Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Milke


Everything In Moderation -- Including Taxes

Posted: 05/01/2013 12:23 pm

For those who file their taxes at the last moment and cut an extra cheque to government, right about now is unlikely to be their favourite time of year. For what it's worth, it might be of some comfort to know taxes have provoked much the same reaction throughout history.

Some background: To find the origins of tax, one has to travel back to the ancient world and to a fertile plain between the Tigris and Euphrates rivers, now modern Iraq. History's first recorded tax was brought to mankind in Sumer, six thousand years ago. It is there, inscribed on clay stones excavated at Lagash that we learn of the first taxes, instituted to fight a ferocious war.

But as is often the case in history, when the battles ceased, the taxes stayed -- a cause of no small discontent on the part of the locals. Local Sumerians apparently complained that taxes filled up the land from one end to the other.

Charles Adams detailed such history in his 1982 book, For Good and Evil: The Impact of Taxes on the Course of Civilization. As his title implies, taxes have been both useful and a scourge.

In Canada, taxes pay for items any sensible person would regard as desirable. One could point to the most basic functions you'd hope taxes would undergird. A few examples: governments that (in theory) protect your property and person from interference; courts to enforce such desirable laws; for cops and others to protect kids.

On the flip side, it wouldn't take long for anyone to identify useless government spending. Think corporate welfare, or taxpayer-financing for professional sports and their stadiums, or above-market compensation in the public sector. Think of absurdly high salaries for some native chiefs, or the Harper government's endless stream of taxpayer-financed commercials that tout the Ottawa's "economic action plan," at a cost of $78-million in 2012 alone.

Anyway, in Canada, the first known instance of taxation was an export duty on beaver pelts (at 50 per cent) and moose pelts (at 10 per cent) in what was then New France, in 1650.

While the tax on beaver furs was soon reduced to 25 per cent three years hence, by 1662, every import was subject to a 10 percent tax for six years, necessary to help pay off colonial debt.

That was then. Ever since, the number of taxes has of course multiplied, not just since the 17th century but even over the past five decades.

Two colleagues recently found that since 1961, tax increases have outpaced the growth in the cost of clothing (up by 607 per cent) food (higher by 578 per cent) and shelter costs (up by 1,290 per cent).

In fact, Statistics Canada's Consumer Price Index, which measures the prices Canadians pay for a wide variety of goods and services, rose by 675 per cent from 1961 until 2012. But taxes? They're up by 1,787 per cent! So in other words, tax hikes since 1961 have outpaced inflation and the necessities of life, thus squeezing family budgets.

And taxes are heading up again, most recently in British Columbia, Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec and in New Brunswick.

The response to such tax facts is usually this cliché: "Taxes are what we pay for a civilized society," this from the American Supreme Court Justice, Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr., in a 1927 case.

Right, but as a percentage of the economy, government spending was much lower in 1927 compared to 2013. One cannot endlessly extrapolate that "taxes are good for you." Not any more than it is useful to overdose on pharmaceutical drugs just because one pill helps kill some pain. Or to propose that because one glass of wine has healthful effects, then a dozen drinks must be even better.

Perhaps a better perspective on taxes comes from a 19th -century gentleman, who made clear how he thought politicians had a duty to exercise restraint in matters of taxation and spending: "All taxation is a loss per se," he said. "It is the sacred duty of the government to take only from the people what is necessary to the proper discharge of the public service; and that taxation in any other mode, is simply in one shape or another, legalized robbery."

It may come as a surprise to some, but the speaker of such words was not some supposed ideologue. It was Richard Cartwright, the Dominion Minister of Finance in the Liberal government of the day, in his 1878 budget speech.

Cartwright had the spirit of it right. Moderation in government and taxes, as in all areas of life, is a virtue.

Loading Slideshow...
  • Sliced Bagel Tax

    You might want to think twice about getting that schmear. In New York City, bagels that are sliced or prepared are subject to sales tax, whereas whole bagels are not, <a href="http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704340504575448033463314628.html">according to</a> the Wall Street Journal.

