Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Worthington

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Worthington
 

Canada Fails at Helping the Ukraine

Posted: 03/17/2012 11:56 pm

Why did my heart sag when I learned of the international conference in Ottawa titled "Ukraine at the Crossroads"?

Over 30 notable academics, politicians, and international experts gathered at the Chateau Laurier on Mar. 7-8 under auspices of the Ukrainian Canadian Council (UCC) to discuss the state of democracy and freedom in Ukraine and its tenuous (and often tense) relations with Russia.

Prior to that gathering -- often involving some of the same "experts" -- was the House of Commons Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development. Again, they rehashed what to do about the loss of democratic reforms that jeopardize Ukraine's ties with Europe.

Former Interior Minister and Opposition leader Yuri Lutsenko, has been sentenced to four years in jail, convicted in December of "Abuse of Office" and embezzlement. Charges that reek of political expediency.

Former Ukrainian PM (2005) Julia Tymoshenko is currenlty serving seven years in prison for "Abuse of Office." An economist and academic, Tymoshenko was Ukraine's first female PM. As a businesswoman in the gas industry, she is reputedly one Ukraine's richest people -- but still she's in prison.

Tymoshenko and Lutsenko were both involved in Ukraine's "Orange Revolution," as was their colleague, Viktor Yanukovych, now Ukraine's president. As a teenager, Yanukovych served time in jail for robbery and assault -- a rough diamond. He narrowly defeated Tymoshenko for the presidency in 2010 -- so she went to jail.

The Canadian Standing Committee is comprised of seven Conservative MPs, five NDP MPs, and no Liberals, which seems a mistake because the Liberals are far more experienced and sensible in foreign matters than the NDP.

The big lapse in the Standing Committee is the absence of Liberal MP Chris Alexander, former diplomat in Moscow and former ambassador to Afghanistan who understands Russia better than the whole Harper Cabinet and NDP caucus is you ask me.

So what can be done to enhance Ukraine's future, living next to Russia?

Not much, I fear.

Some 45 years ago I lived and worked for a couple of years in Moscow, when Ukraine was a republic of the Soviet Union. Even then, tension between Russians and Ukrainians was palpable. This always struck me as curious, because as an outsider it was hard to tell the difference between the two.

I remember asking a Russian why the thinly disguised hostility.

The Russian, remarked on the Stalin-inspired famine in Ukraine that killed some seven million by starvation and tamed incipient rebellion in Ukraine; and the wartime massacre at Babi Yar of several million Jews and more millions of Ukrainians.

That doesn't answer the question "Why?" I remember saying.

"You must remember," said my friend. "That Ukrainians instinctively feel they are more intelligent, more civilized, more efficient than Russians."

"Okay," I said. "That may explain the attitude of Ukrainians, but it doesn't explain why Russians should be so resentful.

"It's because Russians also feel Ukrainians are more capable than they are."

I'd never thought of that, but it added a new perspective: Inferiority complex.

Now that Ukraine is an independent country, but still economically, socially, and culturally dependent on Russia in ways that Belarus is, it cannot escape Russian paranoia about its desire to identify more closely with Europe.

Next to the Jewish lobby, the 1.2 million Ukrainian-Canadians probably wield more influence with the federal and provincial governments than any other group. The UCC is aggressive and vibrant, but it's difficult seeing them having much influence on Russian policies.

After the presidential election in Russia, it's likely that Vladimir Putin is going to be the guy in charge until about 2024 if he so wishes -- and if he lasts.

Despite all the rhetoric and street protests now going on in Russia against Putin resuming the presidency, he is in a strong position. The 64 per cent vote he got is slightly lower than the 72 per cent he got in 2004, but it indicates huge support that is far more significant than any incidents of vote-rigging could have managed.

The Canadian Standing Committee wants to send an observer team to Ukraine for elections due in October. How may times have we heard similar proposals for elections in Africa and other sensitive spots in the world? And how often has such monitoring affected the outcome of elections? Not often.

One doesn't like to contemplate it, but it's hard to see any country that is cheek-by-jowl to Russia following a diplomatic course that makes Russia fearful. Democracy is too new, too fragile in that part of the world, and is not yet a tradition as it is elsewhere.

None of this should -- or will -- inhibit Ukrainians from being dynamic and determined advocates of Ukraine's future in democratic world where human rights and reforms are standard ways of life.

To suggest Ukraine today is at a "crossroads" is perhaps too hopeful.

If, indeed, it is at a crossroads as the title of its recent Ottawa conference suggests, it is stalled at the crossroads -- paralyzed between east and west, unable to advance until one side or the other blinks. Which neither shows any sign of doing. Yet.

 
FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:06 PM on 03/18/2012
Public opinion polls in the Ukraine by the way show majorities favouring association with Russia. For a long time this included support for outright unification. The pro-unification candidates did very well in 1999 and were robbed in the second round of the vote (some of the Orange Revolution people actually admitted in 2004 that Simonenko was robbed of the presidency by fraud in 1999 - Simonenko who advocated unification with Russia!) Just like it's interesting to see anti-Putin neo-Yeltsinite Russian liberals crow about Medvedev admitting that Yeltsin stole the 1996 election from the Communist Zyuganov.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hal Wood
06:53 PM on 03/18/2012
I think cancel the majority of foreign aid to other countries and pick Ukrainia { there I renamed it} WIth Russia hassling us in the north I think our influence could be a bonus for Canada, particularilly because we would be helping them unlike Russia which likes to posess countries.
06:35 PM on 03/18/2012
So, Timoshenko " is reputedly one Ukraine's richest people -- but still she's in prison." Unlike in the civilised West where the richest people never go to prison no matter what they do. Seems like the Ukraine is more enlightened. The part there about some Russian saying that Russians think Ukrainians are better is no surprise; there's this strong idea throughout Europe that the more you go east, the more you slip into barbarism (just as it follows that when you go south you slip more into decadence and indolence). Unfortunately this toxic idea cannot help but enter the minds of some Russians and affect them in this way.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rickthaluddite
What noisy cats are we
12:44 PM on 03/18/2012
Harper dismisses plenty of Liberal input-- especially how to run a budget surplus and make plans to pay down the country's debt.
11:33 AM on 03/18/2012
Chris Alexander is a Conservative MP, not Liberal.
08:56 AM on 03/18/2012
Yeah the title should read

"The Canada fails at helping the Ukraine"
05:07 PM on 03/18/2012
I always tease my ukrainian friend by saying "the ukraine" haha i find it hilarious.
06:36 PM on 03/18/2012
Ukraine means "borderland" and is unworthy as a name, and it should have a "The" by definition so what about its real name; Malorus...
06:46 AM on 03/18/2012
re: article title: Since it's now a country it is no longer "the Ukraine"" but just "Ukraine"
06:36 PM on 03/18/2012
It's Malorus.
02:02 AM on 03/19/2012
If you're Russian...