Don't decide I and other Lost Canadians are guilty before being ruled innocent. Research the issue by following the links in the article by Mr. Chapman. You may just learn a thing or two and understand the frustration I feel by being denied my citizenship.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:03 PM on 07/01/2011
Nowhere in this article does Chapman define the term "lost Canadian". You have go to one of the links to find that out.

Whenever someone is coy about the facts, instead appealing purely to my emotions, I figure they're trying to hide something.
04:34 PM on 07/01/2011
BlackRabbit, the Lost Canadians have nothing to hide. They are people who are are still excluded from citizenship by the continuing application of discriminatory provisions of the pre-1977 citizenship law. They are excluded, solely because of the date and circumstances of their birth, by an obscure, unfair law that was repealed 34 years ago and that no politician today would defend. Among them are War Bride children who were born out of wedlock during the Second World War; Mennonites born abroad who are excluded because their parents, and in some cases grandparents, had only a religious marriage outside Canada; and people born abroad whose claim to citizenship is through the female line.

Contrary to some misinformed perceptions, the Lost Canadians are not ‘Canadians of convenience’ who have suddenly arrived on Canada’s doorstep claiming citizenship. Many have lived their entire adult lives in Canada as Canadians, only to discover in middle age or even later that they are not citizens of the only country they know. From the cases of which I have personal knowledge, their treatment over the years by the Department of Citizenship and Immigration has been coldly dismissive. I know of no similar group in any other democratic country that has been treated in this insulting, unconscionable and politically indefensible way. Why Canada?

For more detailed information on the Lost Canadians, visit http://blog.lostcanadian.com/.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:52 PM on 07/03/2011
Thank you. Pity that some of those hard facts didn't find their way into the article.
06:44 PM on 07/01/2011
For your information, Lost Canadians are individuals who are still excluded from Canadian citizenship because of discriminatory provisions of the pre-1977 citizenship law. They are excluded, solely because of the date and circumstances of their birth, by an obscure, unfair law that was repealed 34 years ago. Did you know that there are 12 ways that you can lose Canadian citizenship? Go to the links provided in Mr. Chapman’s article and you’ll see just how it can happen. It is not the Lost Canadians who are “trying to hide something.” It’s the Canadian government that ignores decisions of the Supreme Court with regard to citizenship and the bureaucrats who appear to be allowing natural attrition to solve the problem. (Most Lost Canadians are pension age and are on the home stretch.) Don’t you believe that your government should live by the same rules and laws that they expect you to respect?
Mr. Chapman is a champion on those who are being devalued by their government. Think how you would feel if you were suddenly told you weren’t a Canadian. Research the issue, read the websites he refers to and maybe, just maybe, you’ll understand how an individual referred to as a Lost Canadian feels.