Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Meet Lawrence Connelly: A Canadian Taxpayer Who's Told He's Not a Canadian

Posted: 05/25/2012 10:04 am

You're not going to believe this.

I had difficulty accepting it, but it's true: A child born to Canadian military family serving overseas can be Canadian -- but has no automatic right to a passport.

Lawrence Connelly was born in Germany in 1967 when his father was a firefighter in the Canadian Air Force. His mother was Canadian, and Lawrence was issued a Department of National Defence certificate of birth, showing him to be Canadian. All pretty routine.

Skip ahead to the present. Lawrence is a teacher, lives in Orillia, works in day care, has no criminal record ("else I couldn't work in day care facilities"), pays taxes, has a social insurance number, an OHIP card, driver's license, pays into a pension fund, is married and has two kids. Can't be more Canadian than that.

For a family vacation, Connelly planned to take the family to Disney World in the U.S. in August, and under new regulations put in place after 9/11, applied in person for a passport. Until recently he traveled in the U.S. without a passport, just his identity documents.

Imagine his surprise when the Passport Office said there was no proof he was a citizen. Where was his Canadian birth certificate?

Connelly showed his DND card verifying his birth to a Canadian serviceman in Germany.

"Sorry, that's not proof of citizenship," he was told.

He showed his driver's license, OHIP card, and other documents.

"Yes, we accept that you are a Canadian, but we can't issue a passport unless you can prove you are Canadian," he was told.

How does he do that, if the DND birth document isn't acceptable proof?

"You can apply for citizenship -- like an immigrant. It may take 10 months. Then you'll get a card saying you are a citizen, and can apply for a passport."

Lawrence Connelly couldn't believe it. Nor could I. Here's a guy who is born a Canadian but needs a card attesting to that fact, while I, also born Canadian, have a birth certificate but don't have to carry a card attesting to my nationality.

Connelly is made to feel second-class.

"How can the Immigration and Citizenship Office agree that I'm a Canadian, but insist that I have to prove it to get a passport?"

And with a six or 10 month wait, there goes his August vacation at Disney World.

Connelly has called people in Ottawa, and apparently nothing can be done.

He contacted his MP, Bruce Stanton (Simcoe North), who agrees that it is frustrating for Connely, "but new security regulations have come into place since 9/11."

Stanton thinks six months is the waiting time.

"The document issued to him by DND at his birth, isn't proof of citizenship for a passport," said Stanton. "It's frustrating, but there's a backlog of passport requests, so he'll have to wait six months or so. Security is important."

It strikes me that any number of Russian spies have acquired phony Canadian passports by taking names off tombstones in cemeteries. That seems easier than acquiring a DND certificate of birth. But times change.

While sympathetic to Connelly, Stanton says there's nothing that can be done about the new security rules: "The document issued by DND at his birth was never intended to be proof of citizenship." Oh? Tell that to kids born to military families.

Connelly says the passport people told him he should have applied when citizenship rules were changed in 1977 -- "when I was 10 years old, for heaven's sake."

Perhaps Connelly would have gotten a more receptive hearing if he approached an NDP member of parliament.

"Funny, I've never before felt anything but Canadian, if I'm not considered Canadian enough for a passport, maybe I should ask for the taxes I've paid to be returned."

It bothers him that he is expected to pay $85 to file for proof of citizenship, "and then pay for the passport on top of that -- all because they accept that I'm a Canadian but not a citizen, and then won't accept my proof of citizenship." Catch-22 , indeed!

So Lawrence Connelly joins the ranks of "Lost Canadians," caught in a bureaucratic spider web from which there seems no escape. All because his parents served Canada overseas, unaware that someday their country would turn on their child.

Connelly apparently joins the ranks of an estimated 200,000 Canadians -- war brides, their offspring and those born overseas to Canadian Armed Forces families -- who are among "Lost Canadians" who have fallen through bureaucratic cracks and didn't know it until they reached retirement age or applied for a passport.

The problem continues -- for Canada and its "lost" citizens.

 
FOLLOW CANADA POLITICS
You're not going to believe this. I had difficulty accepting it, but it's true: A child born to Canadian military family serving overseas can be Canadian -- but has no automatic right to ...
You're not going to believe this. I had difficulty accepting it, but it's true: A child born to Canadian military family serving overseas can be Canadian -- but has no automatic right to ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:45 PM on 05/25/2012
The Passport Office has an Ombudsman. Go to their website and contact him/her. I have dealt with these policy geeks before thru the Ombudsman and he was very helpful in making things work out.
04:16 PM on 05/25/2012
This is the sort of thing that happens as a direct result of these wrong-headed "crackdowns" on immigrants.

Treating any one group like they're all criminals means that EVERYONE can be treated like a criminal, even if you think you're exempt.
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
01:06 PM on 05/27/2012
... except that there is no "crackdown" going on, oddly enough. It is the one action one might have expected from the Minister, but it hasn't happened. Perhaps because the importation of cheap labour at any cost (by which it can crack down on Canadians trying to maintain decent age and benefit levels) is greater in importance to this government than the protection of Canadian citizens.
03:52 PM on 05/25/2012
I have a friend, a kindergarten teacher whose parent's are Canadian. Her mother gave birth to her in China where she and her hubby were volunteering as missionaries in the 1950's.

