Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Matt Price

GET UPDATES FROM Matt Price
 

Canadian Environmentalists Don't Have Time to Be Polite

Posted: 05/04/2012 12:42 pm

There's an old joke that goes: How do you get 20 Canadians out of a swimming pool? You shout, "Hey you Canadians, get out of the swimming pool."

We're generally an obedient lot, except while on skates, so what gives with the plan of a group of Canadians to block Warren Buffett's coal trains near Vancouver this Saturday?

Most of us watched the Al Gore movie on climate change, told pollsters we were concerned about it, and then went back to business as usual.

It's not that we stopped believing in the fact of it -- although there are a handful of reality-challenged columnists who still embarrass themselves on this front -- but rather that we haven't created the structures that build our emotional investment in it.

As KC Golden says, each of us participates in an "ecosystem of denial" where we get confirmation of our own failure to change from the fact that those around us are doing the same -- it becomes a vicious cycle. We therefore bury the reality of climate change to some distant part of our brain where it festers, giving us anxiety similar to a person who knows she has a life- threatening ailment, but refuses to go to the doctor.

Part of this vicious cycle is people thinking, 'if climate change was so serious, then those in the know would be lighting their hair on fire, and they're not, so it can't be.'

How many climate scientists have we heard couching their message in calm, measured tones, so as to appear credible? How many environmentalists have we heard talking only about light bulbs, so as to appear reasonable?

This is why it's such a big deal that Marc Jaccard will be standing in front of the coal trains too. He's a Simon Fraser University professor used to walking in the hallways of power, consulting to governments and industry alike.

In his words, he feels "absolutely sick" about taking this kind of action, but says, "I am in a world now where there isn't any place for sane analysis." Note the use of words relating to sickness and sanity: a microcosm for the psychology of our society as a whole.

It is these kinds of actions that begin to break down our ecosystem of denial and instead create a "culture of responsibility" where we are shown the seriousness of our shared predicament through the seemingly dramatic actions of people around us, including those like Jaccard.

We have already been treated to a chorus of calling those who want clean energy instead of fossil fuels "radical," by the oil ideologues in Ottawa, and I expect we'll hear much more of that. The evidence, though, clearly shows that those who promote coal and oil are in fact undermining the necessary conditions for prosperous human life on this planet, quite possibly the most radical and irresponsible act ever.

Those on the train tracks and those standing up for alternatives to the tar sands -- given what we now know, this is what's "responsible" in today's world.

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
There's an old joke that goes: How do you get 20 Canadians out of a swimming pool? You shout, "Hey you Canadians, get out of the swimming pool." We're generally an obedient lot, except while on skate...
There's an old joke that goes: How do you get 20 Canadians out of a swimming pool? You shout, "Hey you Canadians, get out of the swimming pool." We're generally an obedient lot, except while on skate...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:08 PM on 05/09/2012
I'll tell you why I don't side with these 'Environmentalist'. They are all White collar, armchair Environmentalists. I'd pay more attention to them if they made their living from the land and sea. I'd listen to them if the were Farmers, Woodsmen and Fishermen instead of people who rely on the hard work of others to provide them with their livelihoods. These people couldn't earn a living if we lived like we did 200 years ago like they want us to. Do you think Al Gore and David Suzuki could put in 16 hour days, 7 days per week of hard work on a farm or a Lobster Boat. Ha. Take the taxpayers out of their world and they'd be destitute.
01:37 PM on 05/07/2012
Most of these activists are paid S disturbers, following the agenda that pays them. In many cases these folks with good leadership skills and can organize groups are paid very well indeed, its not just ignorance and naivety.
10:16 PM on 05/05/2012
Oil ideologues? Not quite. Anti-fossil fuel activists are called radicals by the overwhelming majority of Canadians who will not pay for solar panels on their roofs, will not bicycle to work, will not buy an electric car, will not accept to pay a carbon tax, etc.

Have a coffee at Tim Horton's and check for yourself.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:13 PM on 05/05/2012
Environmentalists don't have to be polite, but they do have to obey the law. That they are frustrated because Canadians don't fall into line with their beliefs does not justify criminal acts.
08:26 PM on 05/05/2012
A passage fro "Requiem for a Species" - Clive Hamilton:

"A sudden awakening in a decade by governments and the people to the dangers of climate change will be too late; the global climate system will have shifted course and the future will have been taken out of our hands. In such times we have moral obligations other than obedience to the law. We feel we owe obedience to a higher law even though we have to accept the consequences of disobeying the ones in the statute books. It is for this reason that those who engage in civil disobedience are usually the most law-abiding citizens - those who have most regard for the social interest and the keenest understanding of the democratic process."

So, no we do not have to obey the laws if the laws are damaging our world, but we do have to take responsibility for breaking them.
01:34 PM on 05/07/2012
Oh yes, the sky is falling argument, the difference

Chicken Little didnt want to scam billions of dollars and he did not break the law.

The emperor has no clothes, Global Warming is a giant scam to steal money and many of the greens are just sucking up some of the billions. The green is the money
03:52 PM on 05/07/2012
we live on a FINITE planet, is that simple enough?

Yes we do, however more people living on earth than ever before, producing more food than ever before, people didnt think this planet would support 100 million. Human ingenuity is amazing. Once we get to 100 billion people, it may feel cramped, but no more than today, also it seems that people like to live in cities around the modern conveniences, there is so much rural land available.
I would be willing to bet you live in a city and use the modern conveniences. Likely you even have a computer
09:36 PM on 05/05/2012
environmentalists are frustrated?? Hahahahaha Frustration is so 40 years ago - now they're frantic. And no, they do NOT have to obey the law. “Just as it is the duty of all men to obey just laws, so it is the duty of all men to disobey unjust laws.” - Martin Luther King

btw ... i marked your comment as favorite. oops hit wrong button. sorry
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:16 PM on 05/06/2012
If environmentalists don't have to obey the law, then neither do people who disagree with them, particularly those who believe radical environmentalism is costing them their jobs.

Which makes it civil war.

Is this really what you want? Environmentalists should remember that the rule of law is an ally, not an incumbrance. They degrade and ignore the law at their peril, for it gives their foes free rein.
12:12 PM on 05/05/2012
I fully support Marc Jaccard and his desire to eliminate of coal, but I am frustrated by the number of these protesters that arrive in their trucks or SUVs... Are these the same folks that protest smart meters?? As Pogo used to say... "we have seen the enemy and it is us..."
12:29 AM on 05/05/2012
As with every other cause on this planet....follow the money. Environmentalism is not immune.
06:37 PM on 05/04/2012
'What gives with the plan of a group of Canadians to block Warren Buffett's coal trains near Vancouver this Saturday?"
What's good for the goose...