Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Miranda Frum

GET UPDATES FROM Miranda Frum

War on Mexican Drugs Not Fast and Furious Enough

Posted: 10/13/11 04:53 PM ET

The drug war in Mexico must become a serious issue on the American policy agenda. Not only for humanitarian reasons; the deaths of 15,000 people in the last year alone should be enough of a neighbourly reason to get involved.

The drug war in Mexico is an American war, the only difference being those fighting and those who are dying happen to almost be exclusively Mexican. So what's the link? Aside from the obvious fact of Americans using and abusing drugs controlled by Mexican cartels, Americans also happen to be arming these same cartels. And not just with petty firearms, but now AK-47s and AR-15s. That's some serious weaponry.

Most recently, there has been the "Fast and Furious" disaster which involved the transfer of some 2,020 firearms to the Sinaloa Drug Cartel (which is also partnered with the ruthless Los Zetas cartel, responsible for a majority of the most violent murders) from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) beginning as early as 2009. The ATF, amongst other liaising agencies, never had a practical plan to track any of the weapons. As soon as the guns fell into the hands of the Sinaloa cartel members, they were deemed lost. A number of those guns have reappeared in violent crime scenes.

Even before Fast and Furious, this past September, American customs agents in Texas seized 30 high powered assault rifles when they searched a car heading into Mexico. This was said to be the largest gun bust at the American-Mexican border this year. This news is significant. But it shouldn't be surprising.

In 2009 the U.S. Government Accountability Office made a report to congress: over 90 per cent of firearms seized in Mexico and traced over the past three years have come from the U.S.. 40 per cent of those firearms are coming from Texas. The government is aware that American guns are travelling into the hands of very dangerous people, however nothing is really done. Rick Perry has spoken of a potential American involvement in Mexico, complete with sending troops over the border and maintaining order. But is this effective? Basic firearms are smuggled in a very unique way. Law abiding American citizens with clean criminal records are buying weapons from U.S. gun stores on behalf of Mexican cartel members. These Americans are called "straw purchasers." The cartel rewards the "straw purchaser" with cash after they have safely smuggled the firearms over the border.

But "straw purchasers" only are able to buy basic firearms from gun stores. One cannot buy serious militia machinery at a local Walmart. In 2008, an M26A2 fragmentation grenade was used against a U.S. consulate in Mexico. Automatic weapons, including a U.S.-made M16 was found at a cartel crime scene in May of 2009. So where are these weapons coming from?

According to leaked diplomatic cables uncovered by Fox News, there are three sources. First, the U.S. Defense Department's shipments to Latin America were known and tracked by the U.S. State Department as "foreign military sales." Seems fishy. Second, weapons were ordered by the Mexican government and tracked by the State Department as "direct commercial sales". Getting fishier. And finally, there are arsenals of military weapon stores in Honduras, Guatemala and Nicaragua. What's really incredible is despite the measures the US government will take against the selling of drugs, they won't limit or respond to the selling of high grade American weapons to a group of international criminal murderers.

If it was discovered that the U.S. government was turning a blind eye to sales of weapons to Hamas, or Somali militants, this would be a much more serious issue with much more public attention and would result in a call for action. So why is this happening undetected? The Sinaloa cartel has strong connections within the Mexican government, and thus is able to influence and control Mexican policy. It also doesn't help that some cartels pretend to be individual militant groups attempting to rid their neighbourhoods of gang influence and control. The Mata Zeta group at first glance seemed romantic -- a group of concerned and fed up civilians taking justice into their own hands and defending their families. In reality, the Mata Zetas are ruthless killers using a very old and very good rule of PR: if you pretend that you are doing it for the people, those who are less informed will automatically give you the sympathy vote. There is a reason why the Mexican government has arrested numerous amounts of the group's members. However, the selling of detrimental weapons to small militant Latin American groups isn't unusual in American policy making, remember selling of weapons to the Contras in Nicaragua.

