Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ralph Nader


Dear Mr. Harper, Don't Let Verizon into Canada

Posted: 08/22/2013 1:13 pm

Dear Prime Minister Stephen Harper:

I read with interest that you are considering allowing Verizon Communications to operate Canada with unique acquisition rights.

Bad idea.

Before you proceed any further, I suggest that you read a report by the highly regarded Center for Tax Justice and Good Jobs First titled "Unpaid Bills: How Verizon Shortchanges Government Through Tax Dodging and Subsidies."

Bottom line: Verizon is one of the country's most aggressive corporate tax dodgers.

The report found that Verizon enjoyed some $14 billion in federal and state corporate income tax subsidies in the 2008-2010 period even though it earned $33.4 billion in pre-tax U.S. income during that time!

At the federal level, Verizon should have paid about $11.4 billion at the statutory rate of 35 percent during the three-year period.

Instead, it actually got $951 million in rebates, putting its federal tax subsidies at $12.3 billion.

Its effective federal tax rate was 2.9 percent.

The report found that at the state level, Verizon should have paid about $2.3 billion in corporate income taxes during the period but it paid only $866 million.

Its aggregate state rate was only 2.6 percent, far below the weighted state average rate of 6.8 percent.

This gave it state tax subsidies of about $1.4 billion.

Verizon also used a special tax loophole called the Reverse Morris Trust to avoid paying about $1.5 billion in federal and state and local taxes on the sale of its landline assets in various states.

The report found that Verizon also aggressively seeks state and local tax subsidies through credits, abatements and exemptions.

There is no centralized reporting on these subsidies, but the report documents $180 million in special tax breaks and grants Verizon and Verizon Wireless received in 13 states.

In addition to aggressively dodging taxes, Verizon also overtly rips off our federal government.

In April 2011, for example, Verizon paid $93.5 million to settle whistleblower charges that it had billed the government for "tax-like" surcharges that it wasn't entitled to impose on the government.

Hidden surcharges on communication services have long been an unwelcome cost to business and consumers, and the General Services Administration had negotiated a firm, fixed-price contract with limited surcharges precisely to avoid being hit with hidden surcharges, the whistleblower alleged.

"Verizon was not only charging the government for the costs associated with communication services, but it also was pumping up its revenues by charging the government for Verizon's own property taxes and other costs of doing business," said Colette Matzzie, a Washington, DC, attorney with Phillips & Cohen LLP, who represented the whistleblower. "Under federal law, Verizon was responsible for paying those costs, not the government."

The settlement agreement covers the period from 2004 to 2010, when Verizon allegedly billed the government for a variety of surcharges including property tax surcharges, carrier cost recovery charges, state telecommunications relay service surcharges and public utility commission fee surcharges.

Question: why would you allow one of our country's most aggressive tax dodgers, a company with a track record of overtly ripping off our government, into your country?

What's bad for the United States will be bad for Canada.


Ralph Nader
Washington, DC


Loading Slideshow...
  • Window Phone

    Designed by <a href="http://www.yankodesign.com/2009/08/18/phone-that-shames-the-weather-bureau/">Seunghan Song</a>, this "window phone" concept will reflect current weather conditions on the screen. To input text, you just blow on the screen to switch modes, then write with your finger as a stylus.

  • Cobalto

    <a href="http://petitinvention.wordpress.com/2009/11/20/cobalto-zafiro/">Mac Funamizu's "Cobalto"</a> has taken the cell phone concept way into the future, with an almost all-glass design. The phone would feature 3D imaging that could make Google Maps even more useful, as demonstrated here.

  • Leaf Phone

    <a href="http://www.behance.net/Gallery/leaf-phone/325190">Anastasia Zharkova's organic "Leaf Phone"</a> melds aesthetic creativity with functionality. The winding stem of the leaves could be wrapped around a user's arm, wrist, neck, or other body part.

  • Sticker Phone

    <a href="http://www.yankodesign.com/2009/12/03/sticky-phone/">Liu Hsiang-Ling's "Sticker Phone"</a> has a solar panel on the back of the phone and a curved surface that will allow it to stick to a window via suction to charge. Plus, you won't lose your phone somewhere on your desk.

  • Kambala

    A pop-up phone! <a href="http://www.yankodesign.com/2009/06/08/phone-ear-phone-phone/">Ilshat Garipov's "Kambala" </a> is a fascinating concept that features a center piece that can pop out to fit into your ear, making it an earphone. In theory, it will also have the ability to match your skin tone, rendering it almost invisible.

  • Packet

    <a href="http://www.behance.net/Gallery/PACKET-phone/162229">Emir Rifat's "Packet" phone</a> won first place at the Istanbul Design Week 2007. The tiny phone starts off at 5 cm square, then folds out as needed for different functions.

  • Dial

    <a href="http://www.yankodesign.com/2009/11/30/phone-fashion/">Jung Dae Hoon's "Dial"</a> concept takes the rotary phone of the 'good ol' days' and combines it with mobile technology and modern jewelry sensibilities.

  • Morph

    Nokia's "Morph" phone uses nanotechnology to create a flexible body and transparent screen that can be molded to whatever shape is the most convenient for its user. The nanotech could even clean itself.

  • Natural Year Phone

    People tend to keep cell phones for only two years, and <a href="http://www.yankodesign.com/2008/12/08/now-thats-a-grassy-phone/">Je-Hyun Kim’s Natural Year Phone</a> concept takes that into consideration. The phone is designed to naturally biodegrade after the two years are up.

  • Fujitsu Contest "Pebble" Concept Phone

    At first glance, <a href="http://www.engadget.com/2009/10/06/fujitsu-cellphone-design-contest-yields-mind-blowing-results-ha/">this entrant</a> into Fujitsu's cell phone design contest looks like an ordinary paperweight. Actually, it's a cleverly disguised phone. As the picture shows, the small black dot can be transformed into a keypad, media panel or web browser depending on what corner of the plastic handset you drag it to.

  • Mobile Script

    <a href="http://www.industrialdesignserved.com/Gallery/Concept-Phone-aoeMobile-Scripta/244692">Aleksander Mukomelov's "Mobile Script"</a> phone starts with a stylish and sleek small screen, then reveals a larger touchscreen hidden within the phone's body to meet all of your media device needs.

  • Visual Sound

    <a href="http://www.yankodesign.com/2010/01/25/deaf-phone/">Suhyun Kim's stylish "Visual Sound"</a> voice-to-text concept phone for deaf people is a huge step from current systems like teletypewriters.

  • Coca-Cola Powered Phone

    Forget solar power, electricity, or fuel: <a href="http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/01/10/coke-powered-cellphone-am_n_416839.html">Daizi Zheng's concept phone</a> is powered by Coca-Cola.

  • Wearable Terminal

    NTT DoCoMo's prototype "wearable terminal" brings us one step closer to being cyborgs. You stick your index finger in your ear to hear and speak through the microphone at the back of the wristband, then snap your fingers to connect or disconnect the call.

  • Pen Phone

    This <a href="http://gizmodo.com/320328/pen-phone-design-is-smallest-yet">pen phone</a> is one of the thinnest and smallest phone designs yet. While it's designed to be connected mainly via a bluetooth headset, the top and bottom of the phone do include a receiver and earpiece.

  • Nokia Flexible Concept Phone

    This Nokia concept is made of memory plastic that can be molded to fit around a wrist, for example, then can be heated to return to it's original shape.

  • Fujitsu Concept Phone

    A concept phone from Fujitsu's cellphone design contest.


Follow Ralph Nader on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Ralph_Nader