Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hina P. Ansari

GET UPDATES FROM Hina P. Ansari
 

If People View Muslims As Intolerant, That's Our Fault

Posted: 09/14/2012 12:33 pm

My dearest fellow Muslims, please get over it and toughen your skin.

Yes I'm talking to you fellow Muslim activists and protesters. And yes I'm talking to you too, Muslim rioters and thugs.

The film, Innocence of Muslims, has recently been thrust into the spotlight clearly without any merit whatsoever, has played the willing role of firestarter to what can be seen as a tinderbox which harbours the sensitive feelings of my Muslim brothers and sisters.

I shake my head because this is exactly what the filmmaker Nakoula/Bacile (who, as recently reported, has a total of 17 different aliases) wanted.

So I am pleading with you to please stop taking the bait!

Innocence of Muslims, formerly known as Innocence of Bin Laden and once again formerly know as Desert Warrior clearly is a flimsily filmed hate propaganda packaged as a D-level film. The creator's intensity of hate is evidenced by the obvious strategic dubbing of Islamic references in his pitiful post production work, to really drive his anti-Islamic point home. The production value doesn't even amount to $100 worth, let alone the whopping $5-million tag which was initially stated by the filmmaker.

The same filmmaker, who is now discovered to be a convicted fraudster, financial scammer and a meth maker is probably laughing at all of us from his hiding place.

I saw the trailer and yes it's horrible. It's absolutely gut wrenching and 100 per cent offensive. But you don't see me running to the nearest embassy with a Molotov cocktail and tearing up a flag now do you?

Why you ask? Because a) I have more important things to do and b) I believe in not giving any weight or volume to something that is that overtly offensive. It's one thing to find offense in an obscure matter where it lends itself to an enlightening and adult discussion to explain why we are offended. But it's another thing entirely when the offensive material is so blatant and so poorly executed, that even a five-year-old will understand that it's just not worthy of any thought or discussion because it's just, well, so childish.

Sure, that's my version of turning the other cheek. When something really idiotic or offensive enters my space, I just ignore it and move on. I try to be the bigger person. Pick my battles. And honestly I just don't have the time nor the energy to dedicate to such nonsense.

So my fellow Muslims, I beg of you to get a grip. In this day and age where pretty much any one who can grab a camera, paint a wall green (the home made version of a Green Screen which was done for this vulgarity) and dole out cash for starving actors, can make a movie.

Then they upload it on YouTube and collect a few endorsements by like-minded people. If the blocks are put in the right place, it goes viral, hopefully catching the attention of key media outlets who then talk about it some more, which then gets them more press, more hits, more tweets, more forwards and they become a media sensation. Whether you or anyone else like it or not.

So here we have this Bacile character, this low rent Cecil B. DeMille wannabe (apologies to Mr. DeMille for this reference), who hopes that the aim of his film is to really show the world how crazy us Muslims are.

And cue the riots.

You, my dear Muslim brothers and sisters fell for it. Now, as I breathlessly try to explain to others that this group of rioters in the far away lands aren't like "us," I can't help but feel that the same people who had our backs in the past are now starting to view us with a little bit more skepticism. Sure I may be paranoid but you know what? At this point I have no idea what to think.

You have played right into the hands of this hate-monger and into the hands of his bigoted friends who view Muslims as "crazy," "intolerant," "violent" all in the same breath. And thanks to you we have handed them another high profile example. On a big fat shiny platter.

Bacile is probably sitting back in his armchair, twirling his evil madman mustache (assuming he has one) and roaring his evil mastermind laugh.

And he should, because his plan worked perfectly.

One last thing:

When The Book of Mormon became an award-winning Broadway musical you didn't see throngs of armed and offended Mormons flooding the Great White Way in protest, tearing up theatre programs and setting the billboards on fire. When South Park skewers their laundry list of religions including Christianity, Judaism and, yes, even Scientology, you don't see effigies of Trey Parker burning now do you?

My point exactly.

So can we all just stop being wusses now? It's time to toughen up, thicken the skin and most importantly stop taking the bait. Enough already.

