Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Let Kids Play Ball

Posted: 11/25/2011 12:41 pm

It's not just foolish, but pathetic that elementary schools increasingly are banning sports or activities that can result in injuries.

The issue became newsworthy in Toronto, when Earl Beatty Public School banned balls -- footballs, soccer balls, baseballs, volley balls, basketballs, all sorts of balls except sponge balls -- that conceivably could hurt a person if struck in the head.

The ban was imposed when a mother was apparently bonked by a soccer ball and went to hospital with a concussion.

Trying to produce a risk-free society is understandable at a certain level, but it's an attitude that can lead to unnecessary injuries. By not allowing ball games, reflexes don't get developed and awareness drops.

Earl Beatty's banning of balls is a syndrome that is reflected throughout society.

You don't see diving boards in public swimming pools any more; once, every pool had a diving board that kids loved, but were occasionally injured. And certainly no high diving boards. Pity. No more cannonball jumps or Tarzan leaps. Gone, like the Dodo.

It used to be that injuries were normal for kids: Scrapes, bruises, occasional black eyes, sprained ankles, and such. Now they are cause for alarm.

Some shudder at the memory of kids once playing hockey without helmets. Ignored, is that a head encased in a plastic shell smacking the ice can still cause concussion.

Bicycles used to be ridden without helmets. No more. All are symptoms of risk-free living that infects the nation, where responsibility shifts from the individual to the collective.

Organized sports for kids often try to reduce the competitive aspects -- like rival little league teams banned from keeping score so there'll be no apparent winners or losers, and no hurt feelings. The idea is to instill love for the game, and not winning or losing. This never works. Kids playing the game always keep score and know who is winning, even if the coaches pretend they don't know.

Banning balls in schoolyards condemns some kids to not developing hand-eye co-ordination, or basic skills of throwing and anticipating. And that's a pity.

At recess at Earl Beatty School, one supposes kids now stand around and discuss global warming. Immeasurably few wind up with concussions from being bonked on the bean with a soccer ball.

In the bad old days, recess at elementary schools was when boys wrestled, competed with glass marbles (called "allies"), and played "land" with pocket knives (which every boy carried): You hurled into a square drawn on the ground and carved off land according to where the pocket knife pierced the ground.

All are probably banned now -- especially pocket knives.

Unorganized sports for kids seem discouraged these days. Now parents are sought to supervise games. Kids wear team jerseys. In other times they just played, argued, followed their own rules -- and would have been horrified if parents intruded on games.

It won't be long before there are no swings in parks, no jungle gyms (kids sometimes slip and fall from them) -- just a sandbox from which dogs are banned, for obvious reasons. More risk-free living.

Banning balls from schoolyards penalizes kids and benefits no one -- with the possible exception of mothers who won't get concussions from being bonked with a ball.

 
It's not just foolish, but pathetic that elementary schools increasingly are banning sports or activities that can result in injuries. The issue became newsworthy in Toronto, when Earl Be...
It's not just foolish, but pathetic that elementary schools increasingly are banning sports or activities that can result in injuries. The issue became newsworthy in Toronto, when Earl Be...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:49 PM on 11/26/2011
IT sucks that schools keep banning stuff. Very small risks are acceptable to most people in return for immense amounts of fun. And to be realistic how likely is it that a ball will result in serious injury. I mean I have been hit in the head with soccer balls many times, and I am going for an Engineering degree.
10:51 PM on 11/25/2011
Two weeks ago my son was running around in the schoolyard, having fun, like 12 year olds do, and he tripped and broke his clavicle. The school reacted like they should - they calmly called me at work. I reacted like I should - I drove to the school and took him to the hospital. That was the end of it, except he's in a sling for five weeks.

In my uneducated opinion, I think the bigger concern for schools is not concern for the injured, but rather the fear of getting sued.
04:49 PM on 11/25/2011
Here, here Peter........how very true. One has to wonder how all of us boomers survived childhood what with all the freedoms we had. I truly pity the kids of today, coddled by nervous nelly parents and swaddled in protective gear. I've been hit in the head with a soccer ball and managed to keep on playing - that parent must have had a head like an eggshell.
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
03:17 PM on 11/25/2011
Simple, don't send your kids to nanny school.

Whoever banned balls at Earl Beatty's needs a little smack across the face, just enough for it to be numb for a few seconds and then tingly as hell afterwards.

Pocket knives might have been the norm back when Peter was in school (there was, after all, a need to defend oneself from dinosaur attacks), but the kids I remember in school were too irresponsible for such a thing. Maybe kids are becoming less and less mature every generation, who knows.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:37 PM on 11/25/2011
When balls are outlawed, only outlaws will have balls.
photo
Jay from Ottawa
sovereignty sale, 1.3T OBO
03:13 PM on 11/25/2011
lol - loveit
01:38 PM on 11/25/2011
If kids can't take risks, they can't grow up.
photo
zimpeterw
A politically incorrect, contrarian ex zimbabwean
01:14 PM on 11/25/2011
Very good analysis. The "nanny state" attitude once again. No wonder the former great nations of the West are in decline and those of the East - where they are still allowed to take risks and be competitive - are on the rise. I fear for the future of our society.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JeanFrancois Lord
01:06 PM on 11/25/2011
removing and preventing pain at all cost, the cost is too high.