Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Patrick Brazeau

GET UPDATES FROM Patrick Brazeau
 

You Can Call Me An Asshole, But Don't Punish Aboriginals Who Question

Posted: 01/24/2013 3:30 pm

I've been asked to respond to a recent Twitter attack from Chief Theresa Spence's account. First, I would like to say that it is heartening to learn that Ms. Spence has agreed to end her protest. Like most Canadians, I have been greatly concerned for her well-being for some time. It was over a month ago now that I tried to visit Ms. Spence on Victoria Island. Unfortunately, I was turned away, as were all my colleagues in the Conservative Government who made the effort to speak with her. It is great news for the citizens of Attawapiskat that Ms. Spence will be returning to her community to answer their questions about the recent audit.

Aboriginal Canadians, like all Canadians, deserve to know how public funds are managed. One's racial heritage should not interfere with the right to know how public funds flow through the community. Many Aboriginal Canadians have reached out to me pleading for assistance in confronting their own chiefs and councils about funding. Many question how it is that those with friends on the council receive funds for education, housing and transportation, while those without such connections receive nothing. Many are afraid to speak out for fear of retribution.

While I am untroubled by personal attacks, I am very concerned for those Aboriginal Canadians who live in fear of speaking out. If an Aboriginal Canadian questions Chief Spence, ask questions about Idle No More, or expresses contrary opinions, they will find themselves targeted and marginalized by a small, but vocal group that claims to speak for all. They will be called an apple -- red on the outside and white on the inside. They will be called colonized and other such insulting terms.

I would encourage all Aboriginal Canadians to ask to see the financial records of their local bands. And to do this fearlessly. How can you vote for your chief and council without thorough knowledge of how band finances are managed? At best, you will be guessing. Many First Nations governments have indeed put into place sound accountability practices that ensure transparency and help build confidence among community members. Why not Attawapiskat? Why not all communities? Aboriginal Canadians deserve nothing less.

Loading Slideshow...

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
I've been asked to respond to a recent Twitter attack from Chief Theresa Spence's account. First, I would like to say that it is heartening to learn that Ms. Spence has agreed to end her protest. Like...
I've been asked to respond to a recent Twitter attack from Chief Theresa Spence's account. First, I would like to say that it is heartening to learn that Ms. Spence has agreed to end her protest. Like...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 224
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
05:58 PM on 01/31/2013
Ok Brazeau, why are you claiming cost of living allowance from my tax dollars when you don't actually reside with your father? If you are going to be in an appointed public position, be accountable for yourself first. If you want to make a difference for Aboriginals, then use your (influence?) with the current Federal Government to make things right. You know as well as any in Ottawa (and the rest of Canada for that matter) the audit report found no wrong doing, merely bad paperwork. No, I'm not native, just interested in the truth and accountability in my Government. Remember, when you accepted that Senator position, you started working for all of Canada, every citizen, even Chief Spence.
02:08 PM on 02/07/2013
Indeed ...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
marg mayer
12:39 AM on 01/28/2013
Okay, Senator Patrick Brazeau tweeted reporter Jennifer Ditchburn this little gem, "“while u smile Jen, others suffer. Change the D to a B in your last name and we’re even! Don’t mean it but needs saying", He actually wrote an op-ed about what was sent to him from Chief Spence's account? BTW, Jennifer Ditchburn was bringing attention to him winning the prize for the "poorest attendance record for this session of Parliament ". I actually think whoever tweeted from Chief Spence's account was absolutely 100% correct.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
09:17 AM on 01/26/2013
Thanks for removing my comment...
guess you don't like people who poke sticks into this hornets nest.
My comment was NOT derogatory in anyway shape or form but you seemed to think it must of been.
Not really promoting freedom of speech are ya?
05:23 AM on 01/26/2013
Let me get this strait. You're in bed with Harper but expect marginalized Aboriginals to speak up against abuse?
Harper is the figurehead against the poor and marginalized, but cheers for the free and greedy amongst us. Do you even know what you are doing?
08:05 PM on 01/25/2013
With all due respect Senator I don't think anyone wants to hear from you on the issues of transparency, especially considering how when you were at CAP Health Canada claimed that CAP could not account for money which had been allocated for FN's healthcare initiatives. You are living in a glass house on this issue.
05:35 PM on 01/25/2013
Very quick response senator. How come you don't show up for work more than 60 % of the time? How come a government funded agency like the one you led can endorse and not be partisan? How come you say terms like colonial are insulting when the party you sometimes represent in the senate wants that and in those terms? What about the sexual harrasment complaint? Answer just one real relevant question about yourself before you sit on your Tory throne?
05:23 PM on 01/25/2013
native communities are the same as other communities. there are major problems in today s communities. everywhere there is mismanagement of funds, drugs, lack of funds, drop out of our youth, alcoholism, violence etc i do not think these problems are new but perhaps just more.and when money is available like in prosperous times, we can cover up or re direct the problems to other things.but we are living in a new realityand have to face head on the new challenges coming our way as a human society with honesty, altruism and boldness.i approve of the 'idle no more movement' if only for the fact of showing the youth to not be afraid to stand and speak and be counted for,hopefully to solve the problems and look forward to a better future.especially in a non violent way.
03:23 PM on 01/25/2013
So, transparency about topics sexual harassment lawsuits? And attendance records? Yeah, seems those would be pretty revealing.

