Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hot on the Blog
Raffi Cavoukian
Samantha Kemp-Jackson

GET UPDATES FROM Samantha Kemp-Jackson
 

Why We Shouldn't Force Our Kids Into Sports

Posted: 02/04/2013 5:11 pm

Kids and sports -- if you're a parent you know that it's just a matter of time before you address the topic. It doesn't matter if your child is a boy or a girl, the question hovers over their heads nonetheless. Will they play sports? What sports do they like? Will they excel?

Now, you may have noticed that I didn't ask the question, "What if they don't want to play sports," because, for the most part, it doesn't really matter. Whether your child is the next Super Bowl star of more of the bookish type, the penchant for folks to ask "what sport will he/she be taking" won't diminish. It seems that the millennium has brought on the expectation that parents will automatically enrol their kids into their (the parents') sport of choice -- or else.

Once the domain of hockey parents and soccer moms alone, being a "sports parent" has extended beyond a specific few. Now, we expect children to be enrolled, engaged and excited about the opportunity to participate in our society's sports culture. Having a junior athlete is de rigueur amongst the parenting crowd these days.

Yet, like any cross-section of any large populous, children are no different. Children range in not only personality types but interests as well. And still it happens that sports as a pursuit is expected, regardless of a child's personal wishes.

BLOG CONTINUES AFTER SLIDESHOW

Loading Slideshow...
  • Do Your Homework

    <a href="http://www.dummies.com/store/product/Coaching-Kids-For-Dummies.productCd-0764551973.html" target="_hplink">Read Coaching Kids for Dummies</a>. There’s no shame in admitting you’re a ‘Dummy.’ Starting with the very basics will give you a good sense of everything you’ll be dealing with, from fostering skills and promoting good sportsmanship to preventing burnout and dealing with irate parents.

  • Know The Rules

    Check out <a href="http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/family/coach-your-own-child.htm" target="_hplink">TLC’s comprehensive online guide</a> to coaching your own child. It offers valuable advice about details that could be easy to overlook if you get caught up in the big picture – like making sure you’re familiar with the proper rules of play and determining if your kid even wants you to coach her team in the first place.

  • Understand The Importance Of Role Playing

    Be sure to separate your ‘parent’ and ‘coach’ roles. Psychology professor Shari Kuchenbecker recommends using a ‘Two Hat’ trick in her article <a href="http://www.momsteam.com/team-parents/coaching/coaching-your-own-child/attitude-objectivity-preparation-keys" target="_hplink">Coaching Your Own Child: Attitude, Objectivity and Preparation are Keys</a>. The trick can be as simple as stating that you’re taking off your ‘Coach’ hat and are now speaking with your ‘Mom’ or ‘Dad’ hat on after the game. With your parent hat on, you can even refer to your ‘coach’ self in the third person to replay the game from a supportive parent’s perspective.

  • The Team Comes First

    Remember your end goal is to do what’s best for the team – not ensure that your kid is the next Sidney Crosby or Mia Hamm. <a href="http://tlc.howstuffworks.com/family/coach-your-own-child1.htm" target="_hplink">TLC</a> warns that if you’re grooming your child to be a star athlete, you really shouldn’t be coaching her. After all, if your eye is on that kind of prize, how could you possibly be objective when you’re assigning positions and setting starting lineups?

  • No Favouritism

    Avoid treating your child differently from teammates – either by showing favouritism, or by being overly harsh to demonstrate that you’re not giving her preferential treatment. The article<a href="http://www.dummies.com/how-to/content/balancing-parenting-and-coaching.html" target="_hplink"> Balancing Parenting and Coaching – for Dummies</a> points out that showing favouritism can cause teammates to resent your child, and ultimately make her a pariah on the team. Being extra hard on her, on the other hand, can cause her to resent you and potentially set back her progress if you’re treating her unfairly. <a href="http://www.momsteam.com/team-parents/coaching/coaching-your-own-child/attitude-objectivity-preparation-keys" target="_hplink">Kuchenbecker</a> recommends giving equal advice to everyone based on “observable actions” to avoid paying too much attention to your own child.


So what does this presupposition do to our kids, one has to wonder? For the children who have a propensity to kick that ball with vigour, for those would-be Beckhams, it's a win-win situation. The parents get to live out any vicarious fantasies that they may have, stemming from youthful sporting pursuits yet unrealized; the child gets to bask in the glory of the thrill of victory as well the gleam in their parents' eyes. The darker side to this reality, however, is the ongoing feelings of anxiety, stress and inadequacy felt by those children who may not have the desire or ability to become the next Olympic gold medal winner. For these children, just the mere spectre of competition within the athletic realm is enough to make them quake in their boots. This because all children are not created equal, despite all of us being told otherwise.

