Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
J.J. McCullough

GET UPDATES FROM J.J. McCullough
 

Big Brother Makes for Crappy TV

Posted: 02/17/2012 4:46 am

Assuming your city is anything like mine, you're no doubt aware that the CBC has recently produced a show called Arctic Air. A casual tourist to Vancouver, in fact, could be excused for thinking Canadians toil under the cruel tyranny of Adam Beach, so omnipresent are the enormous billboards bearing the leading man's world-weary mug. Certainly the red-carpet gala Beach and company received on premiere night last month, in which heaps of fawning praise and applause were thrust upon the dear leader, would have done little to dissuade that notion.

And just as the most garish propaganda seeks to mask inner weakness with over-the-top pomposity, Arctic Air's real-world support has proven to be shakier than Gaddafi's. Though the CBC and other Can-con apologists did their best to spin the numbers favourably, the show's January 10 debut yielded barely over a million viewers, a showing so poor that it failed to even crack BBM Canada's top 30 of the week. To be fair, Arctic Air did briefly sneak into the #27 slot during the last week of January (narrowly edging out a re-run of CSI New York), but has remained absent ever since.

Why Canadians aren't warming to the CBC's latest taxpayer-funded opus is hard to say. In typical Canadian fashion, no mainstream publication appears to have tasked anyone with actually watching the show, meaning most coverage has simply been of the "local boy makes good" variety. One can only presume the subject matter, which centers around a gang of moody misfits attempting to run a rural airline in the Northwest Territories, somewhat lacks mainstream appeal, despite Beach's insistence that bush flying across Yellowknife "speaks volumes about what it is to be Canadian."

In any case, it should go without saying that absolutely no lessons will be learned from the failure of Arctic Air. Fat and happy from government subsidies, mandatory broadcast quotas, and unapologetically rigged award shows, the Canadian television industry is quite content to live in its parallel universe where normal laws of success and failure do not apply. In this topsy-turvy dimension, fame and laurels are always awarded first, with trivial things like "viewership" coming much later, if at all.

When pressed, the Canadian media-industrial complex will justify their skewered standards of accomplishment with the conveniently conspiratorial fairy tale that the only reason Canadians aren't watching more Can-con is because the devil Americans wont let us. There's no shortage of violent verbiage available to describe the horror; our markets are "bombarded," "saturated," "overrun," etc. Yet in reality, thanks to the billion-dollar-a-year budget of the CBC and its not-much-less subsidized competitors, never before in history have Canadians had more readily available access to Canadian-made alternatives. It's easier than ever to watch, say, Republic of Doyle rather than Two and a Half Men --  yet we still elect not to.

If you've never done so before, I highly advise checking out Canada's TV ratings, as they offer such a stark view of the reality that Canadian officialdom does its best to deny. Canada's most beloved shows are consistently the most clichéd examples of crass Americana -- The Big Bang Theory, Dancing with the Stars, Canadian Idol, etc -- while the subsidized offerings that "speak volumes about what it is to be Canadian" languish near the bottom.

The fact that Canadian tastes in entertainment are not particularly patriotic but are largely indistinguishable from our southern neighbours is a stubborn fact no amount of central planning can seem to kill; not advertising blitzes, not prime time quotas, and certainly not a fourth season of Being Erica.

In such a climate, the Internet remains a great oasis for Canada's beleaguered audiences, and in a hopefully portentous decision last week, the Supreme Court defied the usual cartel of actors' unions and culture lobbyists in declaring that Internet Service Providers do not officially count as "broadcasters" and were thus immune from the byzantinian web of content regulations that have long shackled the cable networks.

While it's possible to read too much into this narrow ruling, it's clear from the freaked out reactions of some members of the culturati that our present era of forcing Canadians to pay for TV shows they don't want to watch so they can hog air time from those they do isn't guaranteed to survive the information age.

Culture is an undeniable part of any nation's identity, yet it must also be something which arises organically through a mass aggregate of individual tastes, of which (for better or worse) the marketplace remains the most useful measurement. So there's only one conclusion that can be drawn from the cultural climate of a nation like Canada, where a small, self-interested elite exerts so much energy limiting, controlling, and denouncing the preferences of the majority.

In other words, maybe the billboards send the right message after all.

 

 

Follow J.J. McCullough on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JJ_McCullough

 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:08 AM on 03/13/2012
"a nation like Canada, where a small, self-interested elite exerts so much energy limiting, controlling, and denouncing the preferences of the majority."

