Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Kolby Solinsky

GET UPDATES FROM Kolby Solinsky
 

It's Time for Canadian Hockey Fans to Side With the Players

Posted: 08/15/2012 1:16 pm

Give Michael Grange's piece a read. If my analysis of his work is correct, the NHLPA's just-released CBA counter offer is them saying, "Hey, we like it how it is, but we'll take some smaller, broader cuts of things that we don't operate or control on a day-to-day basis because, 1) that's what you wanted, Evil Owner Empire, and 2) this will make us look nice."

Sheep in wolf's clothing. That's what Grange referred to it as, even though he seemed to side with the players in their newest struggle to keep hockey going for one more, Goddamn year. We all know what happened last time, when the league shut down for a full season. Some players' careers were ruined (which will surely happen this time to players who are hanging onto their prime like the Sedin twins, Henrik Zetterberg, and Ilya Kovalchuk), it re-shaped the game and benefited only those who had yet to enter (which none of these players are now, since they're all technically veterans and professionals, whether they've played one year or 20), and it was the first time since Mike Milbury shook and threatened a 12-year-old in Massachusetts last year that players and their crowds felt the same kind of emotion: emptiness.

But, the game has changed, and maybe it's time for hockey fans -- specifically those in Canada -- to do something they've never done: side with the players.

With all due respect to Canadians, our values of socialism and unity are flawed. At least, in this case.

In the United States, they do the Occupy thing and sportswriters throw the gamut of their angry "WE CAN'T LOSE FOOTBALL!" and "DON'T GET RID OF THE NBA; BILL SIMMONS IS STILL WATCHING" reactions at the owners. You know, the owners: the hundred-millionaires and billionaires who own the damn league, but still try and pinch pennies from their employees.

In Canada, fans have always chided the players, because it's easier. Too much money, and Not worth it, and even, YOU SHOULD WANT TO PLAY THIS GAME FOR FREE! MY SON WOULD!

Even when they "Occupy," Canadians just join in for the tent weed and direct their ire at normal business owners. Because, you know, money is bad.

Canadians, while they're decent with money and they understand it, are fatally blue-collar by nature. It works when it's hot dogs and Kokanee around a large family barbecue. It's different on Bay Street.

(*Yes, I'm generalizing, and I apologize, but you have to admit: Canada's Occupy lacked the teeth of Wall Street's, didn't it?)

For some reason, Canadians have historically thought of the players as the ones with too much money. It happens in countries where there's only one sport and not enough people. Everyone has the same dream, so you never look with bitter(sweet) eyes at their bosses or employers.

Instead, you blame the guy who has the job you always wanted, and then get mad when he won't do it for the salary of a grape picker.

It happened when the NHLPA was first formed, when Red Wings' El Hefe Jack Adams clashed with, publicly denounced, and then traded Hall of Famer Ted Lindsay because the left winger was trying to organize a union. 1957 Michigan was 2012 Wisconsin, apparently. Adams blasted Lindsay in the Detroit media, complaining about a salary he never asked for and running his name through the mud.

Every player on Detroit who was a part of Lindsay's NHLPA efforts was traded simultaneously (including Glenn Hall, the goalie who played 502 straight games and set the NHL's only unbeatable record, who was sent to Chicago with Lindsay) in some kind of massive, sweeping, Canadian witch hunt.

The public bought it. And, it's a good thing they didn't get the NHLPA formed right away, because Doug Harvey died in 1989 after living in a railway car.

In 2004, the song remained much the same, even after 50 years and all that was learned. Part of it has been the unrealistically bullish way that the NHLPA has gone about its business, which is not unlike the annoyingly naive business acumen of players unions in the NFL, NBA, and MLB.

But, for whatever, reason, Canadians and hockey fans have tended to direct their glare at the players. They misguidedly view their occasional idiocy and always-present lack of financial knowledge with blame.

After all, it's the owners who continue to throw around ridiculously high-priced, long-term contract, even in August's dog days as the clock is winding down. Wasn't Max Pacioretty just offered a seven-year contract worth $30 million? It would be shocking if any Americans not named "Greg Wyshynski" or "Katie Baker" even know who he is. Sidney Crosby just signed a 12-year, $104-million extension, Shea Weber will be paid $27 million next year, and Ryan Suter and Zach Parise are apparently worth 13 years and $98 million.

