Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Leonard Peltier's Sole Crime Was His Heritage

Posted: 07/12/2012 2:29 pm

Over the years, individuals and groups have emerged and faded in efforts to persuade the U.S. justice system to parole or grant amnesty to Leonard Peltier, convicted of the deaths of two FBI agents, Jack Coler and Ron Williams, in South Dakota in 1975.

Peltier, now 68, has been in prison for 35 years. Since 1977, petitions and pleas on his behalf have been ignored; appeals by the Arhbshiop of Canterbury, Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Nelson Mandela, 55 U.S. Congressmen, and Canadian Parliamentarians, and members of the European Parliament Union.

For six consecutive years, Peltier has been nominated for a Nobel Peace Prize, and is the recipient of over a dozen international human rights awards -- all because of the apparent injustice done to him.

The FBI and retired FBI agents have adamantly opposed anything resembling clemency for Peltier, even though his trial and conviction stunk like rotting fish, based as it was on fabricated evidence and perjury -- since admitted by many involved in his conviction. He's due for release around 2040, when he will be 106 years old.

The closest Peltier came to getting executive clemency was from Bill Clinton, but FBI opposition dissuaded Clinton, who had his own troubles at the time, especially with Monica Lewinsky. Clinton reneged on a previous commitment to Peltier's defense team.

Today, Peltier is in failing health; time is running out for possible freedom.

This year a new champion has emerged to urge executive clemency -- a group that is harder to ignore politically, but which the FBI association will oppose.

The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) represents all tribes across the U.S. and Alaska -- including the American Indian Movement (AIM) to which Peltier once belonged, and which was once a more radical rival to the NCAI.

Under the signature of its president, Jefferson Keel, the NCAI resolution notes that "appellate courts have repeatedly acknowledged evidence of U.S. government misconduct -- including knowingly presenting false statements to a Canadian court to extradite Mr. Peltier...forcing witnesses to lie at trial, and hiding ballistic evidence reflecting Mr. Peltier's innocence..."

Further: "The United States prosecutor [Lynn Crooks]" twice admitted that "no one knows who fired the fatal shots." And an appeal court judge, Gerald Heaney, wrote the president urging amnesty as a gesture to restore decent relations with Indians.

The NCAI has requested a meeting with President Barack Obama to "secure a grant of Executive Clemency to Leonard Peltier on constitutional, and overriding human rights and compassionate grounds."

America's Indians have psychological power in the U.S., if not political influence. When the two FBI agents were killed in 1975 on the Pine Ridge Reservation, it was a time of political turmoil with the Indians. The FBI erroneously branded AIM as a Soviet-backed communist subversive group when, in fact, it was an Indian-rights group.

During the Pine Ridge troubles, 60 Indians were murdered -- with no arrests or convictions made by the FBI. Paramilitary groups ran amok. The same day Coler and Williams were shot, another Indian, Joe Stuntz, was shot and killed -- again, no FBI investigation.

At Peltier's extradition from Canada, Myrtle Poor Bear testified she witnessed Peltier shooting the argents when, in fact, she was nowhere near Pine Ridge and had never met Peltier. The FBI wrote her script -- and at Peltier's trial, the defense was denied the chance to cross examine her, by which time she had recanted, and was deemed mentally incapable.

Not generally realized is that despite declining crime rates, the U.S. prison population is said to have grown six-fold. The number of older prisoners is growing at a faster rate than the total federal prison population. Between 2000 and 2009 the number of prisoners over age 51 grew from 14,275 to 25,160 -- a 76 per cent increase.

With age comes increased medical problems -- with no increase in the budget to address these problems. So by necessity, aging prisoners get sub-standard care.

As for Peltier, he's in failing health, has been for years. He's endured a stroke which left him nearly blind in one eye. He's had a serious debilitating jaw condition for years, that leaves him unable to chew. An offer of free corrective surgery by the Mayo clinic was rejected by prison authorities.

In addition, Peltier has diabetes, high blood pressure and a heart condition. He is susceptible to kidney failure. Yet repeatedly, he's been denied adequate medical care. This has earned the U.S. a rebuke from the UN for inhuman conditions.