No, all children are not equal. Some of them are natural athletes, excelling at any given team or individual sport with ease. Some may have the artistic aplomb to become the next Picasso or Rembrandt, if given the nurturing, love and support required to succeed. It is these children of whom we should be particularly interested -- and concerned. Because as many children that there are realizing their dreams of achieving a magnificent touchdown and leading their team to victory, there are just as many kids as equally talented, but not within the sphere of sports. It is this group of children that need to be remembered, before they are signed up for an activity that has the ability to leave them quaking in their newly-purchased Nike running shoes.

For these are the children that bear the brunt of our desires, who are catapulted into a world that they dread to appease our own vicarious longings. It is this group of unfortunate young ones that have to walk the walk -- or run the track -- in order to satisfy their parents' expectations. Is this fair?

Ask any dad sitting in the stands at a hockey game why he's there. Ask any mother shouting encouragement to their daughter from the sidelines at the soccer game why she's there. Ask both of them whether or not they've gone into debt just to finance their dreams of fame and fortune for their child. The answer to the last question may be yes or no, however I guarantee that the answer to the first two will be the same: Because they want their child to learn about teamwork, excel at an activity and perhaps have fun in the process. That's right -- they want their child to do all of these things. It's often not the child's choice.

Stage parents and hockey parents: are there really any differences between the two? We loathe the stereotype of the pushy, self-serving "stage mom" yet we seem to have no problem at all with the parent who pushes their child to excel at sports at any cost. Why? Are we so enamoured, so inculcated with the idea of sports that we've lost our collective abilities to separate the wheat from the chaff?

Our culture reveres sports stars, elevating them to the status of heroes, often just because they've exhibited athletic prowess. While this feat may indeed be notable, is it really that important in the larger scheme of things? What does it say about us as a society when we pay athletes millions of dollars per year to hit or kick a ball around, yet charities continue to flounder due to lack of funds and support?

We tell our children to follow their dreams, that we will support them in anything they do and that they can be anything they want to be. Yet so many of us impose strict parameters on their extra-curricular activities if they don't involve sports. You see, art classes and piano lessons are all well and good, but don't even think about dropping out of Little League. No, that would be too traumatic for mom or dad.

And in these instances, the message that we're sending to our children is loud and clear: we want you to excel at sports, so you'd better do it. We want to see you become an athletic star, regardless of your interest (and often skill level). We want to finally realize that long-standing dream of hearing the roar of the crowds, experiencing the adoration of the fans and seeing the dollars on the bank statement, even if we didn't earn it. If it's for our kids, that's close enough, right?

"Do as I say, not as I do" is the message that we're teaching our children. This is a direct contradiction of the other messages that we tell them, that they can be anything that they want to be and that they should follow their dreams. Is this fair?

As much as we strive to be the loving and supportive mother and father that we would like to be, our more egotistical and narcissistic need for adulation too often supersedes any semblance of reason -- or fairness, for that matter.

Until we let go of our collective dreams of athletic super-stardom, of touchdowns and home runs, we will continue to negatively affect our children's psyches, despite our desire to do otherwise. So next time little Connor asks to take art lessons, hold your tongue, smile and run out and buy him a paint brush. You'll be glad that you did.

 

Follow Samantha Kemp-Jackson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@samkj27

FOLLOW CANADA LIVING
Kids and sports -- if you're a parent you know that it's just a matter of time before you address the topic. It doesn't matter if your child is a boy or a girl, the question hovers over their heads no...
Kids and sports -- if you're a parent you know that it's just a matter of time before you address the topic. It doesn't matter if your child is a boy or a girl, the question hovers over their heads no...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 25
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:39 PM on 02/05/2013
While I agree with your premise - don't force a kid into an extracurricular activity he hates (and that would include my own futile years of piano lessons), I just don't see what you are talking about with the families I know. Is there really an epidemic of parents forcing clumsy unathletic kids to play sports in the hope they will be the next Michael Jordan or Mia Hamm? Most kids love sports - whether at a super competative club level or just "rec", "everybody plays" teams. Some who don't like team sports might love individual sports like swimming or tennis. I don't think there is anything wrong with parents encouraging kids to try different things - sports, art, music, theater - try all of it, see what the kid likes and is good at. But forcing a child like my daughter to keep taking art classes when she doesn't have an artistic bone in her body and denying her what she loves, running on a field kicking a soccer ball, would be just as cruel as what this article is saying.
Plus, while there are crazy sports parents, the vast majority aren't in it because they have dreams of professional superstardom for their kids. Contrary to the negative spin of this article, sports are good for most kids, for so many reasons: health, teamwork, camraderie, friendship, self esteem, goal setting, rule following, learning to win and lose graciously . . .
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
07:48 PM on 02/08/2013
Unfortunately there ARE parents who continue to push their kids into sports against the kids' wills. "Encouraging" a child is one thing and yes - parents should lovingly encourage their children to try a wide variety of activities. The problem occurs when it is no longer (or never was) fun for the child and the parent refuses to listen. At that point, it becomes about the parent, not the child.
photo
VA Jill
I'm not perfect and neither are you
03:11 PM on 02/05/2013
There is a sport for every child. Not all are team sports and not all are necessarily competitive. If your child doesn't want to play a team sport, try steering him/her toward such things as riding, skating, swimming, or even dance (yes, that is quite athletic!) but just for the fun of it. Most kids are kind of competitive with themselves once they find something they like.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
09:58 AM on 02/09/2013
I couldn't agree more. It's the competitive aspect that doesn't sit right with some kids and these children should be encouraged to participate in physical fitness activities that don't have the competitive factor of team sports. If kids were given more options that took into account their individual strengths, it would make a huge difference in the long run.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CoachNelly2
02:51 PM on 02/05/2013
I see both sides of the argument here. I definitely have coached kids whose parents obviously want their child to be FAR better at volleyball than Susie has any desire to be. But from a public school perspective, those parents are few and far between and most parents are just happy their child is on the team and having a good time.

