Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jeff Cimbalo

GET UPDATES FROM Jeff Cimbalo
 

The G20 Summit's Abject Failure

Posted: 11/05/11 09:50 AM ET

The G20 summit failed utterly to secure any resolution of the eurozone's economic crisis.

Yet two decisions were taken that may at some future point contribute to a solution:

First, the G20 agreed to continue to consider increased involvement of the International Monetary Fund to stem the crisis. In practical terms, this means that the United States and Canada have agreed to consider putting some of their own funds into the rescue pot..

Second, Italy agreed to submit to IMF inspection of its government operations. (Although the Italian parliament could still veto this agreement.

Both items count as good news for Euro bondholders. They also count as bad news for Euro-democracy. As I've been arguing throughout this crisis, Europe can save the euro. Or it can save national democratic self-government. But not both. Getting the IMF involved means less power for voters, more for non-accountable international investors. As Joseph Stiglitz reminds us, the IMF:

does not report directly to either the citizens who finance it or those whose lives it affects. Rather, it reports to the ministries of finance and the central banks of the governments of the world.

Globalization and its Discontents (2002), p. 12.


If, as it appears, there is not enough money in the eurozone and probably the Union to save the euro from the Greek and Italian government assaults on its solvency, can the IMF really accomplish these bailouts on their behalf? Can and will the IMF actually treat Greece or Italy like some desperate LSE-grad-run African country from the 1960s and enforce stringent conditions before aid follows when the eurozone has apparently already cut Greece off? The G20 and the IMF cannot fix the unfixable, so it remains to be seen whether the eurozone can convince them that the crisis can be solved. This week in Paris was not a good sign.

This blog first appeared on FrumForum.com.

 
The G20 summit failed utterly to secure any resolution of the eurozone's economic crisis. Yet two decisions were taken that may at some future point contribute to a solution: First, the G20 agreed ...
The G20 summit failed utterly to secure any resolution of the eurozone's economic crisis. Yet two decisions were taken that may at some future point contribute to a solution: First, the G20 agreed ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:38 PM on 11/06/2011
Many years ago a dyed-in-the-wool socialist told me that in the war between the ideologies of the left and right socialism would eventually win because capitalism would succumb to its own excesses. At the time, we all thought he was crazy. Now I am beginning to believe he might have been on to something. Look around you. The signs are all there.

Have a nice day.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:40 PM on 11/06/2011
Mountain climbers know that hitching everyone to the rope (the Euro) is a mixed blessing. It might save individuals or it might doom the whole lot.
11:10 AM on 11/06/2011
save the euro from the Greek and Italian government assaults on its solvency?

So, the bankers doing the actual assaulting do not merit a mention?

Just like Bloomberg blaming the corrupted while giving a pass to the corruptors.

Government would not be corrupt if Big Money was not buying it. Blaming government is shielding those actually responsible.

We can do better than this spin.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:38 PM on 11/06/2011
The assault on solvency was through a prolonged inability to match government spending with revenue.
07:48 AM on 11/06/2011
There are questions here that need to be answered. First of all just who do we, the people of this planet owe this money to? It seems to me that just about every country, state province and city owes money to "somebody" but to the life of me I ca't seem to fathom who these people are. If there are that many counties in depth then the people lending this money have an awfull lot accumulated and are either doing this illegally or aren't paying a fair share of taxes which would reduce the amount borrowed in the first place. The province I live in, at that time a country of Newfoundland, was once in the same predicament as Greece but it was due to excessive borrowing to support our war effort in WW1. In the 1930's we couldn't pay our loans and we ended up disolving the legislator eventually being governed by a commisioner from Britain which was the very reason we were in default in the first place-fighting a colonial war in Europe for Britain. Today we are pretty much faced with a $8Billion depth and in a very short time will be in the same predicament as our major source of revenue, oil, runs dry. Nearly 60% of the last provincial budget went to pay government salaries in the last government-something which isn' sustainable. I guess Greece isn't alone in this world.
04:51 AM on 11/06/2011
The proposed Greek bailout plan merely postpones the problem and does not solve it. There seems to be little imaginative approaches to dealing with this crisis and kicking the can down the road will not do it. It would be unpleasant to let Greece leave the Euro and go bankrupt but better to deal with the problem right now than having to deal with it in 6 mths time. We are not going to revive the world economy until we get stability even if it means some disasters along the way. In any case the bailout deal for Greece is hardly getting overwhelming support - just 8 vote majority out of 298. What happens if and when there is an election and they then decide not to abide by the agreement? After which time 1.4 trillion euros will have been given to them. Seems like this is going to make the situation worse rather than better. I think people are fed up with bailouts when ultimately the taxpayer has to pay for them, when the taxpayer didn't cause the problem.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norma Ward
09:41 PM on 11/05/2011
Europe's debt problems, outside of Italy, are but a tiny fraction of the world's overall flood of sovereign debt. Here is an article that discusses the projected growth in sovereign debt over the next 5 years:

http://viableopposition.blogspot.com/2011/04/debtworld-were-drowning-in-sea-of-debt.html

The IMF has calculated that the average gross general government debt-to-GDP ratio for the world's advanced economies will rise from 91 percent at the end of 2009 to 110 percent in 2015, an increase of 37 percentage points since the beginning of the Great Recession. When the debt-to-GDP ratio rises above 100 percent, many consider this to be the default danger zone.

Unless governments stop spending and then taxing, we are in for a world of pain.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
peter sfikas
Yia sou
08:05 PM on 11/05/2011
The IMF is really a wolf, in sheep's clothing. The interest of the IMF and it's masters the 1%, has nothing to do with the welfare of a country it pretends to be helping. The real interest of the IMF is to affect more and more, a deeper economic enslavement of the 99%. The bigger the enslavement, the bigger the profits for the vultures. And so, they offer a country in serious economic woes, a quick fix, in return for, a bigger say in running the county's economy and Government. So, I say, save Democracy, preserve your dignity, give the IMF the finger, send them on their way, and give the vulture banks a haircut, as deep as possible. It's the only lesson the bullies can understand.
01:17 AM on 11/06/2011
First off, they need to follow a different template. Austerity as a way to solve economic insolvency was why it took 10 years to resolve the 1930s depression.
05:52 PM on 11/05/2011
It can make the ECB perform the original purpose of a central bank and serve as lender of last resort. A central bank without this function is like a car without wheels and yet these crazy right wingers think it makes sense!
jhNY
Mercy.
01:48 PM on 11/05/2011
"Europe can save the euro. Or it can save national democratic self-government. But not both." Wise words. Fanned.