It is undeniable that the FBI want Peltier to die in prison -- not necessarily because they believe he is guilty of murdering two agents, but because they want someone, anyone, identified as responsible for the deaths of two agents.

Often forgotten is that two Indians initially charged and put on trial for the murder of the two FBI agents -- Bob Robideau (since deceased) and Dino Butler -- were found not guilty, but acting in self-defense. The FBI made sure Peltier was denied any defence.

I visited him three time when he was in Leavenworth. I had initially written editorials in the Sun supporting the FBI, until deeper examination of the case revealed their deceit.

When I first met Peltier, I confessed that I had supported the FBI, not wanting him to be under any misconception. I was startled when he laughed: "My own mother believed the FBI would never lie, so how can I blame you for believing them?"

We got on fine after that. Being a model prisoner was no help. He was constantly harassed. I recall at one meeting in prison he was agitated because he'd been sharing a cell with a recently admitted inmate, whom he found to be pleasant fellow -- and then discovered he was a serial killer. Peltier was genuinely shocked that he'd have to share a cell with someone who was a dangerous criminal.

It reinforced the view that whatever Leonard Peltier was, or might have been, he was not a criminal, not a murderer, but an activist for Indian welfare and rights who got caught up in the politics of the times and has been a scapegoat ever since.

Peltier does not belong in prison -- never did, because all evidence against him was tainted, corrupted, falsified, invented, fabricated on non-existent claims.

That's the way it is with scapegoats. The Leonard Peltier Defense Offense Committee has since moved from Kansas and Missouri when he was in Leavenworth, to Fargo, North Dakota. Those interested can check the website.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:55 PM on 07/16/2012
The white man has always blamed others for there own down fall,They see what some one of none white has and take it ,weather it be from war,or shoot there own to get a story and jail some one, Heck they run there own into dust by there greed.Whats wrong with this story is a child molester gets less time then what Leonard got for supposedly shooting a Fed.What makes a Fed better than a child.Free him,as DNA evidence ect is still freeing people today ,bad police work all the way down .Free Leonard
10:06 PM on 07/15/2012
well presented article....for information about the new lawsuit filed against the U.S. Dept of Justice, on behalf of Peltier (to release FBI documents being witheld) a lawsuit which will positiviely impact Peltier's freedom.....visit http://news.infoshop.org/article.php?story=20120621155752520

also...NCAI resolution can be viewed in it's entirety in the new book Ghost Rider Roads (Wild Embers Press, 2012)
10:03 PM on 07/15/2012
fine article which summarizes past/current efforts to Free Peltier...please see updates about a "new lawsuit" filed against the U.S. Dept of Justice, demanding information which will also positively impact Peltier's case...http://news.infoshop.org/article.php?story=20120621155752520....by the way the ENTIRE resolution by NCAI can be found in a new book Ghost Rider Roads (Wild Embers, 2012) about the American Indian Movement ....
03:29 AM on 07/16/2012
Black Horse, CURRENT lawsuit (June 2012) which will help Leonard Peltier against the U.S. Dept of Justice, filed by Mike Kuzma ....information, here, as well:

"Buffalo Tracks, a Black Horse:" Peltier Supports Lawyer's New Lawsuit (Unne 2012)

http://rnzmagazine.com/2012/06/buffalo-tracks-a-blackhorse-leonard-peltier-supports-his-lawyer-in-new-fbi-lawsuit-by-antoinette-nora-claypoole/