All the while, hockey fans have thought, "Gee, these owners are crazy." But, when the contract curtain is lifted, who's to bet their opinion will change. The players will get the brunt of the blame, because they have less of the microphone and unity exists with a union. It doesn't exist among management. Players have to remain quiet, while owners can say whatever they want.

And, they will. Most likely, they'll try and suck some money back into their own pockets, even while they've been throwing it around like a 17-year-old who has just discovered one dollar bills and strippers at the same time.

How can any owner realistically blame any one of their players (i.e. employees) for the league's current contract fiasco.

It's like they're a bunch of drug dealers who are mad at cocaine.

That's just the Canadian way, but let's hope we learn from this one. Or, at least, that we make an effort to.

*This was originally posted on White Cover Magazine.

 

Follow Kolby Solinsky on Twitter: www.twitter.com/KolbySolinsky

FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:29 PM on 08/17/2012
Actually, it's time the fans ignore all the nonsense, boycott a season, reduce the amount you watch and see what happens.

Fans should be looking out for themselves; but they're not.

The reality is high ticket prices; commercials every few minutes & a sponsor name for every review, break, penalty, spit.....

Used to be a huge sports fan but stopped watching after the 94 baseball strike. Haven't missed much....

Whatever the sport, whatever the reason, prices are going up, quality is down, commercials are more frequentm, labour strife is constant, the attitude of the players is brutal....

I don't even have to watch anything & I can tell what's going on from articles, posts & comments.

Not really that interesting. But the last thing fans need to do is support the players.... or the owners.
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
07:43 PM on 08/16/2012
I'm siding with the puck, it's been played with far to long.
11:07 AM on 08/16/2012
This demand for the player share to be substantially cut echoes what's going on elsewhere, labour's share is being cut down and more for owners in all sectors.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
12:02 AM on 08/17/2012
Yes, but aren't the biggest NHL clubs still making boat loads of money, and don't they have a salary cup anyway, which means that their costs are protected?

The players aren't taking money from anybody, except occasionally some of the men who own their teams and live lives that are beyond anything the "99%" of what you're talking about can even understand.

Your assertion, I think, proves what I was saying in my article. For some reason, people expect players' salaries to be cut back just because "they make a lot of money." The financials aren't even rationally analyzed.
01:34 AM on 08/19/2012
My information is that the owners have decided to demand a larger share of the pie, that officially it shall be divvied up more to favour the owners. The lockout of 2004 was done in part by owners to set in stone a percentage division between both camps as salary escalations were serving to tilt the balance more to the players. Now the owners say that this division is not good enough for them, it must be revised further in their favour. In the general economy, there's been a movement along these lines; more for capital, less for labour, and it's a bit as if the owners are acting a bit like the people running Caterpillar who demand similar changes (though quite a bit worse I think) citing the depressed economy as an excuse to do so.
07:04 AM on 08/16/2012
Why watch hockey ever. It is a sport where players fight and skill is eleiminated by the players who are paid to put the good players out of the game with head injuries. I would like hockey if the audience were not so happy when a player is knocked out of the game.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
12:22 PM on 08/16/2012
Fair enough, but what good does that kind of apathy do?
09:27 PM on 08/15/2012
Gawd, what a puerile piece of fabricated nothingness. Exactly what sort of social science insight are you attempting to accomplish here? You've made sweeping and absurd generalizations about Canadian socio-economic culture, viz., linking "occupy" and "blue collar" values - for which you have provided absolutely no evidence - as the principal culprits in our apparent tendency to side with billionaire owners rather than with multi-millionaire players.
Just how, exactly, did you come to this oh-so learned conclusion? What vast analytical prowess did you bring to bear on this insipid piece of juvenile sophistry?
Tell you what: graduate from high school first and then come back to entertain us with your laser-like socio-cultural and economic acumen. I'm sure we'll learn so, so much.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
01:24 AM on 08/16/2012
So, you didn't like it?
09:19 PM on 08/15/2012
actually, the players and the owners are part of the same thing. and their desire to cash in drives up
prices for the fan who pays for it all in the end. so lets blame them both, because the quantity of
dollars is in a parallel universe, one that 99% of the fans really can't relate to.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Kolby Solinsky
01:24 AM on 08/16/2012
Agreed. Thanks for your comment, Punndit.
photo
Gnomish
ego doctus ignarus
06:45 PM on 08/15/2012
It's ONLY Hockey why worry?