The recent leaks of information regarding these weapon sales leads to some difficult decision making. Ideally and unrealistically, the solution is isolationist. Americans stop buying Mexican drugs, stop selling weapons and smuggling said weapons and then stop aiding the government and completely recluse into an isolationist relationship, allowing the Mexican government to freely take the steps they need to take to fight the cartels.

Mexican President Felipe Calderon has blamed America for the drug related problems now facing Mexico. Here he is wrong. Although there is shady American involvement within this drug war, the reality is that this is an unfortunate situation of Mexicans slaughtering Mexicans. The cartels are controlled by Mexican citizens, who, regardless of American ties, are still choosing to inflict this war and this violence on their own fellow citizens and neighbours. Although these cartels have expanded into Chicago, New York, Boston and Miami, they are based in Acapulco, Tijuana, and Mexico City. The violence really happens in Mexico, after all when was the last time a bunch of mutilated corpses were found in a garbage can in Boston? Or left on a highway in DC?

This drug war shouldn't exclusively be fighting the distribution and selling of drugs. The focus should shift to the elimination of these active cartel thugs. The current war on drugs is fighting for an intangible utopia of a world without drugs. Fighting a tangible enemy is much more effective, and much easier. Fighting the cartels puts a face to the evil. After all, worrying about a shipment of cocaine seems like a waste of time when murder, exploitation and kidnapping are running rampant and turning the current government, who is bravely attempting to thwart these cartels, into an unfunny joke. Attorney General Eric Holder seems unsympathetic to the cause, after all, his government only helped to arm the Sinaloa cartel, it's not like he bought coke from them.

 

Follow Miranda Frum on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@mirandafrum

The drug war in Mexico must become a serious issue on the American policy agenda. Not only for humanitarian reasons; the deaths of 15,000 people in the last year alone should be enough of a neighbourl...
The drug war in Mexico must become a serious issue on the American policy agenda. Not only for humanitarian reasons; the deaths of 15,000 people in the last year alone should be enough of a neighbourl...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 34
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:56 PM on 11/13/2011
Here's the thing, if the problem with drugs is that laws exist, then why don't eliminate all laws related to those fast and furious guns as well?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:11 AM on 10/20/2011
They take out new cartel leaders almost every day, it seems. Several "new" cartels are identified or come forward every few months. The truth is, the drug trade will continue regardless of how well the distribution is organized. Being less organized makes it harder to obtain intelligence about the distribution of smaller and smaller quantities. It's an unwinnable war, if you want to call it a war. I call it a failing control tactic, a type of ethnic cleansing, used to suppress the "undesirables" of our population.
06:35 PM on 10/15/2011
Here's an idea. How about just end the drug war by legalizing drugs, so we arn't filling prisons with people who's only crime is putting non-government approved bad things into their bodies?

Ending the drug war would put the cartels out of business, just like the end of alcohol prohibition shut down organized crime's profits from bootlegging.
04:41 PM on 10/14/2011
The Zetas are "partnered" with the Sinaloa cartel? No I think they are locked in a bloody power struggle.

I would certainly agree that America should concentrate on interrupting the flow of weapons south. A year or so ago the right wing trolls here were denying that there were any weapons flowing south. One budding genius mentioned to me the fact that AK's aren't made in America as evidence that they could not have come from America. Now they seem to have changed their tune to the extent that they think all of the guns shipped into Mexico are being personally sent by Eric Holder.

Obviously what is standing in the way of any meaningful policy change is the gun lobby.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Gudzikowski
free,natural,harmless,individual
04:19 PM on 10/14/2011
Ultrareality is this democrazy or what!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Gudzikowski
free,natural,harmless,individual
04:16 PM on 10/14/2011
Our fate is sealed there is no quick fix. Legalization would be admitting that gov.are wrong about the will and willpower of individuals. The only reality is that decriminalization would cure the majority of this power struggle but then there dreams of great wealth would be gone. So death and destruction will continue on cue. Medicalization may help limited few today but will have no significant effect for many years. So live and let life be the fitting punishment for the role you play in this game of monopoly.
Javalation
Laughing in a Daydream
03:10 PM on 10/14/2011
We are the preeminent weapons manufacturers and distributors of the world, and have been for a long time. Our government has used our weapons to win the hearts of leadership in other countries, probably ever since WW II, and even to bad guys like Saddam & other dictators. It has been so prevalent that Reagan illegally sold them to Iran, while they were an archenemy. A few of his subordinates took the rap, and today he is considered a Saint.
02:57 PM on 10/14/2011
War on Drugs: The people use drugs and the rulers use war. Guess which is actually worse for society.