 

Follow Hina P. Ansari on Twitter: www.twitter.com/hinapansari

FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
My dearest fellow Muslims, please get over it and toughen your skin. Yes I'm talking to you fellow Muslim activists and protesters. And yes I'm talking to you too, Muslim rioters and thugs. The f...
My dearest fellow Muslims, please get over it and toughen your skin. Yes I'm talking to you fellow Muslim activists and protesters. And yes I'm talking to you too, Muslim rioters and thugs. The f...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 58
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
09:51 PM on 09/19/2012
Somehow Ansari you have managed to deflect blame from Muslims to the west . The fact is these protests and violence are not all staged , many Muslims do want to commit violence over a religious insult. It is a fact, not the west assuming something imaginary as you seem to insinuate.Muslims go from secular dictators to religious dictators ,most do not even understand the concept of real freedom.
02:30 PM on 09/18/2012
That is definitely the sanest response to this garbage that I have yet seen. I am not Muslim, or invoked with any mainstream religion, but I believe with all my heart that people should be allowed their own religious (or spiritual, or political, or whatever) beliefs as long as they do not hurt anyone, or deny others the same rights. I don't believe all Muslims are violent, or that any religious or ethnic group is inherently bad. I never will, no matter how much hate is published by the small-minded. It is unfortunate that there is a huge lack of respect or knowledge of others beliefs in our society, but the answer is education and tolerance, not violence and aggression. Thank you for reaffirming my beliefs.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DebbyM
08:01 AM on 09/18/2012
"A Muslim Canadian activist has founded a new group that will promote moderate Islam, saying there are too few progressive Muslim voices countering extremism in Canada. Raheel Raza, the Pakistan-born author of Their Jihad, Not My Jihad: A Muslim Canadian Woman Speaks Out, was once a member of the progressive Muslim Canadian Congress, but this month is formally launching Muslims Facing Tomorrow. " http://news.nationalpost.com/2012/09/11/new-moderate-muslim-group-aims-anti-extremism-message-at-youth/

In order to change the perception of what the average Muslim thinks, condones, etc., more of this lady's activism is needed in the Muslim community. Even she thinks that moderate Muslims are too quiet. That quietness leaves a vacuum that the extremists are only too happy to fill and unfortunately for the moderates, that is what media all over the world reports on.
03:00 PM on 09/17/2012
A good article but Ms. Ansai should be careful. Just today, the Iranians raised the bounty on the head of Salman Rusdie to $3.3 million. See:http://worldnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/09/17/13908002-iran-increases-price-on-satanic-verses-author-salman-rushdies-head-by-500k?lite. And I think it is more than a tiny minority of Moslems who feels insecure about their religion.
03:11 PM on 09/16/2012
If only the message of moderate Muslims would sell as well as images of violent Muslims then we might see more of them. Searching google I can find many Muslim groups advocating tolerance and condemning violence, why have I never heard of them on the news, in newspapers or on sites like HP?
This comment has been removed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cdncommentator
12:36 AM on 09/15/2012
Exactly!!!!!
07:18 PM on 09/14/2012
Excellent article.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lucy Van Pelt
Learn to swim!!
06:10 PM on 09/14/2012
Great blog. You are very insightful and a credit to Islam. Thank you for speaking sense to this insanity that is going on. I hope more people like you come forward and speak out.
05:59 PM on 09/14/2012
hina, excellent article.
04:48 PM on 09/14/2012
thank you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
04:05 PM on 09/14/2012
Excellent article.

Thank you.
02:47 PM on 09/14/2012
This is ridiculous. So society (and Muslims in particular) should just accept or ignore those who perpetrate religious hatred and who create a hateful atmosphere? Oh perhaps society should ignore this hate for one religion but not for another. Madam, you don't seem to know the dangers to society of tolerating and ignoring hate speech. Check out what happened in the Weimar Republic. Check out what is happening in Pakistan.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
colpy
04:08 PM on 09/14/2012
Ahhh....the Weimar Republic did NOT tolerate "hate speech". There were laws against it there. You can see how much good they did.

