Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rachel Décoste

GET UPDATES FROM Rachel Décoste
 

Tories in Tatters When Told To Go Home?

Posted: 11/21/2012 4:13 pm

Perhaps, like first and second generation Canadians void European heritage, the Tories feel at home in the nation's capital. After all, they've been there for years. They live there for most of the calendar year, they work there and they even attend mass there.

Suddenly, like a fly in the ointment, an utterance from a local has rattled their cages and shattered their sense of belonging. What a surprise to be told to "go home" after being integrated into the fabric of one's environment! One wonders how that must feel...

Calgary-born MP Pierre Poilevre called David McGuinty's comments "shocking" while Calgary Tory MP Michelle Rempel challenged McGuinty to make the comments to her face in the House.

Wouldn't you love to have a survey of Alberta's ethno-cultural communities and francophone communities to see how often some Conservative tells him to "go home" because they don't belong there.

The notion that this comment gave Tory MPs a burr under their saddles -- so vexed are they by the comment they so habitually spew -- sounds quite hypocritical to those who are usually on the receiving end of the contempt the Alberta bunch has shown for minorities, immigrants, refugees and francophone Canadians both in and outside La Belle Province.

It is the Tories who have repeatedly told immigrants to 'go home', going so far as exerting two federal departments to look for immigration fraud needles in haystacks of upstanding new Canadians.

It is the Tories who have repeatedly belittled francophones by slowly choking their equal status from the Auditor General's office and the Supreme Court.

It is the Tories who have repeatedly told refugees to "go home" sick, or worse, to go back to their war-torn, torture-endorsing homelands or the overflowing death-traps called refugee camps.

What can one expect from a cluster genetically linked to the Canadian Reform Alliance Party - a party of francophobes, xenophobes and those obsessed with retaining Canada's "traditional" culture.

Perhaps this oh-so-traumatic experience will give Tories reason to pause the next time they throw those familiar stones.

 

Follow Rachel Décoste on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RachelDecoste

FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:10 AM on 11/22/2012
The justifications from the Lib/Left for this incident are highly amusing. It's one thing to throw political darts back and forth, but this was just plain old bigotry.
09:03 AM on 11/22/2012
Am I the only one who can remember Ralph Klein telling all those eastern b's that they could freeze in the dark. How all those Albertans cheered that.
09:01 AM on 11/22/2012
I agree with McGuinty completely. And I think most Canadians do too. And I am from Alberta. My family has lived there since 1882 and that’s early in Alberta. But I now live in the NWT and I know that not one of those Alberta MPs cares one whit about the poison that will flow down the river past my house from those tar sands.

Every time I contemplate how Alberta has given away its oil wealth for a tiny mess of potage and is now having its beautiful landscape ruined I want to cry. All that wealth and it is broke. I don’t think those MPs care about Alberta either. Their loyalty is to the oil companies.
08:42 AM on 11/22/2012
Mme Décoste: what is the message you read when watch the interview of Canada's Minister of Heritage on the the Radio-Canada flagship talkshow, Tout le monde est blanc, earlier this year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jKczSdo5pEA
Or when you check out the "Chroniqueurs" on Radio-Canada's most popular radio show, C'est bien meilleur les blancs: http://www.radio-canada.ca/emissions/cest_bien_meilleur_le_matin/2012-2013/index.asp
Rentrez chez vous, perhaps?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Rachel Decoste
Motivational speaker + | Conférencière ++
03:24 PM on 11/22/2012
Barush, it doesn't matter if every single one of the 24 radio show contributors are purelaine. Don't you know that "diversity" is covered by including an anglo!? Meet your designated diversity guy:
http://www.radio-canada.ca/emissions/cest_bien_meilleur_le_matin/2012-2013/chroniqueur.asp?chroniqueur=dick_howard
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Rachel Decoste
Motivational speaker + | Conférencière ++
08:36 AM on 11/22/2012
@danHarrisNdp: Same day Conservatives chastised McGuinty for telling Alberta MPs to "go home", a Conservative MP yelled at me to "go home" at end of my #SO31. Watch the video: http://t.co/rdJlUKOc
georgee2
My Canada Includes Everyone
07:53 AM on 11/22/2012
It was the prime minister himself who said that all of Atlantic Canada had a defeatist attitude. He is from Alberta, right?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Skookum1
truth can't be bought, but lies sure can be sold..
03:15 AM on 11/22/2012
I seem to recall Albertan MPs telling Quebec MPs to "go back to Quebec" or similar, or to otherwise get out of Parliament and/or the country, on a regular basis. Did even on apologize?
01:48 AM on 11/22/2012
I guess you probably can't see the irony of the sweeping generalization and stereotyping you just did there. I actually wouldn't mind seeing that survey done in Alberta - then a comparable one done among ethnic groups and anglophone communities in Quebec. I'm an ex British Columbian living in Edmonton and find remarks like the ones made by Ms Decoste about Alberta as stereotypical and untrue as saying all African Americans like basketball. There are bigots everywhere, unfortunately.

But if there's anything that gets up my nose, it's listening to someone crap on one group to 'defend' another while smugly patting herself on the back for being an uber-accepting liberal. Shows a staggering ignorance and lack of more than headline-level thought.
This comment has been removed.
08:03 PM on 11/21/2012
Tories are taking it hard because they are sensitive folk... but on the other hand I have heard a lot of anti Quebec talk coming from Alberta and many of her points are valid.
It may be a stretch but the tories are probably just trying to score political points by making their divisive fuss
11:20 PM on 11/21/2012
Probably?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:00 PM on 11/21/2012
Decoste apparently thinks Albertans are bigoted xenophobes who regularly tell people who don't look like them to go back to where they came from.

And it's utter rubbish, the typical puerile stupidity that is so common in Canada today.
10:34 PM on 11/21/2012
That is actually why I left Calgary so many years ago. Edmonton was great for acceptance, but I really found Calgary and many of the smaller communities to be extremely bigoted and xenophobic. I did find some great friends in Calgary, but in general, it was pretty awful for anybody slightly un-rightwing.
08:46 AM on 11/22/2012
@Janice, Found much the same thing myself, many small minded, socially conservative, rabid xenophobes. If they had been simply Albertaphiles, it would have been tolerable and understandable, but the rabid red-neck dislike and contempt for everyone and everything else was intolerable. Have to say though, I also met some of the best people I've encountered in my 50+years in Alberta. I've met many of the same brand of individual in pockets of rural Ontario & B.C., though they tend to be much less vocal and aggressive.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Zozzer
Dum Spiro Spero - While I breath, I hope.
04:01 AM on 11/22/2012
Love to go back where I came from... Not an option however. The history of the world is one of immigration, and at what point would the "go back" crowd like to designate as the time when things were "perfect?" Maybe that would require to much thought. :-)