Select sports is a whole different ballgame because the parents are PAYING for their child to be on the team and there is this "input-output" mentality - you gotta get what you're paying for. That's where you're going to see the burn-out at a young age. But again, most of my 7th and 8th graders are JUST getting into playing volleyball and playing on a club team is super new and exciting.

There are obviously wonderful things to learn from being part of a team but none of which can't be learned elsewhere if your child isn't into playing sports.
04:11 AM on 02/05/2013
I agree that children need exercise, but why does it have to be sports? I hated, dreaded and loathed gym class from kindergarten through grade 10 because I was clumsy, uncoordinated and unpopular -- all in all, a bad combination for any kind of team sport. What about going for a walk? What about dropping by the local pool for a swim? Why does it have to be organized and be part of a team?

When I was a child and teen what I enjoyed was going to the skating rink, the swimming pool and the roller rink with a friend or two. I enjoyed borrowing the neighbour's dog and going for a walk around the neighbourhood. I never played any sports that I wasn't required to play in gym class, but I still got my exercise.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
10:01 AM on 02/05/2013
Agreed. Not every child is an athlete and many have absolutely no interest in team sports. Yet they are often pushed into them by their parents in the hopes that the child will learn to like it and in some cases become rich and famous as a result. All of us as parents have a responsibility to rein in our own expectations of our kids in order to fulfill what the children really want. It's a hard thing to do but we will all be better for it.
11:37 PM on 02/04/2013
Of course kids should not be forced into sports, competitive or otherwise, but I have to agree with the poster below who advocated a "testing" phase. The general advice would be to follow your kid's interests in spite of your own. There are so many activities that don't require competition and they are being actively taught in schools. Parents, I agree, can be too pushy to notice the negative effects of their own dreams and desires on their kids. The pressure to impress mom or dad can be destructive, especially if the kid is easily frustrated. Some will say this is a skill that must be learned (I agree) but not in such a pressurized manner!

I take issue with the negative spin you place on sports because they can and are overwhelmingly positive. They can be fun and they do teach certain character traits not easily taught elsewhere. But also, sports are positive for health and development, even if kids don't take it to the next level. There can be harm in letting your kid not do physical activity. There is a reason P.E. is still a requirement in schools.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
09:50 AM on 02/09/2013
Sorry that you feel that my spin on sports is negative because I do believe that for some kids, this activity can be fulfilling, fun and a learning experience. For these kids, they should absolutely be encouraged to keep up with their activities. It's the kids that do not want to be in sports but are kept there at the parents' insistence that I have a problem with. We've all seen it. Physical fitness is indeed important and should be facilitated by both schools and parents, but this doesn't necessarily mean via competitive team sports. There are just as many activities that kids can do such as hiking, walking, running, etc. that don't have the competitive element that some kids find problematic. If we gave the kids who don't want to participate in team sports these options, they'd likely excel.
09:38 PM on 02/04/2013
If sports activities could be something that kids did because it's fun for fun's sake, I'd be all for it. Our culture has decided that kids need to play sports and parents--if they're supportive--need to be at every practice and game, sacrifice their weekends, and blow their bank accounts to finance "travel team" expenses. The days of a pickup game of ball in the yard, and fun for fun's sake, have been sacrificed for the team sport phenomenon. No thanks.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
09:52 AM on 02/09/2013
Exactly - I couldn't agree more. If it's just for fun, then fine; if it's for competitive reasons, then we have to be sure that the child really wants to be there and is not just going along with it for the sake of their parents dreams. It should be all about the kid's wants, not the parents.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:35 PM on 02/04/2013
Physical activity should be required of kids. The body affects the mind, the mind the body. Everyone should experience the connection on feels when the body is working hard. By working hard we destroy the preconceived notions of what is possible, not just in physical activity, but other areas as well.

