Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

The Toronto Zoo's Elephants Won't Forget

Posted: 05/29/2012 12:16 pm

We all know that bureaucracy has its own rules, and if it is ordered to do something with which it disagrees, there are innumerable ways to frustrate achievement.

This is evident in government ministries. Sometimes the minister can order that something be done that the bureaucracy, or "system," disagrees with, and often the minister is hung out to dry while nothing is done to further his wishes.

That was evident when the late Cliff Wenzel, a multi-decorated Second World War bomber pilot, fought for 30 years to get his reduced pension corrected. The bureaucracy stymied all efforts until finally a Defence Minister more stubborn and adamant than his predecessors, forced financial compensation for Wenzel.

Even then, the bureaucracy got even by getting most of the money back through taxes. But Wenzel felt vindicated -- thanks largely to the persistence of Defence Minister Gordon O'Connor, who was also a retired Brigadier-General and knew the system.

A case right now of the "system" foiling those who make decisions concerns the proposed and agreed upon plan to send the Toronto Zoo's three remaining African elephants -- Iringa, Thicka and Toka -- to an elephant sanctuary in California run by PAWS.

Former TV game show host, Bob Barker, who has affection for elephants, has offered to pay nearly $1 million in moving expenses.

City Councilor Michelle Berardinetti, some zoo staff and a couple of veterinarians visited the PAWS sanctuary last December, followed by Council voting to send the elephants to PAWS. However, concerns have been raised about the possibility of TB being rampant at the PAWS sanctuary. The zoo, apparently, doesn't want to give up its elephants. Although Toronto is not a comfortable environment for them, some zoo people insist it's the elephants' welfare that concerns them -- which I'd argue is unlikely. Rather, it's pride and bureaucratic intransigence.

Council wants to send another delegation to PAWS to investigate -- "part of a due diligence process," the Toronto Star quotes zoo CEO John Tracogna as saying.

The Star also quoted PAWS co-founder, Pat Derby, a former Hollywood animal trainer, as saying he's "sick" of the zoo's "witch hunt," and screw'em, he won't agree to another visit. Who can blame him? Even Bob Barker has threatened to cancel his commitment if Toronto continues to bitch and dither.

To some, it seems a predictable case of the bureaucracy -- i.e.: the zoo people who want the prestige of having elephants -- trying to short circuit or sabotage decisions of those who are their bosses. There are always abundant reasons, real or fabricated, for saying no. Delay is a weapon of obstructionists, and the longer it takes to move the Toronto elephants to PAWS, the less likely that it will happen. At least that seems the thinking.

The Star recently ran an article by Keith Lindsay, a conservation biologist and elephant expert who visited the PAWS sanctuary and gave it top rating. Zoos in other cities have realized that elephants need space -- not the postage stamp-sized enclosure Toronto elephants have -- and have moved them. The PAWS sanctuary is 30 Hectares of space.

As for TB, a couple of Asian elephants at PAWS died from arthritis and had TB. But Asian and African elephants roam in separate areas, and tests done every three months show TB is no longer present. Since 1984, seven elephants have died in Toronto Zoo -- four of them since 2006. So cut the red tape, and send them to PAWS as soon as humanely possible.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
We all know that bureaucracy has its own rules, and if it is ordered to do something with which it disagrees, there are innumerable ways to frustrate achievement. This is evident in government minist...
We all know that bureaucracy has its own rules, and if it is ordered to do something with which it disagrees, there are innumerable ways to frustrate achievement. This is evident in government minist...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:02 AM on 06/09/2012
Journalists should do their research before publishing their junk and give all of the facts on the issue, not just the ones that suit their own personal opinion. There are so many things wrong with this story - it would never have been published if the writer wasn't who he is. I used to admire Mr. Worthington but not any more.

Pat Derby is a she not a he.

"City Councilor Michelle Berardinetti, some zoo staff and a couple of veterinarians visited the PAWS sanctuary last December, followed by Council voting to send the elephants to PAWS. " - actually it was the other way around. The vote came first, then the visits.

" the zoo people who want the prestige of having elephants -- trying to short circuit or sabotage decisions of those who are their bosses. " - the zoo is closing the exhibit which is why they were researching a new home for them when council took over that task.

"The PAWS sanctuary is 30 Hectares of space." - unused space, too hilly.

"As for TB, a couple of Asian elephants at PAWS died from arthritis and had TB. " - there is one African elephant who may have died from TB, waiting for confirmation from the California Department of Public Health.

"Since 1984, seven elephants have died in Toronto Zoo -- four of them since 2006. " - 9 elephants have died at PAWS since 1982, 6 of them from TB related illness, 4 of them
11:45 AM on 06/03/2012
It's not just the bureaucracy stymieing the move. The elephant keepers themselves opened facebook pages, contacted media & did interviews and publicly ridiculed and reviled the councilors involved, the city council, Pat Derby & PAWS. They were indeed supported by zoo administration, and their CUPE union, though the CEO himself has no knowledge of animals or zoos and therefore is not very good at arguing the case. They were finally somewhat muzzled, though continue the campaign using pseudonyms and coaching stand-ins. These are city of Toronto employees, speaking against the city in its decision on city-owned property. I know of no private business where anything like this would be tolerated, but their jobs are secure, even if their behavior anywhere else would be just cause for dismissal. The witch hunt continues, the elephants will stay until the proposed & un-bult zoo breeding center in Florida happens. I gather Iringa is the sickest now, and I pray next winter is as mild as the past one. This gives the zoo a summer to demonstrate that elephants like sunny summer days, but doesn't show the reality of their overall sad and unhealthy lives.
12:33 PM on 05/30/2012
and the PAWS link is incorrect.... it links to Paws Canada.... for housepets! Last time I checked, an elephant was not a house pet!
photo
Ian Llangan
Your Invisible Sky Friend Is Morally Abhorrent
03:04 PM on 05/29/2012
I never thought the day would come when I might agree with Peter Worthington on any issue, but here it is. Your analysis and assessment are bang-on. Elephants do not thrive in our climate, nor particularly in zoos. These elephants should be transported as carefully as possible to the sanctuary immediately if not sooner. Thank you Peter for bringing attention to this particular issue and for recognizing that the interests of the elephants are paramount.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nic the wonder puppy
When life throws lemons, throw them back
12:58 PM on 05/29/2012
I am sorry to say my paws had nothing to do with this mess, just the holes in the yard.
12:35 PM on 05/29/2012
Now, if we could only get the old, the slow, the out of touch, over-the-hill journalists into some nice sanctuary where they could scribble away their days munching on whatever it is they munch,,,, the Huffington Post might be more interesting.