Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Romeo Saganash

GET UPDATES FROM Romeo Saganash
 

Harper's Hypocrites Could Learn a Lesson from First Nations

Posted: 06/28/2012 1:30 pm

In mid-June, Canadians celebrated National Aboriginal Day, a day when we come together to celebrate the contributions of First Nations, Inuit and Métis people to this country we call home. It is a chance to speak about our accomplishments, reflect on how far we have come, and think about how much further we still need to go.

With that in mind I spent part of my National Aboriginal Day in the House of Commons voting. We had only one vote on one bill, the second reading of bill C-27: "First Nations Fiscal Transparency Act." That may sound like a bad joke, but that is what the Conservatives chose to vote on that day.

I am not opposed to the concept of transparency, nor are the vast majority of First Nations leaders. But this bill is being imposed on First Nations without any consultation and runs against the Conservative own promises at the Crown First Nations Gathering to work together with First Nations. It does nothing to increase accountability of First Nations governments to their people and does nothing to help communities to become more accountable.

This bill will also gives the aboriginal affairs minister more power over First Nations communities, moving us further away from true self-government. It gives the minister the ability to withhold any funds to or terminate any funding agreement with a First Nation that doesn't meet their requirements. This is a harsh punishment that does nothing to help those First Nations citizens who depend on those funding arrangements for the of providing safe water, for keeping their schools operating and for paying social assistance for those who need it.

The great irony of this bill is that when passed, it will apply transparency standards that are greater than those for elected officials in many other jurisdictions. This is coming from the government that has done everything it can to avoid being transparent and accountable to Canadians.

In their 2006 election platform, the Conservatives promised to bring in a new era of transparency and accountability. They promised to: "Clean up the procurement of government contracts," "ensure truth in budgeting," and "strengthen auditing and accountability within departments."

Six years after making those promises, we can see just how they have faired. They promised to clean up government procurement, yet they deliberately kept Canadians in the dark about the true cost of the F-35 program. In April, the auditor general reported that the government misled Parliament over the cost of the F-35 program. According to his report, the Conservatives hid over $10 billion of the estimated cost of the jets from Parliament. That doesn't sound very accountable to me.

How about "ensuring truth in budgeting"? Well, before the last election we saw a censure motion that found them in contempt of Parliament for their refusal to disclose accurate costs of crime legislation, corporate tax cuts and the F-35s again. Now after the last election, they are refusing to give Parliament the details of job cuts to the civil service. Sadly we are not seeing very much "truth" in the budgeting there.

Finally, we have the promise to "Strengthen auditing and accountability within departments." Here we can point to the F-35s and the public service cuts again for this promise, but there are even more examples. We have the G8 Legacy Fund, which taught us that to the Conservatives, gazebos in Muskoka are an integral part of Canada's border defense. We can also point to Minister Oda and her insertion of the now famous "not" that defunded KAIROS. In all of these cases, not a single minister was punished.

With their record, I wonder why they think that they can start dictating to First Nations communities about transparency and accountability with any credibility. There are many chiefs and councils all across Canada that could teach these Conservatives a lot about how to be accountable and transparent to their electorate.

We have seen how the Conservatives' approach transparency when it applies to them. When they are expected to be transparent and accountable, they do everything they can to avoid it. They have refused to meet the most basic standards of accountability and transparency, yet they asked us, on National Aboriginal Day, to impose transparency standards on First Nations that are greater than the ones the Conservatives themselves refuse to meet. That is hypocritical and deeply insulting, but typical of the Harper Conservatives.

This government is in no position to speak to others about being accountable and wag their fingers judgmentally. When they learn how to be properly accountable to all Canadians, maybe then they can teach some lesson. But until then, maybe they should keep their word and start to work with Aboriginal communities. You never know; just like in the past they might even learn a thing or two from the First Peoples of this land.

 

Follow Romeo Saganash on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RomeoSaganash

FOLLOW CANADA
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
wetcoastm
Free Speech As Dictated By Our Sponsors
12:07 PM on 06/29/2012
Thank you for writing this it goes to the core of how this government treats every group that they perceive to be against them - with condescension.

We have seen time and time again that this government of frustrated wannabe victims lash out at everyone and every institution that Preston Manning and Tom Flanagan have told them to hate. They are miserable people who make completely inappropriate choices whenever they touch anything because they are guided by their emotions and not by reason.

Thank you for standing up for all Canadians, I am really impressed with all of the opposition MPs. It is too bad that we don't have a dozen courageous conservative backbenchers to stand with the rest of the country.