We almost all can be pretty good at some physical activity. Parents need to look further afield than team sports to find something that their child will appreciate. Far too much emphasis is placed on external competition as opposed to what we learn when we take on challenges. Kids need to be encouraged to take on challenges and place so called failure in its proper context. A few extremely gifted people will become world beaters. The rest of us will have to content with a high level of competence and a decent legacy as a result of a bit of talent and a lot of hard work.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:55 AM on 02/05/2013
Excuse me? You can bring a horse to water but you can't make him or her drink. How do you expect to force a kid to do something like that?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:32 AM on 02/05/2013
fun, fun, fun, variety, keep trying stuff until the kid likes something of finds a peer group it likes. Doesn't have to be sport, could be dance, outdoor skills, whatever.

Should not just be the kids, adults need to lead by example and have family outings focused on getting out there.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CoachNelly2
10:55 AM on 02/06/2013
You start by setting the example by being physically active yourself. This doesn't always mean playing a team sport, but it could even be taking a daily walk around the neighborhood or throwing the frisbee around at the park. There's also the issue of electronics - turning them off and going outside is the first step.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
10:12 AM on 02/05/2013
Yes - physical activity should definitely be part of a child's everyday experience; competitive sports shouldn't - unless the child shows a real interest in it. Otherwise, it's really the parents who are trying to benefit from the child's participation to the detriment of the child. Who wants to be forced into something of which they have no interest? Kids are no different.
07:32 PM on 02/04/2013
The same way a kid doesn't know that he doesn't like beets til he tries them, team sports are no different - give him/her the opportunity to have the experience . Fun, competition, exercise and team playing are beneficial to anyone - especially the shy and the non-athletic, and it certainly doesn't have to be cut throat - there are plenty of teams that are strictly for fun with evenly matched skill levels. And while I have seen some of those vile "sport parents," for the most part the majority of parents aren't trying to relive their own thwarted, or unfullfilled dreams of sporting glory through their children, they just enjoy the camaradarie of being with other parents and watching the kids play and have fun. If the kids truly dislike the activity, then by all means find something else that strikes a cord, but give them the chance first - they might really like it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:57 AM on 02/05/2013
My girlfriend as a child was forced into soccer. So she sat down in the middle of the field and read a book.
I was forced into basketball, and I just refused to participate (and also read a book).
At the end of teh day, if a child does not want to do sports nothing you can do will make them enjoy it.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
10:06 AM on 02/05/2013
I wish it were as simple as that, and true. Good for your girlfriend and yourself for sticking to your guns and refusing to do the sports that you weren't interested in. Unfortunately many kids do not have the wherewithal or courage to stand up to their parents for a variety of reasons (fear of discipline, fear of letting the parents down, etc.). Because of this, they go along with the activity, all the while upset, stressed and anxious that they're not fulfilling their parents' expectations. Oftentimes they become resentful, an emotion that fuels the fire for later teen angst and questionable behavior. Not a good situation all around...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
10:09 AM on 02/05/2013
Point taken, Kikazaru; it would be great if this were always the case. It is true what you say that sometimes kids don't know what they like until they try it. And if they try sports and decide it's not for them, in an ideal world, they would be able to stop with no repercussions from the parents. Unfortunately this is not always the case and we all know of scenarios where the kids are unwitting participants in team sports that they clearly could not care less for, but are doing so because they are being continually "encouraged" by their parents. These are the situations that are so wrong, in my opinion. As noted in the article, not all kids are made to be the next Olympic superstar and we as parents should just accept this fact and find the talent or skill that the child does excel in. It will be a win-win situation as opposed to one where the only ones happy are the parents.
06:15 PM on 02/04/2013
We need to draw a distinction between fitness activities and competitive sports. Not all fitness activities require skill and competitiveness. I believe all parents should require their kids, for their physical and mental health, to be physically active on a frequent and regular basis. I sure wish my parents had required it of me right from day one. But no, children should not be required to participate in competitive sports if they're disinclined to.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Samantha Kemp-Jackson
10:03 AM on 02/05/2013
Very true, RIk. There is definitely a difference between fitness activities and physical fitness and competitive sports. What I was referring to in the article was the team sport situations that many kids end up in, despite their wishes otherwise. These include competitive hockey, baseball, football, soccer, etc. I agree that physical fitness should be a part of every child's life but perhaps without the competition factor.