What to do about bullying -- in schools, in the work place, in families, in society in general?
It's a question that's fashionable at the moment and deplored by everyone. But bullying is a reality that has many forms.
Like the weather, bullying is not going to go away. It is always there. Those who are victimized must learn to cope, or surrender to it. Most people, as they grow older, can remember instances where they were bullied -- but few remember themselves ever doing the bullying.
Crackdowns by schools, and laws and penalties imposed for bullying will not work. They may change the style of bullying, but won't eliminate the practice. Bullying is an aspect of life and a particular concern in schools.
When bullying becomes a headline issue, it is pathological, serious bullying rather than schoolyard teasing. But the latter prepares one for the former. I don't really remember being bullied much as a kid. I certainly never bullied -- though I was regarded (especially by my sister) as a tease which, looking back, can be a form bullying. Words can be more hurtful than deeds.
As an army brat, I changed schools regularly, as my father was posted elsewhere. Arriving at a new school in the middle of the year meant you quickly had to find your place in the class hierarchy. This often meant fighting the class bully at recess, as other kids watched and judged your worth. In those days I quite liked fighting, and instinctively realized that if you were intimidated, life would be harder. My big fear was getting bopped on the nose, causing tears to flow. I didn't want kids to get the wrong idea about tears. I wasn't crying. Tears just happened when the nose was bopped.
My parents never fussed about kids fighting. My father despised bullies and insisted they were all cowards. I learned young that this wasn't necessarily so. Many bullies lust for fighting -- preferably (but not necessarily) against those who didn't fight back.
At Prince of Wales school in Barrie, when my young sister was bullied, I'd trail her and when she was confronted I'd attack. She'd join in, and was a wildcat. I wanted her to be permanent bully-bait, but she objected. I felt let down.
Years later, when my son was bullied in school and wondered what to do, my advice was do nothing. When harassment got to the point where he felt the need to fight back, I advised him not to threaten or posture, but to give one warning for the other kid to stop "or else."
When the warning was ignored (as it usually is), I advised him to quickly hit the other kid on the nose as hard as he could. He did this, blood and tears flowed, the teacher got involved, but the bullying ceased forever.
Nervously, I asked what was the final straw that provoked the punch?
"He called me an awful name. I had to do something."
"What did he call you?" I said, uneasy at what I might hear.
"It's too awful -- I don't want to say it."
"Tell me. I can take it. Not your fault."
"He called me ... 'fish-face.'"
I was momentarily stunned. This was not the name I expected. Then: "You did right -- that's a terrible thing to call someone."
My son was never bullied again.
During 2 years at an elite boarding school, I witnessed pathological bullying that was like something out of Lord of the Flies. What I saw was bad enough, but the full extent of it didn't emerge until after the parents of a badly bullied boy took him out of the school. He had been subjected to an ongoing campaign of beatings and harassment, and was forced to pay his bullies every cent he had to avoid further punishment. Other kids also suffered beatings and extortion. Teachers and housemasters were none the wiser. The trio of bullies were the privileged sons of prominent Vancouver lawyers and businessmen. These were evil kids, skilled in cruelty and expert at covering their tracks even in a highly disciplined environment.
If only ending bullying were a matter of a simple "bop" in the nose. This may have been Worthington's experience 60 or 70 years ago, but it's wishful thinking to believe this is a solution today. Some kids can fight back. Some can't. Social media now give bullies all kinds of opportunities to harass, intimidate and spread malicious gossip.
The only answer is zero tolerance. Kids must be told that if they attack or harass someone once, they will be suspended. Do it again and they're gone.
Shall Canada wake up? ...or shall the snoring continue? Let us all teach each other that "Your life is not about you." Shall we collectively teach children from square one that..... collectively we live for others. Shall we teach each other ( "all of us teaching all of us" ) that we are to love our nieghbour as our selves ? Shut down all the TV-movies-games-etc that promote violence as entertainment.
Remember, you reap what you sow....individually and collectively.
Who gets the blame for bullying? The one who gets caught throwing the punch. ....perhaps it should be the parental-teachers who should get the blame.
Wake up please....
I believe that the schools today would benefit from some of the programs already in use by organisations such as the cadets, which started harassment and abuse prevention courses close to 15 years ago and has morphed into positive social relationships seminars given to all cadets each year. At the end of the seminar, they sign a symbolic contract that defines bullying and engages them to act when they witness it. It sensitzes them to the impacts that their behaviours may have on their peers, regardless of their intentions. Sometimes, people are bullying without even being aware of it. I have observed that since this training began, the teens in the program are much more active in reporting offensive behaviour.
Now it's embarrassing photos and vicious rumours on Facebook for everyone to see. It's non-stop stalking by text messaging. It's threats, vandalism and physical assaults. It's cliques of 3 or more "popular" kids and dozens of hangers on making sure the bullied kids don't enjoy school, after school events or even time alone at home.
Much of the bullying is what would be criminal code violations if the kids were adults. In those cases, the schools and parents have to work together to contact police and social services and get the bullies charged. Sometimes that's the only way to make neglectful parents wise up to their children's immoral, unethical and violent behaviour. Sometimes it's the only way to help social services get kids out of terrible home environments where bullying and violence are considered "normal" behaviour.
Children were good to each other, as everyone was in the same boat, moving all the time.