Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mike Schreiner

GET UPDATES FROM Mike Schreiner
 

Striking Teachers? McGuinty Needs an Education on Labour Laws

Posted: 12/14/2012 11:07 am

The government and teachers need to be talking about getting Ontario schools working again. Our kids' education is too important. Disruptions in the classroom need to end.

Three successive governments in Ontario, NDP, PC and Liberal, have created crises in our education system: Rae Days under the NDP, strikes after Harris and Snobelen's ill-conceived cuts, and now McGuinty's attacks on labour rights through Bill 115. The latest crisis, leading to one day strikes and disruptions in our schools, stems directly from the Liberals disrespect for the democratic rights of workers to bargain collectively.

In August, Dalton McGuinty recalled the legislature to force Bill 115 onto teachers and education support staff. Bill 115 removes their democratic rights to fair labour negotiations. It took only 15 days to unroll decades of labour rights in Ontario when the bill received Royal Assent on September 11.

The supposed reasoning behind Bill 115 is deficit reduction. I agree that tackling our deficit needs to be a priority -- it is irresponsible that the third-largest spending category in Ontario is interest on debt. Yet the old parties at Queen's Park, the ones who have created repeated crises in our education system, refuse to talk about the elephant in the room: ending duplicate funding for a separate school system.

Merging the best of the Catholic and public school boards into one publicly-funded school system will save over $1 billion annually. It is the fiscally responsible thing to do and is more effective than attacking democratic labour rights.

A recent poll of over 1,100 Ontarians concluded that most Ontarians think it's wrong to fund separate schools publically. There are other ways we could save money without resorting to the sledgehammer of legislation. Add in the elimination of EQAO standardized testing and the annual savings jump by another $35 million.

We should also involve teachers, staff, and unions in identifying cost-savings. They came to the bargaining table with a wage freeze proposal, but the McGuinty government rejected it. We can improve education and save money in this province. This starts with an honest an open conversation about all the options on the table , including merging the school boards. This is a choice that will make us all richer.

Loading Slideshow...
  • <a href="http://www.angus-reid.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/2012.09.10_Premiers_CAN.pdf" target="_hplink">Angus Reid Public Opinion surveyed 6,657 Canadian adults</a> from August 21 to August 27, 2012. The margin of error is +/- 1.2 per cent, 19 times out of 20.

  • Brad Wall - Net Approval +38

    Approve: 66 per cent Disapprove: 28 per cent Not Sure: 6 per cent

  • Alison Redford - Net Approval +18

    Approve: 55 per cent Disapprove: 37 per cent Not Sure: 8 per cent

  • Greg Selinger - Net Approval +7

    Approve: 48 per cent Disapprove: 41 per cent Not Sure: 10 per cent

  • David Alward - Net Approval +3

    Approve: 47 per cent Disapprove: 44 per cent Not Sure: 10 per cent

  • Kathy Dunderdale - Net Approval -15

    Approve: 39 per cent Disapprove: 54 per cent Not Sure: 8 per cent

  • Dalton McGuinty - Net Approval -28

    Approve: 32 per cent Disapprove: 60 per cent Not Sure: 9 per cent

  • Jean Charest (Outgoing) - Net Approval -32

    Approve: 32 per cent Disapprove: 64 per cent Not Sure: 3 per cent

  • Christy Clark - Net Approval -36

    Approve: 28 per cent Disapprove: 64 per cent Not Sure: 8 per cent

  • Darrell Dexter - Net Approval -41

    Approve: 26 per cent Disapprove: 67 per cent Not Sure: 8 per cent

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
The government and teachers need to be talking about getting Ontario schools working again. Our kids' education is too important. Disruptions in the classroom need to end. Three successive government...
The government and teachers need to be talking about getting Ontario schools working again. Our kids' education is too important. Disruptions in the classroom need to end. Three successive government...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
techhie
02:36 AM on 01/03/2013
Why should private Catholic schools receive funding from the public purse? That should be a very good question and simply answered.

I read a comment where someone wants this practice to continue because we have done it for so long it comes naturally. Doesa not seem to be to much justification for anything at all.

The real question should be, is the Catholic education system open to all taxpayers in the province, or just to Catholics. Can I send my Muslim son there, or my Hindu son, or my Buddhist son? And not have him be obliged to accept the religious offerings at his school? I don't think so. Now apply the same rules to public schools, funded by the taxpayer. Aha, now it works! Everyone welcome, regardless of creed, colour or religion. Just like taxpayers!

What is really surprising is that this taxpayer funded practice has endured for so long.

So to provide a funding solution we must first make it illegal to strike and bargain with your employer? Such an abuse of the law will not provide anything like a solution. Only another problem...
08:15 PM on 12/16/2012
Right Mike. So you covet collective bargaining rights but eschew the constructionally-protected denominational rights of the Catholic minority. Yes, a "majority" of Ontarians would be fine with a single system because a majority of Ontarians are not Catholics. So you are also fine then with a majority of people determining the rights of a minority? Read your history. It has taken the Catholic minority 170 years to have the rights and funding of public schools. It has been a long struggle. We are not about to give them up. Education is more than a cost-saving experiment. Our Catholic schools stand for a different educational experience with faith values at its core. It's part of the heritage of this province. Take your single system rhetoric somewhere else. We are no Newfoundland; and remember also one third of this province is Catholic. Green Party we are keeping an eye on you, and you to Esther Shreiner.
03:58 PM on 12/17/2012
Browner you are jumping to conclusions on Mike's idea.
How much of a catholic school has to do with religion? A few rooms and a few teachers?
He says nothing about removing catholic school teaching, just there's a lot of overhead separating non catholic students from catholic students.
It makes more sense to add catholic teaching area's into an existing infrastructure rather than have the Ontario government pay for two-three schools within blocks of one another, and vice versa allow non-catholics to attend at a school much closer to where they live in a catholic dominated school.
Anywho keep your eyes on the Green's they might surprise you.
Btw I was raised Catholic and I would definitely support's Mike's views on this.
06:08 AM on 12/19/2012
Based on the what I have read previously, Catholics currently comprise the minority of students of Ontario Catholic public schools (48%), two-thirds of Ontario Catholics elect to direct their taxes toward the Catholic school boards, and discriminates in hiring only Catholics as teachers. If one were to base decisions in "heritage", should blacks continue to be in slavery and women continue to be disenfranchised? Religious instruction is still being subsidized in Ontario due to the religious subsidies (exempt from corporate income, property and parsonage taxes, preferential sales tax treatment, tax deductibility of contributions) associated with the organizations which provide Sunday school instruction, and there are private religious schools (which are exempt from property taxes).