Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
GET UPDATES FROM Lisa Marie Fletcher
 
GET UPDATES FROM Leanna Fisher
 

The Truth About Homeschooling: Myths Debunked

Posted: 11/16/2012 7:24 am

Did you know that across Canada there are approximately 60,000 to 80,000 children who are homeschooled? That number is on the rise. Despite the fact that homeschooling has become much more mainstream in our society, there still seems to be an underlying misunderstanding and prejudices surrounding this method of schooling in the general population.

Here's some of the most common myths:

Blog continues below slideshow...

Loading Slideshow...
  • Homeschool Students Aren't Socialized Properly

    This is one of the most common misconceptions of homeschoolers. The reality is that instead of being separated in groups according to age, these kids can interact with many different people in many different settings on a regular basis. Homeschool groups and activities typically are filled with a wide age-range of children involved. Extra-curricular clubs and sports or other similar activities offer the opportunities to learn how to work under a leader in a group setting. Volunteering puts kids into new settings with people they might not have encountered before.

  • Parents Aren't Qualified Enough to Teach Their Children

    It is easy to understand this concern, but it's actually rather insulting to most of us. We might not all have teaching degrees, this is true, but we typically are skilled enough to be resourceful in our education plans. Even teachers don't know everything about every subject -- but they can find tools, lesson plans, and resources to help teach their classes. So can we.

  • Homeschoolers Are Weird and Different

    Homeschoolers are no different then anyone else. Some are shy, while others outgoing, there are homeschoolers who like to be on their own and the ones that love large groups. Just because the education we teach and receive is outside the conventional box doesn't mean there's anything wrong or weird about us.

  • Homeschoolers Are Lazy and Don't Leave Their House

    There's a joke in the homeschool world that homeschoolers are rarely home. There are classes and programs, volunteering and sports, field trips, and so much more; homeschoolers are usually busy and active in so many interests that there is no chance to be lazy. There are lessons to plan, prep and finish, just like our public school counterparts. Typically, though, we are finished a lot sooner, allowing us the opportunity to get out and do something else, or just relax at home. We don't HAVE to leave our house and can spend the day in our pajamas, if we want. But it's not the every day norm. It's just a bonus.

  • Homeschoolers Are Extreme in Their Religion

    The school system is a secular institution and teaches what they believe is right. This doesn't always line up with religious beliefs. Because of this, there is a large community of faith-based home educators. But that doesn't make every person who homeschools a fundamental, isolating Christian. Yes, some are, but not all of us! In fact, secular homeschooling has been emerging rapidly in the last few years. Most homeschoolers chose to teach at home in order to focus on their child's needs and learning styles rather than religion. The homeschooling community includes a huge range of belief systems, but we all have one thing in common: wanting the best education possible for our children.

  • Homeschoolers Can't go to College/University

    With the recent increase of students taught at home, post-secondary schools have begun to amend and open their admissions policies to homeschoolers. If university or college is the path a homeschooled child wants to take, there are options available: from taking time off from school and applying as a mature student, to registering with an open university first before transferring to a different program, and even just doing online classes.

  • Homeschoolers Won't Ever Be Ready for Real Life

    "Real life" looks different for every person. It's important for us as homeschoolers to provide our children with life skills -- finances, household maintenance, cooking, self-sufficiency -- areas that have been cut out of most public school settings due to lack of funding. Adults everywhere are able to find and hold jobs, have families, and follow their dreams. There's no reason to believe our children are unable to do the same. Some studies point to the fact that adults who were homeschooled are typically more content with their lives than their peers. Homeschooling <em>is</em> outside the typical social norm of education and it's easy to understand that there will be misconceptions around how it works and how it is affecting our children. Remember, though, that different isn't always the same thing as bad. Take the time to get to know some homeschoolers. Ask questions. Become educated in what we're doing and why. Don't make assumptions. We want the same as you -- to see our kids be the best that they can be.

1. Homeschool students aren't socialized properly.

This is one of the most common misconceptions of homeschoolers. The reality is that instead of being separated in groups according to age, these kids can interact with many different people in many different settings on a regular basis.

Homeschool groups and activities typically are filled with a wide age-range of children involved. Extra-curricular clubs and sports or other similar activities offer the opportunities to learn how to work under a leader in a group setting. Volunteering puts kids into new settings with people they might not have encountered before.

