Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Laila Yuile

GET UPDATES FROM Laila Yuile
 

B.C. Politics in a Word: Fallacious

Posted: 08/16/2012 8:05 am

fallacious [fəˈleɪʃəs]
adj
1. (Philosophy / Logic) containing or involving a fallacy; illogical; erroneous
2. tending to mislead
3. delusive or disappointing a fallacious hope

I love the word fallacious.

I love how it sounds, (slightly naughty, as it rolls off my tongue ) but more so, I love that I've finally found one word that so accurately sums of the state of politics in B.C. They are completely fallacious and voters in B.C. are left hanging in the middle of war words and media strategies where the goal is power -- rather than good government.

We have on the right the capitalistic, free enterprise B.C. Liberals. Free enterprise, as defined by the Liberals, means favouring corporate friends and taking everything they can get, but neglecting the very important social needs of the people of B.C. while doing so. People in British Columbia have effectively been held hostage by the still un-elected Christy Clark, who under the B.C. Liberal banner, has been poorly leading with no direction. Democratic process fails each of us when a talk show host can move directly from the studio to the premier's office without an election and a mandate by the people.

Despite campaigning to bring an open and accountable government to British Columbia, Clark has continued to foster an environment within the legislature that not only rewards unethical behaviour, but seems to encourage it. For the last 10 years, the B.C. Liberals have repetitively and with great air of entitlement, shown they are above the same laws we are all beholden to. This isn't rhetoric on my part, it's documented with stacks of research, stories, and evidence. They have, without doubt, written the play book on fallacious politics.

On the left, we have the no-Enbridge-but-reserving-all-comment-on-other-pipelines-B.C. NDP -- the party whose energy critic has gone from being rightly cautious on fracking to full steam ahead, "Let's get fracking!"; the party with a nice, calm leader who wants to be fair and thoughtful instead of condemning lavish spending and calling for heads to roll; the party with the same old, same old Moe Sihota in charge. A political bedbug who you just can't get rid of. So we know the insiders are all the same, leaving much of B.C. in a moral and environmental dilemma that few care to approach for fear of splitting votes and letting the Libs win again.

With the NDP ramping up for 2013, leader Adrian Dix is riding around the province on a white horse, leading the charge to also -- this sounds familiar -- bring a transparent and accountable government to the people. The NDP smell victory already, and have begun campaigning in earnest in many parts of the province, completely ignoring the stench that trails both parties after the revelations of messy finances in the legislature.

However, there is a stark reality facing voters looking at the NDP, where the true financial situation of the province is going to greatly limit their impact in the legislature.

Expect the NDP to fix years of slice and dice Liberal-style closures and cuts to court services, family services, legal aid, education, healthcare, taxes? Not happening in three years in this province. They don't even know the full scope of all the contracts the Liberals signed, the many years of contractual obligations left owing on the provinces many P3s, nor will they have any idea until they get in power - and this is something they have already used as an excuse in the past. There is more than a little fallacious politicking going on in this camp as well.

With the Liberals a non-starter and the NDP likely taking a majority in the legislature, the dark horse in the race is the B.C. Conservative Party. Say what you will about grumpy old men, religious views kinda-sorta mixing with politic, with Enbridge looking more and more like a non-starter (the Cons fully support the project ) don't count them out of the race just yet.

In many areas of the province, voters really are more centre or centre right on some issues and centre left on others than a lot of readers might realize. In my hometown of Prince George, where Liberals have largely won for the last 10 years, many people are very hesitant to vote NDP, but won't vote Liberal again. That leaves just enough room for the Conservatives to ride up the middle if they play the right candidate and the right cards. And oddly enough, many people don't connect the federal party to the provincial one, which works in their favour.

B.C. Conservative leader John Cummins has remained largely silent, happy to sit back and let the Liberals and NDP jab each other, but strategically making smart moves when the NDP fail to jump on an opportunity to attack the Libs, and more importantly, when the NDP have found themselves on the defensive, as with the recent revelations regarding the messy and unprofessional accounting in the legislature. Cummins was immediately calling for resignations, and rightly so, while the NDP leader remained largely silent.