Legalize for users.
'Medicalize' for abusers.
Criminalize for social controllers.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frankko
02:56 PM on 10/14/2011
The American government is just as corrupted as the Mexican, they know that the drug trade benefits
the economy so they would never really try to eliminate it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
looneydoone
not a "cookie"
02:26 PM on 10/14/2011
Miranda Frum
I suggest you acquaint yourself with the opinions of some of Mexico's top political analysts. Manu Dornbierer is a political analyst with 30 years experience, a weekly opinion column and the author of 20+ books.

Read her recent articles "Big Stick War", "feo septiembre", and "Jucio a Calderon". Scroll down the page until you see the articles available (click on "archivos historico" for "Big Stick War" and others)
http://www.esp.mexico.org/lapalabra/colaborador/127/manu-dornbierer

The La Palabra site has opinions from many other political analysts in addition to Manu Dornbierer

also of interest
WWW.DIA SIETE.COM (#585 "La hidra de los narcos" Dia Siete is a well regarded weekly supplement magazine available with the Sunday newspaper edition of Mexico's major newspapers
02:12 PM on 10/14/2011
The drug war was lost when it started. You cannot stop people from destroying themselves.
Make it legal the same way Sweden has and try to get the addicts into some kind of treatment program. This would cost less than trying to fight a multi-billion dollar business who has unlimited funds. Take the profit motive away and win the war!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Frankko
03:01 PM on 10/14/2011
The corrupted American government would never try to eliminate a multi-billion dollar business, legal or not. Don't anybody get it? This drug trade business pumps billions into both American and Mexican economies that's why they would never try to eliminate it.
12:41 PM on 10/14/2011
The root cause of the violence is drug prohibition. So your suggestion is...basically continuing the status quo, except focusing on the cartels personnel instead of the actual drugs?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Bourbon
12:39 PM on 10/14/2011
Legalize drugs in the US.

Legalize guns in Mexico.

Problem solved.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Bourbon
12:37 PM on 10/14/2011
O boy. Here we go, AGAIN, with the "90%" lie.

Miranda, babe, please check with SEDENA, who will be happy to inform you of the TOTAL number of firearms seized in Mexico by police and army forces. (In the 2009-2010 period, the number was about 125,000.) Then please check with ATF, who will be happy to inform you of the TOTAL number of firearms seized in Mexico and traced to the United States.. (In the 2009-2010 period, the number was about 21,000.)

If 21,000 is 90% (or anything close to 90%), please let me know, so I can get a math tutor to teach me to better figure percentages.

If 21,000 is NOT 90%, or anything close to 90%, please stop lying.

Thank you.
photo
darquelourd
You Get What You Play For
12:29 PM on 10/14/2011
As an American, I feel it is time for Canada to come into her own by pre-emptively invading, if not the USA, then at least Mexico.

Surely, you guys can handle this?
12:01 PM on 10/15/2011
Not likely - we might invade if it has to do with hockey. That seems to get us fired up enough to take action ;)
photo
darquelourd
You Get What You Play For
12:02 PM on 10/17/2011
I got all fired up reading this woman's column. It seemed Canada finally had some fire in her belly and was ready to become an Imperial Power!

oh well, should you choose to personally invade, sillyblueness, I shall be happy to help you set up a command center here in Austin, Texas and teach you Spanish phrases that will help in procuring alcoholic beverages and tapas ;)