AND

http://antoinetteclaypoole.blogspot.com/2012/06/buffalo-tracks-ablackhorse-leonard.html
03:57 PM on 07/15/2012
Thank you for another great, insightful and honest article. I believe that the FBI's role in this smells WORSE then 'rotten fish." I hope the new FOIA cases will get the withheld documents released and finally reveal the truth. I for one am very interested as to who were the informants/provocateurs that worked under defamed fired special agent, Joseph Trimbach. Was Frank Blackhorse one of them? I'm also interested in the "Judge Heaney," files and in finding out more about the 20 illegal, behind doors meetings that took place between him and the FBI that were influential in Leonard's appeal decision. Maybe this is why he subsequently recommended commutation of sentence? We differ in that I was never enamored by the FBI myth and I suspected their GUILT all along. Please read through this piece on former FBI agent and Peltier nemesis, Ed Woods, for a deeper historical perspective. President Obama can go a long ways in ending the reign of this tyrannical, racist, domestic terrorist organization by heeding Heaney's recommendation of an immediate commutation of sentence for Native American political prisoner, Leonard Peltier.
http://lpdoc.blogspot.com/2012/05/opinion-ed-woods-and-fbi-misconduct.html
10:37 PM on 07/15/2012
Here, also, a piece about the "Black Horse" factor, and the new lawsuit filed by one of Peltier's Lawyers, Michael Kuzma

http://news.infoshop.org/article.php?story=20120621155752520
06:04 PM on 07/14/2012
What kind of white guilt is this being spewed from? Those old timers in Native country still say he's no good. Ask Clyde "Frenchman" Bellecourt. We Natives don't need any more white folks feeling guilty for us. Dig beyond what you think you know...
12:31 PM on 07/14/2012
I would like to learn more but the link at the end of the piece that says website goes nowhere. Can that be fixed?
09:04 PM on 07/14/2012
HERE IS THE LINK www.whoisleonardpeltier.info/
photo
Ben Carnes
By our actions, we create our destiny.
12:14 PM on 07/14/2012
Thank you for this post Peter. Could you provide a link to the NCAI resolution! As a former of the LPDC and LPDOC, I've advocated on Peltier's behalf since the 80's. In November 1999, we hosted the Peltier Freedom month and met with the Justice Department. We brought Phil Fontaine, Assembly of First Nations, and Ernie Stevens, National Congress of American Indian, to meet with the Justice Department. Their representative, Jackie Agtuca, Office of Tribal Justice, promised she would meet with Janet Reno, US Attorney General and relay the joint resolution the AFN and NCAI had passed in July, along with our appeal for clemency. Obviously, nothing happened.
When Obama was campaigning in Indian Country, he said told a few people that he would look into Peltiers case. However, he since remained silent on the matter.
When Peltier was denied Parole, I conducted a spiritual fast at the White House for seven days in hopes of meeting with Obama. The day I arrived at the White House, I was immediately surrounded by the Secret Service, they knew I was coming and told me that I had no chance of meeting with Obama.
It may seem hopeless to continue the pursuit for justice, but as Lew Gurwitz stated when Peltier was convicted, "This is a case that is not going to go away!", we will come and go, but the demand for justice will never stop! Thanks again for bring this to our attention!
12:48 AM on 07/14/2012
what an awesome post mr. worthington. can you even imagine what this incredible warrior could do if he were free? he has done, from a prison cell, more for his people and humanity than most free people.
why are our leaders afraid to set him free?
05:16 PM on 07/14/2012
Ahh, maybe call more people? Peltier is guilty by his own words, boasting about shooting Ron Williams, a claim he made in front of four witnesses. Inmate Peltier remains manipulative, unrepentant, and very guilty.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:45 AM on 07/13/2012
Thank you for keeping this in the spotlight.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeanMartin
Everything in moderation.
11:11 PM on 07/12/2012
Whatever happened to that whole "innocent until proven guilty" thing? Or is that also just a bunch of words like "freedom and equality under the law" stuff those wacky Americans like to espouse?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:19 AM on 07/13/2012
"Seperation of church and state (but we're a christian country!)", "Freedom of speech is freedom to offend (unless we decide its obscene)", etc etc
They love their slogans down south, but the reality always gets in the way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SeanMartin
Everything in moderation.
09:50 PM on 07/13/2012
Or their misguided perception of reality. :-)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ppaatt
11:06 PM on 07/12/2012
Well done Peter Worthington. And how is keeping Peltier in prison helping anyone?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Brent Millar
When the going gets weird, the weird turn Pro
05:39 PM on 07/12/2012
Send in the JTF-2 under cover of darkness and rescue him.
Post-Haste.

Harper, are you listening? Obama?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:09 PM on 07/12/2012
Well said. Once again, Peter agrees with me.