Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Patricia Pearson

GET UPDATES FROM Patricia Pearson
 

Harper Spin Put Under Third-Party Management

Posted: 12/07/11 12:05 PM ET

Wondering where all the money goes in Attawapiskat?

Given the Harper government's frequent pronouncements this week about how the Conservatives have "heavily invested" in this tiny, freezing James Bay community over several years in power, I'm sure some of you are feeling puzzled about the exotic third-world conditions.

WTF?

Rightly so to be wondering what the heck is going on and thus I've decided to place Harper's communications department under third-party management until all of the facts are sorted out for the Canadian taxpayer.

Let's start by moving into the office of Greg Rickford, Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Aboriginal and Northern Development. Slap down a box of donuts, sigh heavily, and commandeer his chair. He addressed MPs in the House last Friday:

"We have invested heavily in First Nations schools, including in Attawapiskat," Rickford announced, echoing Harper's spin that Attawapiskat must be an unconscionably corrupt money pit, given the government's $90 million "investment" over six years, a sum that other provincial and municipal jurisdictions receive without fanfare as standard transfer payments but that, here, is being played out as some sort of exciting venture capitalism opportunity gone awry.

Okay.

In my capacity as Third-Party Manager reluctantly taking over the message, I have looked into the statements of fact and discovered, oddly, that Attawapiskat has no school at all.

Not only does it lack a three-dimensional school building with standard amenities like a gym, but the absence of a school has been the focus of a nationally and internationally applauded campaign by Attawapiskat schoolchildren, called "Shannen's Dream" for several years.


That's right: one of the children in Attawapiskat, the lively and ardent Shannen Koostachin, actually garnered an International Children's Peace Prize for her ambitious efforts to advocate for the right to have what she called "a safe and comfy school." She and her classmates hoped against hope for something other than an indifferent and poorly-heated mishmash of portable structures on industrially contaminated ground infested by mice, with neither gym nor library, nor what you might loosely call a conducive learning environment.

Oops.

Notwithstanding this rejecting experience, the children of Attawapiskat have been extraordinarily resilient and articulate and bold.

One of Attawapiskat's youth, Chelsea Edwards, was featured in a Globe and Mail article recently about Aboriginal kids determined to succeed against the odds.

If you want to go all high-concept and iconic about it, they have been fighting as valiantly as Disney's Pocahontas over their constitutionally guaranteed right to an education that isn't disrupted by scurrying rodents and gale-force winds. (Surprised that Aboriginal children desire a good education? A free one is provided in Canada to new immigrants, as well as the children of people on welfare and in prison, so, you know, it's not really that outlandish of these kids to hope for same. But feel free to argue they don't deserve it in the comments section, below.)

Meantime, I must say that speaking as his Third-Party Manager what we see here is a bit of an accounting error on Mr. Rickford's part.

Indeed, for Rickford to stand up in Parliament and imply that Attawpiskat not only has a proper school, but one that has been "heavily invested in," as if the government has been rooting for its success as the next model example of First-Rate Canadian Elementary School Education -- rather than yawning about its failure to even exist, is an unfortunate mismanagement of communications -- at least in the expert assessment of this Third-Party Manager.

Sorry. Fail.

It is also a slap in the face of Shannen Koostachin's parents, who lost their daughter as a passenger in a car accident in 2010 when she had to complete her education in Timmins because there is no on-reserve education past Grade 10.

I will continue to bring you updates as I scrutinize the spin, but for the moment this may give taxpayers a preliminary hint as to why Attawapiskat chief and council were so offended that the federal government's response to their despair was to send up -- not blankets and insulated yurts -- but a scowling accountant.

More soon, as I audit further statements...