The question is will voters fall for any of it again, or will they look beyond all the fallacious politicking?
I hope they do. I think the people of B.C. are becoming more involved, and more informed than ever before. I think every political party has better think hard about what they claim, promise or otherwise present to the voters, who've been slapped around so much in the last 10 years voter malaise still might be a concern for parties.

With so much on the line economically and environmentally, the time has come for the people of British Columbia to stand up and demand they not be taken for granted any longer, demand stronger oaths of office, demand accountability and accept nothing less. It wasn't a political party who made this province what it is, it was the people. It has always been the people, and it always will be the people.

Politicians of every party across this great province would do well to remember that, because British Columbians are a powerful political force in their own right. Just look back at Fight HST to see how fierce we really are.

 

Follow Laila Yuile on Twitter: www.twitter.com/lailayuile

FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
fallacious [fəˈleɪʃəs] adj 1. (Philosophy / Logic) containing or involving a fallacy; illogical; erroneous 2. tending to mislead 3. delusive or disappointing a fallacious hope I love the word...
fallacious [fəˈleɪʃəs] adj 1. (Philosophy / Logic) containing or involving a fallacy; illogical; erroneous 2. tending to mislead 3. delusive or disappointing a fallacious hope I love the word...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:18 PM on 08/31/2012
Christie Clark is not "un-elected." (sic) She won the bi-election for the Point Grey riding left vacant by the resignation of Gordon Campbell.
08:49 PM on 08/18/2012
Good to see you here Laila. Much more exposure for your great stories, and many more people to see just how bad it is in BC. Keep up the good work, we appreciate it more than we can express..
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laila Yuile
12:45 AM on 08/19/2012
Many thanks Gary! It's people like you that inspire me to keep digging!! Teamwork!! ; )
01:44 PM on 08/18/2012
welcome Laila ,

Glad to see Huff made the decision to start up in the west and have invited some very knowledgeable writers.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laila Yuile
11:44 PM on 08/18/2012
Thank you wheels! I was really humbled at being invited to blog here and it's such a great platform to share my work! Huff BC is off to a great start!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:14 AM on 08/17/2012
Hi Laila, so good to see you here, the Huff made a quality choice in getting you!
As another reader/poster said, it's time for a complete overhaul, doing things like;
limiting election positions to JUST one 5 year term, things like that, so that we don't have the same old recycled losers working behind the scenes (as they like it) manipulating the parties and policies (and pay) without worry.

We have people in power who shouldn't even be in a political party (christy clark are you listening) and criminals who have worked their way back into positions of authority and control (too many to name, but your blog lists have them all) who are almost literally getting away with murder.

Time to stop the political bedfellows of the Power corporations and Government, time to remove "lobbyists" who lie, cheat, and spend lots of money to sway political views in their favor, favors that don't do a damn thing for anyone else in this province/country but the company who owns the government.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laila Yuile
11:54 PM on 08/18/2012
Thank you Bud! You are too kind!

I think the biggest thing you've hit on here is extinguishing the connections between corporations and government. There are lobbyists who are personal friends of politicians that occasionally, they lobby. Under Campbell, there were a couple of foreign companies who succeeded time and time again in winning bids on lucrative contracts, well documented and reported by myself and others. Under Clark, we have the contentious start to her leadership in BC. when she announced she had asked Gwyn Morgan, to be one of her transistion team advisors. Of course Gywn as we know, is former CEO of Encana and on the board of Directors of SNC Lavalin, who of course has several ongoing contracts with the BC government.... considered a conflict of interest by all for him to advise her and admit to papers he is interested in shaping public policy!!

