Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Canada Should Forgive Japan, But Never Forget

Posted: 12/08/11 04:59 PM ET

Finally!

Some 66 years-plus after it surrendered in World War II, Japan has apologized for its horrendous treatment of two battalions of Canadian soldiers captured at Hong Kong.

Of the roughly 2,000 men of the Royal Rifles of Canada and Winnipeg Grenadiers, plus support troops, that fought for some 18 days to defend Hong Kong from the Japanese attack in December, 1941, about 1,200 returned to Canada.

Nearly 300 Canadians were killed in the Hong Kong fighting. Twice that number died during the three and a half years of being imprisoned in Japan, doing forced labour on the docks and in mines, working 12 hours a day on meagre rations, and enduring various atrocities.

During the fighting, which ended in the surrender of the Hong Kong garrison on Christmas day, Sgt.-Maj, John Osborn became the first Canadian in WWII to win the Victoria Cross by covering a grenade with his helmet and his body, saving a dozen Canadian lives at the cost of his own. It wasn't until after the war that his heroism was officially recognized.

As a curiosity, the only Canadian executed as a "war criminal" in WWII was a sadistic prison guard of Hong Kong Canadians -- Kanao Inouye, a second-generation Japanese-Canadian who taunted and bullied Canadians, and was known and feared as "the Kamloops Kid" or as "Slap Happy." As well as physically abusing PoWs, Inouye would try to provoke Canadians with references to their wives being raped.

Inouye spoke English well and specialized in harassing the Canadians. Ironically, his father had won the Military Medal for Valour as a Canadian soldier fighting on the Western Front in WWI.

Sentenced to death as a war criminal, Inouye appealed that he was a Canadian; a second trial found him guilty of treason, and he was hanged.

In 1988, Prime Minister Brian Mulroney offered a formal apology to Japanese-Canadians interned during WWII, -- as did U.S. President Ronald Reagan. In Canada, each surviving internee was awarded $21,000, and nearly $50 million was donated to institutions dedicated to promoting human rights.

Despite efforts over the years to persuade Japan to apologize for its cruelty and barbarism to prisoners of war, the closest to an apology was an expression of "regret" for what it did -- like using Korean women as "comfort girls" for Japanese soldiers.

On Christmas day it will be the 70th anniversary of the British surrender at Hong Kong. Our Hong Kong vets are a dwindling band of brothers -- every one of whom carries reminders, physically and/or mentally, of his treatment as a prisoner of Japan.

The Japanese government offering an apology to Canadian PoWs for their treatment in WWII is something of a closure for surviving Canadians and for Canada -- and, oddly, for Japan itself.

Just as Canadians today feel no personal responsibility for the internment of Japanese-Canadians in WWII, so today's Japanese were not involved in the mistreatment of WWII prisoners -- Canadians, British, Australians. But misdeeds done in the country's name reflect on today's citizens. Just ask the Germans. Or Russians.

For those interested, Nathan Greenfield's book The Damned, tells the story of Canadians at Hong Kong, and as forced-labour prisoners. For a broader look at the Pacific War through the eyes of a remarkable individual, read Unbroken by Laura Hillenbrand (author of Sea Biscuit -- or better still, buy the audiotape and hear the story of former Olympic runner Louie Zamperini.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
08:15 AM on 12/09/2011
You say "finally" like Canada is some great leader in the role of asking forgiveness from those we have wronged. We still keep our natives in third world reservations, and many Canadians I speak to do not think we owe anything to the people whose land we stole. Yet I bet those same people have some pent-up manufactured anger at the Japanese for kicking our ass in a war. At least they declared their war...we pretended to be friends, made treaties, broke them, killed their women and children and used vastly superiour technology to practically wipe them out. Go us.
photo
Felix99
Born to be mild!!!!
07:35 PM on 12/08/2011
Churchill was the bright light who put our troops in that death trap of Hong Kong! He guaranteed that the several hundred Canadian troopers would stop the Japanese from going to war. The British attitude to its Dominions was what turned Australia from Britain to the US for protection. After Pearl Harbor when Australia tried to bring at least some of its forces back to defend Australia the Brits said: No, So Australia welcomed the Americans, and still does!
06:26 PM on 12/08/2011
Nice summary!

I have always enjoyed your posts!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
Appearances often are deceiving
05:33 PM on 12/08/2011
Never forget? Yeah and they should never forget that we rounded up civilians, stole all of their possessions and locked them in internment camps. There was plenty of dehuminizing done on all sides during WW2. We would be better off introspecting on why our culture chose to act as it did rather than focus on others actions.
06:51 PM on 12/08/2011
Surely you cannot be so absurd as to draw an equivalency between the internment camps (which were wrong, and which have drawn both apologies and money in reparations from the Canadian government) and the mutilations, executions, death marches, forced prostitution, and other atrocities committed by the Japanese during the War.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Aesops
Appearances often are deceiving
02:38 AM on 12/09/2011
And surely you cannot be so absurd as to suggest that by parsing between cruelties we gain any insight into ourselves? The future creates the history and to victor goes the spoils and the narrative. My grandmother in-law remembers the firebombing of Tokyo civilian areas and everything around her being obliterated and innocent people burned to death. Was that not an atrocity to your mind? Those that believe they have cornered morality are blind to their own cruelty. If we want to stop these things from happening again we must guard against our own self-righteousness first.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
08:18 AM on 12/09/2011
What horrors do you think the European Imperialists were responsible for when they were running roughshod over China in the 19th century? We are such hypocrites, for we ignore the many crimes that we engaged in, while making a huge issue of the ones our enemies did. Japanese soldiers were executed at the end of WW2 for the crime of....WATERBOARDING. Apparently that is now a regular part of US military training. We need to get off of our high horse already. Or as my wife says, get off the cross, someone else wants a turn.
photo
MikeDu
Both salubrious and lugubrious concurrently.
05:16 PM on 12/08/2011
Maybe someday Somalia will forgive the attrocities committed against its citizens by Canadian soldiers, too.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sgillhoolley
Occupy the discussion.
08:19 AM on 12/09/2011
Agreed, I have no stomach for hypocrisy. An action is either good, neutral, or evil. It is not good when I do it and evil when you do it.