Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Josey Vogels

GET UPDATES FROM Josey Vogels
 

If Women Don't Want Kids, Are They Inadequate?

Posted: 09/23/11 09:00 AM ET

I've never had any burning urge to reproduce. There's no family pressure and plenty of grandkids, even great grandkids, from the other siblings. And spending two days at our cottage with a friend's rugrats quelled my urge even more.

I admire women who have always known they would have kids, no question. But I also admire the ones who have always known they would not.

Like my friend Karen, now in her 40s, she knew by her mid-20s that she never wanted kids and got her tubes tied at 31. "I could not see bringing yet another child into this messed up world," she says. "If I did want kids, I'd prefer to adopt a child who needed a home, rather than create another human being."

Frankly, I wish people with kids had to defend their position as thoroughly as those who don't want children. Because, heaven knows, some folks are having kids for the wrong reasons.

Say, to have someone to take care of them when they're older.

But, chances are your partner and/or your friends will be more reliable in old age than some kid who will no doubt grow up and move to Australia.

Another argument is that people who don't have children are selfish. And your point is? Yes, I like the freedom to work and enjoy life with just little old me to think about. Besides, give me a break. Why do you think people have kids? To further the human race? For the kid's sake? Doubtful. Usually, it's just the thing to do. Or, as Karen says, to create the ultimate accessory. "It's typically women who are oohing and ahhing over all things baby, the teensy clothes/shoes -- 'oh isn't this adorable?' -- photos, all the nursery stuff. It's like a commodity."

Sure, some people have kids because they genuinely like them, but there are plenty of folks who don't.

The last big grief people who choose not to have kids hear is this: "You'll regret it." There are plenty of things I could regret if I let myself. But I certainly don't want to have a kid just in case I regret not having one. Karen says she hasn't regretted her decision for one second. "If I feel the desire to be around children, I have my sister's kids -- and remember, I don't hate the little buggers in the least!"

Okay, let me say it too. I enjoy kids, sort of. I like the fun stuff but I'm always ready to hand them back after an hour or so. New mothers always say it's different with your own. But what if it's not? You can't toss 'em back.

Obviously, we have some genetic disposition to reproduce or the race would have ended long ago. But it's not for everyone. And I don't want to feel inadequate or less of a complete woman for not popping out a kid.

We make childbearing so noble, such an achievement, like it's the most exciting, fulfilling thing you can do. For some, I'm sure it is. But, given our social bias, deciding not to have a child is an equally noble and difficult decision. And that, I think, deserves a cigar.

 
I've never had any burning urge to reproduce. There's no family pressure and plenty of grandkids, even great grandkids, from the other siblings. And spending two days at our cottage with a friend's ru...
I've never had any burning urge to reproduce. There's no family pressure and plenty of grandkids, even great grandkids, from the other siblings. And spending two days at our cottage with a friend's ru...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 154
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
10:58 PM on 11/10/2011
Are men inadequate if they don't want children?
evecaren
Every cloud has a silver lining
09:50 AM on 10/22/2011
If Women don't want kids, are they inadequate? Certainly not ! If we define inadequate as
not good enough, not good enough for what? Not every woman wants to have a child and
that doesn't make them any less of a woman. It's a very personal decision. Some women
want to have a child, but for some reason are unable to conceive. Some women can't picture
themselves with a child for various reasons. I am lucky because as a retired primary teacher
I had the great priviledge of teaching other people's children and feeling like I made a difference
in their lives.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
slvrfox857
questionevrthing.blogspot.com
12:55 PM on 10/02/2011
I think it would be bad for the children if a woman who doesn't want them were pressured into having them by a society that cares only about appearances (it's expected to have a husband, 1.7 children and a dog.) I've said for some years that we need to redefine what's expected of both women and men for a new, post mythology world.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:46 PM on 10/01/2011
If I ever did have a biological clock, it must have been digital, never heard even one tick! I also married late enough in life that children are not an issue. They give out licenses for driving, for pet ownership, for fishing, but just about anyone who doesn't have fertility issues can have a child or two or three or 17! regardless of emotional stability, psychosis, addiction, poverty, or just plain suitability. What's wrong with this picture? There are some people who should just not contribute to the gene pool.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cye
10:15 AM on 10/01/2011
I live in Australia and this issue is very topical as we currently have a female Prime Minister who is, as well as being unmarried and an atheist, childless.

While I think most Australians don't care very much about her not having children, she has been criticized by a number of politicians (usually conservatives) for being childless. They have labeled here "barren", and seek to portray her as ambitious, heartless and unable to relate to 'everyday' Australians. She was also accused (by one particularly noxious Left-wing polly) of lacking compassion, because she doesn't have children.

All of this is extremely galling because of its sexism and unfairness. You don't need children to be empathetic, or to be a good person, or to relate to others.

Its interesting that this attitude still informs the perspectives of so many politicians in Australia.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cye
09:56 AM on 10/01/2011
I absolutely didn't want kids in my 20s and even in my early 30s. By by mid-30s my partner and I had a change of heart and decided to try for kids. As a result, we found out that, for various reasons, we're unable to have children.