I hope by the time the next election is called the damage they are doing to the structure of the country can be undone.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Francmon
Homo homini lupus
11:22 PM on 06/28/2012
Have to agree with everything written here. But for utmost credibility, the First Nations MUST stay away from radical groups such as the Warriors, who sideline every effort First Nations leaders make to gain recognition. Warriors are to First Nations what Harper's gang are to democracy: a total disaster.
10:58 PM on 06/28/2012
To Harper and his ilk, "consulting" with First Nations means drafting condescending legislation and presenting it as a "solution" to the "Injun Problems".....There is such a wide disparity between the living standard of FN and non-FN but people refuse to see it.

It seems as though anti-"Injun" propaganda (usually from right-wing think tanks) is the last acceptable prejudice. I see it and hear it all the time because, although I am a Métis, I "look white" and "live white". But I have family members who live in Northern communities and the cost of basic items (like orange juice) are through the roof. You can throw out dollar figures that appear impressive at a glance, but when you consider what these amounts have to be used for, how many groups are in line for some of this money etc....you realize that it's not that much. Furthermore, a simple examination of the funding-per-student formula in Ontario shows that FN students receive LESS money than their non-FN counterparts. Who do we hold accountable for that?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
PAKALOLO
Hendrix deus est
10:49 PM on 06/28/2012
Just had milk come out my nose. Good one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
John David Payne
godisimaginary
10:47 PM on 06/28/2012
Regarding First Nations post by Mr Saganash., perhaps he can explain where the money goes. The money I am referring to are the funds that are meant to "assist" the individual members of the tribes all across the country. Vast amounts are taken for the comfort and enjoyment of a few at the top of the food chain...chiefs and councils. Where do they in this case the chiefs and councils get the idea that they are entitled to six figure and in some cases seven figure salaries for doing what??? When someone pays themselves over a million dollars a year to administer a few hundred residents someone has to speak up and ask what's going on. And keep in mind the golden rule...The guys with the gold always make the rules. Don't like it, get a job like the rest of us Canadians.
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
10:11 PM on 06/28/2012
Re: "...maybe they should keep their word..."

Yes, they should....but you, I, and everyone else knows they d^mn well won't.

The CONs don't know the meanings of integrity, honesty or trust.
09:08 PM on 06/28/2012
I don't recall who coined the term "supposi-Tories" but it seems fitting somehow. Harper and his crowd really do need to be run out of town on a rail.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Shahanshah
Liberalism is destroying western civilization
08:07 PM on 06/28/2012
you get more funding per capita than any province or group in the entire country...what are you complaining about??..
photo
Liz Wilson 2
“a small group can change the world
11:42 PM on 06/28/2012
Can you tell me how much per capita funding is provided to a FN community and how much is provided to an non-FN community?
05:08 PM on 06/29/2012
Not sure how much is provided to FN on a per capita basis but know of one instance where the band chief paid himself $160,000/year and his wife got paid in excess of $50,000/year to drive the schoolbus. This band was in Nova Scotia and its population was under 500, and yes they had housing problems as well.
In New Brunswick, a band council ran a deficit of over a million dollars in one year, this bad had the same population as Dieppe, N.B- the town had a surplus for the same period, a small one but a surplus.
02:07 PM on 06/29/2012
First nations people get, on average, $10,000 LESS in government spending on their needs than the average canadian. They are in fact supporting the rest of the country, especially considering the resources on their land.

http://media.knet.ca/node/11129

Hence the push behind the "Shannen's Dream" campaign, that simply asks that first nations youth get the same funding as non-first nations youth. It's absurd that would even be an issue, and yet it is.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
06:15 PM on 06/28/2012
Is someone dreaming? Asking the Harper regime for honesty in its dealings is like trusting a snake not to bite you. Romeo Sagnash must be reading fairy tales to have believed that a politician will point at himself rather than a patsy from the other groups. Just which world are you living in Mr. Sagnash? You had better come down of that pinnacle that you have been living in, and face the stark reality of any politician being honest. Because there is no such animal as an honest politician,.
photo
Another Pesky Canadian
Talk - action = 0
10:15 PM on 06/28/2012
Re: "Asking the Harper regime for honesty in its dealings is like trusting a snake not to bite you."

True.

Re: "...there is no such animal as an honest politician."

Not true. I believe in Elizabeth May's honesty, values and integrity. I am sure there are others as well...just not on the Government side of the House.
photo
Liz Wilson 2
“a small group can change the world
11:42 PM on 06/28/2012
Are you aware of the concept of venial sins and mortal sins?

That is the difference between some politician... like Trudeau's swear word compared to Oda's lie...both made in the house but I think we can find some actually honorable motivation behind Trudeau's comment... Oda on the other hand just plain lied. I would put Oda in a very different pile than I would put Trudeau

I agree with Another pesky Canadian about May, I think I would toss Chow into the mix, and I am pretty impressed by some of the newbies in the NDP party. I am also pretty confident that there are a lot of people with integrity in the liberal party.

