Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Roya Boroumand

GET UPDATES FROM Roya Boroumand
 

Invisible Iranians

Posted: 09/30/11 04:20 PM ET

Some days I yearn for the time when there was no Internet and information about tragic events was hard to verify and slow to reach us. We were disheartened for sure and truly powerless, but today, being well informed does not necessarily empower us.

In the communication age, news may travel fast, it may even trigger interest in a case of human rights violation when it is not competing with news about the Islamic Republic's nuclear ambitions or when the victims are well-known or treated with exceptional cruelty ( in the case of stoning for example), but it is much harder to draw media attention to the ordinary people who constitute the pillars of resistance under any oppressive government and whose refusal to submit is most severely punished as they are unknown and thus invisible.

The White House drew valuable and welcome attention to Iran's decision to execute a Christian pastor for his refusal to convert to Islam. But there are so many more...

Yesterday, I froze in front of my laptop screen, staring at the news of the suicide of a young woman, Nahal Sahabi, in Tehran. Nahal is one of the many young Iranians who find the present unbearable and the future too uncertain to be worth living for. We know of her suicide because she was the girlfriend of the 22-year-old, Behnam Ganji, who committed suicide on Sept. 1, 2011.

Behnam, as I understand from a relative who knew him well, was an optimistic and sensitive young man. He had plans for his future and was enthusiastically cleaning and painting the house that he was going to live in. No one really knows why he decided to end his life. All we know is that his suicide happened three weeks after his release from the infamous Evin Prison in Tehran. Behnam was neither a human rights activist nor a dissident. But these details do not matter in Iran these days. He had the bad luck of being present on July 31, 2011 when plainclothes agents came to arrest his roommate, Kouhyar Goudarzi, a 25-year-old human rights activist. Behnam is one of many ordinary Iranian citizens who become collateral damage every year in the authorities' persecution of dissidents and remain invisible to the world.

Behanm left behind a video in which he clearly stated that he had lost faith in the worthiness of life, and sent an angry message to the police reminding them that "they are looking for nothing" and they "will find nothing." So, what could have happened in Evin to have led to Behnam's suicide and eventually to that of the woman who loved him? Why is it that the third person who was arrested with Kouhyar and Behnam has turned off her cell phone and is not responding to friends since she was released on Aug. 7? Most importantly, why has no one, including Kouhyar's lawyer, been able to see him or talk to him since his arrest? Why are the authorities unclear about where he is and who is holding him?

Kouhyar's arrest didn't come as a surprise. His activism and persistence in calling for the respect of human rights had, since 2006, led to repeated arrests. He spent a year in prison before being released in December 2010 and being expelled from his university. Unlike Kouhyar, Behnam had not been warned about his activities. He was taken along because he was a witness. He was detained and interrogated for more than a week so that he fully understood the danger and would not spread the news. Behnam remained quiet after his release. Kouhyar's mother was also prevented from talking. She was arrested on Aug. 1 in her home town, Mashad (Khorassan Province). According to the Committee of Human Rights Reporters, Kouhyar's group, her charge, "disturbing public order" and "acting against national security," are related to interviews she gave during her son's previous imprisonment. Her trial has already taken place behind closed doors.

So the news matters and we can play a role by making the information available. But our efforts will not have the necessary impact without international support and visibility in the media. As Iranian activists were discussing ways to draw attention to the fact that no one has heard from Kouhyar in two months or about the suicide of his friends, it became clear that none of the actions they considered: posters on the web, web campaigns, actions in Dupont Circle, a sit-in in front of the Washington Post offices, would guarantee coverage by the mainstream media.

To those of us who are familiar with repressive regimes, the equation is simple. Every time a dissident's mother or lawyer is arrested, scores of others' mothers and lawyers are deterred and will remain silent or refuse to follow-up on political cases. We are still getting new names of young people who were killed in 2009, but whose parents had not dared to publicize the news. International support and media interest provide a safe space for people who resist and encourages others to join them. Nothing is as demobilizing for those who fight with tyranny as being invisible or forgotten. What determines political developments in a closed country does not necessarily happen in front of the cameras with tanks rolling over protesters. The most important struggle is a long term fight to be heard and the psychological warfare between the persecuted and the persecutors. The latter's strength lies in their ability to convince those they persecute that the world doesn't hear them and that they are irrelevant.

In the summer of 1988, for example, the news of the secret mass killing in Iranian prisons reached us months after several thousand young men and women were secretly hanged and buried. Their main crime was to refuse to submit to the official ideology in spite of years of harsh treatment in Iranian prisons. They were unknown to most of us and to the outside world. They were invisible. Their death was barely noticed and quickly forgotten. In July, 1999, thousands of students came out in the streets to protest a brutal attack on their dormitories. These were for the most part unknown ordinary young Iranians. They were brutally repressed and the world forgot them once they were removed from public view. In their case however, the new means of communication may have had a role in preventing mass executions.

Since 1999, thousands of students have been arrested, tortured, suspended or expelled from their universities for doing what every student does here in the United States. Some died in prison, some were forced into exile, and many more are held hostage with high bail amounts or suspended prison sentences. The pattern was the same, following the well-covered 2009 post-electoral protests. This time however, the prison sentences were much longer and not suspended, and instead of having scores of refugees leave Iran, we are facing a flow of refugees. In each case, many were caught because they were at the wrong place at the wrong time and, like Behnam, they became collateral damage. We can't draw attention to them because they are not well-known and they are deemed irrelevant.

Understandably, there is much to cover around the world and we cannot expect every human rights violation in Iran to get visibility outside Iran. As activists discussed what the "news hook" would be in the case of Kouhyar's disappearance and Behnam death, one person suggested the recent suicide of the women who was in love with Behnam. Of course this would be newsworthy if it had happened here in the United States. Those who cover government policies, police brutality, or legal issues in the United States are well aware that the arrest of an ACLU activist for example or the suicide of a person following a week of interrogation may be relevant to their work. However, when it comes to covering other countries, this logic gets lost in a maze of analysis about what is relevant and what is not, in which in spite of years of observation many of us are still lost.

 
Some days I yearn for the time when there was no Internet and information about tragic events was hard to verify and slow to reach us. We were disheartened for sure and truly powerless, but today, bei...
Some days I yearn for the time when there was no Internet and information about tragic events was hard to verify and slow to reach us. We were disheartened for sure and truly powerless, but today, bei...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 70
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:06 PM on 10/04/2011
This is a huge concern. This Iranian Pastor has done no wrong. Please note that Christians & Jews are being specifically targeted by Arab Governments and extremists. There is no freedom of religion, justice or equality under Sharia Law for neither muslim and especially non - muslim (christians and jews). The christians in the arab world (iraq & egypt) are suffering, with increasing attacks on their houses, businesses, churches, clergy, converts, girls & women. There are thousands of victims, as a result of these human rights violations. Islamic Sharia Law is evil and oppresses humanity. Steal and your hand is cut off, stoning for women committing adultry, converts out of Islam sentenced to death, beating of women accepted as disciplinary action and the list goes on. 20 March 20 2011- A group of Muslim extremists attacked Ayman Anwar Mitri, a 45 year old Christian Coptic man in the Upper Egyptian town of Qena (Egypt), cutting off his ear. The muslim extremists claimed they were applying Sharia law because he was allegedly framed of having an affair with a muslim woman. They also made a 10cm cut at the back of his neck, cut his other ear, his face and his arm. Mr. Mitri said they wanted to throw him off the fifth floor. The muslim extremists called the police and told them “We have applied the law of Allah, now come and apply your law,” according to Mr. Mitri in an interview for the Egyptian Human Rights Organization.
04:15 PM on 10/03/2011
Millions dead and displaced over the past 10 years, and there are no pictures of them, no comical violin playing for them.

They look hard and they find 2 people in Iran, and it's all over the net.
photo
grizzly bear55
King of the forest
08:14 AM on 10/03/2011
This the price of evolution.

First they kicked the shah out and brought the religious fanatics and once they had to live by their principals, they changed their mind.

The problem is there are too many spies in Iran and to be sure who is and who is not, the state has to use an Iron fist.

The best advice is to stay clear of any demonstrations and social media if you want to have a happy life.

The Persian empire was not known to treat people with a velvet glove.

Today Iran is facing the West European block and the US plus their enemy Israel who is killing their Scientists with the help of locals who the regime is trying to catch.

These traitors would become INVISIBLE and will pay the price for betraying their country regardless what their motives are.

I am not a fan of Iran, but I do not tolerate traitors.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
anugs
12:14 PM on 10/04/2011
Sure sounds like you're a fan of Iran, and a hater of Israel.
12:18 PM on 10/05/2011
It seems that you agree with the current practice in Iran's judicial system: everyone is guilty until proven innocent. It is not really fair to say: "The best advice is to stay clear of any demonstrat­ions and social media if you want to have a happy life." for others when you are not staying away from the social media and your are easily posting your views and opposition to anything you don't like.
04:03 AM on 10/03/2011
"invisible"

Yet this story is all over the internet, and in almost every site, and simultaneously. How many more of these stories are backed by the NATIONAL ENDOWMENT FOR DEMOCRACY, the organization dedicated to overthrow of other regimes?
photo
fairwayhill
1948 Palestine belongs to the Palestinians
02:15 PM on 10/02/2011
It is time to overthrow the US supported dictatorsh­­ips of Yemen, Bahrain, Kuwait, Oman, Saudi Arabia and Jordan. Iran has the right to have nuclear weapons to defend itself against its nuclear enemies threatenin­g Iran with war.
03:15 PM on 10/02/2011
fairwayhill thinks "Iran has the right to have nuclear weapons ..."
fairwayhill, you wouldn't be Iranian by any chance, would you?

I ask because nobody ELSE thinks it would be good if the mad, misogynist, murdering mullahs of Iran obtained nuclear weapons.

"enemies threatening Iran with war"? Ahem, it's Iran that doing all the threatening.
Just yesterday, the main Mad Mullah of Iran threatened genocide once again:

" Khamenei, who spoke at a pro-Palestinian conference in Tehran, called Israel a “cancerous tumor” that should be removed. "

See http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/middle-east/irans-supreme-leader-lambasts-two-state-solution-for-palestinians-and-israel/2011/10/01/gIQArxazBL_story.html

In Iran, many women every every year are stoned to death (or hanged if they're lucky) for the "crime" of having consensual sex with a man.

Is this the regime that you support?
03:23 PM on 10/02/2011
You don't happen to be Israeli are you?
03:56 AM on 10/02/2011
The author is the Executive Director of her own person foundation. That is supposed to bring her credibility. I too am the Executive Director of Leutenizer Banned Twice foundation and you should listen to me because that means something somewhere I am sure.
11:56 AM on 10/02/2011
Not sure what you're talking about. "The Abdorrahman Boroumand Foundation receives approximately 50% of its support from private U.S. foundations, 34% of its support from private European foundations, and 16% of its funding from the National Endowment for Democracy (NED)"

http://www.iranrights.org/english/foundation.php

Show us *your* website and funding summary.
photo
Wozzeck
Pearl Bay, Australia
01:40 PM on 10/02/2011
National Endowment for Democracy:
"A lot of what we [NED] do was done 25 years ago covertly by the CIA"
Alan Weinstein, one of the founders of the NED

http://sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=National_Endowment_for_Democracy
08:41 PM on 10/02/2011
She doesn't like Iranian government because her father was killed by Iranian government agents, so she will do anything to take her revenge. Human rights excuses, nuclear excuse, anything to overthrow the government of Iran and any money from Israeli supporting groups in the US will do. This is the true fact.
photo
MikeCm
Occupy Reality
12:18 AM on 10/02/2011
"...there is much to cover around the world and we cannot expect every human rights violation in Iran to get visibility outside Iran...."

Yes, and if journalists spent as much time and energy on human rights issues here at home it might actually do some good.