Love it! The same can be said of the Monarchists.
04:41 PM on 02/19/2012
I am not so sure that The Big Bang Theory should count as " just another American show " . The root of The Big Bang Theory is the geek sub-culture, not American culture writ large. Plenty of Canadians watch Big Bang Theory, and what do the characters on Big Bang Theory watch? Doctor Who and plenty of anime.
09:01 AM on 02/19/2012
I love CBC radio and the CBC website. These two sources expose me to many things I wouldn't find in the mainstream media. I don't watch CBC TV very often. I watched Being Erica and i enjoyed it but it isn't important to me.
10:40 PM on 02/18/2012
I know what JJ is saying about the Canadian TV industry. I also don't feel there is enough Canadian prime-time content out there, but this is where I disagree with JJ- I feel that while it's still far from ideal, Canadian content has been getting better in the past 10-20 years. I work in the film/TV industry in Vancouver as well, and it is a definite up-hill battle, I've seen so many good shows fail because some exec had a difference of opinion over what people watch or whatever, but I'm still feeling optimistic about future content.
Also, by and large the numbers show that we watch American shows. So what? It's in English. and reality TV shows have dominated all the english speaking country markets since the first season of 'survivor'. What IS exceptional is that the 2nd highest viewership in Canada is for the Big Bang theory, a 30-minute comedy about scientists. THAT'S unusual. I don't think it's really an example of 'crass Americana'.
07:28 PM on 02/18/2012
Excellent article as always. Don't let some of these other commenters get you down. Film and television types in Canada, and elsewhere, have an insanely overinflated opinion of themselves as being 'culture creators' and 'storytellers'. Arctic Air is an abysmally bad show. Bad acting, bad writing, bad concept. The CBC hasn't done anything worth watching since Kids in the Hall, and the Toronto decision makers hated that show with a passion.
04:21 PM on 02/18/2012
Wow! CBC puts together a truly original show (i.e. no cops show, no house full of contestants with fake breasts and roided up muscles, no doctor show or otherwise copy of a usual format) and they do it with one of our most talented actors and draw a huge audience and that's a failure.
You must be waiting for an American production company to swipe the idea and call it "AirAlaska ". No doubt that would give them access to the "real" audience in the US and it could take its place along classics like "Big Brother" and 2 and a half reruns
As for Rick Mercer? Why don't we ask everybody who's the better known comedian. Never heard of you before HP and you've never written anything funny here that I've seen. Or is this really an ethical oil dispatch in disguise.
07:50 PM on 02/18/2012
Just because a show is original doesn't mean its good. Planes flying across the arctic hasn't been done before probably because its a boring concept. You call it as Canadian as you want, but how many Canadians live anywhere close to the Arctic? Ratings for Arctic Air are "good" for Canadian programming, which is really bad - because the ratings are less than 1 million normally. The CBC is just feeding terrible shows and scripts. Rick Mercer is an exception, and him being funnier does nothing to take away from the writer's comments.

Canadian programming can be very good, and when that happens, it doesn't really need to be subsidized. Take a look at Flash Point, its a phenomenal show, and gets multimillion ratings worldwide.
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
01:52 PM on 02/19/2012
It's not a totally original idea. Wings made a hit show from fundamentally the same concept; the life and times of a rural airline staff.

Also, US shows take the top 10 spots among Canadian audiences; having access to a "real" audience in the US doesn't come into the debate at all.

And finally, your appeal to fame is crap. Rick Mercer has more fame than JJ, but unless you've appeared on SunNews JJ has more fame than you. None of that proves which one of you three is right.
04:57 PM on 02/19/2012
Good point about "wings",JJ. However, CBC. regularly cracks top ten on individual nights and Rick Mercer does well even with reruns. As to SunNews, JJ (oh sorry, I"ll call you Brad for this post) that's not fame that's infamy.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:03 PM on 02/18/2012
As a 55 yr. old wife of 37 years, mother of 2 daughters, & a Canadian business owner, living 65 miles from Detroit, MI and 62 miles from Cleveland, OH, across lake Erie, I was raised on both Canadian and American T.V. My preference is good t.v., no matter where it comes from. I absolutely hate sexually suggestive or down right hard cor porn that passes for entertainment these days, and most if not all "reality t.v.". That is why most of the day, CBC is on at our house. I love the political, drama, news and pure Canadian humour like no one can deliver like Rick Mercer and Ron James! I will gladly pay my taxes to support our talent that emerges from our borders. I am very proud to live in a country that supports its entertainment industry, actors, musicians, and the grants for local theatre, in order for our up and coming Justin Biebers, Michelle Wrights, Anne Murrays, William Shatners, & Michael J. Foxs to get a strong foundation to have successful careers. We live in one of the most diverse countries, and if we do not allow that diversity to shine in all its original spirit, instead of the cookie cutter crap that seems to ooze out of our HDTV boxes, how will the next star ever have the courage to shine? The negative vortex surrounding the USA these days for anything "different" can't become our standard, let us be better than that.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
03:42 PM on 02/18/2012
All irrelevant. TV is dying and internet content is the coffin.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
03:40 PM on 02/18/2012
Speaking of culture, the CBC has been around for many, many decades. How about yourself?
jimbo57
ni dieu ni maitre
08:49 AM on 02/18/2012
Haven't laughed at anything made in Canada since "Made In Canada".
10:51 PM on 02/17/2012
The problem with Canadian television is that it isn't good. Arctic Air? A terrible cliche ridden drama. Rick Mercer? About as funny as a 90 year old man dying of cancer of the colon. Why can't it be like the BBC?
03:19 AM on 02/18/2012
People complain about the BBC in exactly the same way. They just don't pay those people any attention because they are.....ta da!!!!! provincial.
10:31 PM on 02/18/2012
Because the BBC has 6 times the budget, is located in a much smaller country, and only has to produce content in one language.
05:07 PM on 02/17/2012
The fact that Canadians seem to prefer crappy celebrity/reality, cops and robbers, and stupid comedy sitcom shows over CanCon only reaffirms the truth of television being - mostly - a vast wasteland, and indicates that we do indeed need more Canadian made shows (with the exception of the Kevin O'Leary and faux talent shows). Arctic Air isn't great drama, but I do like how it opens a window into our northern culture and terrain and the importance of aircraft above the 60th parallel. Republic of Doyle is amusing, and I like the (all-too-brief) shots of St. Johns in the background. Little Mosque on the Prairie has much-deserved international recognition, and David Suzuki, the Passionate Eye, Doc Zone, Marketplace, Fifth Estate are interesting and informative, 22 Minutes is very funny, Heartland is very popular, etc. etc. I'd rather watch those shows than most crap coming out of the US.

