Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Keith Beardsley

GET UPDATES FROM Keith Beardsley
 

Paul Martin Should Get Off Aboriginal High Horse

Posted: 01/25/2012 10:37 am

Most reports indicate some progress was made at the Crown-First Nations Gathering yesterday. This is positive news and a sign that both sides are inching forward and making progress. While there was speculation that Harper would only attend for a few minutes, he surprised observers by committing much of his day to the proceedings.

While we can concentrate on the differences between the sides right down to what symbolism was used -- Harper referred to the Indian Act as a tree while Shawn Atleo, National Chief, described it as a rock -- there are other positive signs. Clearly Atleo and Harper get along and communicate with each other. I get the sense that there is a mutual respect for each other and this comes across in public. This bodes well for any private discussions they might have.

Another significant feature of yesterday's meeting was the amount of time the Prime Minister committed to the event. Anyone who has worked with a Prime Minister knows the intense pressure their schedule is under. This holds true at the ministerial level as well. Meetings and time commitments are measured in minutes, not hours. The fact that Harper set aside his agenda to spend a significant amount of his day at the conference sends a signal to both ministers and departmental officials that the Prime Minister has now taken a keen interest in these files. That should translate into better results.

Clearly the Indian Act will be overhauled. While Atleo suggested doing away with it, in effect that is what will happen by the time it is updated, amended, and changed. This will be a significant step forward providing of course both sides cooperate, show good faith, and agree on the necessary changes.

Some of the items announced in the joint statement are important to First Nations as they try to manage their affairs. Moving to a multi-year funding arrangement is crucial. No longer will Chiefs have to go cap in hand to the minister and department each year.

The same holds true for educational reforms and developing an action plan for economic development for First Nations. Both sides are inching forward. If the constructive tone on display at the gathering continues, there is a possibility of real progress. Long overdue progress, maybe measured in inches, but at least things are moving in the right direction.

I was disappointed to see former prime minister Paul Martin come out and attack Harper on the conference. I think this was a missed opportunity. Martin has built up considerable experience working with First Nations. His foundation -- Martin Aboriginal Education Initiative (MAEI) -- and its success in working to advance education and training opportunities offers one model, although not the only one, on ways to move educational issues forward.

He has also had success in attracting corporate donations and investment to encourage aboriginal business development. I would have preferred to see him offer to work with the present Prime Minister, rather than refight old battles. In the same way I hope the present government will not ignore Martin's work or expertise simply because he is a former political opponent and Liberal Prime Minister. First Nations issues should cross party lines. Solutions not scoring political points should be the end game.

 

Follow Keith Beardsley on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Atory01

 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:55 AM on 01/29/2012
Yawn. Another Harper flunky gets to spout Harpercon talking points and attack the Liberals.

Funny how Keith Beardsley (Government relations strategist; former senior advisor and deputy chief of staff for issues management to Prime Minister Stephen Harper.) takes offence with Martin for what he wanted to do but praises Harper for just showing up.... One wonders if Mr. Beardsley is letting his lobbying get in the way of an objective article...
07:13 AM on 01/27/2012
Nice that Huffpo lets us drift back and forth across the border without ever showing a passport .

I reminds me of growing up in N. New York..where....friendly, pleasent policemen from both countries seemed to enjoy easy duty on both sides of the line smiling and waving at the cars that slowed to the posted 15 mph speed limit......which ALL invariably did

It seems like ancient history now when "There's gettin' ta be noo difference between uz ya know"..was routinely heard on both sides of the border....for the excellent reason that it was TRUE...

By the way...with regard to "first nations" such a better term than indians...(dot OR feather as they say in Canada)....Your history isn't a whole lot less barbarous than ours...... but you seem to have at least limited the amount of hypocrisy in the LANGUAGE you use to discuss this issue (and many others btw)...such to mitigate some of the harshness, and IGNORANCE which is the mainstay of discussions between native-Americans and we (many) tawmee-come-lately types..for a couple of hundred years.