Yes, you have to tolerate being offended. That is the price of liberty. Talk back, if you wish....but murder and mayhem are not a reasonable option.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
big666dog
04:51 PM on 09/14/2012
Is this how a society should react to hate speech: rioting, attacking, assaulting and even killing people, even who have nothing whatsoever to do with the offending article? Just what are you advocating? Are people's religions so incredibly brittle that this is condonable behaviour under any circumstance?
08:21 AM on 09/15/2012
Is this how people in the US should react to hate speech: ignoring and tolerating hate speech and those people who deliberately set out to light a fire in their neighbours houses? Just what are you advocating? Are people's right to express themselves above all other rights under any circumstance?

I think enough people have said that rioting, attacking assaulting, killing is unacceptable as a response by Muslims. However you chose to ignore this. Even, the new US demon, Egyptian President Morsi said the following: "it is required by our religion to protect our guests and their homes and places of work."
He called the killing of U.S. Ambassador Chris Stevens in Libya unacceptable in Islam. "To God, attacking a person is bigger than an attack on the Kaaba," he said, referring to Islam's holiest site in Mecca.
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
02:19 PM on 09/14/2012
MS. Ansari, though your piece is heartfelt indeed, I would remind you that had you written it in an Islamic country, it would never have been published. Conversely, had it been published you would now be living under threat of a death fatwah. Your koran is quite clear that its minutely detailed instructions are to be taken literally and in the present (not viewed historically, as in the bible and torah), and that chonologically later, violent suras regarding infidels are to be deployed and that earlier, peaceful ones are to be disregarded.

Frankly, islam has not had the taming and civilising influence of a Reformation (Martin Luther) or an Enlightenment (Jean-Jacques Rousseau) to bring it to heel. As a religion, islam has a huge housecleaning task to do of its own before it dares to have the temerity to be offended by any outside criticism. Given that thoughtful, insightful critics such as Irshad Manji and Ayaan Hirsi Ali lie under 24 hour police protection for voicing even the most mild and well-reasoned arguments to reform Islam, how long do you suppose that might take?
05:20 PM on 09/15/2012
Speak to Arab Christians who can read the Koran in their own language and they unfortunately have views very similar to the gist of the film. Islam does denegrate other religions including Christianity and most if not all Christians I know from the middle East have great contempt for Islam. This is why they supported the dictators such as Saddam, Mubarak and still Assad as without their support of secularism they have no future in their own countries, only a past.
photo
NTodd
Aude Sapere
10:45 PM on 09/15/2012
I know you mean well, but your condescending tone is the kind of thing that gives us atheists a bad name.
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
12:27 AM on 09/16/2012
I don't particularly mean well. I mean for her to own up to her membership in a violent, fascistic political-religious ideology that has as its stated goal the absorption of the entire planet. Islam is no different from The Borg, except by wardrobe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
01:31 PM on 09/14/2012
The problem with the Arab world in their media they portray non-Islam religions as sub human but if anyone outside of the Muslim even criticizes Islam everyone in the Mulsim world flips out such as another example when South Park had a show on Mohammad and showing a image of him and the episode is clearly view able on their website. I did think the video was in poor taste but it is freedom of expression. For example there is not a religion in which South Park has not attacked. Personally I think the Islamic world needs to understand in the West we have something called freedom of speech and expression. That video is just one example of it
04:52 PM on 09/14/2012
Studying cultural theory in University shows us that free speech does not mean to invade in to peoples private lives and destroy them by juggle religion in porno's and music industries like (lady gaga wears an underwear with the cross upside down). Also to make abusive film about Prophet Muhammad. If you look at (The 100: A Ranking of the Most Influential Persons in History) book written by Micheal H Hart through the median of free speech it was never put on story self to the public. If you were to ask your grandparent that you wanted to marry the same sex person they would smack the teeth out of your mouth. Does not mean that norms change as popular culture takes shape in the light of modernism. I had so much to say but will just finish off by this you do not intend to consciously hurt people by aestheticism or doing foolish things like this, and if things happen then we should be prepared to face them by the antagonist free will of expression. To remind you all FREEDOM OF SPEECH CAN ALSO BE UNJUST LIKE THIS CASE WAS TO 1.2BILLION PEOPLE.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Charles the Great
Canadian/Israeli Goy in Alert,Nunavut
12:12 PM on 09/15/2012
and those 1.2 billion people can say non Muslim are sub human? they do say this in Arab and Muslim Media all the time