Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Milke

GET UPDATES FROM Mark Milke
 

Ontario's Beer Cartel Paints Alberta Liquor Privatization as the Bogeyman

Posted: 02/17/2014 9:52 pm

It's been two decades since the Alberta government exited the business of selling beer, wine and spirits to consumers. The privatization of all government liquor stores (completed in 1994) led to a dramatic expansion in the number of private sector liquor outlets in Alberta, vastly improved product selection, better customer service and price-competition, while creating thousands of new jobs.

Unsurprisingly, liquor monopolists in other provinces criticize Alberta's liquor privatization. The latest critic is Ted Moroz, president of the Ontario-based The Beer Store, which has a near monopoly on private sector beer sales in the province. In a recent speech, Moroz argued that Alberta's privatization of government liquor stores and embracing of competition (Alberta sets no limit on the number of new liquor stores) led to "skyrocketing" beer prices and a "less efficient, more expensive retailing system." Moroz also warned that if Ontario treads this path, there will be more societal problems.

But Moroz cherry-picked his numbers. For example, he claimed a 24-pack of Molson Canadian costs $50.70 in Calgary but $37.95 at the Beer Store. I phoned up the Real Canadian Liquorstore in Calgary (owned by Loblaws). His 24 Molson Canadian was $40.89. Moroz also failed to note his Ontario example was on sale; according to The Beer Store website, the regular price of a 24-pack of Canadians is $40.95.

Liquor stores in Alberta operate in a free market so one can find prices higher than that and perhaps lower than the above example. Which leads to another useful point: If Ontario (and other provinces) allowed the sale of beer in corner stores they might well be more expensive than the current (Ontario) cartel price. Convenience stores regularly charge more for items found much cheaper in big box grocery stores, be it milk, bread or in the future--beer.

But that's the price of convenience. That doesn't mean corner stores shouldn't be allowed to sell beer, wine or spirits; it does mean provinces across Canada should allow corner markets plus existing grocery stores and would-be liquor store operators to get into the market. Then, as happens on regular grocery purchases, consumers could buy beer and other beverages based on their preference for cost or convenience.

On price, according to a comprehensive 2003 study by the University of Alberta's Douglas West, liquor store prices rose by four percent in Alberta between 1993 (pre-privatization) and 1996. They then fell between 1996 and 2000 as competition increased.

But Moroz still claims Alberta's private stores gouge consumers. Using numbers from a Parkland Institute report, Moroz compares alcoholic beverage prices in Alberta between 2002 and 2013 (up 28.2 per cent) to Ontario (up 9.2 percent).

Except, critically, the Parkland Institute and Moroz ignore how provinces with government liquor stores in abundance saw price spikes in excess of Alberta. According to Statistics Canada, for example, government-liquor-store-happy Saskatchewan saw prices rise by 32.2 per cent between 2002 and 2013; neighbouring Manitoba, also stuffed with government liquor stores, saw prices rise by 36.3 per cent.

When Moroz asserts that competition among liquor stores leads to a less efficient retail system, he ignores the reality in multiple other sectors that face competition every day. In groceries, computers, long distance calls, and airline tickets to name but a few, competition has driven down prices and made companies more--not less--responsive to consumers. Meanwhile, privatization of government businesses has long led to substantial economic and employment growth. To claim otherwise is to suggest the Soviet-era GUM department store in Moscow was better for consumers and the economy and more efficient than say, Wal-Mart, Costco or Loblaws.

As for social ills, also brought up by privatization opponents such as Moroz, a 2009 Frontier Centre study found that Saskatchewan, a province with a plethora of government-run liquor stores and comparatively low overall sales and alcohol consumption rates, still showed the "highest, second-highest or third-highest rates of alcohol-related harm with respect to friendships, marriage, work, studies, employment, finances, legal problems and physical violence." Apparently social problems, including in provinces with government-run liquor stores, are a bit more intractable and unrelated to whether a government or private sector employee swipes your credit card for your case of beer.

The Beer Store president claims Ontario's government/private liquor cartel model is the "envy of jurisdictions across North America and around the world." Moroz might care to get out more, say to wine-producing California (or most American states) or to European countries. As Frommer's travel guide notes about Italy, for example, "consumption of alcohol isn't anything out of the ordinary" and "there's almost no restriction on the sale of wine or liquor." Contra Moroz, I doubt your average American and European would look forward to traipsing to a government liquor store for wine and spirits and to a government-sanctioned cartel for their beer.