Funny how those get swept under the rug when the offender has connections.
03:13 PM on 01/25/2013
First Nation councils should be accountable to the members of their community, not the federal government. The type of accountability brought about in C-27 continues the implicit view that Natives cannot look after themselves, they need the federal government.
09:24 PM on 01/25/2013
Not as long as there's the Indian Act. They are ONLY accountable to the government....unless the Indian Act is abolished. But then, no more money for the FNP.

What to do...what to do?
09:48 PM on 01/26/2013
"What to do...what to do?"

So glad you asked! Well, the government could start by settling land claims and honoring the treaties. They could stop stealing the land and resources in the meantime and compensate for the billions already stolen. Further, they could account for the little compensation provided which they generously hold in trust for First Nations. They could stop mismanaging that trust and turn it over to the First Nations themselves to manage as they see fit as the courts have already instructed them to do.

Billions of First Nations dollars are sitting in the federal government coffers for which the federal government pays a pittance in interest. Realistically, that money is earning much much more but where do those funds go? To the federal government of course for the use and benefit of the rest of Canada. First Nations don't see a dime. Even when some of our own money is transferred to bands to fund our programs it's micromanaged to the hilt by the feds. The band literally has to ask the feds for permission before any expenditure is made. And yet it's the First Nations who are attacked and smeared in the media for taking "handouts" and not being "accountable" for "public" funds.

What to do...what to do indeed.
08:52 AM on 01/28/2013
You are sorely misinformed. The indian act is an office document which was plagarized from the US government on how to control and destroy the amercian indian. It is a racist and overreigning office procedure.
The peace treaties which existed prior to the colony of british crown, ensures that FNP are always paid and cared for. However, if you think removing the peace treaties is the way to go, then start writing letters to your monarchy.
02:57 PM on 01/25/2013
Interesting responses... but why does this have to be an either/or thing? One can't support the principles of Idle No More and be concerned about financial mismanagement and nepotism on the reserves as well? Isn't it all part of the same package? Theresa Spence is not the spokesperson for Idle No More although she has certainly put the spotlight on it. I thought it was a grassroots movement. Is it completely inconceivable that she might be part of the problem and part of the solution as well?

I am also curious about the false equivolencies. So if the Harper government has mismanaged their finances... it is okay for Band leaders to mismanage theirs? Or are you saying the government can not comment on the way FN funding goes because their own record is also tarnished?

Their are no smoke screens here... only issues and more issues that need to be addressed. No more excuses. No more finger pointing. We all know there are problems... its time to roll up your sleeves, address, and start working towards solutions to those problems.
08:54 AM on 01/28/2013
I am guessing everyone is not listening to the messages from Idle No More. Bill-C-45 is bad for all citizens. When federal protection of our water is removed, business and industry will buy it all for manufacturing purposes. Good point on government spending, I am sure there are plenty of slackers earning WAY TOO Much money, sitting around ottawa.

Then you have to think about their pensions they receive after such a short employment period. Hmmm, the guys in ottawa shifting focus to the First Nations again.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Prattly Ponsarello
That's me on the left...I think.
02:42 PM on 01/25/2013
Divide and conquer...the in-fighting within the First Nations serves no one but the status quo. Secondly, those who expect perfection do so at the expense of pursuing and achieving the good. There's nothing like vilifying each other to turn a heck of a lot of us off.
02:30 PM on 01/25/2013
the argument for and against Teresa Spence are unproductive. what needs be addressed is her calling the Governor General to come to a meeting with the PM. This is the crux of the problem - the GG is being used by the Crown of England to disarm the First Nations Peoples. This is the only problem that need be addressed and we are calling FN peoples from around the world to get the Crown to be responsible to the Two Row Wampum Treaty. nothing less works - the proof is in the pudding as they say.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
logicanada
Blogger, radio co-host, writer, editor, voice-over
12:19 PM on 01/25/2013
Having said this, maybe Mr. Brazeau would be willing to spearhead an public expose into where every other Canadians' money is being spent. For a government who promised fiscal responsibility and accountability they sure are going to have a hard time explaining our debt. Bookmark this debt clock (which IS accurate) and look at it once in a while. It truly is astounding.

http://www.debtclock.ca/
02:52 PM on 01/25/2013
Don't deflect from the purpose of this post,it certainly does no good to the Native people.

