Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
GET UPDATES FROM Dr. James L. Jones
 

Concordia Disaster: Could It Happen Here?

Posted: 01/23/2012 5:00 pm

As two more bodies were pulled from the wreckage of the Costa Concordia on Monday, wary travelers may be changing their plans to book a cruise, wondering -- legitimately -- could that happen to me?

As a maritime physician, in laymen's terms a cruise ship doctor, I have watched the news we've seen from Italy with interest and regret. Reports tell us Capt. Francesco Schettino was one of the first people to abandon ship. Of course, we're all asking how a trained professional could do such a thing. But as someone who works in the industry, I can't help but also wonder:

• Where was the rest of the ship's command? There are always people who can take over leadership if the captain is not aboard or in some way incapacitated. Why haven't we heard from, or about, them?

• Why was there confusion regarding who was onboard? In my experience, ships can't come into or leave port without a manifest signed by the captain and me (the ship doctor), confirming exactly how many souls are present.

• Whenever a ship is moving, there are always several crewmembers using radar or sonar instruments to determine where the boat is headed. How did all the usual precautions fail?

As many have noted, without a captain's leadership, the crew and guests were left to their own ingenuity to escape. Watching the first reports, it was obvious to me that most of the lifeboats and rafts on the port side of the boat, that is the left side, had been deployed. One could assume this meant the same for the right, or starboard side. To launch that many boats, at least a couple of hundred deck engineers would have had to stayed on board and tended to their responsibilities. Why have we not heard from them?

The cruise industry is notoriously tight-lipped and it comes as no surprise to me that we've seen few interviews with the crew so far. But in the coming weeks, I expect many individual stories to come to light.

Still, I can't imagine how anything like the Concordia incident could have happened on any American-run boat -- certainly not the ones I've worked on. The captains are exceedingly careful and take no chances.

When a boat enters or leaves a port, or when it is in a situation of the slightest risk, like swinging close to shore, the boat is said to be in a "Red Zone." On the bridge this means all attention is on the boat and where it's going. There are no extraneous conversations, no phone calls, and only essential personnel are allowed on the bridge. Two officers walk back and forth on a walkway toward the front of the bridge and their only job is to look. To look for anything.

This did not seem to be the protocol aboard the Concordia, as it dangerously steered into a "Red Zone." According to new reports, "Prosecutors say Schettino steered the vessel, which carried more than 4,200 passengers and crew, within 150 metres of the Tuscan island of Giglio to perform a maneuvre known as a 'salute' - a greeting to the islanders."

The vessel struck a rock and tipped over. It is now precariously lying on its side on an undersea ledge, half-submerged and threatening to slide into deeper waters.

Costa Cruises have said they were not aware of the dangerous practice of bringing the ship so close to the shore and have suspended the captain, saying he was responsible for the disaster.
But in a sign of the growing confrontation between Schettino and the ship owners, the captain told investigating magistrates Costa had instructed him to do the salute, according to transcripts of his hearing published by Italian media.

"It was planned, we should have done it a week earlier but it was not possible because of bad weather," Schettino said. "They insisted. They said: 'We do tourist navigation, we have to be seen, get publicity and greet the island.'"

Aboard North American passenger ships, officers are constantly monitoring the sonar and radar.
The crew on the walkway are always there, watching. Even at night. Once we found a guest who had jumped overboard on a ship that was 30 minutes ahead of us, over the horizon. They're always looking out.

I can't see how an accident would happen under such circumstances unless possibly there were a computer malfunction. It has happened, as far as I know only once.

Confusion reigns during critical events like Concordia's, and the first priority is to establish communication and assess damage. Protocol for American boats would be to order all guests to their muster stations once it was determined the boat was in serious trouble, certainly if it was listing. Then the captain would sound Abandon Ship once he determined the boat was sinking.

Always more than half of our guests are repeat cruisers. It's a reasonable assumption that these repeaters could have coached the rest of the crew to the muster stations on deck four where the lifeboats and rafts are deployed. At the time of the accident the Concordia had not had a safety drill.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 16
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:38 PM on 03/06/2012
Well doctor, there are many ways that such an accident can happen. One way is Engine failure, by design these types of ships loose power (and since they have no rudders) they go in the same direction as they did prior to the power failure. If this would have happen when an American ship was going close to shore, and American ship could also suffer an accident, with or without sonor and radar. If the shore control was lax when it came to the water-tight doors, or some malfunction in the water-tight doors would happen, then an American ship could also capsize. Before capsizing it would also tilt so that there would not be sufficient time (30 minutes) to release all life-boats, and then there would still be people on board after the captain would have left the ship and all those left to fend for themselves. I think the myth of "This passenger ship can't sink" has been shown to be a myth, and it would still be a myth as "This passenger American ship can't sink". There have incidents where cruise ships have had incidents that under the certain conditions could have been tragedies instead of just incidents. When an incident happens everyone needs to first be calm, follow the orders, but at some point it becomes each person for themself.
10:58 AM on 02/17/2012
American passenger ships? To my knowledge the ONLY US flagged cruise ship is operated by NCL
photo
joebaggadonuts
Civilization: Evolutionary pathway of choice.
12:31 PM on 01/24/2012
Thank the lawyers and tort law in the US for the good behavior of corporate overlords towards people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
09:02 AM on 01/24/2012
"Aboard North American passenger ships, officers are constantly monitoring the sonar and radar."

I think, Doctor, you should review the inquiry into the Queen of the North disaster in British Columbia, on the "Inside Passage" route heavily used by cruise ships (the whole of which is a "Red Zone"). And also various other ship collisions in that region - notably a Russian freighter, with a locally designated pilot, nearly cutting in half one of the BC Ferries "Queen" fleet in the middle of a tortuous strait called Active Pass, in broad daylight.

Now, BC Ferries and its American counterpart, Washington State Ferries, are very well-run and safety conscious. They're also not owned by international steamship lines with foreign-recruited and poorly-trained crews with slack regulations.....y'see here in the Pacific Northwest, we're not so much concerned with a Costa Concordia-type incident, since we have a lot of trust in our ferry systems and a relative amount of faith in the cruise lines. It's the oil industry's freighters for bitumen we're worried about.........
photo
joebaggadonuts
Civilization: Evolutionary pathway of choice.
12:34 PM on 01/24/2012
http://www.saudiaramcoworld.com/issue/198406/bitumen.-.a.history.htm

most folks probably don't recognize asphalt by that name.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
clearasmud
Obama Is Nothing More Than A Moderate Republican
09:02 AM on 01/24/2012
Sounds as if a Safety Drill with passangers should be held before the ship leaves the dock.
11:35 PM on 01/27/2012
I've been on two cruises and both times the safety drill took place after the gangway was pulled up and before we left Miami. Our first was on the Carnival Paradise and the second on Royal Caribbean's Freedom of the Seas. I was under the impression that these drills must occur before leaving port. Now I know.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony frm Banff
Search for truth,not spin
06:13 PM on 01/23/2012
Well good Doctor it can happen here and it most likely will not be a cruise ship but a tanker carrying bitumen from the coast and will devastate the eco-system of our west coast.

And that is our biggest threat!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
07:37 PM on 01/23/2012
What about the tankers on the east coast and in the St Lawrence?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tony frm Banff
Search for truth,not spin
03:01 AM on 01/24/2012
sorry the bitumen is worse then refined oil.