 
Wondering where all the money goes in Attawapiskat? Given the Harper government's frequent pronouncements this week about how the Conservatives have "heavily invested" in this tiny, freezing James B...
Wondering where all the money goes in Attawapiskat? Given the Harper government's frequent pronouncements this week about how the Conservatives have "heavily invested" in this tiny, freezing James B...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:25 AM on 12/15/2011
Why are people so quick to blame our Goverment? I understand that there are Harper Haters, but its a little rich to say this is his doing... The Conservative Goverment has gernerously given this Band 90 million dollars, Plus how many millions from the Provincial Goverment AND the Debeers mine.... That is alot of money! If this Cheif really cared about her people she would step aside and let another deal with the third party manager and a audit to take place. The money has gone somewhere, and if there has been mismangement and or theft, The people resonsible should be prosecuted no matter there skin colour.
06:59 PM on 12/27/2011
Harper`s in charge; therefore, he is responsible. It`s a bit rich to suggest that the prime minister is not reponsible for the responsibilities of the federal government. Harper did put a guy who made a career of attacking native rights in BC in charge ... he knew what he was doing and he did it. Where the money went is a matter of public record and unlike many small municipalities, Attawapiskat is up to date with audited financial statements. Harper is an economist. It`s inconceivable that he couldn`t know the numbers unless he doesn`t want to know. Another audit of already audited accounts is just a waste of money. Even the TPM fee seems questionable; for the Barriere reserve they pay $600K so why is Attawapiskat so cheap - $1300 per day -- or why couldn`t they get the same deal for Barriere. What responsible small community would pay their manager as much $1300 per day ... that alone makes Harper look bad. BTW, it isn`t even the TPMs job to audit old books.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Don McLeod
11:30 AM on 12/08/2011
Maybe Canada should be renamed "TomFlanagan" a Christian (with a K) Conservative Country.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nadine Lumley
unseatHarper circle ca
11:13 AM on 12/08/2011
From Emily Dee:

Harper’s Neoconservatism: This entire “hard right” movement is a crock.

It is not a religious evangelist movement, **OR a moral movement.
It is a corporate movement.

http://pushedleft.blogspot.com/2010/11/democracy-for-sale-and-my-epiphany.html

HUFFPOST SUPER USER
montezaro
10:59 AM on 12/08/2011
"Mismanagement of the funds and communications" reminds me to the concentration camp commander in Bosnia statement, when NATO forces meet skeleton-like prisoners. They just didn't know how to manage all that food...
09:39 AM on 12/08/2011
Goodness. "WTF" and "fail" are hardly professional phrases - otherwise a well-intended article.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
CanadaStan
Cogito ergo spud, I think, therefore I yam
09:58 PM on 12/07/2011
This column needed some third party fact checking...
This comment has been removed.
02:56 PM on 12/07/2011
keep up the good work, thanks for cutting through the spin.
02:53 PM on 12/07/2011
Patricia,
Keep up the good work. The facts need to come out.
Lies have many faces. The truth, but one.
02:48 PM on 12/07/2011
Sorry, you don't have jurisdiction to impose third party management on Harper. The only jurisdiction you had was to vote in the last election, an election which left The Right Honorable Stephen Joseph Harper with a majority government. If you aren't happy with how he imposes third party management on First Nations you will have to wait until the next elections to voice your concern. That is the only power you have. Best regards.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Glass Cannon
Let every eye negotiate for itself.
05:04 PM on 12/07/2011
Well, she also has the power to protest and speak out against the government. Just like in this article. Awesome, eh?
photo
BCSLAVE
Got a key?
10:29 PM on 12/07/2011
No we got more rights than that dude - you dilute yourself. As for juristiction, the Supreme Court can impose third party management that superceds Harper's power in the affairs of that town. Additionally, the citizens of that town can demand it to because they were not bought and sold to Harper in the last election were they?
01:26 AM on 12/08/2011
SCC does not want to get involved in political questions (see e.g. Khadir series, Re: Quebec secession).

Where is your precedent for saying that the SCC can impose third party management going above, beyond, and contrary to third party management imposed by the Executive? While the SCC has a lot of powers, it cannot go against the Legislature on purely political decisions except if the Legislature is doing something unconstitutional.

The citizens of that town can demand all they want, but the only power they have is on election day.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Atim-moot Tugayak
Sun News is Dark and Hateful.
01:51 PM on 12/07/2011
Keep up the good work and expose the conservative crap.
01:40 PM on 12/07/2011
Patricia, I hate to tell you this but the entire Canadian government has been under 3rd party management for years.
01:29 PM on 12/07/2011
All of this could be true and Attiwapiskat would still fail the only test that matters: the ability to become economically self sustaining. In any normal community people work at jobs to earn money to build and look after their own homes, and pay taxes to build community infrastructure. This can never happen in Attawapiskat or in dozens of other reserve communities. Their very existence is an illusion created by the reserve system itself. It is time to actively discuss dismantling these communities that can never attain self sufficiency and direct resources to those who can
04:04 PM on 12/07/2011
Agreed. The model doesn't work and never has. Neither do bringing Potato chips to the far North and watching big screens. The people up there need to take it back and develop their resources. If the place in not viable economically, I suggest they move to a place that is. No one is building a University there, and I would think the Youth with ambition want to go to where they can fulfill their potential.
02:16 PM on 12/08/2011
Agreed with above two, except that they cannot 'take it back' as they need permission to do ANYTHING. What needs to happen BEFORE all that, possibly even before economic self-sufficiency (or in tandem with), is that First Nations need become their own people under the law, NOT wards of the State.