Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

I Saw Lee Harvey Oswald Gunned Down

Posted: 11/22/11 01:00 AM ET

Scroll down for video

Every anniversary since the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963, I've been asked to comment or review what happened that sorry day.

I happened to be the only Canadian journalist in the underground garage of the Dallas police station that bright Sunday morning two days later, when JFK's accused assassin, Lee Harvey Oswald, was gunned down by Jack Ruby.

Police had planned to move Oswald to the county jail at 5 p.m., but advanced the timing to Sunday morning.

In those days I was a reporter with the old Toronto Telegram, and as soon as the news came over the wire that the president had been shot, several of us were dispatched to Washington where the late Gordon Donaldson was bureau chief.

It was a Friday, and within the hour Ken McTaggart, Dorothy Howarth and I were on our way with news still breaking. Ken and Dorothy are dead now -- arguably, both the greatest reporters of their day.

We worked all that night, and on Saturday realized we had no one in Dallas to cover the accused assassin. The Toronto Star was there -- Rae Corelli, a street-wise, old-time reporter. One of us had to catch the 1 a.m. milk-run flight to Dallas. Me.

I remember the endless flight to Dallas, landing at various spots en route, and feeling a deep depression and sense of personal loss at Kennedy's death. The flight was the first chance I'd had to reflect, without having to cover some aspect of the tragedy.

In Dallas I checked into the hotel -- I forget which one. I was exhausted and intended to sleep until the 5 p.m. advertised time of Oswald's transfer.

It was around 9 a.m. on the Sunday, and I remember thinking of my army days and the admonition: "Time spent on reconnaissance is never wasted." An agitated conscience persuaded me to check out the police station before bedding down. I wanted to know the lay of the land for the 5 p.m. move. I'd still catch a couple of hours sleep.

The police station was quiet, but stairs leading to the underground garage was alive with the babble of voices. I went down, prepared to show what credentials I had and to explain my dishevelled, unshaven presence if there was a security check.

There was none. I found myself on the police side of the garage, TV cameras and journalists packed and hollering across the driveway. I began chatting with a plainclothes cop, hoping to discourage others from questioning my presence.

I think local cops assumed I was FBI, while the FBI figured I was a local cop.

Soon, out of a doorway, came sheriffs, escorting Oswald who was wearing a sweater, had a bruise mark on his face, and was furtively darting glances side-to-side.

I began to shift down towards the car that would take him, when suddenly from the packed crowd of journalists, a hunched figure wearing a fedora lunged at Oswald and there was the sharp "pop" of a handgun being fired into his side.

Oswald crumbled, shrilly moaning "Oh... oh... oh." The gunman vanished under a pile of police bodies.

Pandemonium erupted. I thought I recognized the gunman as a Chicago Tribune reporter I'd met during the Saskatchewan Medicare crisis a year earlier, and was relieved when it wasn't him, and I wouldn't have to try and remember our conversation at the time, which I'd totally forgotten.


The plainclothes detective and I both felt the shock waves of the gun being fired. We nodded at each other and remarked that we were lucky the gunman was a good shot. Had he missed, we felt we were in the line of fire.

Oswald was dragged inside. The police were frantic. There was yelling and shouting. A TV crew was held at gun point to explain themselves. Individual reporters faced guns as police hunted for accomplices. It was a nervous time. Hysteria beckoned. Still, no one questioned my presence.

Oswald soon reappeared on a stretcher, being taken to an ambulance. The big question was whether he was alive, and would he live?

He was at my feet, the grey colour of cement. His eyes flickered. He was alive, but it was clear to me that he was already dead. Or soon would be. His sweater was rolled up and I could see the shape of the bullet beneath the unbroken skin, around his kidneys.

What I remember, that seems rarely to get mentioned, is the cheer from the crowd lining the street outside the police station when they heard that Oswald had been shot. This was Dallas -- no friend of Kennedy, but a city embarrassed that he'd been shot there.