Socialization is much more than just spending time in a classroom with other kids -- it's a skill learned and taught when allowed the opportunity to interact with other people.

Quick Poll

Would you ever homeschool your kids?

VOTE

2. Parents aren't qualified enough to teach their children.

It is easy to understand this concern, but it's actually rather insulting to most of us. We might not all have teaching degrees, this is true, but we typically are skilled enough to be resourceful in our education plans. Even teachers don't know everything about every subject -- but they can find tools, lesson plans, and resources to help teach their classes. So can we.

One of the best things about homeschooling is the network that you can tap into. Yes, there are times and subjects that we can't teach to the amount needed. Using the community and the network available allows us to find experts and better equipped teachers than ourselves. Workshops, co-ops, classes, online courses and programs, distance studies -- there are lots of ways that homeschoolers can learn about something their parents can't teach. Education is not limited by what a parent knows!

We also get the opportunity to learn along with our children. It's a great way to keep the brain active, pull up the lessons we ourselves learned while schooling, and show our kids that learning is fun. It's our goal as homeschoolers to create a passion for learning and to equip our children with the tools to research, discover, and absorb information for themselves.

3. Homeschoolers are weird and different.

Homeschoolers are no different then anyone else. Some are shy, while others outgoing, there are homeschoolers who like to be on their own and the ones that love large groups. Just because the education we teach and receive is outside the conventional box doesn't mean there's anything wrong or weird about us.

4. Homeschoolers are lazy and don't leave their house.

There's a joke in the homeschool world that homeschoolers are rarely home. There are classes and programs, volunteering and sports, field trips, and so much more; homeschoolers are usually busy and active in so many interests that there is no chance to be lazy. There are lessons to plan, prep and finish, just like our public school counterparts. Typically, though, we are finished a lot sooner, allowing us the opportunity to get out and do something else, or just relax at home. We don't HAVE to leave our house and can spend the day in our pajamas, if we want. But it's not the every day norm. It's just a bonus.

5. Homeschoolers are extreme in their religion and want control their children in every aspect of their life.

The school system is a secular institution and teaches what they believe is right. This doesn't always line up with religious beliefs. Because of this, there is a large community of faith-based home educators. But that doesn't make every person who homeschools a fundamental, isolating Christian. Yes, some are, but not all of us! In fact, secular homeschooling has been emerging rapidly in the last few years.

Most homeschoolers chose to teach at home in order to focus on their child's needs and learning styles rather than religion. The homeschooling community includes a huge range of belief systems, but we all have one thing in common: wanting the best education possible for our children.

6. Homeschoolers can't go to college/university.

With the recent increase of students taught at home, post-secondary schools have begun to amend and open their admissions policies to homeschoolers. If university or college is the path a homeschooled child wants to take, there are options available: from taking time off from school and applying as a mature student, to registering with an open university first before transferring to a different program, and even just doing online classes.

7. Homeschoolers won't ever be ready for real life.

"Real life" looks different for every person. It's important for us as homeschoolers to provide our children with life skills -- finances, household maintenance, cooking, self-sufficiency -- areas that have been cut out of most public school settings due to lack of funding. Adults everywhere are able to find and hold jobs, have families, and follow their dreams. There's no reason to believe our children are unable to do the same. Some studies point to the fact that adults who were homeschooled are typically more content with their lives than their peers.

Homeschooling is outside the typical social norm of education and it's easy to understand that there will be misconceptions around how it works and how it is affecting our children. Remember, though, that different isn't always the same thing as bad. Take the time to get to know some homeschoolers. Ask questions. Become educated in what we're doing and why. Don't make assumptions. We want the same as you -- to see our kids be the best that they can be.

What questions do you have about homeschooling?

 
FOLLOW CANADA BRITISH COLUMBIA
Did you know that across Canada there are approximately 60,000 to 80,000 children who are homeschooled? That number is on the rise. Despite the fact that homeschooling has become much more mainstream ...
Did you know that across Canada there are approximately 60,000 to 80,000 children who are homeschooled? That number is on the rise. Despite the fact that homeschooling has become much more mainstream ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 63
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:28 PM on 11/18/2012
My niece was homeschooled from k to grade 11. She did a regular grade 12 to avoid trouble getting into university. She is now working on her doctorate in history on full scholarship at the University of London.