The financial machinations of anyone else are NOT the subject,so stick to it,and let's have some accountability from the Band leaders who claim to have so much respect for their people.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bpavich
laughter is medicine for the soul
06:19 PM on 01/26/2013
And what is the role of Abo affiars in all this? their role is to do exactly what you're saying, Abo affairs - Ottawa is not doing their job. Abo affairs reports less than 3% of bands have "accountability problem" compared to the rest of Canada = bands are doing much better than most Cdn communities.
It is time for Ottawa and Harper's gov't to act and no more dancing around photo ops
08:57 AM on 01/28/2013
But the real point is, if you want to question government spending, start at the top and work down. Guess how much you are paying the politicians today and for the rest of their lives? You have no idea do you.

Such a short employment time should not earn some politician (popular kid on the block) a pension off the backs of taxpayers. Therefore, this politician has no right to speak out against any other payroll.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
07:23 PM on 01/25/2013
I believe it is called an income tax form.
12:01 PM on 01/25/2013
This entire conversation regarding First Nations' financial mismanagement is a distraction from the real issues. It seems to me that when Britain (and France) came to Canada, they signed a treaty with the folks living here. That treaty stands, and the whole issue is that this elected parliament has taken it upon themselves to trump the treaty for corporate profits. The conservatives don't have the right to do that, and Idle no more is about bringing that fact to the Canadian public. Trying to refocus the conversation on First Nation's mismanagement of funds is a detraction from the issues.

The conservatives can say what they want, but the fact remains First Nations people in Canada have historically gotten the short end of the stick. This is chump-change in comparison to what we, Canadians, have taken as ours. This land, that we appropriated, was never ours... the monarchy realized that and wrote the treaty. It's not perfect, but it was agreed to and signed. Who does this government think they are to change the treaty without consulting First Nations?

I just hope that in 2 years when we, the Canadian public, have an opportunity to vote we do so strategically and morally, and vote this authoritarian excuse for a party out!

It breaks my heart that so many Canadians are duped by this nonsense.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Prattly Ponsarello
That's me on the left...I think.
02:39 PM on 01/25/2013
It's frustrating for two reasons, the cynicism of those who do it (who as far as I know have been elected to run the country, not vilify those with legitimate complaints) and those who buy into it. If you read the posts of the second group one thing becomes clear, they couldn't care less whether there is merit to the accusations, they are just using it as a smokescreen to mask their true feelings, which are quite simple: shut up.
04:13 PM on 01/25/2013
And which party has dominated governing? Liberals. Do not blame the present, look to the past.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bpavich
laughter is medicine for the soul
06:23 PM on 01/26/2013
Liberals created the Kelowna accord -2005 after years of consultation with FN and since 2006 CONS have been ripping it up and avoiding the issue. Harper's CONS should start working instead of "photo ops" with "Occupation double" reality stars.
03:17 PM on 01/27/2013
While you may be correct about the liberals, looking to the past does nothing about our present-day predicament. The current government is responsible for the actions of today, and since they refuse to listen to the official opposition or anyone that disagrees with their ideological agenda, they alone are responsible for their current actions.

I suggest you take a look at the following link: http://elizabethmaymp.ca/news/publications/press-releases/2012/10/18/bill-c-45-greatly-diminishes-right-to-unimpeded-navigable-waters/

and then think of a favorite waterway and check and see whether it is currently unprotected.

http://elizabethmaymp.ca/is-your-lake-safe

I have never voted Green, but I truly appreciate that this party has been so helpful to me as I strive to understand the impact of the omnibus bills that the conservatives have been passing. One must remember that they were not elected by a majority of Canadians, and they must be held accountable for their obvious disregard for the parliamentary process.

 It is not just about the past, or even the present. There must be some account for the future as well. The impact of removing  protection of 2,500,000 lakes and rivers to now 159, is mind-boggling and frankly, unacceptable.

This environmental offense lies squarely on the shoulders of the current government. In two years, we Canadians must go to the polls and hold them accountable. All of us need to be idle no more. We are blessed that leadership from our First Nations have lit the path to a better, more fair, and more just future, but we must be weary of the tools that work