No so sure about any of the conservative MPs .... while there may be some really good ones... they are all standing back and letting their government lie, cheat, steal, and act in contempt...so hard to find a good one in that mix.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kenneth T Tellis
11:00 AM on 06/29/2012
Integrity an the Liberal Party are poles apart. Time to stop reaming an face reality,
06:10 PM on 06/28/2012
"When they learn how to be properly accountable to all Canadians, maybe then they can teach some lesson." Indeed! ACCOUNTABILITY IN GOVERNANCE 101 is a lesson well worth waiting for, regardless of who ends up teaching it. Canadians have paid their hard-earned tuition for decades, and certainly deserve a qualified and conscientious teacher, but it appears the Harperites have cynically chosen to go on a long teacher's strike at the moment.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
05:52 PM on 06/28/2012
10,000 INAC employees, their salaries and benefits, $4 Billion. The other $4 Billions rest goes to the 1,172,790 First Nations citizens. Plain and simple truth.

Aboriginal Engagement

Aboriginal people are the fastest-growing population group in Canada, however this group is also among the most challenged when it comes to skills, training and integration into the domestic workforce.
By 2017, Aboriginal peoples are expected to represent more than 1.4 million or four per cent of the Canadian population.
Eight per cent of Aboriginal people aged 25-34 complete some form of higher education compared to twenty-eight per cent of non-Aboriginal Canadians.
Employment rates of Aboriginal people have dropped since 1996 and continue to do so in 44 per cent of First Nations communities.

http://www.cga-canada.org/en-ca/MediaCentre/Pages/ca_mdr_2007-05-29_backgrounder.aspx
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
05:52 PM on 06/28/2012
The Canadian Taxpayers Federation must now show reciprocal by disclosing to the Canadian public the entire and unredacted list of donors names, and amounts donated so they also can show some transparency and accountability which they demand from everyone and thei grandmothers....come on Kevin Gaudet, Colin Criag and Troy Lanigan, show us some transparency and accountability by releasing the list of over 17000 donors to the Canadian Taxpayers Federation....I wonder how many sitting Conservative MP names and big Oil CEO's names would appear on this list???
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
05:51 PM on 06/28/2012
http://www.sixnations.ca/2010AnnualReport.pdf

&

http://www.stolonation.bc.ca/about-us/documents/SN%20Annual%20Report%2009-10.pdf

newsetter of Certified General Accountants Assoc. of Canada

"CONSIDERING SOCIAL NEEDS

Both aboriginal leaders and government officials concede that there is a wide disparity in the way finances are managed by the 633 individual First Nations across Canada. But, some argue that, even though funds are sometimes reallocated within certain native communities, that doesn't necessarily imply financial mismanagement.

"In some cases what is viewed as mismanagement is just some chiefs who are so hard-pressed to try and meet the needs of their community, they redirect assigned funds to try and meet what are perceived to be more immediate social needs," says Jean LaRose, media relations adviser for the Assembly of First Nations (AFN), a national organization that represents First Nations across Canada (see "AFN: Fighting for a Unified Voice").

And many of these social needs are urgent. According to DIAND statistics, the average annual income for persons living on native reserves in 1997 was only $9,000.

Furthermore, about half of the approximately 78,000 homes located on reserve were considered in a state of disrepair, while 11% were considered overcrowded. "

http://www.cga-canada.org/en-ca/AboutCGACanada/CGAMagazine/1998/November/Pages/ca_1998_11_ft2.aspx

& lastly

http://www.keyband.com/pdfs/Financial_Act_reformatted.pdf
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
05:51 PM on 06/28/2012
How can the Canadian Taxpayer’s Federation justify comparing First Nations salary and travel expenses to the Prime Minister’s salary alone?

“It’s an unfair assumption. What is jaw dropping is that our Chief and Councils can serve for years in their community and do not receive benefits/pensions once their term has expired. Unlike, MP’s and MLA’s who receive lifetime benefits for their services.

22.5% of First Nations leaders make less than $25,000 a year, 33% make less than $40,000 a year and only 7.1% are making over $100,000 a year.

The report focuses on 7% of more than 3,300 First Nation elected officials across Canada.

The Canadian Taxpayer’s Federation is a lobbying group. They should be promoting harmony instead of giving misleading information and widening the gap between First Nations and non First Nations people.
Donna Meness
www.findmaisyandshannon.com
05:50 PM on 06/28/2012
"Figures don't lie, but liars can figure," said Grand Chief Doug Kelly.
*********************************************************************************

Words that'd make John Kelly proud..

see: Ink Lake : We are all in the Ojibway Circle

Who'd of imagine a Canadian taxpayers organization "padding" it's reports..sigh

Kitigan Zibi Activity and Audit Reports
Audit Reports

http://www.kza.qc.ca/aar.php

&

http://www.kza.qc.ca/assets/aar/KZ_AuditReport2009_2010.pdf