I also want to plug two shows that the Aboriginal People's Television Network (APTN) airs - Cashing In and Blackstone. If you have virgin ears, don't tune in, but if you want to see some well-made, gritty, Canadian aboriginal-focussed drama, with good acting (especially the deliciously EVIL Eric Schweig), then by all means give them a look. Too bad they're not on CBC!
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
12:11 AM on 02/18/2012
The only Canadian TV show I've really liked was DiVinci's Inquest -- one of those cops and robbers shows you'd call part of the television wasteland and blame on the US. Something about that makes me chuckle.
04:21 PM on 02/18/2012
Au contraire. One of my alltime fave shows was DaVinci's inquest, as was the American Law and Order (the original series, not the spinoffs), and Homicide. But I find the vast majority of cops and robbers shows nowadays are lame imitations of the best ones, with formulaic plots, glitzed-up actors (c'mon, all policewomen, women lawyers and judges can't all be that beautiful!!), and run-of-the-mill acting. Waste of time.
04:19 PM on 02/17/2012
Never mind the guy's ignorance on ratings numbers and what they mean...but the facts are not that Arctic Air is a failure. In a country of 30 million, only 23 mil of whom speak English, the show has consistently drawn over a million viewers. That's the equivalent of 14 million viewers in the USA (10% of the USA pop) which would be, by any measure, a massive hit.

What JJ has done is somehow divine failure by using as his metric the Top 30 programs, which are regularly dominated by sports, live events, programs like Idol, and yup, U.S. shows -- Canadians love em. But that's roughly like looking at the home run totals of Aaron, Babe Ruth, Sosa and declaring that Jose Bautista is a failure.

Then he twists himself into knots to concede that this "failure" DID, in fact, crack this mythical top 30 shows. It's sheer nonsense.

Cdn made shows like Arctic Air, Heartland, The Listener, Flashpoint, Rookie Blue, now regularly top a million. Cdn shows were in the top ten all summer, which is where most of the private nets burnoff their CanCon. They manage to do this without the benefit of simulcast (running on two channels at once, and on the backs of US promotional budgets 100x the size of Canadian ones.)

There's facts, and there's fantasy. JJ's fantasy of failure comes with a sponsorship:, doctrinaire conservative dogma. HuffPo doesn't pay its columists. Clearly you get what you pay for.
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
12:55 AM on 02/18/2012
So you're saying the US shows have 100x the budget, and you get what you pay for? And Canadian shows are Jose Bautista to the USA's Babe Ruth? Are you sure you're disagreeing with JJ?
photo
Brady Postma
Know-it-all.
01:58 AM on 02/18/2012
BBM seems to indicate that more Canadians watch The Big Bang Theory than all of Canadian-made narrative television combined. I don't know how you can spin that as a victory for Canadian television.

In case it's not clear, I say "narrative television" to differentiate between shows with scripted plots (sitcoms, dramas, etc) and shows without (such as sports, reality, and news shows).
02:29 PM on 02/18/2012
Only in Canada would you find someone pointing to the number one show on television and saying that all domestic shows are a failure because they don't beat it. It's a ridiculous argument, and a ridiculous article.
10:36 PM on 02/18/2012
It's not a zero-sum game. If Big Bang Theory is successful, it doesn't diminish the achievements of Arctic Air.
02:47 PM on 02/17/2012
There's only one option: Ban American TV shows.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigLittle
12:20 PM on 02/17/2012
You are either fibbing for effect or you have no idea how the t.v. business works in Canada.
Other than the Parliamentary appropriation, for which the CBC alone guarantees service to the ENTIRE COUNTRY....
...All the broadcasters, public and private, receive the same subsidies.
CTV, CBC, Global....all their subsidies are equally doled out, from same money pit, all of it tax money.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Maria Korovessis Sewell
To decimate is to reduce by one tenth.
02:39 PM on 02/17/2012
F&F'd.