ALSO ON HUFFPOST:

Loading Slideshow...
  • IPA: Red Racer Pale Ale

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Red Racer Pale Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://centralcitybrewing.com" target="_blank">Central City Brewing</a> <strong>City:</strong> Surrey, British Columbia <strong>The Type:</strong> Imperial pale ales are hoppier than regular pale beers, originally thanks to the extra hops added in the United Kingdom to keep the beer fresh on its journey to British soldiers stationed in India. <strong>The Brew:</strong> Central City won Brewery of the Year at the <a href="http://www.canadianbrewingawards.com/winners/years/2012/" target="_blank">2012 Canadian Brewing Awards</a>. The brewery describes the taste as "ruby red grapefruit, with depth of malt backbone."

  • Gluten Free: Glutenberg Belgian Double

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Glutenberg Belgian Double <strong>Brewery:</strong><a href="http://glutenberg.ca/fr/bieres" target="_blank"> Brasseurs Sans Gluten</a> <strong>City:</strong> Montreal, Quebec <strong>The Type:</strong> Traditional beer is definitely not gluten-free friendly, because it's made with barley (and sometimes wheat). The gluten-free beer offerings are still slim, but growing. <strong>The Brew:</strong> All of Brasseurs' brews are gluten free, made with grains like millet. Love strong, comforting tastes? This warm and spicy beer has notes of molasses, clove, and nutmeg, and 6.5 per cent alcohol.

  • Wheat: Weissbier

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Weissbier <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.denisons.ca/Denisons_Brewing_Company/" target="_blank">Denisons Brewing Company</a> <strong>City:</strong> Toronto, Ontario <strong>The Type</strong>: These beers are light and low on aftertaste, thanks to the use of wheat in brewing. <strong>The Brew:</strong> "Weissbier" is what they call wheat beer in Bavaria, and this beer from Denisons is a traditional Bavarian-style brew made with a special Bavarian yeast. It's been number one in the German Hefeweizen category on <a href="http://www.ratebeer.com" target="_blank">ratebeer.com</a> for more than a decade.

  • Porter: Nutcracker Porter

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Nutcracker Porter <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://blackoakbeer.com/" target="_blank">Black Oak Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Etobicoke, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> Porters are dark like stouts, but generally sweeter and less hoppy. <strong>The Brew:</strong> Save this suggestion for the holiday season, when this dark cinnamon-spiced brew will be perfect with some figgy pudding—which Black Oak says is one of the flavours in this beer.

  • Stout: St-Ambroise Oatmeal Stout

    <strong>Beer:</strong> St-Ambroise Oatmeal Stout <strong>Brewery: </strong><a href="http://mcauslan.com/" target="_blank">Brasserie McAuslan Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Montreal, Quebec <strong>The Type:</strong> These dark and rich beers often use unmalted roasted barley to give the beer a character kind of like coffee. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This beer is brewed from 40 per cent dark malts and roasted barley, but also has oatmeal to give it body and a mocha-coloured head.

  • Farmhouse Saison: Saison Station 16

    <strong>Beer: </strong>Saison Station 16 <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.hopfenstark.com/" target="_blank">Hopfenstark</a> <strong>City:</strong> L'Assomption, Quebec <strong>The Type:</strong> These highly carbonated beers were originally brewed in the cooler months in Belgium and then stored by farm workers to drink in the summer months. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This spring seasonal brew is Belgian style with citrus and clove aromas.

  • Belgian: La Fin du Monde

    <strong>Beer:</strong> La Fin du Monde <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.unibroue.com/en" target="_blank">Unibroue</a> <strong>City:</strong> Clarington, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> Belgium has a centuries-old beer brewing tradition, and Belgian-style beers can be of several different varieties. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This beer with a floral bouquet has, so far, won more <a href="http://www.unibroue.com/en/beers/15/medals" target="_blank">medals and awards than any other Canadian beer</a>.

  • Mead: Meade

    <strong>Beer: </strong>Meade <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.applewoodfarmwinery.com/" target="_blank">Applewood</a> <strong>City:</strong> Stouffville, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> This ancient beverage is not exactly a beer: rather, it's a fermented honey and wine beverage that sometimes also contains grain mash and/or hops, which can give it a beer-like flavour. <strong>The Brew:</strong> If you're looking for a buzz, you'd get a good start reaching for this beverage, with a 20 per cent alcohol content.

  • Fruit: Blueberry Cream Ale

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Blueberry Cream Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://pumphousebrewery.ca/" target="_blank">Pumphouse Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Moncton, New Brunswick <strong>The Type:</strong> These tend to be ales, but have a different character because of the low bitterness and malt flavour required to let the fruit shine through. <strong>The Brew:</strong> East Coast blueberries are delicious, and this beer ads spicy notes to kick things up a notch.

  • Summer: Dooryard Organic Ale

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Dooryard Organic Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.picaroons.ca/" target="_blank">Picaroons Traditional Ales</a> <strong>City:</strong> Fredericton, New Brunswick <strong>The Type:</strong> When the weather is warm you want a seasonal brew that's clean and refreshing, like the ones in this category. <strong>The Brew:</strong> Picaroon's certified-organic summer ale, with three traditional wheat beer styles in the blend, won bronze at the Canadian Brewing Awards in 2009 and 2010.

