Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Meg Tilly

GET UPDATES FROM Meg Tilly
 

Mothers and Daughters: The Worst Child?

Posted: 07/13/11 10:17 AM ET

In last week's post Emily posed the question, what it means "to daughter" someone.

Seven years ago I would have been able to answer that question with a clear conscience. I was what the world would call "a good daughter." Seven years ago, I saw my own mother frequently. I took her out to lunch several times a month. I called her often. When her Volvo was acting up, I bought her a new car. When she decided she didn't like the car she chose, I bought her another one. I invited her to any family celebration or get-together, big or small.

Once a reporter asked me what I splurged on with the money I earned from my first starring role in a movie. The answer was simple, I paid off my mother's mortgage.

What is a good daughter? Not me. Not anymore. I am the worst daughter in the family. It was hard to go from the "best" to the "worst" from the "good" one to the "bad" one.

And yet, if I could make the decision to step away, all over again, I would decide to walk this same path.
I don't talk to my mother. I don't call. I don't see her. She does not have my address or phone number. I prefer to keep it that way.

I do send her flowers, loving thoughts and money. It is easier to love her when I have no contact. It is easier to sort through the mess that was our childhood and forgive and forget. Not seeing her makes it easier to hold the good memories, the kind ones close to my heart.

Not so easy when I am in the same room with her. Not so easy when she insists that I am lying and none of it happened. Not so easy when she believes that my husband is her soul mate, not mine. Not so easy when she tries to turn me against my own children.

What is a good daughter? Not me. Not anymore.

People will have their opinions and judgments about this choice I have made and I'm sure some of the comments that will be posted will hurt my feelings, however, they have not walked in my shoes for the last 51 years. They have no idea.

It's weird, because it wasn't like I woke up one day and said, "That's that, I'm done." It just happened.
I had gone to a spa with my sister, Jennifer. We do this every year or so, whenever Jenny decides she needs to get back on a healthy track, wants to start exercising and eating right. And of course when she calls me to see if I'm free, I find a way to clear my schedule, act like it's no big deal to spend way more than I would feel comfortable spending for a week away. Because it means I will have a precious week with my sister, being sisters, talking, laughing, sharing stories, catching up on what's going on in our lives. I do whatever it takes to be able to go. It's worth it to me.

So this particular week, I went to one of Ann Harriet's talks. I don't remember the name of the workshop, but I do remember that she had us remove our name tags and then re-pin them back on our t-shirts. We all accomplished the task rather efficiently.

Then Ann Harriet had us close our eyes and told us to get a picture in our mind of ourselves at age four. Then she had us open our eyes, keeping the image of that four-year-old child in our hearts, and told us to take off our name tags and re-pin them on ourselves as we would on that four-year old child.
It was amazing the difference, the tenderness with which we re-attached those name tags.

We were then told to do something for that four-year-old girl twice a day. Go to the kitchen and ask for juice if we were thirsty. Take a little nap if we were tired. That kind of thing.

I found it very hard to ask for what I wanted, to look after, to fill my needs. I was an expert at anticipating other peoples needs, but almost embarrassed to ask for something for myself.
It was a very important week for me. This was one little 45-minute workshop and yet it had such an impact.

On the last night, there was a farewell labyrinth walk after dinner. From the dining room we walked in silence in the moonlight, crickets, frogs, night birds singing. A group of women together and alone, each one thinking back on the week and what we had discovered, the friendships made, stories shared. The rustle of our clothes, the quiet shuffle of our shoes and sandals, first on the wood boardwalk, then up the stairs and on to the dirt path, dried leaves crunching under our feet, the wind softly rattling the branches of the trees as we approached the labyrinth.

Then a row of us, waiting for our turn to step out onto this last journey, the one that signifies our departure from the safety and nurture of this spa and the re-entry back into our regular lives. Deep in thought. What did we want to take with us, what did we want to leave behind?

It was my turn to step out on the labyrinth and so I did and around one third of the way in, I felt a small hand slip into mine and I looked down and there was myself as a four-year old child. And we walked together, hand-in-hand, to the centre of the labyrinth and in the centre of the flower, I knelt down and I apologized for not taking better care of her and I made her a solemn promise that from now on I would.
And that is when it happened.

It wasn't a conscious choice. It just happened. And whenever my hand wants to go to the phone, to call my mother, to get back on that old path I was on, I remember the little four-year-old girl inside, and that promise I made to love her and keep her safe and I can't do both, be a good daughter and a good mother to myself. And so I make a choice.

For the first 45 years of my life, it was one choice, for the last six years another. Neither one right or wrong. Just the way things are.

 
In last week's post Emily posed the question, what it means "to daughter" someone. Seven years ago I would have been able to answer that question with a clear conscience. I was what the world would ...
In last week's post Emily posed the question, what it means "to daughter" someone. Seven years ago I would have been able to answer that question with a clear conscience. I was what the world would ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 66
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetgreensnowpea
alien researcher with a notepad
09:54 AM on 08/18/2011
my relationship with my mother only works if i don't participate in it.
08:53 AM on 08/18/2011
Thank you for this beautifully written article. As a daughter of a mother with Narcissistic Personality Disorder, I completely relate. Sadly, our culture assumes if you have a Mother, she is loving, nurturing, involved, caring, etc...it's difficult because no one sees our invisible abuse. Yes, we may not have bruises and what not, but the rage, the neglect, the constant psychological torture and endless well of parentification made upon children is rarely seen beyond closed doors. If anyone questions this article, they clearly do NOT have a Mother who has a personality disorder or NPD. Consider yourself very lucky.