We homeschooled three of our kids at different times, two of them to leave vicious bullying. It worked well for all of them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SanguinesDream
~Scio me nihil scire~
01:13 AM on 11/18/2012
My, my, my. The vehemence that has met the subject of homeschooling is truly appalling.

It seems that anything outside of the norm has dispersion cast upon it due to baseless assumptions, regardless of evidence to the contrary, simply because the concept is not predictably normal.

Interestingly though......the concept of "normal" shifts over generations. The only constant is change and if you embrace change and the possibilities that may come along with it, you are actually the ones to experience the least amounts of adjustments to societal norms and those who are wildly grasping to the past for stability are the ones that experience the greatest turbulence.

Enjoy the ride.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EQ8Rhomes
05:24 PM on 11/17/2012
Home schooling rules out the institutional bullies. That's good . But how does the education tax paying public know that kids are not radicalized by insecure, paranoid, and ultra religious, isolationist parents?
How do two income parents home school? Is it only for voluntarily poor and the rich?
08:43 PM on 11/17/2012
Thanks for your questions.

Food for thought: Homeschoolers pay education tax too. How do we know the school system isn't brainwashing your children into brainwashed, "government - approved" zombies? (FYI - this is not what I feel, simply a reversed example).

There are 2 income families that homeschool. It takes creativity and commitment - dividing work schedules, outsourcing lessons with other homeschool families, and thinking outside the box.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SanguinesDream
~Scio me nihil scire~
12:37 AM on 11/18/2012
As a homeschooling family of 3 children, we were "voluntarily poor".

I am a professional with several degrees that chose to educate my children as opposed to fopping them off on a questionable, at best, education system. Our family still pays taxes to the school district with no return to us.

It is about priorities. Putting your ego in check and looking out for the best interests of the children that you helped to bring into the world.
10:40 AM on 11/17/2012
It's not only a style of education, but a lifestyle. People love to bash something they don't understand. Religion has nothing to due with the reasons we homeschool. We educate year round and travel the world with my husband's job as much as possible, exposing our kids to the "real world." If the article was read properly, many would have read the part describing all the classes and co-ops available to those parents who don't feel strong teaching a certain subject at home. I'm a member of a homeschool group of over 200 families. At last year's graduation 19 kids were heading off to large and local universities. Surprise, surprise, they were also entering college with 15-30 credit hours, due to taking dual credit classes at their local community college since age 15. There are successes and failures in ever form of education (public, charter, private, homeschool), don't label one group wrong over the others, it's ignorant. Btw, don't assume homeschoolers are public school haters. I'd love for the system to go through a revolution: testing nationally (Iowa & Stanford) vs. state minimum skills test, pay teachers more, lower class ratios, not lump all kids into one class (special needs, ESL, basic and gifted skill levels). I'd love to send my kids to a public school that is worth my tax dollars. I gave up a great income to home educate my children. We all choose a path for our children, lets support each other and not judge.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
03:56 AM on 11/17/2012
As the grandmother of four children my daughter is homeschooling I made myself bite my tongue and let her do for her kids what she thought was right just as I did for her as a parent. I guess I did a heck of a good job because her kids are really thriving under this system of learning - and no, she is not religious. I cannot say enough good things about homeschool and the best part of it is I have now become part of the teaching staff she used to help expand their world. It has expanded mine further than any of you can ever know at the same time. I thank her for that.
01:39 AM on 11/17/2012
As someone who works in the public school system, I can see first hand that for some kids home schooling may be the better choice - if the parent and the child are up for it. As with anything, there are good homeschoolers and bad ones, however, it's been my observation that many fall in to the second catagory. Very often the parents who choose to do this are doing so for religious reasons and wish to shield their children from various "ideas" or they are not all that well educated themselves. I am related to a someone (by marriage) who homeschooled her 4 children and went on and on about how they are learning life lessons (how to garden, home chores etc) but not one of those kids went on to higher education, and one had a speech impediment which would have been identified and corrected had they been to public school. I think that home schooling would be fine if they followed the provincial curriculum and had regular (thrice yearly perhaps) testing which met provincial standards, but if they don't meet those standards (which my relative most assuredly did not), how is this in any way benefical to these children - or to society -of which they are and will be a part of?
This comment has been removed.
12:54 AM on 11/21/2012
Based on my experience I do not believe many homeschoolers fall into your second category but in fact are doing extremely well. I too, have worked in the public school and although it worked for some students the majority fell through the cracks and were just trying to make it through. I believe that the majority of homeschooling parents have a invested interest in their child's education and to often we are stereo typed based on one's experience with one or two homeschooling familes they know. As I don't like to speak negatively about the public education based on what I have seen I want the same respect from others when it comes to homeschooling.

My point in all of this is let's not judge based on what we may think we know or what we have seen once or twice. I have seen the public school fail time and time again as well as see it succeed with some kids. The same goes for homeschoolers, although when looking at the stats that are out there, homeschoolers tend to thrive in all areas of their lives.

I do not homeschool my children for any religious reasons and I don't wish to shield them from any ideas and in fact they have a much broader view of the world then most people, as do the majority of homeschoolers in the community I know.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Larry Mutter
10:57 PM on 11/16/2012
The uneducated taught by the untrained.Do you really believe you can put in the proper time and effort to teach 8 periods a day on a myriad of subjects. If you were an educated person it would be hard enough.Schools serve a function that would be hard to replicate in your kitchen. Typically Mom and Dad just want to keep the kids from that horrible secular world.Better ignorant and compliant than educated and critical.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SanguinesDream
~Scio me nihil scire~
12:54 AM on 11/18/2012
Actually, between my spouse and I, we have 4 degrees, two being graduate degrees.

Who better to educate our children but the people who know how to motivate and stimulate them? We can tailor fit differing education models for each child, as opposed to one model used for the masses.

We have a library, a lab, a gym, all in our home, in addition to 12 biosphere tanks, an art studio and an observatory.

Our colleagues are also professionals who can mentor or assist with projects that may stretch our limits. We can travel the world and expose the children to experiential learning or do a myriad of local projects that typically would not have school aged children involved (palliative care, wildlife rehabilitation, municipal planning).

Really, when you think about it, why would we send our children to an underfunded, understaffed, mass modelled, regurgitation creating schools?
01:21 AM on 11/18/2012
The wonderful thing about homeschooling is that you don't have to teach 8 periods a day. Students can learn each at his own pace, almost always in far less time than the typical school day, taking into account extra time spent on a topic a student struggles with or takes longer to learn, or one a student has extra interest in and wishes to pursue further. Most homeschooling families who use a formal curriculum spend 1-3 hours a day on formal school work in the lower grades and perhaps 4-5 hours a day in the higher grades (though, of course, most homeschooling families understand learning to be a constant, lifelong, nondelineated process). As much as this would seem to bolster your assertion that home education is academically inferior, the fact remains that homeschooled students, on average, perform equal to or better than their public-schooled peers on every standardized measure. So not only are homeschooling families successfully competing with public schools, they're doing so in less time, for (usually) less money, and with better results. Individualized instruction can do that.
09:52 PM on 11/16/2012
The authors seem quite cavalier about # 6, university or college. To me this says weird religious people who don't encourage higher education for their children.
I've known highly educated home schooling parents but it disturbs me that they may be closing this door for their own children.
And yes, i found them to be weird.
08:25 PM on 11/17/2012
Homeschooled, public schooled, or any other schooled - I'm not sure why university or college has to be the ultimate goal for any person? If someone wants to go - they can go. As with the kids who go through the school system, it's really a personal choice for each student as to what steps they take after they finish their high school years. As parents, our job is to be there to support and encourage the choices that they make.
01:02 AM on 11/21/2012
Luckily for homeschoolers more and more post secondary institutes are amending what is needed to enter into their schools and some of them even recruiting homeschoolers themselves. And I'd be interested to know what constitutes weird to you as you may find those same personalities amongst the publicly educated people as well.
06:25 PM on 11/16/2012
I knew a smart home schooled girl who discovered that it was very difficult to get a job when she turned 18.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frnkndad
06:02 PM on 11/16/2012
The concept is amazing.
But unfortunately, the reality is that homeschooling has become dominated by socially regressive religious fundamentalism.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kapjam
06:24 PM on 11/16/2012
Home schooling, an oxymoron, is to meet the needs of parents and their personal issues. There are a few families that actually have learning goals for their children, but most home schooling situations are the result of social dysfunction of the parents.
09:30 PM on 11/16/2012
People homeschool for a variety of reasons. I homeschool because it is best for my child and his needs. Some people homeschool for religious reasons but that doesn't mean they are socially regressive. Most homeschoolers ( religious or not) are a part of homeschool groups and active in the community. I am very thankful to live in a country where I am free to raise my children the way I feel is right and I have the right to choose the method of education for my children.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frnkndad
02:42 AM on 11/17/2012
good for you... I have no doubt your child's future therapist will appreciate the exclusivity of the social interactions you've allowed.
05:55 PM on 11/16/2012
The problem isn't homeschooling per se. It's the motivations of a lot of homeschoolers.

Some genuinely do want their kids to get a better education - but for a large number the motivations are of sheltering children from perspectives the parents disagree with. Sometimes being in school is the only place children can escape from abusive home situations, or even realize that other perspectives even exist beyond what they were raised with.

Public school may be far from perfect, but the dangers of the homeschooling model are too acute to promote it as a desirable alternative.
09:41 PM on 11/16/2012
I think there is a greater danger in letting a public institution raise our children than letting parents raise their own children. This is a free country and we are all free to make choices for our families and children. Most parents are not abusive and the ones that are wouldn't likely homeschool because they couldn't be bothered. I homeschool my son and I teach him my perspective but I also tell him what other people believe and why. Schools don't do that . Public schools teach children that their perspective is right and religions or people who believe otherwise are bad or wrong. I do not think all homeschoolers shelter their children. My children are active in the community. We do not stay home and keep to ourselves.
02:38 AM on 11/17/2012
Thank you for proving my point about homeschoolers promoting a distorted worldview.

If you seriously think that "Public schools teach children that their perspective is right and religions or people who believe otherwise are bad or wrong", I'd really wonder whether you ever attended one.

Considering how wrong your view of public schools is, I'm not sure you'd really qualified to teach anyone about what anyone else believes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EQ8Rhomes
05:41 PM on 11/17/2012
why are some religious perspectives on the universe and humanity no open to examination? Kids in public schools have many teachers with different perspectives and they are instructed to inform kids about the diff views about our world.
Do Christian Creationists who fight over teaching evolution in public schools actually teach evolution with the same open-mindedness as they teach creationist thought?
08:16 PM on 11/17/2012
You are right, there are definitely situations where a child should be out of the home and I'd fully agree that abuse would qualify as one of the key ones. However, these situations are extreme and thankfully rare.

Why is sheltering children something inheriently wrong? Protecting our children is part of parenting. The truth is that there are a lot of things available, taught to and exposed to our children in today's world that would never have been acceptable in the past. It's not necessarily a bad thing to want to preserve the innocence of childhood.
08:40 AM on 11/19/2012
What makes you think child abuse is rare? It gets rarely reported, but it happens frequently, across social and economic classes. 
04:33 PM on 11/16/2012
Very well done. Many dozens of research studies support what you have written here. You can see some of them at www.nheri.org.
On your point #5 about religion, however, please consider something. You are correct that the public/State school system always “teaches what they believe is right.” Furthermore, all parents and citizens of “free” and “not-so-free” nations should realize that whenever a person or system (e.g., State-run schools) teaches what it believes to be “right” it is promoting religion. This is religion in the sense of an “institutionalized system of religious attitudes, beliefs, and practices” and/or “a cause, principle, or system of beliefs held to with ardor and faith” (merriam-webster.com). In addition, many scholars have pointed out that “public schooling functions as our established church” (Carper & Hunt, 2007). So, general public and parents, please know for sure that all children who are sent away from home to State/public schools are being taught the normative faith-filled religion that the professors, curriculum deciders, and policymakers have delivered to the masses.
09:42 PM on 11/16/2012
I agree.
05:02 PM on 11/17/2012
I was hoping someone would point that out. Well said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DoctorHorror
02:39 PM on 11/16/2012
I see no problem with homeschooling. It shows that there are parents that really care and what to put time and effort into teaching their children. Let's just hope they are teaching them the right values in life.