  • Smoky: Holy Smoke Scotch Ale

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Holy Smoke Scotch Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.churchkeybrewing.com/" target="_blank">Church-Key Brewing Company</a> <strong>City:</strong> Cambellford, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> These beers are given their smokey flavour through the use of malted barley dried over an open flame. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This peat-smoked Scotch ale is so dark that it's nearly black.

  • Wit: Oranje Weiss

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Oranje Weiss <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://amsterdambeer.com/" target="_blank">Amsterdam Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Toronto, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> This Belgian-style beer is light and crisp that <a href="http://www.germanbeerinstitute.com/weissbier.html" target="_blank">narrowly escaped extinction twice in the 20th century</a>. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This seasonal brew is an unfiltered white, flavoured with orange peel, coriander, and anise.

  • Scotch Ale: Wee Heavy Scotch Ale

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Wee Heavy Scotch Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://amsterdambeer.com/" target="_blank">Amsterdam Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Toronto, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> These dark and strong beers are bittersweet and sometimes slightly metallic. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This ruby-red beer is available every winter, with a blend of five different malts to keep your belly warm.

  • Rye: Rye Pale Ale

    <strong>Beer: </strong>Rye Pale Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.cameronsbrewing.com/" target="_blank">Cameron's Brewing</a> <strong>City:</strong> Oakville, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> Rye beers are made when a portion of the barley malt is replaced with rye, which is generally malted. <strong>The Brew: </strong>Part of Cameron's brewmaster series, this bittersweet beer has won several Canadian Brewing Awards, including a bronze in 2013.

  • Pale: Imperial I.P.A

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Imperial I.P.A <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.garrisonbrewing.com/" target="_blank">Garrison Brewing Company</a> <strong>Toronto:</strong> Halifax, Nova Scotia <strong>The Type:</strong> Copper coloured and fruity, these beers are originally from England. <strong>The Brew:</strong> Garrison bills this as "the hoppiest beer in Atlantic Canada." Depending on your taste for hops, that either sounds great or awful. If you're a hophead, this is your brew.

  • Pilsner: Pilsner

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Pilsner <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.kingbrewery.ca/" target="_blank">King Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Nobleton, Ontario <strong>The Type:</strong> These beers have a more distinctive hop taste than other lagers, with a dry and somewhat bitter flavour. <strong>The Brew:</strong> King imports the Bohemian malts used to brew this Czech-style beer, which won a silver medal in 2013 at the Canadian Brewing Awards.

  • Red: Fighting Irish Red

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Fighting Irish Red <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.yellowbellybrewery.com/" target="_blank">Yellow Belly</a> <strong>City:</strong> St. John's, Newfoundland and Labrador <strong>The Type:</strong> Thick bodied and amber or red coloured, depending on the particular brew used. <strong>The Brew:</strong> Billed as the brewery's most complex beer, Yellow Belly's red brew has notes like burnt toast and strawberry jam.

  • Brown Ale: Traditional Ale

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Traditional Ale <strong>Brewery:</strong> <a href="http://www.bigrockbeer.com/" target="_blank">Big Rock Brewery</a> <strong>City:</strong> Calgary, Alberta http://www.bigrockbeer.com/sites/default/files/images/beer/main/beer-bottle-traditional.png <strong>The Type: </strong>Look for caramel and chocolate flavours, sometimes with a slight citrus accent. <strong>The Brew:</strong> This beer was first brewed in 1985 with the goal of creating an English-style beer that was markedly different from the typical Canadian bottle.

  • Lager: Black Cat

    <strong>Beer: </strong>Black Cat <strong>Brewery: </strong><a href="http://www.paddockwood.com/" target="_blank">Paddock Wood Brewing Co.</a> <strong>City:</strong> Saskatoon, Saskatchewan <strong>The Type:</strong> Lagers are aged longer, which gives them a smooth finish. These are the world's most popular beers. <strong>The Brew: </strong>This beer with "delicate coffee notes" comes from Saskatchewan's first microbrewery.

  • Kolsch: Lug Tread

    <strong>Beer:</strong> Lug Tread <strong>Brewery: </strong><a href="http://www.beaus.ca/" target="_blank">Beau's All Natural Brewing Company</a> <strong>City:</strong> Vankleek Hill, Ontario <strong>The Type: </strong>This German style of beer has a noticeable hoppiness without being extreme, and is not as bitter as regular German pale lager. <strong>The Brew:</strong> Beau's flagship brew is a tribute to the classic beer of Cologne, Germany. It's top fermented like an ale and then cold aged like a lager.

 

Follow Mark Milke on Twitter: www.twitter.com/milkemark

FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS