Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Paul Mott

GET UPDATES FROM Paul Mott
 

Once a Separatist, Always a Separatist?

Posted: 08/10/11 02:17 PM ET

I've never been a fan of the NDP, but I've always had a liking for Jack Layton and a grudging admiration for his political accomplishments.

Therefore, even as a long time supporter of Team Tory, I'm reluctant to take pleasure in the controversy now surrounding her Majesty's Official Opposition.

As if Jack doesn't have enough on his mind battling cancer, he's likely now sweating his choice of interim leader, newbie Quebec MP, Nycole Turmel.

While Ms. Turmel insists that she's not now and never has been a separatist, many Canadians aren't buying it considering the evidence.

She was, until just prior to the last federal election, a card-carrying member of the Bloc Québécois. She claims she doesn't support the party's goal of separation, but joined anyway to "support a friend."

Really!? You join a party you oppose because a buddy is a member? Who does that!?

And what about her link with Québec Solidaire, a provincial separatist party? Still a member, she now says she'll end the relationship that began in 2007.

Then there's the fact, that when she was president of the Public Service Alliance of Canada she backed the union's endorsement of four Bloc candidates in the 2006 federal election!

More friends?

Nycole Turmel may well be a patriotic Canadian strongly opposed to Quebec separation. But at this point it doesn't matter... what matters now is the optics. The doubt is out there, and her opponents will play it for all it's worth. Even party-hopper Bob Rae is tsk tsking!

If Ms. Turmel is really true blue to the Orange, she'll do the party a favour and step aside as interim leader, sparing it the embarrassment of eventually pulling the plug and risking losing hard-won support in the province of Quebec.

Jack Layton's goal is to be back in time for the resumption of Parliament... and your God willing, he will be.

But if he isn't, and Turmel is at the helm, the good ship NDP is in for one hell of a stormy session.

As for the revelation that now Transport Minister Denis Lebel was also, once-upon-a-time, a card-totin' member of the Bloc, his story differs from that of Turmel's.

Unlike the interim-leader of the NDP, he walked away from the separatist gang more than a decade ago, not months ago. And he has been a Tory Member of Parliament since 2007! And, of course, the biggest difference is... he's not the leader of the party.

A politician switching his or her political allegiance can be tough, but getting others to believe it, even tougher.

 
I've never been a fan of the NDP, but I've always had a liking for Jack Layton and a grudging admiration for his political accomplishments. Therefore, even as a long time supporter of Team Tory, I'm ...
I've never been a fan of the NDP, but I've always had a liking for Jack Layton and a grudging admiration for his political accomplishments. Therefore, even as a long time supporter of Team Tory, I'm ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:07 AM on 08/11/2011
The biggest diffference is he is part of a wing nut. far right party led by a man who has to have a smile coach, limits journalists, was found in contempt of parliament, loves a system which takes from the poor and gives to the rich, gives billions of Canadian tax dollars to third world poverty stricken women but only if they don't get birth control or abortion rights, legitimizes the sale of asbestos. The list goes on. Going from the Bloc to the neo cons was a big change. It was a search for power for himself and not a desire to do anything for canada.
05:50 PM on 08/10/2011
no I am not going to play. I've spent close to 4 years on HP now with a long time interest in politics, especially North American politics and after seeing the cluster#%c* that debate in Washington has stooped to, I am not looking for that divisiveness to start here.

Ms. Turmel was member of the Bloc. She no longer is. So it's done.

Move on...this is non-issue.
03:14 PM on 08/10/2011
The election is over. The next one is four years away. You don't need to divide Canadians over nonissues till then.
canuckjen
A life that is lived is a life of evolution.
06:34 PM on 08/10/2011
The conservatives are clearly using the Republican playbook of hypocrisy and h@te in Canada and hoping Canadians are too dumb to realize they are being played.
02:23 PM on 08/10/2011
"Team Tory"? Like the Reform/Alliance/Conservative thing in Ottawa are the Tories?

GMAFB!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve Karmazenuk
Author, Freelance Journalist, Curmudgeon
01:58 PM on 08/10/2011
Separatism is gasping its last breath in Quebec, though I'm hardly shocked by the separatist / Tory connection: the Bloc Quebecois were born, after all, from the spectacular failure of Mulroney's Meech Lake Accord. The Bloc's founders were pretty much all former Conservative MP's, as well.

But the Bloc, while separatist-leaning, has never been more than a gang of political opportunists, holding on to power in Ottawa more for the sake of the benefits afforded to them than to help Quebec attain so-called independence. If Harper wants to "get tough" with Quebec separatists, he should start showing leadership and clean house, evicting everyone, the Transport Minister included, from caucus and membership in the Party, if they have at any time been a separatist; be it Quebec or Western Alliance.

Let's see Harper stand for Canada.

What disappoints me about the NDP is that they were the only remaining party not to have turned their back on Quebec Federalists, and its minority Anglophone communities. In this past election cycle, they did just that, avowing support for the draconian French Language Charter, and rejecting the Federal Clarity Act, which was put in place after separatist shenanigans in the 1995 referendum.
05:52 PM on 08/10/2011
good post