It doesn't require a saint to live up to "honesty is the best policy"...provided it doesn't require an unusually enterprising scholar to cut through the myths to find out what actually happened.....
WHich often turns out to be the ROOT of the problem on this "side of the line"

Just my two cents
tm
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
02:48 PM on 01/26/2012
Paul Martin must be an Indian he is living in the past. Would anyone out there have a relationship with someone that is continually bringing up the past to you? If white people followed an Indian culture we would still be shooting Germans maybe we could take on Japan again too. How sad that Indian Chiefs have to keep their people in a perpetual state of hate instead of showing oportunities that are available.
10:40 PM on 01/26/2012
I'm sure our First Nation's look back with regret at losing the opportunity to advance their cause, and ultimately this countries, with the initiative that former PM Martin offered with the Kelowna Accord - six years have been lost. Now, the Harper Gov't chooses to address his abandonment of same when the wood hits the coals - reactive instead of proactive as there history shows. Be interesting to follow this governments 'progressive' steps in addressing this ongoing tragedy.
09:35 AM on 01/28/2012
'Continually bringing up the past'? A little geography for you, India is a subcontinent on LITERALLY the other side of the world. White people call Natives Indians because as settlers they were told by the church they were in India collecting spices. In the spirit of being the most easily deceived race of people to ever walk the earth, they continued to believe this up until, well we don't really know because as far as I can tell white people think they're STILL in freaking INDIA collecting FREAKING SPICES!!!! Maybe if we spent a little time 'bringing up the past' we wouldn't use terms that actually showcase how we believe anything anyone tells us without knowing that the words that come out of our mouths are actually like big billboards pointing out how easy we are to trick.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
11:48 AM on 01/26/2012
When is the HuffPost going to stop giving right-wing think tanks column space as if they were somehow not Tory-allied? Shouldn't you at least identify True North Public Affairs in such a manner, or do you want to pretend (as they like to) that they're independent of political allegiances?
04:33 PM on 01/26/2012
No Kidding! This one just like Nichols is in the Harper Inc. inner circle.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tnanimation
11:35 AM on 01/26/2012
Thank you for the message from the PMO, Keith.
08:25 AM on 01/26/2012
Actually Paul Martin is not on a high horse. It is just that Harper is writhing on his belly. Haper's plan is to get the chiefs to allow the pipeline to the Pacific to cross their lands in exchange for some money. The thing is the pipeline is a no go if the aboriginals say no to it. And so far they are saying no. What they want is a new deal - jobs. and rights to a share of the profit from the various resources mined in their territory. Martin has done a lot for the aboriginals. Harper sees the m as a model for most of the Canadian population. And to denigrate Martin does not elevate Haper. Harper is PM and so far he has been dirtier and greacier and slimier and more damaging than any PM in the history of Canada. He makes snakes in the grass look good and the chiefs weren't fooled by him.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigLittle
12:42 AM on 01/26/2012
Still say this is p.r. copy. If not billing by article, is the author on retainer? We should know.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
11:49 AM on 01/26/2012
Of course it's PR copy, True North Public Affairs is not a think-tank, it's a Tory-allied/supported p.r. firm.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
geminivoyager
11:39 PM on 01/25/2012
Paul who?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Good to know
07:30 PM on 01/25/2012
Shame on you. Educate yourself please.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
toofarleft4thisworld
The Right Is So Wrong
04:11 PM on 01/25/2012
i concur, the shame of how the First Nations have been treated in Canada crosses party lines. it's not about the last 6 years. it's about the last 300.
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
04:08 PM on 01/25/2012
The Conservatives haven't done anything in the past six years and they will do nothing in the next six. Why would Mr. Martin want to be associated with these people? The only way the Conservatives will do anything at all is if they find natural resources where they live. Even than they will take the majority of the royalties.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kristopher Leang
training to take down the elite
04:59 PM on 01/26/2012
ya that was might thought exactly.. actually first it was "eww gross" why would you want to soil your reputation by giving the cons ANY legitimacy or support by agreeing with them. we dont, their actions have been insulting and counter to the canadian way..
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bec DeCorbeau
Le langage de l'invisible est le silence
02:47 PM on 01/25/2012
You start with a false premise (or named: dream of harper):

"While Atleo suggested doing away with it, in effect that is what will happen by the time it is updated, amended, and changed."

It's a way of saying, no means yes!
02:40 PM on 01/25/2012
Hey Keith,

Can you tell me the total amount of time our current Prime Minister has devoted to Aboriginal Affairs? How much time has he spent sitting down with our Aboriginal Peoples? He had to fly to Switzerland for a meeting which cut short his time at this meeting. As a Canadian, as an Aboriginal Canadian I'd rather see him say to the rest of the world "I have problems at home which I haven't dealt with so excuse me if I'm a little late".

Yes let's work with the government to make things better for all Canadians but if Harper continues to hold onto the Indian Act these talks will ultimately fail. Our Prime Minister continues to put the needs of big business ahead of the needs of the country and he's doing so again with aboriginal affairs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tokenblackman
02:30 PM on 01/25/2012
Of course your disappointed with Paul Martin. You work for Harper!