We're in the process, I guess, of trying to accept this. Its been difficult. I never had a burning desire to have kids when I was younger, but always thought that it would eventually happen. I feel regret and have been second-guessing every decision I ever made in my life. But at the same time, it seems silly to regret not having kids earlier, when we simply didn't want them and, in all honestly, couldn't have supported them.

But I also have been wondering what exactly would be so terrible if we didn't eventually have kids.

I am not sure how all of this will end. I don't know if I will end up feeling inadequate and less of a women for not being able to have kids. I guess only time will tell.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Vicki Larson
Journalist, mother, thinker
10:46 AM on 09/28/2011
It's true — women who don't want kids are thought less of, wrongly, which I wrote about on Mommy Tracked: http://www.mommytracked.com/watercooler_vicki_larson_elizabeth_gilbert_ayelet_waldman. Elizabeth Gilbert addressed what makes a hero in her book, "The Last American Man" — our idea of the classic American masculine hero is totally lacking any romantic or sexual notions. It’s man versus wild, alone or perhaps with a sidekick — a male sidekick. Women? If we choose whatever classic heroic journeys might be available to us, we’re seen as selfish, especially if we choose ambition over family. Why?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Wren Egan
10:46 AM on 09/28/2011
I'd rather regret not having a kid but be happy I spent my time and affection on my friends' and family's children than regret having one.
09:17 AM on 09/28/2011
Great article!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pantsy
04:45 PM on 09/27/2011
its really nice to see other women feel the same way. i've known since i was a child i didnt want to have kids. people would always say, oh you will. no, i wont. and havent. not once have i felt that need to have a kid. (and i still find the idea of it pretty gross)
plus, i'm pretty happy with the way my vagina came, why would i want to muck it all up? the moment i learned what episiotomy means, that solidified my decision.
01:20 PM on 09/27/2011
My thoughts exactly. I think attitudes are changing a little bit about childless women, but we've got a long ways to go before choosing to be childless is as revered as choosing motherhood. Starting the discussion is a good first step.

www.elizabethfarrar.com
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Rozgonyi
Writer and traveler
02:35 AM on 09/27/2011
Sing it, Sister! I had to travel out of state (from Colorado to Wyoming) to get my tubes snipped at age 21, because every doctor said I'd regret it. Guess what? 13 years later, with a partner who also never wants kids, I spend my days writing in peace and quiet with none or few of the worries and financial issues my friends with children have. Apart from that, I spend the rest of my life on two wheels, motorbiking around Europe and Asia. :) Can't do that with a kid strapped on the back. We live exactly as we please, every minute of the day. One kid would wreck that in an instant.

I'm selfish about it, unashamedly. I'm also one of those people who will freely admit I do not like children. I don't h8 them, but they offer me nothing, so why bother with them unless I have to (like when hanging out with friends with kids)? We support a beautiful little Khmer girl in a village in Cambodia, and have even committed to pay for her college education in full. That's about as much "kid" as I can do.
11:45 AM on 09/26/2011
I applaud your decision! Your feelings are exactly like my 29 yr old daughters'. She could have written this article word for word! There is NOTHING wrong with women who choose not to have kids. Get that people NOTHING! I get so tired of people telling me that "Oh,she(my daughter) will change her mind" Nope dont hold your breath!! She does.not. want. kids. Her dad and I are fine with and respect her decision. So get over it people. Everyone doesn't have to have a kid to feel complete! And I certainly dont want her to have one just so I can be a grammie.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
americancolonyinhell
11:15 AM on 09/26/2011
Personally, I love looking at, listening to, and watching my son. Wish I had managed to give him a sibling. Furthermore, since I've done my best to love him, I'm guessing he'll be there for me when I'm breathing my last.
07:24 PM on 09/26/2011
Men rarely take over care for their aging parents. It is typically the eldest daughter or the daughter-in-law. Not speculation, entirely research-based, but then again, that research is now a generation behind. It will be interesting to see whether or not it holds true in our generation given the decrease in number of children per family.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
americancolonyinhell
11:37 PM on 09/26/2011
As long as I don't poison our love, I'm sure he'll be there for me.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Rozgonyi
Writer and traveler
02:36 AM on 09/27/2011
I don't mean to be crude, or to belittle what you have, which sounds like exactly what you want and need. But to mention a benefit of kids as being there to watch you die in the third sentence is a bit off.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
americancolonyinhell
09:36 AM on 09/27/2011
Dude, the article specifically mentions children not being there for their parents when they reach adulthood. I assume we'll have a wonderful relationship up until the time of my death.
09:50 AM on 09/26/2011
Men who say they don't want kids never seem to face the same criticism as women. Men are never told that they need to become fathers to be "complete."

The people I know, both married and single, who have made the choice not to have kids have put much more thought into their decision than most of those people I know who pop out kids one after the other.

I do not want kids of my own. I am an assistant karate teacher, so I spend a great deal of time with kids, and I really do enjoy working with them. Parents have told me, "I'm surprised you don't have kids. You are so good with them." I say, "Thank you," while I'm actually thinking, "Your 90 minutes are up. Please take your kids home now."

We are not all cut out to be parents, just as we are not all cut out to be soldiers, doctors, artists, teachers, or athletes. We should not be forced defend our decision to pursue the lives that will make us happy. The human race will not be endangered if some of us choose not to procreate.