  • Pet Tax

    If you live in Durham, North Carolina, you could be <a href="http://blog.turbotax.intuit.com/2011/01/03/americas-most-bizarre-taxes/">paying a tax on Rover</a>. The state charges a $10 tax for neutered and spayed pets and $75 for pets that are not neutered or spayed, according to Turbo Tax.

  • Candy Tax

    In Illinois, all <a href="http://www.marketwatch.com/story/thomson-reuters-reports-2012-quirky-tax-laws-2013-01-28">candies are subject to an extra tax</a>, unless they contain flour, like the Whopper pictured here.

  • Elderly Tax Exemption

    By the time you're 100, <a href="http://www.efile.com/unusual-strange-funny-taxes-throughout-the-world-and-history/">you've paid enough in taxes</a>, at least according to the state of New Mexico, where people over 100 years old are tax-exempt.

  • Flush Tax

    If it's yellow, let it mellow could be the motto of some Maryland and Virginia residents looking to save money. In these two states there's a <a href="http://www.bing.com/videos/watch/video/2-minute-tax-tips-weird-taxes/1zyohv7aj?from=gallery_en-us&cpkey=626b3129-89f2-5b5b-1fb7-b9a5bfa67758%257c%257c%257c%257c">tax on flushing the toilet</a>, according to Bing.

  • Crack Tax

    Tennessee <a href="http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=6861075">anonymously collects a tax on illegal drugs</a>, according to NPR. In 2006, the state collected $1.5 million from the tax.

  • Diaper Tax

    Adult diapers <a href="http://www.marketwatch.com/story/thomson-reuters-reports-2012-quirky-tax-laws-2013-01-28">are exempt from sales tax in Connecticut</a>, but if you're buying diapers for your kids you'll have to pay taxes on those, according to Thomson Reuters.

  • Napkin Tax

    Colorado levies a tax on <a href="http://www.businessinsider.com/the-5-weirdest-sales-taxes-we-could-find-2012-1">"non essential" food packaging</a> items, according to Business Insider. That means you'll pay a tax on paper cup lids and napkins, but not on paper cups themselves.

  • Sex Tax

    Businesses in Utah that employ nude or partly nude workers are required to pay a <a href="http://money.usnews.com/money/personal-finance/slideshows/the-10-strangest-state-taxes/11">10 percent sales tax</a>, according to U.S. News and World Report.

  • Card Deck Tax

    If you buy cards in Alabama you'll <a href="http://turbotax.intuit.com/tax-tools/tax-tips/General-Tax-Tips/7-Crazy-Taxes-from-the-US-and-Abroad/INF12163.html">pay a 10 cent tax</a> on the deck, according to Turbo Tax. Meanwhile, Nevada gives free decks in exchange for completed returns.

  • Holiday Decorations Tax

    In Texas, holiday-themed pictures that are <a href="http://www.efile.com/unusual-strange-funny-taxes-throughout-the-world-and-history/">meant to be placed on walls</a> are taxed, according to efile.com.

  • Tattoo Tax

    In Arkansas, there's a <a href="http://blog.turbotax.intuit.com/2011/01/03/americas-most-bizarre-taxes/">6 percent sales tax on tattoos</a>, according to Turbo Tax.

  • Litigation Tax

    New York has <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/Business/strangest-taxes-50-states/story?id=16089204&page=2">a tax on litigation</a>, according to ABC News.

  • Hot Air Balloon Tax

    In Kansas, you have to pay <a href="http://abcnews.go.com/Business/strangest-taxes-50-states/story?id=16089204&page=2">taxes on that hot air balloon</a> ride -- or risk flying away. In that state tethered balloons are taxed, but those that roam free are not because they are considered a legitimate form of transportation, according to ABC.

  • Fresh Fruit Vending Machine Tax

    Another reason not to buy your fruit from a vending machine. Fresh fruit is exempt from sales tax in California, unless <a href="http://money.usnews.com/money/personal-finance/slideshows/the-10-strangest-state-taxes/5">it's sold from a vending machine</a>, according to U.S. News and World Report.