Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kathy Buckworth

GET UPDATES FROM Kathy Buckworth
 

The "No Internet" Punishment: Online Rules for Out of Line Kids

Posted: 03/19/2012 2:17 pm

I've always believed in the parenting principle of finding out what your kids like the most... and then taking it away from them as a form of punishment.

The thing is, kids are very transparent, or "authentic" in today's social media terminology. They simply cannot hide when there is a toy they really love, a friend they prefer over all others, or an activity they can't wait to do. Favourite things vary for each child, and of course this changes for the child themselves as they go through different ages and stages. I have four children, and taking away Star Wars Lego is a much bigger punishment for my nine-year-old son than it is of course for his 18-year-old brother. On the other hand, they'd both feel the pain from an imposed Xbox ban -- something that wouldn't bother either one of my daughters at all. I even have one child who would be extremely unhappy if I didn't let him mop the kitchen floor anymore. (I rarely use this as punishment. Why deny him such fun? )

But as kids outgrow their personal preferences and you start to think about resorting to the age old parenting technique of grounding them, remember that this action results in them spending more time in the house (you want to think this one through, trust me). We can also run out of ways to follow through on the verbal threat, simply exhausting the list of appropriate non-permanently damaging course of punishment actions. This can sometimes result in an empty threat, such as "You'll never watch TV again." At this point, all of your threats and promises become meaningless, and they know it. Kids sense indecision like dogs sense fear.

Which is why I love parenting in this digital age. While many parents (rightfully) bemoan the challenges of guiding their children through the online complexities of email, Facebook, Twitter and the Internet as a whole, I embrace these challenges as a small price to pay to encourage my kids to get online for the simple reason that it gives me a whole new set of punishment tools.

"Don't want to clean up your room? No Facebook for you."

"You're going to talk to me like that? I guess you won't be emailing with your friends about how unfair I am."

I even once made my teenage son friend me on Facebook as a type of punishment. They really don't want to be your friend, and they really don't like it when you comment "Cute top!" under a picture of them at a party.
And we haven't even begun to discuss the pure parenting enjoyment that comes from taking away a smartphone. Or simply letting their pre-paid cell phone run out as a more passive-aggressive form of digital punishment.

Forget the Time Out Mat; let their phones time out instead. And tell them everyone you connected with on Twitter agrees with you. You might want to even "favourite" it yourself.

Quick Poll

Is "No Internet" a realistic punishment?

VOTE



Follow Kathy Buckworth on Twitter @KathyBuckworth; visit www.kathybuckworth.com. Kathy's latest book, "I Am So The Boss of You" will be released by McClelland & Stewart in March, 2013.

 

Follow Kathy Buckworth on Twitter: www.twitter.com/KathyBuckworth

I've always believed in the parenting principle of finding out what your kids like the most... and then taking it away from them as a form of punishment. The thing is, kids are very transparent, or ...
I've always believed in the parenting principle of finding out what your kids like the most... and then taking it away from them as a form of punishment. The thing is, kids are very transparent, or ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:35 PM on 03/20/2012
That's right. Take away the very thing that enables them to learn and compete in the Future. That's a good idea!
03:33 PM on 03/20/2012
The bigger question is about boundaries for behavior -- is putting an electronic muzzle on your child going to make them say the right things when you take it off, or just push them away from the source of censorship (the home)? A spanking is just an unpleasant sensation and later a shaming; restriction of friendships (has that EVER worked?) is a basic dehumanization tactic; a message to the child that you consider their friendships and thoughts as less valuable than other peoples. Perhaps demonstrating a lack of respect for their values is your strategy; if so , this is definitely the way to go-- silence them. Many organizations, countries, religions, etc have employed this strategy of silencing "their children", and look how great it turned out for them.
03:32 PM on 03/20/2012
I think the author should take an informal survey of people her parents age who enjoyed punishing their children and see how their relationships are to their adult children. Or the idea that punishment is a positive force in a child's life at all. Is being good simply a transactional cost-benefit analysis for a child? And is restricting communication on people something that should be taught as corrective behavior in a free society? I imagine this would cause a child or teen to seek out information on people in covert ways when they are forbidden to do it openly. Which of course may pay off for them, so they will now have a way to find out things about their parents covertly as well. I like the comment above about the child that didn't care about punishments; but I have two follow-ups to that: A) The kid may just have decided you weren't worth enough to respond to, or B) wait until you need them and then too bad for you.
08:29 AM on 03/20/2012
No internet is fine , IF that is what is important to them. Now, one of our biggest issues was our second son never really had an issue with punishment, no matter what is was he just took it and never gave much of a response as far as how much it bothered him. THAT was frustrating as heck...lol. Thank God they are all 20+ now, we all lived through it, if only the last 2 would move out !!!!lol.
mikiao
Empty my micro-bio is.
02:17 PM on 03/20/2012
My parents had the same problem with me. If they sent me to my room, I'd read. Take away my computer/Nintendo/toys? I'd read. Can't go to my friend's house? I'd read. They tried to ban me from reading once...I spent most of the time just staring at them. Apparently that freaks parents out, a quiet child always looking at 'em.

I've told all my cousins my method. Apparently, even pretending like they enjoy reading is enough to short out parent's brains when it comes to punishment. I hope my kids never learn about this....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FearlessFreep
A radical leftist with a JS Woodsworth avatar.
06:21 PM on 03/19/2012
Kids, don't let your parents know what you like best!
photo
oneyippie
Leaning far to your left
05:17 PM on 03/19/2012
Funny and on target! Good luck with your book.