Pointing the moral outrage finger at other countries is self serving and distracts from problems at home. It creates the misperception that there are are no human rights issues in the US or Canada. Besides, there's plenty being said about Iran's record. In fact, the US and Canada never miss an opportunity to point out Iran's human rights record on the world's stage. That and Iran's WMD threat, presumably building a case for future invasion.

Of course, The US Gov fails to remind us that 58 years ago Iran was a democratic republic with a democratically elected, parliamentary government. This situation was intolerable to the US and UK so in a now declassified coup d'etat known as the TPAJAX Project, the US gov overthrew that democratically elected government and installed the brutal dictator Pahlavi (aka "The Shah"). The Shah favored US oil interests and purchased arms from US defense contractors in order to keep the population suppressed.

I'm not sure why HuffPost Canada comes out wth indignant human rights articles about Iran, unless this is the Canadian way of slowly building the case for invasion. Here in the US we do things the old fashioned way; our government simply lies.
04:01 PM on 10/01/2011
The ability to take a tragedy of two young human beings and turn them into some political non.sense is amazing. Who knows why Behnam had a suicide. On the other hand, Nahal's suicide is due to being depressed. No one other than her family and loved one should be blamed for not looking after her.

Depression is common everywhere. In August of a this year two people I knew of, in the US committed suicide. Both on the surface had nothing wrong in their lives. One of them in his thirties with a wife and a kid, was apparently depressed and taking medications. Few days earlier he was arrested for driving under influence. In this lady's book Should we blame the state of Louisiana or mothers against driving?
04:09 PM on 10/01/2011
I should have said "mothers against drunk driving".
TORSTEN HUSVEDT
I luvs my ellipsii..........
08:34 PM on 10/01/2011
Maybe.
photo
GohBokhor
www.ifamericansknew.org
02:59 PM on 10/01/2011
Emotional pleas sans evidence don't justify sanctions that hurt the Iranian people or the war-like, militaristic stance our country has exhibited against Iran with a FACADE of diplomacy.
09:36 PM on 10/01/2011
And what evidence support your doubts? How about seeing this just as what it is: an effort to get information on someone who was arbitrarily arrested and from whom no one has heard in more than two months? Of course, one could have called his mother, had she not be arrested! One could also had talked with his lawyer but authorities are not giving her access. Are all the organizations below making statements without evidence to encourage war with Iran? Or perhaps, the violence against Iranian citizens is irrelevant in the political equation here in the US!
http://www.hrw.org/news/2011/09/19/iran-charge-or-release-rights-activist
http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/asset/MDE13/087/2011/en/25317220-c315-4fbd-871a-a07349387ea4/mde130872011en.html
http://gerknevis.blogspot.com/2011/08/still-no-news-of-kouhyar-goudarzi.html
http://www.frontlinedefenders.org/node/15899
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce banned
Never let them tell you it can't be done.
09:48 PM on 10/01/2011
Of course, if the US government based its sanctions policies on evidence, the numerous HRW, Amnesty International, and even Red Cross reports about what Israel does would make it subject to arms embargoes, trade sanctions, and all the rest. (And Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait, and Jordan would be sanctioned too)
photo
GohBokhor
www.ifamericansknew.org
10:01 PM on 10/01/2011
WMDS in Saddam's Iraq, the Kuwaiti Ambassador's daughter testifying before a Senate Commission prior to the first Persian Gulf War that Iraqi soldiers were taking Kuwaiti babies out of incubators in hospitals (found out to be a lie and a false justification to get us in there), Gulf of Tonkin, Gaddafi news stories about his troops "mass raping using Viagra", politicians pretending like Ahmadinejad actually said "Wipe Israel off the Map" and more.

You can show me all you want about these second-hand reports, The truth is, Amnesty has NO ear to the ground in Iran and gets told lies by expatriates with ulterior motives.

Also, there are terrorists working with some politicians as highlighted here on HP from the NCRI / MEK under Maryam Rajavi.
photo
GohBokhor
www.ifamericansknew.org
02:58 PM on 10/01/2011
No way to verify any of these stories.