In those days I'd spent more time covering wars, revolutions and crises abroad than stories at home, and was not used to on-the-spot TV reporting. I phoned the Telegram to reassure the Sunday editor that I had the story covered. I was mildly surprised and disappointed he wasn't more enthused. He said they knew I was there because I was on TV all morning. It was my first exposure to TV news coverage.

Unbeknownst to me, the rival Toronto Star was also looking at live TV coverage from Dallas and saw the Tely man, and wondered where their guy was. They phoned his hotel and woke him up. He still thought 5 p.m. was the moving time.

Better him than me, I thought when I heard the details. More evidence that time spent on reconnaissance is never wasted. As punishment, the Star suspended Correlli without pay for a couple of weeks.

In Dallas, attention shifted to the gunman -- small time bar owner and criminal wannabe Jack Ruby, whose trial I covered three months later.

Over the years, and in innumerable interviews, I've been asked about the case. Was it a conspiracy? Maybe Ruby was a hitman for organized crime? How about Oswald's Cuban connection? And/or the Soviet connection, where Oswald had defected as a Marine and then re-defected back home? Was Vice-President Lyndon Johnson involved? How about a gunman on the grassy knoll? How could Oswald have shot so accurately and so fast? What about so many skeptics of the assassination dying suddenly?

To all these and other theories, I simply don't know. I was just there.

What I do know is that over the past 48 years, no memoir, no diary, no deathbed confession has materialized that indicates a conspiracy. This absence in America, which is a chatterbox nation that can't keep secrets, seems substantial evidence that Oswald acted alone.

Yet even now, theories keep emerging. A woman claiming to be Oswald's lover has recently written a book claiming inside knowledge that Oswald didn't kill Kennedy, but was trying to prevent his assassination. What nonsense!

There's recently been a claim that Oswald's shot didn't kill the president -- it was a Secret Service man's gun firing accidentally that hit the president's head, killing him. This lapse supposedly has been covered up.

And so it goes.

Perhaps the conspiracy theories rage because it's difficult to accept that this shining hope for America and the world was extinguished by a pathetic nonentity, unworthy of notoriety. We may never know. The crime of the century seems destined to provoke questions and theories, far into the 21st century -- just as the assassination of President Lincoln did in 1865.

The violent, untimely deaths of both these presidents has guaranteed them a form of immortality, which is more than can be said of most presidents.

 
Scroll down for video Every anniversary since the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963, I've been asked to comment or review what happened that sorry day. ...
Scroll down for video Every anniversary since the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963, I've been asked to comment or review what happened that sorry day. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 250
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
04:53 PM on 11/24/2011
Simple physics can prove that Oswald didn't act alone and President Kennedy was shot from the front as well as the rear; disproving the "magic bullet theory" proposed by a then young attorney by the name of Arlen Specter.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockshock
08:05 PM on 11/24/2011
True, someone else shot President Kennedy from the front. People are saying, accidentally, the driver of the Presidential limo, hit the President, while he was kinda aiming somewhere over his left shoulder at the Book Depository Window. Right. Moving on.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockshock
11:09 PM on 11/24/2011
And don't forget, the Secret Service stole the body from the hospital "on their authority to take care of the President" which was against Texas law, which demanded the autopsy of a murder victim in Texas, be done in Texas. Yep, moving on.
03:40 PM on 11/24/2011
After watching T.V. the other night and seeing the Zappruder film and have it in digital for the first time.
Also many other films that have never been shown before, I am convinced after all these years Oswald acted allone. I'm not saying the C.I.A. or other factions of goverment had nothing to do with it.
The pattern of the ejected shell casings prove he fired when the Limo first in front of the book depository, hit the street signal and the ricochet hit the curb.
My question is why did the Dallas Police have jurisdiction of the murder of the President? Why wasn't he taken by an agency directley to Washington or a Federal facility? Why wasn't he allowed council?The killing of Oswald by Jack Ruby was also of question. Why wasn't he put in a federal prison?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockshock
03:27 PM on 11/24/2011
And then two years later after the tragic death of Young President, the French in 1965 became members of the Nuclear Club and detonated their bomb. It wasn't a Peugot. How chic.
03:18 PM on 11/24/2011
I remember President Kennedy's press conferences and how entertaining he could be and have full command of the facts.I was in school at Ole Miss when Kennedy ordered troops into the integration of that school.It was surreal to sit in the student union at Ole Miss and hear Kennedy on TV address the use of troops.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
billywms
03:17 PM on 11/24/2011
Wow,Neat!-Thanks 4 sharing your story.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Judy Gyarmathy
03:17 PM on 11/24/2011
I watched the tapes played on tv the other night and I got a gut feeling that Oswald sounded innocent by the way he talked to the police when they arrested him. Then I saw online a video and it said that Oswald was in the lunchroom, some floors down and couldn't have ran down from the window and been in the lunchroom that soon after the shooting. He was calm and not winded. That was just a scenario that I never heard before. I think it was a govt conspiracy myself. JFK wanted to be transparent to the American people and he had info that someone didn't want known. My theory anyway. I was 15 and having lunch at school, when I heard the news. I was shocked.
03:32 PM on 11/24/2011
I was 14 and I remember all it very well.....sad time
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bohol2528
of course I am a agitator, I design t shirts
05:02 PM on 11/24/2011
Not only would Oswald of had to hide the gun at the other end of the sixth floor, and then run down 4 flights of stairs, the lunchroom was on the second floor, but he would have had to do it within 90 seconds as well as pass 2 women on the stairs at the time and not be seen.