I finally had to move across the country to escape her toxicity and the emotional and psychological abuse. However, many of my Mother's friends and even members in our own family would never know. She was a teacher, she puts on a good act. Before you judge or assume someone is a great mother, realize that you have no idea how she truly treats her daughter.
02:58 AM on 07/18/2011
You aren't a bad daughter, being a bad daughter would be to blame everything on her and say that all your problems are her fault, however you don't seem to be doing this your just trying to make things easier for both of you and enjoy your life. You deserve to be happy just like everyone else and I hope that I can one day overcome my difficulties and problems just like you because I have had the unfortunate luck to have a childhood similar to yours.
photo
Ms NYC
Republicans for Voldemort
01:14 PM on 07/15/2011
Wow. I don't think you are a bad daughter. I don't think there are bad or good daughters. When my mom suffered a stroke 2.5 years ago I would not leave her side. She couldn't talk or move her right side and I thought she would fell less vunerable with me there. She was in rehab for 3 months and I was there almost everyday and when I wasn't my father or brother was. Every visitor, nurse, doctor, etc commented on how lucky she was to have such a wonderful daughter. My mom and I would just look at eachother and smile. We knew the truth. She's not lucky I am. I am the daughter she raised me to be and I could not be luckier to have had such a wonderful mother. So you're not a bad daughter and I'm not a good one, we are both our mother's daughter.
01:15 PM on 07/14/2011
interesting choices being made. Not willing to see your mom but still helping her financially is noble, but i would think it would be wise to keep the "loving thoughts" to a minimum if you dont want to see her. Loving thoughts seems in a way cruel and somewhat misleading especially when you refuse physical conatct . good luck to you.
11:36 AM on 07/14/2011
Thank you Meg....that makes me feel a lot more "normal" to read that other people feel the same way about their mothers as I do....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetgreensnowpea
alien researcher with a notepad
08:22 AM on 07/14/2011
"motherhood" is so revered in our culture...
"parenthood"
as if that automatically bestows "heart and love".
the dark side is very complicated.
no one in my life has thrown me under a bus like my "mother" has.

i have new respect for you.
photo
Ossit
Ossit
11:49 PM on 07/13/2011
Why do celebrity mom problems matter more than regular folk? This harmless question will be pended because I won't side with this actress.
08:55 AM on 08/18/2011
You clearly don't get it. You probably have a healthy mother or parent. Why did you have to bring this back to issue of celebrity? Totally unrelated.
10:09 PM on 07/13/2011
Thanks for being brave enough to share this. It's hard to walk away from a bad mother. I've done a lot of therapy from what I've been through with mine, and have tried hard, very hard, to keep in mind that old annoying adage 'she did the best she could with what she had' - and even now, as she's old and sick, and still doing things I don't like, I try to rationalize it, but it's bad. I feel guilty for not liking my mother and not wanting to be around her. Reading your post helped me feel better.
07:52 PM on 07/13/2011
According to my very twisted mother I am responsible for the deaths of my brother and my father. I am also responsible for her unhappiness, all the bad choices she made throughout her life, and also 9/11. When you have a crazy Mom like that, you just cannot win. I have tried, but just after my father's death this year, I decided I will not take her garbage anymore. I am in her house now in the aftermath of my father's death, but in a month, I am gone, and finally free. Took me 60 years! Congrats to all who realised sooner.
07:50 PM on 07/13/2011
Two years ago I made the decision to walk away from most of my family. Truthfully I should have done it earlier, would have been less stressful on my family (Husband and children). Most members of my family are horrible to each other, things have happened over the years that would keep several therapists busy for a lifetime. Mine finally ended when my grandmother stole my identity ran up a few bills in my name then sued me for close to $9000 all with the help of 2 of her sons (yes technically my uncles).

I am providing this small amount of background because people said that there was not enough to go on in Ms. Tilly's article.

I love my family, but sometimes having them close is damaging. At some point you need to take care of yourself. I know because my issue stated was not my Mother people will say it is not the same, but it is hard for me to knock down my mother right now. She is the youngest woman in her nursing home after having several debilitating strokes. She has done some horrible things to us as well, but her mother still tops her.

In the end my grandmother did not win the money she attempted to extract from us, the bills she accumulated in my name however I am still fighting.

Sometime it is okay to walk away. Don't let a person destroy your life just because they are related.
07:07 PM on 07/13/2011
I really appreciate this article. I too have broken off all contact with my mother due to her instability and mentally abusive behavior towards me. At age 40 I recently started seeing a therapist to finally get past all the pain of having a narcissist for a mother. The therapist told me that if I never accomplished anything else in my life the fact that I got myself out of the family situation I was in is more than most people will ever accomplish. I've never wanted sympathy for my situation but it was nice to hear someone really so how difficult and mentally abusive my childhood was.
05:29 PM on 07/13/2011
I completely understand her point. As one of 4 girls I have no contact with 2 sisters and deal rarely and cautiously with the other, most as a direct result of my mother. Although I loved my mother until the day she died last year I became painfully aware over the years that she pitted us against each other at every opportunity. I would never have walked away from her mostly because I am the baby and quite honestly the only one willing to do anything and everything she needed. As an adult with adult children of my own I see the damage and heartache and I have been very careful not to repeat the cycle. I understand why you feel the way you do Ms. Tilley and don't for a minute regret your choice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
onwisconsin
Trust women; protect choice.
06:25 PM on 07/13/2011
You and I could have had the same mother, except that I was #3 and our mother is still alive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
05:13 PM on 07/13/2011
What a great article. Ms. Tilly you are a terrific writer, and I thank you for sharing this experience. I need to go find my four year old self and have a chat.
photo
darquelourd
You Get What You Play For
05:04 PM on 07/13/2011
Thank God for Google. I'm not sure why the pertinent facts are absent from this column since People magazine published an article on her childhood sexual abuse, i.e. it's not a secret, but what the Hay.