She had the same experience with her passport. She was told " you are technically Canadian, but Chinese too." It was a nightmare for her to correct this over sight.
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
03:03 PM on 05/25/2012
So yeah Mr. Worthington, how's that whole "Jason Kenney as Minister of Immigration & Citizenship" thing workin' out for ya? After all previous incidents and now this (AND today's ridiculous announcement from him about immigration "consultants" "policing" other immigration "consultants - which is just ABSURD!), how much more proof do you require that Kenney's a serial bungler? He could solve issues like this through an order-in-council in a trice - if he were 1/10th competent.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:33 PM on 05/25/2012
This is what drives Canadians crazy. Here an MP, the person elected to manage and direct our civil servant employees is afraid to tell our taxpayer paid employees what to do! Why do we elect these guys, is it not to run and manage the governemnt for us? So Stanton does have the courage to ask Baird to fix this, it is Baird who has claimed it is the elected officials who are responsible for government not the civil servants - guess Stanton didn't get that memo.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
01:28 PM on 05/25/2012
This year join us march across the U.S-CAN border.

Parade start Niagara Falls NY, across Whirlpool Bridge & through Niagara Falls Ontario to Oakes Park.

The celebration is held in Niagara Falls on the third Saturday in July - everyone is welcomed.

http://www.iroquoismuseum.org/PASSPORTS.htm

Contact us at idla@live.com for more information!
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=13902305963

http://http-server.carleton.ca/~domarsha/4302/LeagueofIndianNations.pdf
http://www.eculturalresources.com/news/990.html
http://firstnationcitizenship.afn.ca/uploads/Sui_genesis_citizenship.pdf
http://sisis.nativeweb.org/mk/infokit.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NsysGJB2ImM

http://www.amphilsoc.org/mole/view?docId=ead/Mss.Rec.9-ead.xml

http://www.trentu.ca/newsevents/newsDetail.php?newsID=819 ( Miss Brant)
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
01:26 PM on 05/25/2012
Indian Defence League of America:the oldest continuous Native protest movement in North America.

Perhaps people would like to know that idloa has been upholding the Jay Treaty of 1794 & the 1812 Treaty of Ghent SINCE 1927.

Clinton Rickard -a chief of the Tuscarora Nation, the Martins of the Six Nations Reserve along with my grandparents- Frank & Teresa Meness of Kitigan Zibi Anishnebeg organized the first march in 1927 after a fateful visit from a traditional Cayuga leader Levi General,Deskaheh,chief of the Younger Bear Clan.

Deskaheh was one of the first to assert Iroquois national rights in an international forum, traveling to Geneva, Switzerland, in the early '20s to petition the new League of Nations,forerunner of the United Nations.

While staying at Chief Rickard's house on the Tuscarora territory in New York, Deskaheh fell ill and sent for his traditional medicine man from the Six Nations Reserve in Canada.

But the medicine man was not allowed across the border. The U.S. had just passed the Immigration Law of 1924, which denied entry to anyone who did not speak English. Although the measure was directed against Asians, it also barred the traditionally raised medicine man, who did not read or write English and only spoke his own language. He could not make it to Deskaheh, who passed away in Chief Rickard's house.

Rickard was so moved that he began the border crossings and devoted his life to defending the right of free passage for Aboriginal people
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
02:24 PM on 05/25/2012
His people had heard in 1515, he said, of a repulsively homely white chief.

The young Indian men had swiftly formed a regiment and gone across the big water to fight for world freedom and justice as the allies of the government that had once so gratefully guaranteed his nation its lands.

Here he repeated a passage from the Treaty of 1784, as worded by Sir Frederick Haldimand, governor-in-chief of Quebec and territories depending hereon:

“I do hereby in his Majesty’s name, authorize and permit the said Mohawk nation and such other of the Six Nations Indians as wish to settle in that quarter to take possession of and settle upon the banks of the river commonly called Ouse or Grand River…which them and their posterity are to enjoy forever.”

Then he recited the tale of the broken pledge,

the raid of the Royal Mounted Police,

the rummaging of his own house,

the building of the police barracks,

the seizure of the sacred wampum.

The story would be incredible without evidence, but he had foreseen this and had the proofs with him. Then he lifted the lid of the suitcase and with care and reverence drew from within the old beaded wampum on which might be read the sworn agreements of white governments with his people.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
02:26 PM on 05/25/2012
Speaking with deep feeling, translating these documents slowly and impressively, stopping now and then to make clear the meanings of the bead colors and of the representations of the symbols, he made his entranced listeners feel that this was not the narration of the grievances of a small indigenous nation, but the story of all minority peoples – the tragedy of every small nation that is a neighbor to a larger one.

When he finished, there was a moment of silence – then a roar of a tremendous ovation.

Thousands rose to their feet to cheer him and the great hall echoed and re-echoed with their applause.

Straight, unsmiling, impassive, he waited until after many minutes the sound began to wane. Then, still expressionless he left the platform.

Before the end of 1924, the Speaker of the Six Nations Council had returned to the United States, a disillusioned and discouraged man. An exile from Canada and from the nation he thought he had failed, he found refuge with Clinton Rickard in the house of the benign old chief.

There, by the Niagara River, which marks the Canadian boundary, he found that the people for whom he had fought did not think him a failure.

From their northern homes in Grand River Land, they journeyed here to see him and assure him of their loyalty.

Though his disheartening experience had weakened him physically, his spirit took fire from their words and with never-ending courage, he kept up his battle.
compro01
Conservatism : Policy-based evidence making
12:53 PM on 05/25/2012
I think it's time to stop fooling around with the bureaucrats and take it to court.
12:41 PM on 05/25/2012
According to PW, "Connelly is made to feel second-class." because "...but don't have to carry a card attesting to my nationality." Welcome to the world of immigrants (landed and otherwise) who have to carry a card attesting to their nationality after having paid thousands of dollars to get here. And I do understand and empathise with Lawrence, I am merely pointing out that us "immigrants" are considered 2nd class citizens even by the likes of PW....just sayin'...