And yet, the women claimed that no one passed them on the stairs and 90 seconds after the shooting Oswald was seen by a co worker and a Dallas cop drinking a coke in the lunch room and he wasn't winded. Not only that, but a picture taken 30 seconds after the shooting seems to show at least 2 people on the 6th floor, who these people were are still unknown.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockshock
03:14 PM on 11/24/2011
There are quite a few unpopular facts from that fateful day in Dallas. Like in Fort Worth, some of the Secret Service were mortified that Kennedy and Jackie, just got off Air Force One, and waded into the crowd and shook everybody's hand, like they were the most popular boy and girl in the world.

And Kennedy's breakfast address in Fort Worth, is considered one of his most cogent and coherent speeches, in his career as a politician. And then in high end, the President and his First Lady, flew from Fort Worth to Dallas in Air Force One. Thanks for the memories JFK and Jackie Oh. You were a sly laugh by the sophisticates at the time. I was ten years old when Kennnedy was killed. I think he would have gotten out of Viet Nam, because he would have likely had a very tough re-election bid in 64' if he had continued escalation of the war. During the Kennedy Administration, the Viet Nam conflict or military intervention, officially became known as the Viet Nam War. His approval ratings were sagging, hence the trip to Texas to try to shore up his numbers, so he could win some of the South again, in the upcoming 1964 re-election bid. Sad days. Johnson was very depressed and wanted to win one, for his young friend, but the Tet Offensive and the Cong had different plans. RIP with a sadly beautiful era that will happen only once in a universe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bohol2528
of course I am a agitator, I design t shirts
05:04 PM on 11/24/2011
Kennedy had said 6 weeks before his death that he would withdraw all troops from Vietnam by 1965.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rockshock
06:41 PM on 11/24/2011
Thanks for the reminder. I believe the caveat to your historical detail, is that Kennedy did not say his plans to withdraw from Nam', more than a time or two in a showy public setting, and the press didn't cover it well. Leadership 'by committee' was probably the problem there. I like to remember that JFK lived long enough to see the gorgeous 64 Imperial unveiled, with the coupe and convertible equipped with the aircraft type leather bucket seats. Chrysler and the Kennedys were almost a great success. A love song to a sad era, of what might have been. Happy Thanksgiving, 2011. Another John, in Arlington. And what is left of the beat, does go on.
02:51 PM on 11/24/2011
and no one heard a rifle going off at the school book depository
02:49 PM on 11/24/2011
I saw it too . The live feed from Dallas . Looked easy , Ruby just ran up in front of those cops and shot Oswald .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sheckyb
03:39 PM on 11/24/2011
They really knew how to do security in Dallas in 1963.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
pcs5141
cut the crap
02:27 PM on 11/24/2011
JFK and his brother Bobby,the Attorney General were cracking down on the mob.Marilyn Monroe's "overdose"(one of JFK's mistresses),
could have been a warning that was ignored.This whole deal stinks and was played out like a movie script.Nice touch, blame it on the Russians.I was in Jr.High School history class when the announcement came over the PA speaker.It was surreal,everyone was in shock.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sheckyb
03:49 PM on 11/24/2011