Reminds me of the Kuwaiti Ambassador's daughter lying about Iraqi soldiers ripping Kuwaiti babies out of incubators.

Still doesn't justify sanctions or war against Iran, even if true.
09:38 PM on 10/01/2011
There are ways to verify these stories for those who care enough to try!
http://www­.hrw.org/n­ews/2011/0­9/19/iran-­charge-or-­release-ri­ghts-activ­ist
http://www­.amnesty.o­rg/en/libr­ary/asset/­MDE13/087/­2011/en/25­317220-c31­5-4fbd-871­a-a0734938­7ea4/mde13­0872011en.­html
http://ger­knevis.blo­gspot.com/­2011/08/st­ill-no-new­s-of-kouhy­ar-goudarz­i.html
http://www­.frontline­defenders.­org/node/1­5899
photo
GohBokhor
www.ifamericansknew.org
10:03 PM on 10/01/2011
That's hardly verification. Those are links to additional re-tellings of the same story. Nice try. You wouldn't know Maryam Rajavi would you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sloyd
Return to original Republicanism to save America
02:52 PM on 10/01/2011
"Iranian Christian pastor accused of 'apostasy' must be released"

http://www.amnestyusa.org/news/news-item/iranian-christian-pastor-accused-of-apostasy-must-be-released
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:10 PM on 10/01/2011
Very well said. This is such a sad situation I can only imagine the depression in Iran. This regime will not change, therefore, when the time is right, the people must change it.
photo
Jelle NL
Unity in Diversity
12:20 PM on 10/01/2011
Imagine the prosperity of Iran, the high standing of Islam, and the growth of the global Muslim community, should the ayatollahs succeed in combining the Qur'an with Democracy and Human Rights.
08:56 PM on 09/30/2011
So sad goes the story though I can hardly believe it.
06:16 PM on 09/30/2011
I can't beleive, a headline and 2 blogs about this guy, whose life was never in danger. If he is an Assyrian Christian, then not only he has the same rights as any Iranian and is protected as a minority under the law, he even gets to buy and drink alcohol legaly instead of black-market like rest of the Iranians.
07:18 PM on 09/30/2011
From what I've learned, his conversion is the issue, not his faith per se.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Richard Pearce banned
Never let them tell you it can't be done.
09:41 AM on 10/01/2011
How do you make 60 million Iranians invisible?

Ignore them, and make sure the only stories that get told involve a couple of thousand ones, at most.

PS, if all you heard about the US justice and police systems were stories about people like Troy Davis and Anthony Bologna, you'd believe the American government was extremely repressive and oppressive. And stories about the protests against the building of Mosques, the attacks on them, and all the rest of the Islamophobia that a certain type promotes would also convince you that it was religiously intolerant, too.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Khirad
09:34 PM on 10/01/2011
False equivalency straw man par excellence. But of course, two wrongs don't make a right.

At least I'm consistent on those issues.
10:09 PM on 10/01/2011
Why is always about the US? I wish once every now and then, some concerned and well-wishing Americans were able to think about other people's concern and remember that talking about violence elsewhere is not a justification of the wrong that happens in the US. It is not always about the US!

a couple of thousand???? Where do you get the statistics? You have access to Iranian prison archives perhaps? The Iranian prison authorities admit themselves that last year close to 800,000 people were detained in Iranian prisons. During a week of protests, at least 10,000 people were arrested, according to official sources. The law does not entitle Iranians to have an attorney during interrogations and until they are charged.
Please have a look at the UNHCR reports on the number of asylum seekers from Iran. Just for last year.
PS. What happened to Troy Davis was terribly wrong. One execution is one too many.That is why executions should not occur anywhere. I am glad that Tory Davis mother was not arrested and his lawyer had access to him and to his file. Otherwise, we wouldn't know about his case.The percentage of executions per capita is much higher in Iran than in the US and the likelihood of mistakes much higher as well considering the fact that the presumption of innocence is a joke and the judiciary is accountable to no one but the Spiritual Leader.