This is what most people in BC find so appalling. The ongoing nepotism between corporations and government has no place in good government.
12:31 AM on 08/17/2012
thank you so much for adding laila .i have so much faith in her and her ability to make a difference .we need her honest and fact based journalism to tell us what is really going on in bc politics. i have enough of slimy lying polititians who tell us bold faced lies and expect us to believe them .you are all that is wrong in bc with your greedy corrupt doings
12:26 AM on 08/17/2012
The conservatives may not have much of a chance given their lack of "direction" & some decidely bad direction. This maybe the election of the independants. It maybe people do not want to run under a party banner & are interested only in what is best for the people in their riding. Delta has done just fine with their independant.

Part of the problem is to run for a party you first need to win the nomination for the party. That can be a whole can of worms on its own & does not always lend it self to having the best person for the job. Then there is the problem of having to "follow" the party line. Not always good for your constituency.

It might be entertaining to see a few independants run & win. It will keep all parties on their toes.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laila Yuile
04:40 PM on 08/17/2012
Now you are talking. Considering how hard it is to run and finance a campaign independently, one needs a candidate with name recognition and solid community backing via volunteers etc. However, I have always wondered if a coalition of independents would work in B.C, for the purposes of giving good, alternate representation to constituents. If enough candidates could be located to run on a non-partisan slate, each truly independent, strong candidates... you could get enough for party status in the leg and keep both sides on their toes, as you point out.

I think many people are looking seriously at how party politics and agendas can adversely impact good government, in particular where that party agenda does not serve a specific riding.

I'd be curious to hear others view on this !!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
08:14 AM on 08/18/2012
I should dredge up my notes about a formal "Coalition of Independent Candidates", or "Independent Coalition", which could get party status and so be eligible for the tax status that the undeservedly official parties can have....no ideology required, only a vow to represent constituents....then let the parliamentary process work as it's supposed to...and if there are enough Independents, form a government/cabinet from them....or let the big parties, reduced to minority status, have to bargain for power by enlisting their help.....but only with their constituent's approval. In the old days, cabinet appointees would face byelections to affirm their appointment......

Another idea for such candidates and any MLAs resulting would be for regular "constituency assemblies" where they have to face their electorate, instead of hiding from them...
02:48 PM on 08/16/2012
Finally, an ethical journalist who says it the way it is, and one that can back up all she says. Thank you Huffington for adding Laila, who will make your proud. Take heed to this story, British Columbians, as it is fact, what this journalist writes. We are still paying the illegal HST. It was illegally implemented and they (Liberals) are still reaping the rewards.
01:35 PM on 08/16/2012
Welcome to BC Huffpost readers. If you follow Laila's links you will find out just how corrupt BC has become. I think it is as bad, if not worse than Quebec.

Historically, I have voted NDP. My vote is not garaunteed to go there in the future, however. The leaders of all BC Parties would be well advised to read this article and Independent candidates should be encouraged to run.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
01:36 PM on 08/18/2012
Much, MUCH worse than Quebec...and in fact always has been, right from the foundation of the Mainland Colony in 1858. Not just the close ties between the money crowd and the political machinery, but the deep historical ties between the media and the political class.....and the media have helped the BC Liberals hide so much it's like they should be indicted for the crimes of the BC Liberals...cronyism in BC extendsd far outside the party apparatus. Not just party heads should roll for the nastinesses of BC Rail and the systematic destruction of BC Hydro.....
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laila Yuile
12:06 AM on 08/19/2012
Thank you Kim! I agree, independents could really make a big impact in how government works in BC, if those candidates could be found.

And I agree entirely, as you already know that B.C certainly does have a large degree of corruption, it simply has not been reported on as often, or investigated as often as Quebec where corruption seems to have become the acceptable standard in many industries. In the following link, I speak directly to a report that was released to me informally after an FOI request by the federal public safety ministry. It was quite provocative and surprised many, although from what I have researched on previous stories, it is more far reaching than suspected. What was telling was how inexperienced some employees are in government who rely on companiestht bidding on jobs, to also provide advice along the way.... http://lailayuile.com/2012/06/19/money-and-corruption-are-ruining-the-land/
12:56 PM on 08/16/2012
Yaay Laila! Glad to see you're here.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Laila Yuile
12:06 AM on 08/19/2012
; ) Thank you Deeby! I am too!!