It's hard to accept that one person of no consequence can destroy a person of great consequence and wreck havoc on a nation and history but that's exactly what happened. It's happened many times before and many times since.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetjudi1
02:10 PM on 11/24/2011
Old saying believe nothing you hear and half of what you see, somethings are never as they seem.
02:41 PM on 11/24/2011
And those hoof beats you hear behind you? Don't look for zebras
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetjudi1
01:38 PM on 11/24/2011
I am sure no one will agree but I have never thought Oswald shot the president.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
reedshelby
man may dismiss compassion from the heart, but God
01:56 PM on 11/24/2011
they found his gun in the book depository on the top floor with his finger prints on it...he was also the only employee missing when they rounded everyone up that worked there...why did he shoot officer Tidman when he was stopped if he did nothing wrong....why did he go hide in a theater?
He did it and even his family acknowledges he did. His brother said if he had any doubt whatsoever that Lee did not do it...he would have been trying to prove his brothers innocence. Osward ordered that rifle and balistics showed the bullets came from his gun.
02:36 PM on 11/24/2011
Reedshelby no fingerprints were actually recovered from the weapon and there is no conclusive evidence that Oswald was in fact the person who shot Tidman.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
ncrespi
My dogma is in my karma.
03:13 PM on 11/24/2011
I concur with reedshelby. Whatever there's no proof of or insuffucuent, no one can deny that Oswald was in a frenzy to escape. And the only one to leave out of an entire building of employees, which was verified. Also the warehouse room Oswald was in on the 6th floor contained a rifle with bullets that matched the ones that killed JFK. What more dow e need: Oswald's ghost jumping up & down screamong, "I CONFESS! "

Many cases in court have been won on circumstantial evidence. This is practically beyond it
as there's also witnesses involved, such as the police officers that took Oswald out of the movie theater he hid in.
02:18 PM on 11/24/2011
I think you could be right. The whole thing look's fishy.
01:34 PM on 11/24/2011
He was the color of concrete not "cement" ! Cement is just a powdered ingredient in concrete, amazing how people,even educated reporters get that wrong everyday.
01:41 PM on 11/24/2011
@creteslavesja. Cement is when it's wet. Concrete is when it's dry.
02:03 PM on 11/24/2011
No, cement is a powder that when mixed with stone & sand & water becomes concrete. Its like the flour in a cake, u need more than flour to make a cake. Has nothing to do with being wet or cured or as you called it "dry" no such thing as "dry" its called "cured".
02:13 PM on 11/24/2011
@creteslavesja. I said dry so you would understand. I said it because of you statement. It didn't sound like you knew what you were talking about. I know that the correct word is cured. "WET CEMENT" -- "HARD CONCRETE." Concrete evidence.....etc.
02:15 PM on 11/24/2011
@creteslavesja. Besides, I think you might be referring to lime.
01:29 PM on 11/24/2011
Let's try again,,, In Any picture or video the SS agent that guarded the Right Rear by the special Jump Bumper was waved away and was shrugging his shoulders multible times in disbelief moments before The SHOT................................
mindbender48
personally involved in our almost useless governme
02:11 PM on 11/24/2011
The secret service was in on it. They blamed Oswald because he was the perfect patsy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Savage Saint Roger
Card Carrying Liberal
01:19 PM on 11/24/2011
Cool Story! I was nine. I didn't see it on TV at the time.